Diesel Cayenne and VW emission issue
#5791
In Porsche's record our In-Service date is correct, our warranty expiration date expired one month early. Just suggesting that folks here verify with their dealer the dates.
We had a couple of nits that we waited to get resolved - our dealer discovered the issue and is working with Porsche to resolve the dates.
In the interim dealer said they would take care of us regardless which is very nice!
#5792
Has anyone specifically contacted Porsche North America for the diesel turbo lag issue, post emissions fix? Anyone know of a specific address or have a link to the proper contacts? Has anyone tweeded #PorscheCares with this issue? I'm ready to start formalizing my complaint and want to do things right. First I'll bring my 2016 CD into the local dealer specifically for turbo lag. In the past I had them check it when performing an Oil change or other maintenance and no real testing or fix mentions the lag in performance. They did change out my AC compressor because the lag appears to be worse in hot weather and maybe that was the issue. I expect they will not have a fix, but then I'll have a start to my paper trail. Next step will be the survey after my trip to the local dealer. Porsche NA seems to always send me a survey checking up on the local dealer. I will then see if they say anything and will report back to the list.
Comments are welcome even if I'm posting at the wrong spot or wasting my time. Looking for feedback.
Comments are welcome even if I'm posting at the wrong spot or wasting my time. Looking for feedback.
#5793
You will probably get a response like this...
Thank you for your email. Based on the previous technical evaluations, your vehicle is performing to the approved specifications of the agreed upon emissions modification.
While the performance is different than when it was originally delivered, our evaluations indicate that it is performing in the manner expected after the modification as outlined in the pamphlet titled "Important information about your Porsche Cayenne Diesel". We would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-modification behavior.
Kind Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
While the performance is different than when it was originally delivered, our evaluations indicate that it is performing in the manner expected after the modification as outlined in the pamphlet titled "Important information about your Porsche Cayenne Diesel". We would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-modification behavior.
Kind Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
#5794
Rennlist Member
That email could actually help! They're claiming the vehicle performs as specified in the pamphlet. And doubling down on it.
</span><br /><br /><span style="color:null;">I think, however, the big deal here is the drivibility issue. According to the DOJ Consent Decree:<br /><br />
<br /><br />I'd say a 2 second lag in the delivery of power when demanded by the driver isn't keeping with this definition. Nor is the instant hit once the computer decides that the throttle is pressed... or the "surging"<br /><br />And from the settlement itself, they are supposed to specifically tell us about a number of things, including:<br /><br />
<br /><br />I'm thinking the lack of response and surging ("drivibility" things) are of considerable importance to us as vehicle owners. And there is nowhere, in any of the documentation I have or have been able to find online, that says the vehicle will have the roll on power of a vintage Mercedes 300D because of a 2 second delay in delivering power.<br /><br />It's almost of the software has a built in 2 second delay before it accepts accelerator positioning. And then when it does, it says, "holy ****, you want 3/4 throttle... here you GO!" Or maybe it's just my accelerator sensor that's weak or something.<br /><br />But I think the bottom line is that they are trying to stiff arm these apparent anomalies and their emails saying it's normal will be directly in conflict with the settlement and published materials.<br /><br />
<br /><br />I don't think it's turbo lag. At least not in my case. It is a complete engine response lag. I hit the throttle, nothing happens for 2 seconds. Actually, that's not completely true... typically, the tach rises initially for a fraction, then falls, and then after waiting the requisite 2 seconds, flys up to about 2200 and the power hits. Hard.
WTF just happened to my post?? This is the 3rd time RL has "eaten" my post. Looks like I can fix it, but wtf? Why did it change to BB code or whatever crap is showing here?
Originally Posted by 2015 Fix pamphlet
Emissions Modification: As described above, Porsche will perform an agreed-upon emissions modification that modifies the emissions control system software on your vehicle. Drivers may notice some differences in vehicle operating characteristics after the modification, but other than as described in this booklet, drivers should not notice any adverse changes in vehicle reliability, durability, performance, drivability, or other driving characteristics. The software upgrade approved by EPA and CARB will only change the way your car’s engine and emission control systems interact. - Clearly that's not the case. Or, if it is, there is something else defective in the vehicles not caused by the fix.
The new software will affect your car in the following ways:
• Engine sound may differ somewhat from your vehicle’s prior operation. There might be a difference in combustion noise from the engine that may be noticeable during vehicle warm-up. The potential change in sound will not result in any <span style="color:#e67e22;">noticeable changes to the driving characteristics</span> of your vehicle. <span style="color:#2980b9;">-OK, it'll sound a bit more like a diesel. I can live with that, especially since it won't make any changes to the "driving characteristics" of the vehicle. Great, the noise isn't the cause.</span><br />• Shift Patterns – The shifting behavior has been adapted to run with slightly higher engine speeds during vehicle warm-up and when driving at high altitudes. <span style="color:#2980b9;">-Mildly annoying, but I get it, you have to get everything up to temp quickly. Fine.</span><br />• Downhill Driving – Removal of the enhanced automatic engine braking feature may require drivers to apply more brake pedal in downhill driving. <span style="color:#2980b9;">- Sucks, but it wouldn't have changed my purchase decision, so not having it isn't a big deal.</span><br />• In Sport mode, some drivers might notice less dynamic shifting behavior. <span style="color:#2980b9;">- Less dynamic would be OK. Totally MIA, not so much.</span><br />• Diesel Exhaust Fluid (“DEF”) consumption – DEF (also known as AdBlue®) consumption for your vehicle may change. MY15 vehicles may experience an increase of 40% on average, while MY16 vehicles may on average experience a decrease. The exact amount of the change will vary depending on driving style and other factors. This means some drivers will need to refill the DEF tank more frequently; however, we anticipate that a full tank of DEF will last through a full 5,000-mile recommended service interval. <span style="color:#2980b9;">-Think we all knew this one was happening. No big deal; DEF is cheap at Walmart.</span><br />• Decreased Fuel Economy – Your vehicle’s fuel economy will decrease by up to 1 mpg, depending on driving style and habits. <span style="color:#2980b9;">- Yep. Fine. About right in town. On the highway, no noticeable difference.</span><br />• On-board diagnostic (“OBD”) system changes – Your OBD system’s operations will be modified based upon the agreement with EPA and CARB and will be compliant with existing emission standards. We do not anticipate that the modification will affect the OBD system in a manner that would make identification and repair of any components difficult, compromise warranty coverage, or compromise your vehicle’s ability to comply with the inspection and maintenance (Smog Check) test of your vehicle. Furthermore, the extended warranty coverage outlined in this booklet offers additional protection for any OBD-related issues. These changes should not be noticeable to you and do not have any impact upon driving characteristics. <span style="color:#2980b9;">-Good to know. The system will still report on itself and can be used to troubleshoot. Except for the current problems impacting drivibility.
The new software will affect your car in the following ways:
• Engine sound may differ somewhat from your vehicle’s prior operation. There might be a difference in combustion noise from the engine that may be noticeable during vehicle warm-up. The potential change in sound will not result in any <span style="color:#e67e22;">noticeable changes to the driving characteristics</span> of your vehicle. <span style="color:#2980b9;">-OK, it'll sound a bit more like a diesel. I can live with that, especially since it won't make any changes to the "driving characteristics" of the vehicle. Great, the noise isn't the cause.</span><br />• Shift Patterns – The shifting behavior has been adapted to run with slightly higher engine speeds during vehicle warm-up and when driving at high altitudes. <span style="color:#2980b9;">-Mildly annoying, but I get it, you have to get everything up to temp quickly. Fine.</span><br />• Downhill Driving – Removal of the enhanced automatic engine braking feature may require drivers to apply more brake pedal in downhill driving. <span style="color:#2980b9;">- Sucks, but it wouldn't have changed my purchase decision, so not having it isn't a big deal.</span><br />• In Sport mode, some drivers might notice less dynamic shifting behavior. <span style="color:#2980b9;">- Less dynamic would be OK. Totally MIA, not so much.</span><br />• Diesel Exhaust Fluid (“DEF”) consumption – DEF (also known as AdBlue®) consumption for your vehicle may change. MY15 vehicles may experience an increase of 40% on average, while MY16 vehicles may on average experience a decrease. The exact amount of the change will vary depending on driving style and other factors. This means some drivers will need to refill the DEF tank more frequently; however, we anticipate that a full tank of DEF will last through a full 5,000-mile recommended service interval. <span style="color:#2980b9;">-Think we all knew this one was happening. No big deal; DEF is cheap at Walmart.</span><br />• Decreased Fuel Economy – Your vehicle’s fuel economy will decrease by up to 1 mpg, depending on driving style and habits. <span style="color:#2980b9;">- Yep. Fine. About right in town. On the highway, no noticeable difference.</span><br />• On-board diagnostic (“OBD”) system changes – Your OBD system’s operations will be modified based upon the agreement with EPA and CARB and will be compliant with existing emission standards. We do not anticipate that the modification will affect the OBD system in a manner that would make identification and repair of any components difficult, compromise warranty coverage, or compromise your vehicle’s ability to comply with the inspection and maintenance (Smog Check) test of your vehicle. Furthermore, the extended warranty coverage outlined in this booklet offers additional protection for any OBD-related issues. These changes should not be noticeable to you and do not have any impact upon driving characteristics. <span style="color:#2980b9;">-Good to know. The system will still report on itself and can be used to troubleshoot. Except for the current problems impacting drivibility.
Originally Posted by DOJ Consent Decree Appendix B, Paragraph 2.21 (Definitions)
</span> 2.21 “Drivability” means the smooth delivery of power, as demanded by the driver or operator. Typical elements of Drivability degradation are rough idling, misfiring, surging, increased hesitation, or insufficient power.
Originally Posted by Diesel settlement para 7.3
(5) any and all reasonably predictable changes resulting from the Approved Emissions Modification, including but not limited to changes to reliability, durability, fuel economy, noise vibration, vehicle performance, drivability and any other vehicle attributes that may reasonably be important to vehicle owners;
WTF just happened to my post?? This is the 3rd time RL has "eaten" my post. Looks like I can fix it, but wtf? Why did it change to BB code or whatever crap is showing here?
Last edited by skiahh; 09-02-2018 at 01:50 PM.
#5795
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Never mind.
Last edited by Needsdecaf; 09-03-2018 at 05:56 PM.
#5796
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Has anyone specifically contacted Porsche North America for the diesel turbo lag issue, post emissions fix? Anyone know of a specific address or have a link to the proper contacts? Has anyone tweeded #PorscheCares with this issue? I'm ready to start formalizing my complaint and want to do things right. First I'll bring my 2016 CD into the local dealer specifically for turbo lag. In the past I had them check it when performing an Oil change or other maintenance and no real testing or fix mentions the lag in performance. They did change out my AC compressor because the lag appears to be worse in hot weather and maybe that was the issue. I expect they will not have a fix, but then I'll have a start to my paper trail. Next step will be the survey after my trip to the local dealer. Porsche NA seems to always send me a survey checking up on the local dealer. I will then see if they say anything and will report back to the list.
Comments are welcome even if I'm posting at the wrong spot or wasting my time. Looking for feedback.
Comments are welcome even if I'm posting at the wrong spot or wasting my time. Looking for feedback.
#5797
Rennlist Member
Mine's supposed to go in for the third time this next week. Expect a PCNA rep to be involved this time. Then I expect the stiff arm email/decision.
But my dealer is excellent and agrees with my concerns, so we'll see.
But my dealer is excellent and agrees with my concerns, so we'll see.
#5798
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by skiahh
Mine's supposed to go in for the third time this next week. Expect a PCNA rep to be involved this time. Then I expect the stiff arm email/decision.
But my dealer is excellent and agrees with my concerns, so we'll see.
But my dealer is excellent and agrees with my concerns, so we'll see.
#5800
Rennlist Member
Guys, I think you should talk to "our lawyers," not PCNA. They are the ones who have to report to the judge about the "driveability" issues. PCNA/VW/Audi will just try to wash their hands bc they don't really want to deal with EPA/CARB again.
#5801
It's been noted by me and others that the lag is much worse at higher ambient temperatures I've also noticed that the mileage is much worse in hotter temperatures.
I've had the opportunity the last couple of days to drive the exact same route at the same time of day at different temperatures. Sunday was 70 deg, and I saw 32.1 indicated MPG for a 15 mile run. Monday was 82 degrees, and I saw 26 indicated MPG.
Just another data point.
Don Winston
I've had the opportunity the last couple of days to drive the exact same route at the same time of day at different temperatures. Sunday was 70 deg, and I saw 32.1 indicated MPG for a 15 mile run. Monday was 82 degrees, and I saw 26 indicated MPG.
Just another data point.
Don Winston
#5802
Porsche could care less about our issues.
Edited for space and personal info.
Mr. ,
While the roads traveled and loads carried may be the same, a wide variety of additional factors contribute to the MPG seen on any trip. Multiple evaluations of your vehicle have confirmed that your vehicle is performing to spec for this engine type after the emissions modification. To reiterate, we would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-emissions modification behavior.
per the settlement agreement, your vehicle was modified with your approval and you were compensated for the changes made to the behavior of the vehicle.
Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
Phone: (248) 413-3963
FAX: (866) 334-5280
eMail: external.richard.cook@porsche.usFrom: Jason
Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 11:25
To: Cook, Richard (PCNA, CR_EXT); Battie, Doug (PCNA, O13)
Subject: Re: (5473239)
The milage when not towing and towing has suffered more that 3 MPG not towing and 5+ towing. This is much more than the stated 1 MPG. Each drive is on the exact same road with same load inside as always and same trailer when towing. This shows the Cayenne is not performing to the approved specifications of the emissions modification. I used to see as high as 37 MPG and now rarely break 30. To date multiple parts have been replaced with little to no impact on the concerns over the course of three service visits. The team at Porsche Minneapolis directed me to contact your team as they stated they can do nothing without direction from PCNA.
This is not my first VW group vehicle (12 cars in 15 years).
I have included Doug as the regional VP.
Sent from iCloud
On Apr 05, 2018, at 05:45 PM, "Cook, Richard (PCNA, CR_EXT)" <External.Richard.Cook@porsche.us> wrote:
Thank you for your email. Based on the previous technical evaluations, your vehicle is performing to the approved specifications of the agreed upon emissions modification.
While the performance is different than when it was originally delivered, our evaluations indicate that it is performing in the manner expected after the modification as outlined in the pamphlet titled "Important information about your Porsche Cayenne Diesel". We would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-modification behavior.
Kind Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
Phone: (248) 413-3963
FAX: (866) 334-5280
eMail: external.richard.cook@porsche.us
[/QUOTE]
Edited for space and personal info.
Mr. ,
While the roads traveled and loads carried may be the same, a wide variety of additional factors contribute to the MPG seen on any trip. Multiple evaluations of your vehicle have confirmed that your vehicle is performing to spec for this engine type after the emissions modification. To reiterate, we would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-emissions modification behavior.
per the settlement agreement, your vehicle was modified with your approval and you were compensated for the changes made to the behavior of the vehicle.
Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
Phone: (248) 413-3963
FAX: (866) 334-5280
eMail: external.richard.cook@porsche.usFrom: Jason
Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 11:25
To: Cook, Richard (PCNA, CR_EXT); Battie, Doug (PCNA, O13)
Subject: Re: (5473239)
The milage when not towing and towing has suffered more that 3 MPG not towing and 5+ towing. This is much more than the stated 1 MPG. Each drive is on the exact same road with same load inside as always and same trailer when towing. This shows the Cayenne is not performing to the approved specifications of the emissions modification. I used to see as high as 37 MPG and now rarely break 30. To date multiple parts have been replaced with little to no impact on the concerns over the course of three service visits. The team at Porsche Minneapolis directed me to contact your team as they stated they can do nothing without direction from PCNA.
This is not my first VW group vehicle (12 cars in 15 years).
I have included Doug as the regional VP.
Sent from iCloud
On Apr 05, 2018, at 05:45 PM, "Cook, Richard (PCNA, CR_EXT)" <External.Richard.Cook@porsche.us> wrote:
Thank you for your email. Based on the previous technical evaluations, your vehicle is performing to the approved specifications of the agreed upon emissions modification.
While the performance is different than when it was originally delivered, our evaluations indicate that it is performing in the manner expected after the modification as outlined in the pamphlet titled "Important information about your Porsche Cayenne Diesel". We would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-modification behavior.
Kind Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
Phone: (248) 413-3963
FAX: (866) 334-5280
eMail: external.richard.cook@porsche.us
[/QUOTE]
#5803
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#5804
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
It's been noted by me and others that the lag is much worse at higher ambient temperatures I've also noticed that the mileage is much worse in hotter temperatures.
I've had the opportunity the last couple of days to drive the exact same route at the same time of day at different temperatures. Sunday was 70 deg, and I saw 32.1 indicated MPG for a 15 mile run. Monday was 82 degrees, and I saw 26 indicated MPG.
Just another data point.
Don Winston
I've had the opportunity the last couple of days to drive the exact same route at the same time of day at different temperatures. Sunday was 70 deg, and I saw 32.1 indicated MPG for a 15 mile run. Monday was 82 degrees, and I saw 26 indicated MPG.
Just another data point.
Don Winston
Thanks.
#5805
Rennlist Member
It's been noted by me and others that the lag is much worse at higher ambient temperatures I've also noticed that the mileage is much worse in hotter temperatures.
I've had the opportunity the last couple of days to drive the exact same route at the same time of day at different temperatures. Sunday was 70 deg, and I saw 32.1 indicated MPG for a 15 mile run. Monday was 82 degrees, and I saw 26 indicated MPG.
Just another data point.
Don Winston
I've had the opportunity the last couple of days to drive the exact same route at the same time of day at different temperatures. Sunday was 70 deg, and I saw 32.1 indicated MPG for a 15 mile run. Monday was 82 degrees, and I saw 26 indicated MPG.
Just another data point.
Don Winston
15 miles doesn't even run a gallon through the system, so it can't really give you a good reading. If you accelerated hard once, you'll skew the numbers badly with that little distance.
Sorry, Don, but this isn't a valid data point.
Porsche could care less about our issues.
Edited for space and personal info.
Mr. ,
While the roads traveled and loads carried may be the same, a wide variety of additional factors contribute to the MPG seen on any trip. Multiple evaluations of your vehicle have confirmed that your vehicle is performing to spec for this engine type after the emissions modification. To reiterate, we would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-emissions modification behavior.
per the settlement agreement, your vehicle was modified with your approval and you were compensated for the changes made to the behavior of the vehicle.
Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
Phone: (248) 413-3963
FAX: (866) 334-5280
eMail: external.richard.cook@porsche.usFrom: Jason
Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 11:25
To: Cook, Richard (PCNA, CR_EXT); Battie, Doug (PCNA, O13)
Subject: Re: (5473239)
The milage when not towing and towing has suffered more that 3 MPG not towing and 5+ towing. This is much more than the stated 1 MPG. Each drive is on the exact same road with same load inside as always and same trailer when towing. This shows the Cayenne is not performing to the approved specifications of the emissions modification. I used to see as high as 37 MPG and now rarely break 30. To date multiple parts have been replaced with little to no impact on the concerns over the course of three service visits. The team at Porsche Minneapolis directed me to contact your team as they stated they can do nothing without direction from PCNA.
This is not my first VW group vehicle (12 cars in 15 years).
I have included Doug as the regional VP.
Sent from iCloud
On Apr 05, 2018, at 05:45 PM, "Cook, Richard (PCNA, CR_EXT)" <External.Richard.Cook@porsche.us> wrote:
Thank you for your email. Based on the previous technical evaluations, your vehicle is performing to the approved specifications of the agreed upon emissions modification.
While the performance is different than when it was originally delivered, our evaluations indicate that it is performing in the manner expected after the modification as outlined in the pamphlet titled "Important information about your Porsche Cayenne Diesel". We would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-modification behavior.
Kind Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
Phone: (248) 413-3963
FAX: (866) 334-5280
eMail: external.richard.cook@porsche.us
Edited for space and personal info.
Mr. ,
While the roads traveled and loads carried may be the same, a wide variety of additional factors contribute to the MPG seen on any trip. Multiple evaluations of your vehicle have confirmed that your vehicle is performing to spec for this engine type after the emissions modification. To reiterate, we would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-emissions modification behavior.
per the settlement agreement, your vehicle was modified with your approval and you were compensated for the changes made to the behavior of the vehicle.
Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
Phone: (248) 413-3963
FAX: (866) 334-5280
eMail: external.richard.cook@porsche.usFrom: Jason
Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2018 11:25
To: Cook, Richard (PCNA, CR_EXT); Battie, Doug (PCNA, O13)
Subject: Re: (5473239)
The milage when not towing and towing has suffered more that 3 MPG not towing and 5+ towing. This is much more than the stated 1 MPG. Each drive is on the exact same road with same load inside as always and same trailer when towing. This shows the Cayenne is not performing to the approved specifications of the emissions modification. I used to see as high as 37 MPG and now rarely break 30. To date multiple parts have been replaced with little to no impact on the concerns over the course of three service visits. The team at Porsche Minneapolis directed me to contact your team as they stated they can do nothing without direction from PCNA.
This is not my first VW group vehicle (12 cars in 15 years).
I have included Doug as the regional VP.
Sent from iCloud
On Apr 05, 2018, at 05:45 PM, "Cook, Richard (PCNA, CR_EXT)" <External.Richard.Cook@porsche.us> wrote:
Thank you for your email. Based on the previous technical evaluations, your vehicle is performing to the approved specifications of the agreed upon emissions modification.
While the performance is different than when it was originally delivered, our evaluations indicate that it is performing in the manner expected after the modification as outlined in the pamphlet titled "Important information about your Porsche Cayenne Diesel". We would not be able to make any modifications that would attempt to return your vehicle to a pre-modification behavior.
Kind Regards,
Richard Cook
Customer Commitment Senior Specialist
US Central Region and Canada
Porsche Cars North America, Inc.
One Porsche Drive
Atlanta, GA 30354-9817
Phone: (248) 413-3963
FAX: (866) 334-5280
eMail: external.richard.cook@porsche.us
Sad to say, you will not win that one. Your vehicle IS performing to spec. It just used to be better than spec.
Last edited by skiahh; 09-04-2018 at 07:25 PM.