911R Driving Impressions
#286
Thank you GrantG for telling me by PM that the speeds at 7,000 rpm for the GT4 looked wrong and for giving me the ratios. Apparently my source for the relative ratios after including tyre sizes was flawed so I went back to basics using an online tyre size calculator. I also found from an old Road & Track data sheet that 2nd to 6th gears for the 996.2 GT3/RS were wrong and corrected them.
I'm pretty the charts are accurate now but let me know if you see any more errors. If anyone has ratios for the 996.1 GT3 I'll include it.
I'm pretty the charts are accurate now but let me know if you see any more errors. If anyone has ratios for the 996.1 GT3 I'll include it.
#287
My opinions...
Yes, it does move around if you push it. I'm not one for driving cars sideways (ingrained from racing as a bad thing...), but it doesn't feel planted like say an 991RS. Definitely more playful. (Having said that, my perfect R would have an old fashioned handbrake for proper cornering in the snow!)
The steering is very precise, and does give good feedback. It is a bit lighter than I woukd like, and I would prefer if it was hydraulic given the choice. However, it's not something you think about while driving - ie it's not an irritation, I would just go the other way if asked.
Turn in and agility is great, at least partly because of RWS, which is much more resolved than in the RS. RWS is a great feature and I would always order it now.
Stripes - I think they suit the car right now, although I guess I wouldn't have thought to spec a car with stripes if it wasn't launched like that (notwithstanding the historic link).
I've considered having them painted, but that would take away the option of removing them in future if the look 'wears off'.
Yes, it does move around if you push it. I'm not one for driving cars sideways (ingrained from racing as a bad thing...), but it doesn't feel planted like say an 991RS. Definitely more playful. (Having said that, my perfect R would have an old fashioned handbrake for proper cornering in the snow!)
The steering is very precise, and does give good feedback. It is a bit lighter than I woukd like, and I would prefer if it was hydraulic given the choice. However, it's not something you think about while driving - ie it's not an irritation, I would just go the other way if asked.
Turn in and agility is great, at least partly because of RWS, which is much more resolved than in the RS. RWS is a great feature and I would always order it now.
Stripes - I think they suit the car right now, although I guess I wouldn't have thought to spec a car with stripes if it wasn't launched like that (notwithstanding the historic link).
I've considered having them painted, but that would take away the option of removing them in future if the look 'wears off'.
#289
Drifting
Excellent point! I was waiting for a 991RS allocation got fed up and test drove a TTS and loved it. I don't have much time for the track these days and I am very pleased with the way it performs in the canyons.
#290
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I've added maximum speeds in gears, tidied up the chart and uploaded it as a single PDF but for some reason it wont display like the individual screen shots did so you have to click on it to download it. The redlines and max speeds in top are from Porsche literature, the max speeds in other gears are calculated from the gear and final drive ratios and tyre sizes.
Attachment 1125433
Attachment 1125433
#291
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
As someone who will almost certainly never own an R (maybe a GT3 at some point?) I wanted to say thank you to those owners kind enough to share the intimate details of owning (driving!) this car. I grew up pouring over reviews by Rich Ceppos, Pat Bedard, Brock Yates, Dennis Simiantis, Paul Frere and Peter Egan, so most all of my early auto impressions were formed by their ability to accurately describe what I was not yet old enough to do. I still appreciate the writing of true automotive journalists, but they are sadly far and few between. Most magazine articles these days spend 2/3 of the time regurgitating the press pack and about two paragraphs of boring, cliched type on how it drives. There are a few exceptions, like Henry Catchpole.
Thanks owners and drivers for continuing to feed this hungry soul for more info. In the meantime, I'll enjoy my lowly C2S cab and continue to dream as I did as a young lad..unless someone in Houston in a GT3 / RS / R wants to take me for a spin.
Thanks owners and drivers for continuing to feed this hungry soul for more info. In the meantime, I'll enjoy my lowly C2S cab and continue to dream as I did as a young lad..unless someone in Houston in a GT3 / RS / R wants to take me for a spin.
#292
It's now more complete (previous page) with the 996.1 included thanks to the ratios provided by JarmoL. I shrank the chart so I could take a screen shot which, unlike the PDF, displays even though it is a bigger file.
Anyway, the whole gearing question arose with the query of the comment that the R pulls harder than the 991 RS. The reasons why have been provided but the chart shows that gearing - at least in the first four gears - is not a factor, with speeds at 7,000 rpm and the redline only 1-2 mph different.
The chart also shows the significantly lower gearing introduced with the 997 RS 3.8 continuing at a similar level in subsequent models except for the GT4, which is even higher geared than the 996-997.2 GT3s - but reaches similar speeds to them at maximum rpm.
Anyway, the whole gearing question arose with the query of the comment that the R pulls harder than the 991 RS. The reasons why have been provided but the chart shows that gearing - at least in the first four gears - is not a factor, with speeds at 7,000 rpm and the redline only 1-2 mph different.
The chart also shows the significantly lower gearing introduced with the 997 RS 3.8 continuing at a similar level in subsequent models except for the GT4, which is even higher geared than the 996-997.2 GT3s - but reaches similar speeds to them at maximum rpm.
#294
Crystal ball:
Is the R a one-off like the Cayman R, the beginning of an ongoing exclusive model line or the prelude to a Carrera 2.7/3.0 successor - a full production Motorsport designed road car now that the Carrera has become a grand tourer?
Porsche will want to keep its best customers happy which means differentiating the .2 GT3 from the R. Apart from a fixed wing, no magnesium or carbon panels, PCCB as an option (not standard), maybe 10 hp less and higher production - what else can Porsche do?
Is the R a one-off like the Cayman R, the beginning of an ongoing exclusive model line or the prelude to a Carrera 2.7/3.0 successor - a full production Motorsport designed road car now that the Carrera has become a grand tourer?
Porsche will want to keep its best customers happy which means differentiating the .2 GT3 from the R. Apart from a fixed wing, no magnesium or carbon panels, PCCB as an option (not standard), maybe 10 hp less and higher production - what else can Porsche do?
#295
Instructor
Thread Starter
It seems pretty much the perfect Porsche for the current era. The only things I question are:
- With so much more grip than previous generations is it possible to manipulate the handling as much on the road?
- Are the technical benefits of EPAS worth the reduction in feel?
- The wide, thick, matt stripes on an otherwise elegant car. If they were painted on they would integrate better. However they are a delete option.
- With so much more grip than previous generations is it possible to manipulate the handling as much on the road?
- Are the technical benefits of EPAS worth the reduction in feel?
- The wide, thick, matt stripes on an otherwise elegant car. If they were painted on they would integrate better. However they are a delete option.
On the road, I am happy to have great front end grip as I am not interested in sliding the front. And when appropriate, it is easy to light up the rear tires on power as the grip at the rear is easily overcome by the engine. The 911 R feels overpowered for its tires so road handling is fantastic and very engaging on the road. It is not just grip and power that makes the car engaging - the RWS makes the car more fun with excellent turn-in when charging up the hairpins on a mountain road. The better turn-in with RWS makes for higher corner entry speeds, and therefore even easier to light up the rears on corner exit.
The electric power steering is very precise, but does not have the same road feedback as the previous hydraulic systems. If I could choose, I would rather have hydraulic power steering.
Agreed that the stripes are a matter of taste. I optioned my stripes to match the paint as a compromise to retain the uniqueness of the stripes while remaining more subtle than contrasting stripes. BTW, painted stripes cost around 50k, so only about 5 or 10 cars have that.
Crystal ball:
Is the R a one-off like the Cayman R, the beginning of an ongoing exclusive model line or the prelude to a Carrera 2.7/3.0 successor - a full production Motorsport designed road car now that the Carrera has become a grand tourer?
Porsche will want to keep its best customers happy which means differentiating the .2 GT3 from the R. Apart from a fixed wing, no magnesium or carbon panels, PCCB as an option (not standard), maybe 10 hp less and higher production - what else can Porsche do?
Is the R a one-off like the Cayman R, the beginning of an ongoing exclusive model line or the prelude to a Carrera 2.7/3.0 successor - a full production Motorsport designed road car now that the Carrera has become a grand tourer?
Porsche will want to keep its best customers happy which means differentiating the .2 GT3 from the R. Apart from a fixed wing, no magnesium or carbon panels, PCCB as an option (not standard), maybe 10 hp less and higher production - what else can Porsche do?
Last edited by BusDriver; 01-16-2017 at 01:13 PM.
#296
Rennlist Member
Crystal ball:
Is the R a one-off like the Cayman R, the beginning of an ongoing exclusive model line or the prelude to a Carrera 2.7/3.0 successor - a full production Motorsport designed road car now that the Carrera has become a grand tourer?
Porsche will want to keep its best customers happy which means differentiating the .2 GT3 from the R. Apart from a fixed wing, no magnesium or carbon panels, PCCB as an option (not standard), maybe 10 hp less and higher production - what else can Porsche do?
Is the R a one-off like the Cayman R, the beginning of an ongoing exclusive model line or the prelude to a Carrera 2.7/3.0 successor - a full production Motorsport designed road car now that the Carrera has become a grand tourer?
Porsche will want to keep its best customers happy which means differentiating the .2 GT3 from the R. Apart from a fixed wing, no magnesium or carbon panels, PCCB as an option (not standard), maybe 10 hp less and higher production - what else can Porsche do?
IMO Porsche (and VW as a whole) is more concerned with increasing revenue than retaining resale values of sold units. Besides, they will provide other baubles for their 'best customers' to keep them happy...
#297
But, but, but...you can't drive in snow with performance tires, you'll die and your car will burst into flames...
But, but, but...nobody specs PCCB in snow...the gravel!!!
#298
Race Director
Originally Posted by Archimedes
But, but, but...991R owners don't even drive their cars...
But, but, but...you can't drive in snow with performance tires, you'll die and your car will burst into flames...
But, but, but...nobody specs PCCB in snow...the gravel!!!
But, but, but...you can't drive in snow with performance tires, you'll die and your car will burst into flames...
But, but, but...nobody specs PCCB in snow...the gravel!!!
#299
#300
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 13,328
Received 4,510 Likes
on
2,568 Posts
I have both a Cayman R and GT4, and the feel of the cars is quite different. The GT4 is more capable, refined, and comfortable, but the Cayman R feels lighter, smaller, and generally more like a go kart, and hydraulic steering is nice too. I view the Cayman R as a 'last of its kind' sort of car.