A place to discuss all things ADM
#7516
Race Car
BaT does provide some useful data, but Manheim provides a much larger data set -- obviously making it a better temperature of the market as a whole.
I also think a big reason the BaT pricing is so low is the last 5 sales include stripped out flip cars, that were very low specs -- thus fetching a price that reflects their lack of build quality.
I also think a big reason the BaT pricing is so low is the last 5 sales include stripped out flip cars, that were very low specs -- thus fetching a price that reflects their lack of build quality.
The following 2 users liked this post by Diablo Dude:
RUF RS (11-22-2023),
Tombstone4478 (11-22-2023)
#7517
Unsolicited $0.02 here: I have a few local friends and acquaintances that have been on the 'wait til they drop to msrp train' first on the allocation hunt a few years ago and later predicting doom and gloom of the economy, recession etc. to ****** that coveted NA 992 GT car at msrp to then go brag about it. All this while providing scathing reviews of those who dare pay ADM and feed the infamous beast of capitalism. Fast fwd to today, and most if not all have come to the realization that msrp (and ADM) allocations are gone and that the secondary sale examples are not coming down to msrp ever! so now they are cutting their (time) losses and buying some of the pre owned cars that are within the $35-$50/$60K over sticker out there. They don't volunteer they are into that, but its so funny to see the sudden appearance of new (pre owned) GT3 cars within the local cars and coffee community and other car events, with some of these folks behind the wheel, while not realizing that for a lot of us this is yesterday's news already. The whole thing is just hilarious.
The following 3 users liked this post by JAB12:
#7518
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 13,028
Received 4,350 Likes
on
2,475 Posts
Unless we're filthy rich and truly don't care about how we spend money (a good recipe to become no longer filthy rich!), I think the reality is that most of us do care about costs and depreciation, and like the idea of getting good deals, owning and using things for free, etc. I personally know some quite wealthy people, and all of them care about how they spend their money (a few of them to great excess). I also know a lot of middle-class people who have little or no savings because they have a 'live and spend now' mentality with no regard for budgeting, saving, and investing. It's not a coincidence that we have a lot of money-related discussions throughout this Porsche forum, and I think there's nothing wrong with that.
All of that said, I've never hesitated to put miles on my cars and track them, because I won't buy a car unless I intend to drive it as much as I want to. I tracked three quarter million dollar cars this season, and while that was a new experience for me, I just said to myself "well, this is what I bought them for, and I'm having fun, and I know I can afford to track them" and then I just put the costs and likely depreciation out of my mind. So my approach is to carefully consider the financial aspects before buying a car and be sure I can afford the car assuming that I'm going to drive it without restriction, but once I've bought it, I don't think about the financial aspects anymore, because that would undermine the enjoyment of driving the cars.
All of that said, I've never hesitated to put miles on my cars and track them, because I won't buy a car unless I intend to drive it as much as I want to. I tracked three quarter million dollar cars this season, and while that was a new experience for me, I just said to myself "well, this is what I bought them for, and I'm having fun, and I know I can afford to track them" and then I just put the costs and likely depreciation out of my mind. So my approach is to carefully consider the financial aspects before buying a car and be sure I can afford the car assuming that I'm going to drive it without restriction, but once I've bought it, I don't think about the financial aspects anymore, because that would undermine the enjoyment of driving the cars.
The following users liked this post:
EMdoc (11-26-2023)
#7519
Race Car
I couldn't care any less about depreciation on my GT3 Touring.
Honestly, it doesn't even enter into my mindset. Besides, I tend to own my cars for 5 years or more.
That's why I find all of these "value" threads to be a waste of time.
The only thing that I find entertaining is how many (educated) people have been repeatedly wrong about the economy,
the financial markets, and new GT cars priced back at MSRP as we head into 2024.
But hey, it's the internet.
Honestly, it doesn't even enter into my mindset. Besides, I tend to own my cars for 5 years or more.
That's why I find all of these "value" threads to be a waste of time.
The only thing that I find entertaining is how many (educated) people have been repeatedly wrong about the economy,
the financial markets, and new GT cars priced back at MSRP as we head into 2024.
But hey, it's the internet.
#7520
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 13,028
Received 4,350 Likes
on
2,475 Posts
Is it consistent to care about what we pay for a car, but not care about depreciation? I think not.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_accounting
Part of the reason I bought a used McLaren is because I didn't want to take the big depreciation hit of a new one.
Part of the reason I bought a CPO 992 TTS is because it will have less depreciation than a brand new one.
Part of the reason I track Porsches, especially GT cars, is because they tend to not depreciate as much as other cars.
Part of the reason I bought a CPO 991.2 3RS at more than the original MSRP (but less than inflated MSRP) is because I think it will tend to hold value since it's a very special car.
Part of the reason I bought a new 992 GT3 and new 4RS is because I could get them at MSRP, so I have some buffer against depreciation since the market values are currently higher than MSRP.
I'm not rich enough nor free-spending enough to not care about depreciation. But I won't avoid driving the cars to reduce depreciation, because the assumption that I'll drive the cars was built into my decision to buy the cars.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_accounting
Part of the reason I bought a used McLaren is because I didn't want to take the big depreciation hit of a new one.
Part of the reason I bought a CPO 992 TTS is because it will have less depreciation than a brand new one.
Part of the reason I track Porsches, especially GT cars, is because they tend to not depreciate as much as other cars.
Part of the reason I bought a CPO 991.2 3RS at more than the original MSRP (but less than inflated MSRP) is because I think it will tend to hold value since it's a very special car.
Part of the reason I bought a new 992 GT3 and new 4RS is because I could get them at MSRP, so I have some buffer against depreciation since the market values are currently higher than MSRP.
I'm not rich enough nor free-spending enough to not care about depreciation. But I won't avoid driving the cars to reduce depreciation, because the assumption that I'll drive the cars was built into my decision to buy the cars.
Last edited by Manifold; 11-22-2023 at 01:08 PM.
#7521
I'd venture to say that most of the folks that pay over MSRP for their cars are not filthy rich but are upper middle class to comfortable.
The following users liked this post:
EMdoc (11-26-2023)
#7522
Burning Brakes
Unsolicited $0.02 here: I have a few local friends and acquaintances that have been on the 'wait til they drop to msrp train' first on the allocation hunt a few years ago and later predicting doom and gloom of the economy, recession etc. to ****** that coveted NA 992 GT car at msrp to then go brag about it. All this while providing scathing reviews of those who dare pay ADM and feed the infamous beast of capitalism. Fast fwd to today, and most if not all have come to the realization that msrp (and ADM) allocations are gone and that the secondary sale examples are not coming down to msrp ever! so now they are cutting their (time) losses and buying some of the pre owned cars that are within the $35-$50/$60K over sticker out there. They don't volunteer they are into that, but its so funny to see the sudden appearance of new (pre owned) GT3 cars within the local cars and coffee community and other car events, with some of these folks behind the wheel, while not realizing that for a lot of us this is yesterday's news already. The whole thing is just hilarious.
keep investing in gt3!!!! Or be priced out forever
your no 992 gt3 for sticker ever comment is going to age like milk
#7523
Pule was once milk too. Enjoy the Holidays.
#7524
992 GT market is in a hilarious free fall fueled by the stealers and new GT buyers that are delusioned into thinking these are investments which is honestly sad they think that.
This market is getting the death by 1,000 knives, and by 1k knives, I mean 1, 1% knife every month for 50 months until 992 GT is 20-3k under sticker which will happen this time next year.
You heard it here first. 20-30k under 992 GT sticker Oct 2023. Here come the 992 GT ADM buyers to tell us they caught the falling knife
This market is getting the death by 1,000 knives, and by 1k knives, I mean 1, 1% knife every month for 50 months until 992 GT is 20-3k under sticker which will happen this time next year.
You heard it here first. 20-30k under 992 GT sticker Oct 2023. Here come the 992 GT ADM buyers to tell us they caught the falling knife
The following 4 users liked this post by deVeil:
AlexCeres (11-22-2023),
fueledbymetal (11-24-2023),
speed77 (11-22-2023),
Tombstone4478 (11-22-2023)
#7525
^^^^That dude is a total clown show^^^^
#7526
Rennlist Member
The following 4 users liked this post by Jbravo23:
#7527
Race Car
The following 8 users liked this post by Diablo Dude:
AlexCeres (11-22-2023),
fueledbymetal (11-24-2023),
JAB12 (11-22-2023),
Jbravo23 (11-22-2023),
jjw285 (11-26-2023),
and 3 others liked this post.
#7528
Burning Brakes
The question I never see discussed is for the GT3 or even the Turbo S -- is what differences are there mechanically from say the 2022 model year cars to 2024 model year cars? I don't see Porsche providing to many comments on any changes or improvements between the 992 model years. I know they upgraded the Software in the screen to provide connection to Google and Apple-- and the screen is more colorful, and the design is more fluid. But what about areas that really count-- like Engine fixes or improvements or suspension parts -- maybe made stronger? Porsche did add the ability to display a "track" focused screens to eliminate the complaint about the gauges not being visible through the steering wheel. But they must have found some parts that fail too often or some materials that wear better.
Should there be a difference in value then from a GT3 2022 with 1,000 miles compared to a 2024 with 1,000 miles-- same spec.?
There are new colors like Rubystar neo and arctic gray metallic -- do these colors then make a 2024 car worth more than say painting a 2024 in Guard's red?
You see today a lot of 2022 GT3's for sale -- but almost zero 2024 cars-- were more cars made in 2022 and now Porsche is reducing the number of GT3's being made?
Should there be a difference in value then from a GT3 2022 with 1,000 miles compared to a 2024 with 1,000 miles-- same spec.?
There are new colors like Rubystar neo and arctic gray metallic -- do these colors then make a 2024 car worth more than say painting a 2024 in Guard's red?
You see today a lot of 2022 GT3's for sale -- but almost zero 2024 cars-- were more cars made in 2022 and now Porsche is reducing the number of GT3's being made?
#7529
The clown show is known for who and what he is here on RL.... a probable millenial who prides himself on the quantity of posts in a forum versus the quality of them; and, one who hangs onto every word of his own because he breathes only his own exhaust fumes thinking people actually care and take stock in his rhethoric.
The following 3 users liked this post by Joe mac:
#7530
The question I never see discussed is for the GT3 or even the Turbo S -- is what differences are there mechanically from say the 2022 model year cars to 2024 model year cars? I don't see Porsche providing to many comments on any changes or improvements between the 992 model years. I know they upgraded the Software in the screen to provide connection to Google and Apple-- and the screen is more colorful, and the design is more fluid. But what about areas that really count-- like Engine fixes or improvements or suspension parts -- maybe made stronger? Porsche did add the ability to display a "track" focused screens to eliminate the complaint about the gauges not being visible through the steering wheel. But they must have found some parts that fail too often or some materials that wear better.
Should there be a difference in value then from a GT3 2022 with 1,000 miles compared to a 2024 with 1,000 miles-- same spec.?
There are new colors like Rubystar neo and arctic gray metallic -- do these colors then make a 2024 car worth more than say painting a 2024 in Guard's red?
You see today a lot of 2022 GT3's for sale -- but almost zero 2024 cars-- were more cars made in 2022 and now Porsche is reducing the number of GT3's being made?
Should there be a difference in value then from a GT3 2022 with 1,000 miles compared to a 2024 with 1,000 miles-- same spec.?
There are new colors like Rubystar neo and arctic gray metallic -- do these colors then make a 2024 car worth more than say painting a 2024 in Guard's red?
You see today a lot of 2022 GT3's for sale -- but almost zero 2024 cars-- were more cars made in 2022 and now Porsche is reducing the number of GT3's being made?