Stop Sale?
#2371
Instructor
#2372
Instructor
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
No surprise. You'll read very little about this in the motoring press. CH and the mags all want/need press cars and biting the hand that feeds you isn't smart.
#2377
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I think Porsche has earned the benefit of the doubt over the years of a hard won reputation. Let's wait for Porsche to offer its "make good" before writing off the brand. Some of the whining is overdone IMO.
#2378
Drifting
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
My guess; Porsche will send a team of engineers to oversee the engine swaps. Modifying the engines at PDI for un-delivered cars make more sense and less travel for them. I believe that's why they are keeping all undelivered cars at the port. They will then work on the cars delivered to owners
They all paid up anyways, LOL.
![Smilie](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#2379
Intermediate
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Luxembourg
Posts: 26
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Hello, long time since I last posted!
Yesterday I had dinner with the chief aftersales manager from my PC (lifelong friend of mine) he was in Barcelona for the presentation of the Macan and they talked about the GT3 too. It's VERY sure we'll all get new engines, the GT development team (Preuninger included) have not had one free weekend since the recall. They have done over a 1000 laps of Leipzig with GT3's to find a fix the issue (I've seen a video and it's impressive to see 5-6 GT3's lapping as hard as they can, relentlessly). We will get all the info on Monday, but it seems it's the conrod bolts which aren't in spec.
Porsche is very aware the owners are not happy and they had a whole team working on the compensation package. Apparently GT3 owners still are Porsche's most valued customers as they consider us technically versed, good drivers, brand loyal and aware of the heritage (we are internally ranked higher priority than Turbo or 918 owners!).
Anyway we are all getting new engines, current owners first (in the order of delivery) and undelivered cars next.
All details will be sent to the aftersales guys Monday afternoon in Europe, so we will get official letters on Tuesday.
I'll keep you posted!
PS: cup and RSR are currently testing with the DFI engine and a Turbo with energy recovery (like F1) so that they cover all bases for next regulations.
Yesterday I had dinner with the chief aftersales manager from my PC (lifelong friend of mine) he was in Barcelona for the presentation of the Macan and they talked about the GT3 too. It's VERY sure we'll all get new engines, the GT development team (Preuninger included) have not had one free weekend since the recall. They have done over a 1000 laps of Leipzig with GT3's to find a fix the issue (I've seen a video and it's impressive to see 5-6 GT3's lapping as hard as they can, relentlessly). We will get all the info on Monday, but it seems it's the conrod bolts which aren't in spec.
Porsche is very aware the owners are not happy and they had a whole team working on the compensation package. Apparently GT3 owners still are Porsche's most valued customers as they consider us technically versed, good drivers, brand loyal and aware of the heritage (we are internally ranked higher priority than Turbo or 918 owners!).
Anyway we are all getting new engines, current owners first (in the order of delivery) and undelivered cars next.
All details will be sent to the aftersales guys Monday afternoon in Europe, so we will get official letters on Tuesday.
I'll keep you posted!
PS: cup and RSR are currently testing with the DFI engine and a Turbo with energy recovery (like F1) so that they cover all bases for next regulations.
#2381
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Sounds more like buttering up and kissing *** for the fact they've alienated their most loyal customer base over the past few years and this time, possibly for the last time...
#2382
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Hello, long time since I last posted!
Yesterday I had dinner with the chief aftersales manager from my PC (lifelong friend of mine) he was in Barcelona for the presentation of the Macan and they talked about the GT3 too. It's VERY sure we'll all get new engines, the GT development team (Preuninger included) have not had one free weekend since the recall. They have done over a 1000 laps of Leipzig with GT3's to find a fix the issue (I've seen a video and it's impressive to see 5-6 GT3's lapping as hard as they can, relentlessly). We will get all the info on Monday, but it seems it's the conrod bolts which aren't in spec.
Porsche is very aware the owners are not happy and they had a whole team working on the compensation package. Apparently GT3 owners still are Porsche's most valued customers as they consider us technically versed, good drivers, brand loyal and aware of the heritage (we are internally ranked higher priority than Turbo or 918 owners!).
Anyway we are all getting new engines, current owners first (in the order of delivery) and undelivered cars next.
All details will be sent to the aftersales guys Monday afternoon in Europe, so we will get official letters on Tuesday.
I'll keep you posted!
PS: cup and RSR are currently testing with the DFI engine and a Turbo with energy recovery (like F1) so that they cover all bases for next regulations.
Yesterday I had dinner with the chief aftersales manager from my PC (lifelong friend of mine) he was in Barcelona for the presentation of the Macan and they talked about the GT3 too. It's VERY sure we'll all get new engines, the GT development team (Preuninger included) have not had one free weekend since the recall. They have done over a 1000 laps of Leipzig with GT3's to find a fix the issue (I've seen a video and it's impressive to see 5-6 GT3's lapping as hard as they can, relentlessly). We will get all the info on Monday, but it seems it's the conrod bolts which aren't in spec.
Porsche is very aware the owners are not happy and they had a whole team working on the compensation package. Apparently GT3 owners still are Porsche's most valued customers as they consider us technically versed, good drivers, brand loyal and aware of the heritage (we are internally ranked higher priority than Turbo or 918 owners!).
Anyway we are all getting new engines, current owners first (in the order of delivery) and undelivered cars next.
All details will be sent to the aftersales guys Monday afternoon in Europe, so we will get official letters on Tuesday.
I'll keep you posted!
PS: cup and RSR are currently testing with the DFI engine and a Turbo with energy recovery (like F1) so that they cover all bases for next regulations.
With that said, I have a few questions:
1. Why is PAG replacing the longblock? Why not the short block? More importantly, why not just update each car's present rotating assembly by replacing the problematic rod bolts? It seems inefficient to replace an entire engine simply for rod bolts.
2. What is included in this "compensation package"?
3. Do you mean the Cup and RSR programs are currently testing the 9A1 block?
Thanks for the update, TomTom!
#2383
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Hello, long time since I last posted!
Yesterday I had dinner with the chief aftersales manager from my PC (lifelong friend of mine) he was in Barcelona for the presentation of the Macan and they talked about the GT3 too. It's VERY sure we'll all get new engines, the GT development team (Preuninger included) have not had one free weekend since the recall. They have done over a 1000 laps of Leipzig with GT3's to find a fix the issue (I've seen a video and it's impressive to see 5-6 GT3's lapping as hard as they can, relentlessly). We will get all the info on Monday, but it seems it's the conrod bolts which aren't in spec.
Porsche is very aware the owners are not happy and they had a whole team working on the compensation package. Apparently GT3 owners still are Porsche's most valued customers as they consider us technically versed, good drivers, brand loyal and aware of the heritage (we are internally ranked higher priority than Turbo or 918 owners!).
Anyway we are all getting new engines, current owners first (in the order of delivery) and undelivered cars next.
All details will be sent to the aftersales guys Monday afternoon in Europe, so we will get official letters on Tuesday.
I'll keep you posted!
PS: cup and RSR are currently testing with the DFI engine and a Turbo with energy recovery (like F1) so that they cover all bases for next regulations.
Yesterday I had dinner with the chief aftersales manager from my PC (lifelong friend of mine) he was in Barcelona for the presentation of the Macan and they talked about the GT3 too. It's VERY sure we'll all get new engines, the GT development team (Preuninger included) have not had one free weekend since the recall. They have done over a 1000 laps of Leipzig with GT3's to find a fix the issue (I've seen a video and it's impressive to see 5-6 GT3's lapping as hard as they can, relentlessly). We will get all the info on Monday, but it seems it's the conrod bolts which aren't in spec.
Porsche is very aware the owners are not happy and they had a whole team working on the compensation package. Apparently GT3 owners still are Porsche's most valued customers as they consider us technically versed, good drivers, brand loyal and aware of the heritage (we are internally ranked higher priority than Turbo or 918 owners!).
Anyway we are all getting new engines, current owners first (in the order of delivery) and undelivered cars next.
All details will be sent to the aftersales guys Monday afternoon in Europe, so we will get official letters on Tuesday.
I'll keep you posted!
PS: cup and RSR are currently testing with the DFI engine and a Turbo with energy recovery (like F1) so that they cover all bases for next regulations.
Exactly what was quoted almost seven pages before.
According to this most recent article from the renown German WiWo newspaper it is most likely that the rod bolts are failing.
See the interview with Matthias Mueller (only available in German language):
http://www.wiwo.de/unternehmen/auto/...9619970-2.html
See the interview with Matthias Mueller (only available in German language):
http://www.wiwo.de/unternehmen/auto/...9619970-2.html
#2384
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
This last part is incorrect. The rules for 2016 will be set in the summer and Porsche will only then start working on the engine for the race programme depending on what they feel is needed. Mezger engine is homologated until 2020. The LMP car for this season is using a 4cyl turbo with energy recovery.
#2385
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
There seem to be some very short memories on here regarding the way Porsche appear to have treated problems on their cars over the last decade right across the range. From issues big down to small its very much been a case of ignoring design issues and leaving to warranty (or hopefully owners) to fix. Its a simple cost v risk strategy for them in every case. The move towards profit above all else has been gathering pace for a while.
There were engines on the 991 GT3 failed during testing and apparently also during reviews (from rod issues), a simple search should show the heads of those saying as much being bitten off.
IF this is a rod problem and engines are about to be swapped, then its probable that a dice was rolled initially on this but didnt work out quite like they hoped. Failures on the road and with so few miles are harder to brush off than track use failures where owners can be thrown under the bus. Fire also grabs headlines shining a light in a way that a simple blown engine does not
Theres a strong whiff that the issue that is trying to be identified was known all along. If so perhaps this explains the stop sale. There potentially serious risks there if someone is toasted from a decision taken simply on risk strategy.
It sucks massively for all concerned here. I have no dog in this fight, the 991 GT3 does not interest me and I dont own a Porsche road car.
There were engines on the 991 GT3 failed during testing and apparently also during reviews (from rod issues), a simple search should show the heads of those saying as much being bitten off.
IF this is a rod problem and engines are about to be swapped, then its probable that a dice was rolled initially on this but didnt work out quite like they hoped. Failures on the road and with so few miles are harder to brush off than track use failures where owners can be thrown under the bus. Fire also grabs headlines shining a light in a way that a simple blown engine does not
Theres a strong whiff that the issue that is trying to be identified was known all along. If so perhaps this explains the stop sale. There potentially serious risks there if someone is toasted from a decision taken simply on risk strategy.
It sucks massively for all concerned here. I have no dog in this fight, the 991 GT3 does not interest me and I dont own a Porsche road car.