View Poll Results: Who's interested in 3D printed door pocket reinforcements?
Yes
70
95.89%
No
3
4.11%
Voters: 73. You may not vote on this poll
Next 3D printing project.....Door Pocket reinforcements.
#167
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Added the slight projection to the Hifi piece as well and ordered a print. This fixes the problem that the surface under the edge of that pocket is uneven. There are screws which are covered in vinyl. To model an edge that conforms to that isn't practical so the overhang hides the worst of it from above.
#168
Rennlist Member
gmorat, after reading through this thread, it seems youve done a few more prototype prints than you might have expected? I know people have offered to help with the prints, but if you want to run a few iterations at once just for test pieces (because they will be PLA), I can print some sets for you. I dont need any pieces thankfully for my car, but just want to help if you can use it.
#169
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
gmorat, after reading through this thread, it seems youve done a few more prototype prints than you might have expected? I know people have offered to help with the prints, but if you want to run a few iterations at once just for test pieces (because they will be PLA), I can print some sets for you. I dont need any pieces thankfully for my car, but just want to help if you can use it.
G
#170
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
I'm going to try something different because of print quality issues. The pieces are warping in ABS so I may end up going with Shapeways and people would just order the pockets reinforcements they want from them.
As overhangs and underhangs aren't an issue, it would allow me to be more complex with the design without affecting strength but also minimizing material.
As overhangs and underhangs aren't an issue, it would allow me to be more complex with the design without affecting strength but also minimizing material.
#171
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
This is them on Shapeways. I have a set in production. If they turn out as I hope I will make it so that anybody will be able to buy a set off of that site. I'll continue to talk to my printer, but as a low-stress solution for me, I like the thought of outsourcing the production/QA\shipping etc.
G
G
#172
I really appreciate the effort you put into the bumperette delete, and I know it must have been a ton of logistical work.
I think going with Shapeways for future projects is a win-win for you and rennlisters interested in your projects.
I think going with Shapeways for future projects is a win-win for you and rennlisters interested in your projects.
#173
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Hopefully, I'll have them up for people to order early next week. At that point, I will do a similarly elegant Hifi and hang my hat up until something else in my car bugs the crap out of me. Fake pulls to get rid of blanks on the lower dash? Who knows? Suggestions welcome.
G
#176
Burning Brakes
#177
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
A few quick updates......
The price on these is actually going to be in the $50-60 range rather than the previously stated $80-90. They are cheaper to produce than the bumperettes and with the latest refining of the design to remove unnecessary material, the cost were considerably lower than initial projections. If you look at the first post on this thread, you can see how I was so far out as the initial design is military grade and completely over the top.
srbean, 2 new sets of prints are on their way to you. I have a set of the more complex prints on their way to me from Shapeways for my non-hifi car. As soon as that arrives I will test fit them and if they are good, I will put the Shapeways link up on a new thread.
I had to modify the non-hifi piece from what is seen above to reduce the projection from the outside edge which was stopping the piece from sitting in place correctly.
Hifi
Non-hifi
Depending on how the fitting goes for srbean, I'll make a decision on whether to release the hifi pieces as beta, where I am prepared to make small changes to the model based on the feedback I receive.
The benefit of Shapeways for me is that once figured out and proven to be printable, I have no further involvement in their production. It's a set and forget type deal for me. If somebody comes along in 6 months and wants a set, they are there, on the site, ready to be printed.
G
The price on these is actually going to be in the $50-60 range rather than the previously stated $80-90. They are cheaper to produce than the bumperettes and with the latest refining of the design to remove unnecessary material, the cost were considerably lower than initial projections. If you look at the first post on this thread, you can see how I was so far out as the initial design is military grade and completely over the top.
srbean, 2 new sets of prints are on their way to you. I have a set of the more complex prints on their way to me from Shapeways for my non-hifi car. As soon as that arrives I will test fit them and if they are good, I will put the Shapeways link up on a new thread.
I had to modify the non-hifi piece from what is seen above to reduce the projection from the outside edge which was stopping the piece from sitting in place correctly.
Hifi
Non-hifi
Depending on how the fitting goes for srbean, I'll make a decision on whether to release the hifi pieces as beta, where I am prepared to make small changes to the model based on the feedback I receive.
The benefit of Shapeways for me is that once figured out and proven to be printable, I have no further involvement in their production. It's a set and forget type deal for me. If somebody comes along in 6 months and wants a set, they are there, on the site, ready to be printed.
G
#179
Instructor
Join Date: Nov 2015
Location: Bismarck, North Dakota
Posts: 138
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The design with the extension fits very nice. The top and sides look fantastic, and i like the height as it supports the door hatch litch which tended to bow a bet if your elbow leaned on it.
The second set, did not fit well at all. The dimensions were off side to side, and the bottom had a gap. It seems as though this can be taken out of the selection process.
Thanks guys!
Once the other screws are adjusted, this should suck everything up nice, and the fit is superb!
Fantastic, and supports the compartment lid.
Not so good. . . .
The second set, did not fit well at all. The dimensions were off side to side, and the bottom had a gap. It seems as though this can be taken out of the selection process.
Thanks guys!
Once the other screws are adjusted, this should suck everything up nice, and the fit is superb!
Fantastic, and supports the compartment lid.
Not so good. . . .
#180
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Does the overhang sit on top of the original plastic or is there a gap between it and the new piece?
Is the projection a little tight to the side of the pocket or is the clearance close but not rubbing against it?
Is the overhang too thick? If it were a mm thinner would that be better?
Otherwise, I'm pretty happy!
I like the thought of this design which can only be printed in an SLS machine vs just extruding via FDM. I'm trying to make it look as finished and professional as possible, removing material where it isn't necessary.
G
Is the projection a little tight to the side of the pocket or is the clearance close but not rubbing against it?
Is the overhang too thick? If it were a mm thinner would that be better?
Otherwise, I'm pretty happy!
I like the thought of this design which can only be printed in an SLS machine vs just extruding via FDM. I'm trying to make it look as finished and professional as possible, removing material where it isn't necessary.
G