Another exhaust sound data point
#481
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
He talks about how it switches between left and right banks when in 3 cylinder mode to keep the catalytic converters warm. That would still happen with a particulate filter delete pipe, and I don’t expect cat temperatures to change greatly with a filter delete pipe.
He also mentions how this bank switching affects particulate filter temperatures, though I’m not sure why this would matter if you’re using a filter delete pipe. For the North American models, they don’t even have active filters with coating/catalyst/monitoring, they are just sound deadeners that also increase back pressure.
It’s nice to hear the JCR over axle pipes will have heat shielding similar to stock.
On a separate note, JCR-Porsche, do you have any video clips recorded in similar conditions comparing fully stock sound to the sound with GPF delete pipes but keeping the stock muffler? This won’t be a common configuration in Europe because the filter is monitored and used for emissions control, but it sounds like the simplest exhaust mod for North America and other non-OPF markets for those who just want a little more sound than stock.
He also mentions how this bank switching affects particulate filter temperatures, though I’m not sure why this would matter if you’re using a filter delete pipe. For the North American models, they don’t even have active filters with coating/catalyst/monitoring, they are just sound deadeners that also increase back pressure.
It’s nice to hear the JCR over axle pipes will have heat shielding similar to stock.
On a separate note, JCR-Porsche, do you have any video clips recorded in similar conditions comparing fully stock sound to the sound with GPF delete pipes but keeping the stock muffler? This won’t be a common configuration in Europe because the filter is monitored and used for emissions control, but it sounds like the simplest exhaust mod for North America and other non-OPF markets for those who just want a little more sound than stock.
JC
__________________
WE'RE NO LONGER ACTIVE ON THE RENNLIST FORUMS - FOR ALL ENQUIRIES PLEASE CONTACT US VIA THE JCR WEBSITE BELOW
/ / / JCR PORSCHE \ \ \
contact@jcr-developments.com
Facebook | Instagram | Youtube
/ / / JCR PORSCHE \ \ \
contact@jcr-developments.com
Facebook | Instagram | Youtube
The following users liked this post:
metalone (07-03-2020)
#483
His concerns regarding the valves aren't of any relevance to be honest, if the valves were that important they would be electronic valves which allows for much more finite control and also monitoring via the ECU.
He is right however about the EGT and thats one of the reasons why we will be offering our OPF delete pipes only with heat shielding included
He did reach out to ask if we would be interested to supply an exhaust, I kindly declined however I would imagine that he will be running something or other in the not too distant future.
JC
He is right however about the EGT and thats one of the reasons why we will be offering our OPF delete pipes only with heat shielding included
He did reach out to ask if we would be interested to supply an exhaust, I kindly declined however I would imagine that he will be running something or other in the not too distant future.
JC
Offering the OPF delete with heat shielding shows above-average concern, so that is a good sign for me . Personally I pay a lot of attention in how an aftermarket followed OEM principles and carry over things related fo fitment like anti-vibration clamps, that others vendors may say that are unnecessary.. of course this applies to this heat protection/dissipation topic which already some aftermakers are saying that are a waste of time (which would make laughing the engineers at Flacht for sure).
After having bad experiences in the past with aftermarkets companies (that I prefer not to mention), Cargraphic has been the only brand to fit my demands, but now I'm looking forward to see if the JCR OPF delete package would meet this criteria as well.. I really hope so because I'm very keen of having all the reducing weight benefits of Titanium pipes, especially in a car like the 718 Spyder.
I also have the feeling that many people with no monitored OPF would go with only replacing the OPF pipes and keeping the OEM muffler, so actually would be very encouraging to pull the trigger hearing a comparison with the OEM muffler.
Cheers,
#484
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Agree with you with the reasoning about the valves. I don't doubt they play a role maximizing the efficiency of the emission system, but not in the performance department, or at least not when the valves are closed. This guy of Obsessed Garage took the time to record some data at the dyno, I think that his results can be extrapolated to the GT4/Spyder case. Here's the video
Offering the OPF delete with heat shielding shows above-average concern, so that is a good sign for me . Personally I pay a lot of attention in how an aftermarket followed OEM principles and carry over things related fo fitment like anti-vibration clamps, that others vendors may say that are unnecessary.. of course this applies to this heat protection/dissipation topic which already some aftermakers are saying that are a waste of time (which would make laughing the engineers at Flacht for sure).
After having bad experiences in the past with aftermarkets companies (that I prefer not to mention), Cargraphic has been the only brand to fit my demands, but now I'm looking forward to see if the JCR OPF delete package would meet this criteria as well.. I really hope so because I'm very keen of having all the reducing weight benefits of Titanium pipes, especially in a car like the 718 Spyder.
I also have the feeling that many people with no monitored OPF would go with only replacing the OPF pipes and keeping the OEM muffler, so actually would be very encouraging to pull the trigger hearing a comparison with the OEM muffler.
Cheers,
Offering the OPF delete with heat shielding shows above-average concern, so that is a good sign for me . Personally I pay a lot of attention in how an aftermarket followed OEM principles and carry over things related fo fitment like anti-vibration clamps, that others vendors may say that are unnecessary.. of course this applies to this heat protection/dissipation topic which already some aftermakers are saying that are a waste of time (which would make laughing the engineers at Flacht for sure).
After having bad experiences in the past with aftermarkets companies (that I prefer not to mention), Cargraphic has been the only brand to fit my demands, but now I'm looking forward to see if the JCR OPF delete package would meet this criteria as well.. I really hope so because I'm very keen of having all the reducing weight benefits of Titanium pipes, especially in a car like the 718 Spyder.
I also have the feeling that many people with no monitored OPF would go with only replacing the OPF pipes and keeping the OEM muffler, so actually would be very encouraging to pull the trigger hearing a comparison with the OEM muffler.
Cheers,
I ran aftermarket OAP on my 2013 Boxster for 3 years and noted no adverse effects, but that was only a 305HP engine as opposed to 414HP, I would think that the more powerful engine produces more heat?
#485
Regarding heat dissipation, I am following this as well, all but one company (IIRC) have said that on the over axel pipe that it was not needed, but I am inclined to believe that the factory installed it there for a valid reason, dismissing it out of hand seems dangerous, maybe not in the short term as the effects and damage may take time to show but for those of us who keep our cars for more than a couple of years it is a real consideration.
I ran aftermarket OAP on my 2013 Boxster for 3 years and noted no adverse effects, but that was only a 305HP engine as opposed to 414HP, I would think that the more powerful engine produces more heat?
I ran aftermarket OAP on my 2013 Boxster for 3 years and noted no adverse effects, but that was only a 305HP engine as opposed to 414HP, I would think that the more powerful engine produces more heat?
#486
Rennlist Member
Quite a cool comparison of a 100% OEM 991.2 GT3 vs our 718 GT4 installed with JCR OPF Delete Pipes / JCR Titanium Silenced Valved Race Pipe
https://youtu.be/BbHse3q9XPA
As we all know, its extremely difficult to capture the true tone and sound in a video however comparing different cars with exactly the same equipment minutes apart does give a better idea. We all know how good a GT3 sounds so this is a great insight
All being well, tomorrow whilst on track we will be able to gather direct comparisons of a 981 GT4 vs our 718 GT4 for another interesting comparison
JC
https://youtu.be/BbHse3q9XPA
As we all know, its extremely difficult to capture the true tone and sound in a video however comparing different cars with exactly the same equipment minutes apart does give a better idea. We all know how good a GT3 sounds so this is a great insight
All being well, tomorrow whilst on track we will be able to gather direct comparisons of a 981 GT4 vs our 718 GT4 for another interesting comparison
JC
#487
Cargraphic is offering three types of OPF Pipes, one of them looks like is empty inside, but I'll inquiry to be sure. The main advantage of this is that the fitment is exact, all the OEM brackets and supports will remain to fulfill it's purpose and most important, the OEM heat shields will remain
Link
CARGRAPHIC Otto Particulate Filter Replacement / Housing Set
- without filter insert
- witouht sensor connections
Part No. CARP82GT4OPFER
Link
CARGRAPHIC Otto Particulate Filter Replacement / Housing Set
- without filter insert
- witouht sensor connections
Part No. CARP82GT4OPFER
Last edited by metalone; 07-04-2020 at 05:27 PM.
The following users liked this post:
Croc999 (07-07-2020)
#488
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Regarding heat dissipation, I am following this as well, all but one company (IIRC) have said that on the over axel pipe that it was not needed, but I am inclined to believe that the factory installed it there for a valid reason, dismissing it out of hand seems dangerous, maybe not in the short term as the effects and damage may take time to show but for those of us who keep our cars for more than a couple of years it is a real consideration.
I ran aftermarket OAP on my 2013 Boxster for 3 years and noted no adverse effects, but that was only a 305HP engine as opposed to 414HP, I would think that the more powerful engine produces more heat?
I ran aftermarket OAP on my 2013 Boxster for 3 years and noted no adverse effects, but that was only a 305HP engine as opposed to 414HP, I would think that the more powerful engine produces more heat?
Cargraphic is offering three types of OPF Pipes, one of them looks like is empty inside, but I'll inquiry to be sure. The main advantage of this is that the fitment is exact, all the OEM brackets and supports will remain to fulfill it's purpose and most important, the OEM heat shields will remain
Link
CARGRAPHIC Otto Particulate Filter Replacement / Housing Set
- without filter insert
- witouht sensor connections
Part No. CARP82GT4OPFER
Link
CARGRAPHIC Otto Particulate Filter Replacement / Housing Set
- without filter insert
- witouht sensor connections
Part No. CARP82GT4OPFER
JC
#489
I believe this is more for the EU market where the cars need to pass visual inspection so an OEM ‘look’ is important. Saying that, still no heat insulation over axle and running that canister design without any substrate is creating its own issues rather than solving them
JC
JC
They offer this for non-EU markets as well. The EU has a high flow OPF inside ( monitored ) and for ROW they offer one with a filter and another empty. I think that the heat insulation consist on reusing the stock wrapping as this are the same shape.
#490
Cargraphic is offering three types of OPF Pipes, one of them looks like is empty inside, but I'll inquiry to be sure. The main advantage of this is that the fitment is exact, all the OEM brackets and supports will remain to fulfill it's purpose and most important, the OEM heat shields will remain
Link
CARGRAPHIC Otto Particulate Filter Replacement / Housing Set
- without filter insert
- witouht sensor connections
Part No. CARP82GT4OPFER
Link
CARGRAPHIC Otto Particulate Filter Replacement / Housing Set
- without filter insert
- witouht sensor connections
Part No. CARP82GT4OPFER
how much does it cost?
#492
Supersprint also publish some videos of the the product they're building...
#493
#494
It's here... :/ not sure I love it though, sounds like they didn't merge the center bit like JCR and most other options.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y4ohf6eItVU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y4ohf6eItVU
#495