strut tower failure
#241
Rennlist Member
Again, compared to the GT3 engine problems I can live with the GT4 issues. I don't regret the switch.
#242
Drifting
Nah, I wouldn't be willing to let GT4 money sit tied up in a bubble wrapped car; I'd sooner sell it to buy something else that will give me some actual enjoyment for my cash. But I didn't stop driving my E92 M3 as a result of the Great Rod Bearing Scare, so I don't intend to change how I drive the GT4 as a result of these issues. I also have a 2015 production GT4, which so far at least has not had a report of a gearbox problem. At least that issue is being covered under warranty, although I definitely sympathize with owners who are having to wait forever to actually GET the replacement gearbox, especially since thus far there's no reason to believe that the replacement will last any longer. Sigh....
#243
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: On a pygmy pony over by the dental floss bush
Posts: 3,307
Received 615 Likes
on
420 Posts
The 3rd gear problem doesn't concern me much at all, other than it's a major PITA to wait on the replacement gearbox and the shop work, and not knowing when the solid fix will be in replacement gearboxes and which cars will never need them.
#244
Burning Brakes
Nah, I wouldn't be willing to let GT4 money sit tied up in a bubble wrapped car; I'd sooner sell it to buy something else that will give me some actual enjoyment for my cash. But I didn't stop driving my E92 M3 as a result of the Great Rod Bearing Scare, so I don't intend to change how I drive the GT4 as a result of these issues. I also have a 2015 production GT4, which so far at least has not had a report of a gearbox problem. At least that issue is being covered under warranty, although I definitely sympathize with owners who are having to wait forever to actually GET the replacement gearbox, especially since thus far there's no reason to believe that the replacement will last any longer. Sigh....
#245
Technology Porsche should use to help reduce this issue on all of their vehicles.
Pothole Detection available now on the $33,000 2017 Ford Fusion Sport.
Technology that can detect potholes and adjusts the active suspension damping to the affected shock that keeps the tire and wheel from dropping as deeply into the pothole.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YK3U...ature=youtu.be
Pothole Detection available now on the $33,000 2017 Ford Fusion Sport.
Technology that can detect potholes and adjusts the active suspension damping to the affected shock that keeps the tire and wheel from dropping as deeply into the pothole.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YK3U...ature=youtu.be
Last edited by Track Junkie; 12-14-2016 at 11:48 PM.
#246
I think with the tower failing it saves damage to the rest of the chassis, if it didn't give, it would probably twist or break something more costly
Last edited by Window Cleaner; 01-15-2017 at 05:46 AM.
#247
Drifting
If that were true, I would expect this failure mode to be better known from experience with other cars, but it seems that what normally happens is the wheel absorbs the brunt of the impact to avoid passing it up into the chassis (or perhaps it DOES get passed up into the chassis and everything up there is just strong enough not to give). But yes I suppose if this area were reinforced and nothing else were changed, then theoretically something even more expensive would be damaged/broken, but even that doesn't address the issue that even if the strut tower were designed to be the sacrificial component, it shouldn't be failing under the circumstances that the ones in these cars have been.
#248
If that were true, I would expect this failure mode to be better known from experience with other cars, but it seems that what normally happens is the wheel absorbs the brunt of the impact to avoid passing it up into the chassis (or perhaps it DOES get passed up into the chassis and everything up there is just strong enough not to give). But yes I suppose if this area were reinforced and nothing else were changed, then theoretically something even more expensive would be damaged/broken, but even that doesn't address the issue that even if the strut tower were designed to be the sacrificial component, it shouldn't be failing under the circumstances that the ones in these cars have been.
Pothole depth, car speed, braking, angle of impact, tire pressure, modifications, etc. I haven't seen the specifics.
I don't think any similar aluminum chassis sports car made now can survive all potholes regardless of pothole size or vehicle speed.
#250
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: On a pygmy pony over by the dental floss bush
Posts: 3,307
Received 615 Likes
on
420 Posts
We do not know yet that just hitting a "pothole" will cause this failure. Joe Weinstein's failure on public roads at highway speeds after hitting a "small dip" in the road does not indicate these shock towers fail after one such event. Joe's car may have experienced a severe impact before he took delivery of the car. Cars experience all kinds of damage during factory-to-dealer transportation, so who knows? We simply just don't have enough information at this time to jump to the conclusion that a single pothole impact causes this failure on GT4 (or GT3 ) cars. Interesting study on potholes, yes, but that doesn't necessarily transfer as something that analyzes the issue we're seeing on some of the 981 (or 991) cars.
Think about it. How many 981 and 991 GT cars with the same camber plate and shock/strut have hit bumps, potholes, racetrack berms, etc., and never so much as missed a beat, with no shock tower rupture.
Think about it. How many 981 and 991 GT cars with the same camber plate and shock/strut have hit bumps, potholes, racetrack berms, etc., and never so much as missed a beat, with no shock tower rupture.
Last edited by okie981; 12-16-2016 at 09:22 AM.
#251
Rennlist Member
It's hard to imagine a repair more costly than a $25,000 or $30,000 structural replacement with collateral damage. The only thing worse would be irreparable damage to the structure, which this repair is dangerously close to due to associated costs. The repair would easily total a used 981 Cayman or Cayman S.
The road wheel should be first line in a line of sacrificial metal, followed by a suspension arm or the like—in other words, things that bolt to the car's structure.
A long line of Porsches and other automobiles sets a precedent that makes the failure seen in these GT4s hard to swallow. These cars probably aren't being used any harder out of the box than 996 and 997 GT2/GT3s were—and they should certainly fare better than 30-50yo Porsches being used on track and for autocross.
It's important to remember the we are still seeing only tiny numbers of these failures in terms of percentages. However, they are nevertheless alarming due to their nature, repair cost, and frequency within a short period of time in essentially new cars.
#253
Race Car
What they have done is reduce the suspension travel by lowering the car. So now it bottoms out quicker and what it hits is a brittle piece of thin, inherently brittle cast aluminum They need to redesign the shock giving it more travel before it bottoms out . Its that simple. carl
#254
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: On a pygmy pony over by the dental floss bush
Posts: 3,307
Received 615 Likes
on
420 Posts
What they have done is reduce the suspension travel by lowering the car. So now it bottoms out quicker and what it hits is a brittle piece of thin, inherently brittle cast aluminum They need to redesign the shock giving it more travel before it bottoms out . Its that simple. carl
#255
And if they'd approve a kit to allow a decent range of alignment so I could
get an honest 2.5 degrees of negative camber without lowering the car from
as-delivered ride height, I might have never had this happen.
get an honest 2.5 degrees of negative camber without lowering the car from
as-delivered ride height, I might have never had this happen.