718 GT4?
#6751
Welcome to the Wonderfull World of Porsche. I haven't got a GT car and I want one before we are all forced into autonomous EV's. It needs to be as analogue as possible. Loud as hell, heavy clutch and a hard ride! Give it to me! Take my money!
#6752
Rennlist Member
#6754
Rennlist Member
Just speculating on my part... Let's assume a GT4 RS (with PDK) will be made available next year or so. A friend of a friend told me that he knows "for sure" this will happen @ a price of about 120k€. Such GT4 RS would have the GT3 engine, maybe slightly detuned to about 475hp.
Now, wouldn't it make more sense to use a simplified version (not that I am knowledgeable about engines, but deleting the expensive parts that let it rev to 9k) of the 4.0 GT3 to make a standard GT4 with 420hp vs using the old 3,8 from the new ClubSport?
Now, wouldn't it make more sense to use a simplified version (not that I am knowledgeable about engines, but deleting the expensive parts that let it rev to 9k) of the 4.0 GT3 to make a standard GT4 with 420hp vs using the old 3,8 from the new ClubSport?
#6755
The difference between a Carrera engine and a GT3 engine is essentially "the expensive parts". The Porsche product line is very modular and essentially a Carrera engine is a detuned GT3 engine and a GT3 engine is a tuned Carrera engine. The media and many on this thread seem quite obsessed with the engine being a "detuned GT3". It is really just semantics and marketing spin... I recommend to focus on the actual performance stats like HP and RPM and not get hung up on the pedigree or perceived lack there of...
#6757
Burning Brakes
The difference between a Carrera engine and a GT3 engine is essentially "the expensive parts". The Porsche product line is very modular and essentially a Carrera engine is a detuned GT3 engine and a GT3 engine is a tuned Carrera engine. The media and many on this thread seem quite obsessed with the engine being a "detuned GT3". It is really just semantics and marketing spin... I recommend to focus on the actual performance stats like HP and RPM and not get hung up on the pedigree or perceived lack there of...
Also, the engine doesn’t cost porsche that much, the retail prices quoted don’t equate to the supply cost. It costs more than a 9A1 for sure but it’s marginal compared to the cost of research and Development, international certification, plant tooling costs etc to put a new engine in the 718 GT4 and Spydet that will only sell a few thousand units world wide before they go electric.
That being said, Porsche may intend to sell many more than last time based on the previous success and was able to make a business case that a new engine, or at least a heavily revised one, is warranted.
Again, I’m not expecting it to happen but for those of us who spend a lot of time on the track it would be nice to have that extra little comfort in engineering.
#6758
That GT4 has the red brake calipers while the one from 04/12 by "cvdzijden" had the yellow ones..
Edit: there are 3 different GT4's!
Plate xx 852 has yellow calipers, plates xx 8580 and xx 873 the standard red brakes
Edit: there are 3 different GT4's!
Plate xx 852 has yellow calipers, plates xx 8580 and xx 873 the standard red brakes
#6759
#6760
But I do agree with your statement......for those that track durability and the manufacturer standing behind the product even when used on track is very important.
#6761
Three Wheelin'
I’m more interested in track durability than I am in a car manufacturer’s published performance numbers. Those “expensive parts” make a difference. Forged rods and crank, a true dry sump, upgraded oil pumps for the top end etc.
Also, the engine doesn’t cost porsche that much, the retail prices quoted don’t equate to the supply cost. It costs more than a 9A1 for sure but it’s marginal compared to the cost of research and Development, international certification, plant tooling costs etc to put a new engine in the 718 GT4 and Spydet that will only sell a few thousand units world wide before they go electric.
That being said, Porsche may intend to sell many more than last time based on the previous success and was able to make a business case that a new engine, or at least a heavily revised one, is warranted.
Again, I’m not expecting it to happen but for those of us who spend a lot of time on the track it would be nice to have that extra little comfort in engineering.
Also, the engine doesn’t cost porsche that much, the retail prices quoted don’t equate to the supply cost. It costs more than a 9A1 for sure but it’s marginal compared to the cost of research and Development, international certification, plant tooling costs etc to put a new engine in the 718 GT4 and Spydet that will only sell a few thousand units world wide before they go electric.
That being said, Porsche may intend to sell many more than last time based on the previous success and was able to make a business case that a new engine, or at least a heavily revised one, is warranted.
Again, I’m not expecting it to happen but for those of us who spend a lot of time on the track it would be nice to have that extra little comfort in engineering.
718 GT4cs kept the 3.8, that engine will probably have more race miles on it than anything else in the PMA catalog.
#6762
Burning Brakes
Be careful there....981 GT4 turned out to be more reliable in the engine department than the 991.1 GT3...and we just had a lowly de-tuned 991 Carrera S engine.
But I do agree with your statement......for those that track durability and the manufacturer standing behind the product even when used on track is very important.
But I do agree with your statement......for those that track durability and the manufacturer standing behind the product even when used on track is very important.
Great point! I have a 9A1 in my 99.1S too and have come to love the lump for what it is.
#6763
I mean... they're blowing out transmissions left right and center but the engines are rock solid!!
#6764