997.1 ENGINE SWAP Thread: K24!
It's funny seeing all the purists come barging in. To each his own, we can coexist. More curiosity, less animosity.
A few weeks back, went on a road trip to pick up my buddy's DC5 with EFR turbo from TCS up in CT, took turns driving it few hours at a time, I couldn't wipe the stupid grin off my face.
It's funny seeing all the purists come barging in. To each his own, we can coexist. More curiosity, less animosity.
A few weeks back, went on a road trip to pick up my buddy's DC5 with EFR turbo from TCS up in CT, took turns driving it few hours at a time, I couldn't wipe the stupid grin off my face.
and in the case of this one, when you lose an engine in a car with only 40,000 miles on it, you have to scratch your head… I hate fixing other people‘s F ups lol
The Best Porsche Posts for Porsche Enthusiasts
Here's a question, I keep hearing (even in this very thread) that the K will be low torque, not as good on the street, peaky. Also, in the same breath talk about how great NA engines are, especially when you can keep the revs up high. Which one is it? The "low torque" turbo application sucks because the revs have to be kept high, or the NA application is great because you have to keep the revs high?
Here's a dyno graph from one of Nick's videos overlaying a stock 986 2.7 L 240 hp (PURITY!!!!) Porsche engine and a stock, Naturally Aspirated K24. Would someone please point to the part of the graph where the K has drivability issues, low torque, no low-down power, or for that matter a peaky, unusable powerband? I do see at least 1500 RPM of 'more fun' at the top end and the area under the curve is massively different, so it wouldn't be hard to guess which one would win in a drag race, all else equal (which they aren't since the K and trans combo is quite a bit lighter).
Here's a K24 at 11 psi with the 2.7 overlay (underlay, I guess). To me it looks like it's a very linear curve that climbs and climbs and climbs in power until you shift. Isn't that what you want in a sports car?
.....Being a purist is appreciating the sound/feel/design of the 911 engine from it's early years to current 997. ---->Porsche engine is unique in sound and torque/etc.which is something I like/admire.
Throwing a different engine in the back might be a fun for some but it devalues the car and just isn't what I would ever consider buying.
But who cares what anyone thinks as long as you don't mind a much smaller buyer market and lost money out the window when selling.
.....Being a purist is appreciating the sound/feel/design of the 911 engine from it's early years to current 997. ---->Porsche engine is unique in sound and torque/etc.which is something I like/admire.
Throwing a different engine in the back might be a fun for some but it devalues the car and just isn't what I would ever consider buying.
But who cares what anyone thinks as long as you don't mind a much smaller buyer market and lost money out the window when selling.
.....Being a purist is appreciating the sound/feel/design of the 911 engine from it's early years to current 997. ---->Porsche engine is unique in sound and torque/etc.which is something I like/admire.
Throwing a different engine in the back might be a fun for some but it devalues the car and just isn't what I would ever consider buying.
But who cares what anyone thinks as long as you don't mind a much smaller buyer market and lost money out the window when selling.




