WTF...Water Pumps!
#76
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
This may be the first water pump out of 50,000 factory installs and all the replacements over the years that has seized with <500 miles on it(or maybe not, but bear with me).
This just proves what I said, and what Sterling expanded on so eloquently. It's impossible to manufacture any assembly that will have a failure rate of "0". I think that most of us would **** and moan about a new pump leaking right away... hell, I pissed and moaned about mine leaking from the seal at 26K. But that isn't such a big deal in the scheme of things... it happens, and you have plenty of warning to fix it before the bearing goes out, unless you never look under the hood.
What's really scary is that this one seized. Personally, I'm not really interested in leaky pumps. What I want to know is, how many pumps have been known to seize, from any source, at whatever mileage? Let's not count pumps that were run long after they started leaking, to the point where the bearing failed and they dug into the block.
I'm still very interested to know what happened here. Aside from the two failure modes that I already speculated on, another possibility is that the seal/bearing cartridge moved in the bore causing it to bind.
This just proves what I said, and what Sterling expanded on so eloquently. It's impossible to manufacture any assembly that will have a failure rate of "0". I think that most of us would **** and moan about a new pump leaking right away... hell, I pissed and moaned about mine leaking from the seal at 26K. But that isn't such a big deal in the scheme of things... it happens, and you have plenty of warning to fix it before the bearing goes out, unless you never look under the hood.
What's really scary is that this one seized. Personally, I'm not really interested in leaky pumps. What I want to know is, how many pumps have been known to seize, from any source, at whatever mileage? Let's not count pumps that were run long after they started leaking, to the point where the bearing failed and they dug into the block.
I'm still very interested to know what happened here. Aside from the two failure modes that I already speculated on, another possibility is that the seal/bearing cartridge moved in the bore causing it to bind.
#77
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I have to agree with Sean R. on this whole water pump affair. The amount of failures experienced by the masses and what has been noted by Mark A. is very low and this thread really escalated.
From my vantage point there are currently only two real options available:
1. Buy a new Porsche pump
2. Buy a new Laso pump.
As others have noted and as we all well know, being mechanical devices there will be failures, no way around it.
What I find a bit surprising is how much concern this water pump issue generates given the amount of failures seen. There seems to be more instances of thrust bearing failure (TBF) of 928 engines than there are catastrophic failures of 928 engines caused by defective water pumps. However, people are willing to risk using inferior methods to counteract a known problem that could lead to TBF. A bit ironic really.
Yes, the last statement is a bit self serving, but true.
From my vantage point there are currently only two real options available:
1. Buy a new Porsche pump
2. Buy a new Laso pump.
As others have noted and as we all well know, being mechanical devices there will be failures, no way around it.
What I find a bit surprising is how much concern this water pump issue generates given the amount of failures seen. There seems to be more instances of thrust bearing failure (TBF) of 928 engines than there are catastrophic failures of 928 engines caused by defective water pumps. However, people are willing to risk using inferior methods to counteract a known problem that could lead to TBF. A bit ironic really.
Yes, the last statement is a bit self serving, but true.
#78
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I agree Constantine. 100%
#79
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Just my thoughts....I have to agree with the Pros here. When you look at the incidence of catastrophic issues, the thrust bearing would be my first concern by a huge margin for A/T units. (Which I own). And frankly, I really don't think that Constantine's point was all that self-serving but rather accurate. (There are other methods and theories to prevent the TT shift, but having said that, his solution seems the utlimate with current technology), so all in, you really have to deal with the fact that there is no mechanical system that is truly failsafe (or if there is it certainly will not be cost effective with the level of redundancy which would be required to achieve anything approaching the ideal on any relatively complex system). Does a certain shuttle launch and or reentry come to mind? You do the best with what you've got, and considering the options available, a new water pump at the cost of roughly a quarter of the cost of one having the Porsche logo on it will do for me at this point. You have to consider the cost/benefit reality. We really have no significant data on the failure rate (for whatever reason) for the Porsche "New" units versus the quality new and reman units. So, it comes down to what's it worth to you? Personally, I can deal with the odds. Where I'd really freak though, is if I had indeed paid the freight for a Porshe "New" unit, and it took out the top end.
#80
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
find this thread and ones like it funny.
Bearings, seals etc. all fail eventually and there are always a few which fail almost right away. This is the nature of things.
If you have only had 4 pumps fail in 40 years or so which is the impression I get from your first post. That is a VERY VERY small percentage. And I can tell you that domestics have more failures than that too.
Bearings, seals etc. all fail eventually and there are always a few which fail almost right away. This is the nature of things.
If you have only had 4 pumps fail in 40 years or so which is the impression I get from your first post. That is a VERY VERY small percentage. And I can tell you that domestics have more failures than that too.
#81
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Gone. On the Open Road
Posts: 16,535
Received 1,674 Likes
on
1,087 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
If 1% of water pumps fail and provide evidence though leaking then in the statistical scheme of things it isn't a big deal. The probability of motor loss is very low provided that the leaking water pump is quickly replaced.
If 1% of water pumps fail due to bearing cartridge migration and the metal impeller machines the block then it is a bigger deal. But, not catastrophic.
But, if 1% of pumps fail and the mode is seizure, then it is a very big deal.
The probability of catastrophic loss depends upon the nature of the failure mode. A well-designed part (or system) fails in such a way that the most common modes have low risk of loss while the high-loss-risk modes are very, very uncommon.
So far, IIRC, this forum has seen one catastrophic failure of a rebuilt water pump on a high-power motor. If Doc Brown didn't have quick reflexes it would have been two. We have seen lots of leaking pumps, some under-rotating plastic impellers and some machined blocks. But, very few seizures.
#82
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
In general, we've seen very few failures. Should there be a better, or more updated solution for us? Hell yes, but the issue we run upon is who puts the tooling costs up. Who is going to put the neck out there for the solution.
I'd love to see what Sterling is talking about. Someone would need to get the design, the tooling, the 50k miles of testing to see if it works. That is the problem we run in to. Most of the stuff that is coming out for our cars from Carl, Mark A, DR, Roger is all development on their own dime. As of late I wonder what it would take for all of the BIG 4 to pool resources to get a solution.
There has been talk about an electric, or pulley driven. What would it take for everyone to actually get past ego's and come up with a solution?
I know that there are several that are working on it, testing it, and hope to get a better solution to market, the issues are cost vs return. Which leads us right back to what we are dealing with, which is a .5% failure rate. Which to me, is a damn good %, unless I'm one of those cars.
If everything on the cars is in top knotch condition, Cams gears, oil gear, tensioner, tensioner bolt/bushings (go Porken, those are gone) rollers etc and you can narrow the failure to the water pump, I'd believe that there is an issue with the pumps. Right now, with my limited experience, I've seen other components fail first.
I'd love to see what Sterling is talking about. Someone would need to get the design, the tooling, the 50k miles of testing to see if it works. That is the problem we run in to. Most of the stuff that is coming out for our cars from Carl, Mark A, DR, Roger is all development on their own dime. As of late I wonder what it would take for all of the BIG 4 to pool resources to get a solution.
There has been talk about an electric, or pulley driven. What would it take for everyone to actually get past ego's and come up with a solution?
I know that there are several that are working on it, testing it, and hope to get a better solution to market, the issues are cost vs return. Which leads us right back to what we are dealing with, which is a .5% failure rate. Which to me, is a damn good %, unless I'm one of those cars.
If everything on the cars is in top knotch condition, Cams gears, oil gear, tensioner, tensioner bolt/bushings (go Porken, those are gone) rollers etc and you can narrow the failure to the water pump, I'd believe that there is an issue with the pumps. Right now, with my limited experience, I've seen other components fail first.
#83
Former Vendor
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I agree and this point represents a set of details omitted from H's risk analysis.
If 1% of water pumps fail and provide evidence though leaking then in the statistical scheme of things it isn't a big deal. The probability of motor loss is very low provided that the leaking water pump is quickly replaced.
If 1% of water pumps fail due to bearing cartridge migration and the metal impeller machines the block then it is a bigger deal. But, not catastrophic.
But, if 1% of pumps fail and the mode is seizure, then it is a very big deal.
The probability of catastrophic loss depends upon the nature of the failure mode. A well-designed part (or system) fails in such a way that the most common modes have low risk of loss while the high-loss-risk modes are very, very uncommon.
So far, IIRC, this forum has seen one catastrophic failure of a rebuilt water pump on a high-power motor. If Doc Brown didn't have quick reflexes it would have been two. We have seen lots of leaking pumps, some under-rotating plastic impellers and some machined blocks. But, very few seizures.
If 1% of water pumps fail and provide evidence though leaking then in the statistical scheme of things it isn't a big deal. The probability of motor loss is very low provided that the leaking water pump is quickly replaced.
If 1% of water pumps fail due to bearing cartridge migration and the metal impeller machines the block then it is a bigger deal. But, not catastrophic.
But, if 1% of pumps fail and the mode is seizure, then it is a very big deal.
The probability of catastrophic loss depends upon the nature of the failure mode. A well-designed part (or system) fails in such a way that the most common modes have low risk of loss while the high-loss-risk modes are very, very uncommon.
So far, IIRC, this forum has seen one catastrophic failure of a rebuilt water pump on a high-power motor. If Doc Brown didn't have quick reflexes it would have been two. We have seen lots of leaking pumps, some under-rotating plastic impellers and some machined blocks. But, very few seizures.
I can't accept a new pump that seizes, without some sort of warning...like a loud bearing noise. I sincerely doubt that the bearing in these pumps, which appears to be of good quality, can just quit turning, suddenly. That would suggest that something must have "migrated" far enough to keep the pump from turning.
It will be next week, before we get this pump off the engine.....especially since the "new" pump needs to come from Germany. I'll be interested to see what happened.
#84
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Gone. On the Open Road
Posts: 16,535
Received 1,674 Likes
on
1,087 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I can't accept a new pump that seizes, without some sort of warning...like a loud bearing noise.
I have a PCNA plastic impeller rebuilt in my twin-screwed car. So, I'm all ears on water pump stories for the high-power motors.
I've made my opinion and preference known on the other water pump threads. But, in summary: I'd pay good money several times every year for a water pump wherein the seizure failure mode was a practical impossibility or was always followed by warning signs like leaking, etc.
That would suggest that something must have "migrated" far enough to keep the pump from turning.
#85
Rest in Peace
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Bird lover in Sharpsburg
Posts: 9,903
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
My failure with a new waterpump is a matter of fact and can be found with a search.
The thing that is different for Greg Brown and myself, and some others here is, even on a stock motor, we have to stand behind it, and it is never that part from Porsche, Lasso or where ever failed, it is I just paid him XXXX.XX dollars to fix my car and it only ran "This long".
We can do a 1000 right, and it only takes one guy to have a problem to give us fits.
l
Guys that fix cars for a living, (Greg Brown fixes cars also, they are just fixed to be faster) are the end guys, we pay (sometimes) the towing, the rental cars, and fix the damage the failed part did.
It is not our fault the part failed, we are the ones that spent the money for the 9201, and the factory oil seal tools.
But if the part fails, we eat it.
The thing that is different for Greg Brown and myself, and some others here is, even on a stock motor, we have to stand behind it, and it is never that part from Porsche, Lasso or where ever failed, it is I just paid him XXXX.XX dollars to fix my car and it only ran "This long".
We can do a 1000 right, and it only takes one guy to have a problem to give us fits.
l
Guys that fix cars for a living, (Greg Brown fixes cars also, they are just fixed to be faster) are the end guys, we pay (sometimes) the towing, the rental cars, and fix the damage the failed part did.
It is not our fault the part failed, we are the ones that spent the money for the 9201, and the factory oil seal tools.
But if the part fails, we eat it.
#86
Under the Lift
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
#88
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I wonder if these failures, as they appear to be increasing , could this be due to odd harmonics from the damper??
how many of these engines are using the stock balancer ???
And how many engines with failures are modified ??
how many of these engines are using the stock balancer ???
And how many engines with failures are modified ??
#89
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I think you missed a few...
#90
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Larry,
From my investigation Bosch and AC Delco do not make pumps for the 928.
I have seen them listed but found they did not exist when ordered.
If they do exist they will be a Laso, MPG (porsche OEM) or Hamburg Technic pump renamed.
I know they would not be Laso as there pump is not sold under any other name.
If it is HT that would be scary.
Roger
From my investigation Bosch and AC Delco do not make pumps for the 928.
I have seen them listed but found they did not exist when ordered.
If they do exist they will be a Laso, MPG (porsche OEM) or Hamburg Technic pump renamed.
I know they would not be Laso as there pump is not sold under any other name.
If it is HT that would be scary.
Roger
__________________
![](https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1694/8685/files/928sRus_rennlist.png?v=1621798567)
Does it have the "Do It Yourself" manual transmission, or the superior "Fully Equipped by Porsche" Automatic Transmission?
George Layton March 2014
928 Owners are ".....a secret sect of quietly assured Porsche pragmatists who in near anonymity appreciate the prodigious, easy going prowess of the 928."![thumbsup](https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/bigok.gif)
![](https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1694/8685/files/928sRus_rennlist.png?v=1621798567)
Does it have the "Do It Yourself" manual transmission, or the superior "Fully Equipped by Porsche" Automatic Transmission?
![thumbsup](https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/bigok.gif)
928 Owners are ".....a secret sect of quietly assured Porsche pragmatists who in near anonymity appreciate the prodigious, easy going prowess of the 928."
![thumbsup](https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/bigok.gif)