"Racing room" not required to be given in PCA club racing?
#151
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Small
Business Sponsor
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Small
Business Sponsor
PCA is unique in that we have the only race group with a 13-13 rule that is actually consistently enforced. We do have very clearly defined passing “rules” that are part of every orientation meeting. Maybe we do need to put them in the book. I am not sure what that would change. We have those clear points defined to be able to make consistent decisions concerning 13-13 incidents.
#152
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
As to judging the corner at turn in, consider a 90° bend. What happens when two cars are near each other coming into the bend and the outside car is in the lead and elects an early turn-in and apex? Does that car "have" the corner and the inside car must back out? My concept of racing room is that if there is reasonable overlap of the two cars when the first car to turn in does so (reasonable being maybe at least 30-50% overlap), then the outside, early-turning car must leave at least 3/4 car width of the racing surface for the inside car to traverse. Driving to the edge of the racing surface and either forcing the inside car to back out, go agricultural or contact the outside car is not leaving racing room.
#153
Rennlist Member
One thing it would change is that those who have not attended an orientation meeting or who do not recall a meeting or who recall it incorrectly would have a definite statement of the rule. I encourage you to put it in the book. Other sanctioning bodies do--see the quotations in the original post.
Nevertheless, it cannot hurt & is simply good business practice to codify them in the rule book.
#154
Race Car
"If they are even + or – they should share the corner."
"Now if you are chasing someone and continue your pass attempt when you are not going to get even by turn in but you might get a couple of feet of overlap prior to the door being closed completely with the guy driving a normal line did you really earn anything? Aren’t you really just being a bully?"
Scott
#155
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
You guys are quick! I revised my question, in hopes of clarifying it, whilst you were typing!
No need to defend Bryan. I did not think I was attacking him and I certainly did not intend to.
"If they are even + or – they should share the corner." If that is the requirement for the leading car to give the following car racing room, it is not consistent with the racing I have thus far done.
No need to defend Bryan. I did not think I was attacking him and I certainly did not intend to.
"If they are even + or – they should share the corner." If that is the requirement for the leading car to give the following car racing room, it is not consistent with the racing I have thus far done.
#157
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
"So far I've raced under UK and German FIA rules and SCCA rules in the US...."
I think the key difference is the amount of overlap that requires one car to give the other car room on the racing surface. Being "even" (even "even + or -") is more overlap than I think other sanctioning bodies require.
I think the key difference is the amount of overlap that requires one car to give the other car room on the racing surface. Being "even" (even "even + or -") is more overlap than I think other sanctioning bodies require.
#158
Drifting
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Suburban DC
Posts: 2,641
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
In Bryan's defense, I will say this: a couple of years ago I was given a provisional PCA race license based on other active licenses I held at the time such as FIA. Nevertheless, I still had to attend the orientation meeting for rookies, provisionals like myself, and those on a 13. Provisionals only had to stay in the meeting for ~30 minutes. But it was made VERY clear to me what the passing rules were, and they directly jibed with whhat Bryan posted above. And I still remember them clearly.
Nevertheless, it cannot hurt & is simply good business practice to codify them in the rule book.
Nevertheless, it cannot hurt & is simply good business practice to codify them in the rule book.
PS: I'm not criticizing the school -- it was great -- just pointing out that the passing rules are not core curriculum.
#159
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Durham, NC and Virginia International Raceway
Posts: 19,068
Received 3,212 Likes
on
1,851 Posts
As a data point, I recently finished SCCA 3 day competition school and passing rules were not discussed at all. There was a comprehensive test on the GCR (which offers the "racing room" concept as the sole guidance on passing), but then we were all just turned loose on track with open passing.
PS: I'm not criticizing the school -- it was great -- just pointing out that the passing rules are not core curriculum.
PS: I'm not criticizing the school -- it was great -- just pointing out that the passing rules are not core curriculum.
__________________
-Peter Krause
www.peterkrause.net
www.gofasternow.com
"Combining the Art and Science of Driving Fast!"
Specializing in Professional, Private Driver Performance Evaluation and Optimization
Consultation Available Remotely and at VIRginia International Raceway
-Peter Krause
www.peterkrause.net
www.gofasternow.com
"Combining the Art and Science of Driving Fast!"
Specializing in Professional, Private Driver Performance Evaluation and Optimization
Consultation Available Remotely and at VIRginia International Raceway
#160
Drifting
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Suburban DC
Posts: 2,641
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
In truth, we had such a mixed group that competitive passing was relatively rare. We had a Formula Atlantic, Formula Ford, a couple of D Sports Racers, a few Formula Vees, F500 and three SRFs... Plenty of passing but much of it was uncontested.
#161
Rennlist Member
I've been following this discussion with interest. As a solid mid-pack racer with just five years' experience, I have to say that so much of what is being discussed comes down to judgement and common sense; the need for a clearly defined "rule" is, I suppose, necessary to separate the combatants and lay blame in the event of an incident, but when we're on the track together, I'd never rely soley on a rule to pass or be passed. When I started out, good friends (who are good racers) took me aside and pointed out that I was making it too easy for people to get by, wrecking my momentum and spoiling any chance I had at a good race with people of like ability. As they said, the faster guys will get by. With seat time, I began to see the track and the action around me a bit more clearly. I also know who the faster guys are, and make an effort to let them through while keeping my own race going. In terms of passing, I'm more confident in myself and in the guys I race with, and I try to have a plan in case I get chopped. Last year at Road America, I raced a guy in the sprint and tried for five laps to get by, couldn't do it. Stuck my nose in at Canada corner on the last lap, and he promptly cut it off. I laughed to myself- he was absolutely correct, and was having none of my lame-*** move, but I was ready when he came down, and followed him meekly to the finish. First sprint race at the Glen recently, followed a fast D car and made an inside pass at turn one; the car I passed gave me room, but little else. I made it stick, and assumed he'd fall in behind as we entered turn two, but damned if he didn't plant himself on my left door handle and race me side-by-side up the hill. As we got to the top, I gave him the room he needed at the apex left, and we split a slower car as we went right onto the back straight. Either one of us could have backed off, but no need-we gave each other the room we needed, and not a bit more. Great stuff, and great racing- tough, unyielding, but considerate and fair. Had a great chat and laugh with the other driver afterward. The point of my stories is that, in each case, common sense and good judgement was the key. Not always gonna happen, that's for sure, but it sure is fun racing guys with that attitude.
#162
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Durham, NC and Virginia International Raceway
Posts: 19,068
Received 3,212 Likes
on
1,851 Posts
I've been following this discussion with interest. As a solid mid-pack racer with just five years' experience, I have to say that so much of what is being discussed comes down to judgement and common sense; the need for a clearly defined "rule" is, I suppose, necessary to separate the combatants and lay blame in the event of an incident, but when we're on the track together, I'd never rely soley on a rule to pass or be passed. When I started out, good friends (who are good racers) took me aside and pointed out that I was making it too easy for people to get by, wrecking my momentum and spoiling any chance I had at a good race with people of like ability. As they said, the faster guys will get by. With seat time, I began to see the track and the action around me a bit more clearly. I also know who the faster guys are, and make an effort to let them through while keeping my own race going. In terms of passing, I'm more confident in myself and in the guys I race with, and I try to have a plan in case I get chopped. Last year at Road America, I raced a guy in the sprint and tried for five laps to get by, couldn't do it. Stuck my nose in at Canada corner on the last lap, and he promptly cut it off. I laughed to myself- he was absolutely correct, and was having none of my lame-*** move, but I was ready when he came down, and followed him meekly to the finish. First sprint race at the Glen recently, followed a fast D car and made an inside pass at turn one; the car I passed gave me room, but little else. I made it stick, and assumed he'd fall in behind as we entered turn two, but damned if he didn't plant himself on my left door handle and race me side-by-side up the hill. As we got to the top, I gave him the room he needed at the apex left, and we split a slower car as we went right onto the back straight. Either one of us could have backed off, but no need-we gave each other the room we needed, and not a bit more. Great stuff, and great racing- tough, unyielding, but considerate and fair. Had a great chat and laugh with the other driver afterward. The point of my stories is that, in each case, common sense and good judgement was the key. Not always gonna happen, that's for sure, but it sure is fun racing guys with that attitude.
#163
Rennlist Member
#164
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
"So far I've raced under UK and German FIA rules and SCCA rules in the US...."
I think the key difference is the amount of overlap that requires one car to give the other car room on the racing surface. Being "even" (even "even + or -") is more overlap than I think other sanctioning bodies require.
I think the key difference is the amount of overlap that requires one car to give the other car room on the racing surface. Being "even" (even "even + or -") is more overlap than I think other sanctioning bodies require.
#165
Mr. Excitement
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I've been following this discussion with interest. As a solid mid-pack racer with just five years' experience, I have to say that so much of what is being discussed comes down to judgement and common sense; the need for a clearly defined "rule" is, I suppose, necessary to separate the combatants and lay blame in the event of an incident, but when we're on the track together, I'd never rely soley on a rule to pass or be passed. When I started out, good friends (who are good racers) took me aside and pointed out that I was making it too easy for people to get by, wrecking my momentum and spoiling any chance I had at a good race with people of like ability. As they said, the faster guys will get by. With seat time, I began to see the track and the action around me a bit more clearly. I also know who the faster guys are, and make an effort to let them through while keeping my own race going. In terms of passing, I'm more confident in myself and in the guys I race with, and I try to have a plan in case I get chopped. Last year at Road America, I raced a guy in the sprint and tried for five laps to get by, couldn't do it. Stuck my nose in at Canada corner on the last lap, and he promptly cut it off. I laughed to myself- he was absolutely correct, and was having none of my lame-*** move, but I was ready when he came down, and followed him meekly to the finish. First sprint race at the Glen recently, followed a fast D car and made an inside pass at turn one; the car I passed gave me room, but little else. I made it stick, and assumed he'd fall in behind as we entered turn two, but damned if he didn't plant himself on my left door handle and race me side-by-side up the hill. As we got to the top, I gave him the room he needed at the apex left, and we split a slower car as we went right onto the back straight. Either one of us could have backed off, but no need-we gave each other the room we needed, and not a bit more. Great stuff, and great racing- tough, unyielding, but considerate and fair. Had a great chat and laugh with the other driver afterward. The point of my stories is that, in each case, common sense and good judgement was the key. Not always gonna happen, that's for sure, but it sure is fun racing guys with that attitude.