Suspension (Moton Clubsport vs Moton Motorsport)
#32
How often do you have to set it up? I will be frequenting 4-5 tracks ( Barber, RA, CMP and VIR) Surely one size doesn't fit all. I need something that's low maintenance, I'm not the arrive and drive type, I sometimes decide the day before if I'm going (based on weather).
As far as turns 3 and 5 at Road Atlanta (I presume those are the 2 of which you spoke) there should be a much better transition through compression and rebound with the Motons. I haven't had a good test day at RA to determine that but hope to get some answers first part of March with BMW.
My current settings are middle of the road, for the most part, and the ride on the expressway is surprisingly comfortable, even with 20 and 26kg springs.
Car is a 996 turbo and weighs about 3450 with driver.
Last edited by Accelerator; 02-22-2009 at 07:54 AM.
#33
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
With any Moton product comes increased maintenance. I transitioned from JIC Cross to 3-way Motons. I now have to jack up each side of the car (the only way to get an accurate pressure reading) in the AM to check canister pressures and carry along all the amenities to add N2, if needed.
__________________
Larry Herman
2016 Ford Transit Connect Titanium LWB
2018 Tesla Model 3 - Electricity can be fun!
Retired Club Racer & National PCA Instructor
Past Flames:
1994 RS America Club Racer
2004 GT3 Track Car
1984 911 Carrera Club Racer
1974 914/4 2.0 Track Car
CLICK HERE to see some of my ancient racing videos.
Larry Herman
2016 Ford Transit Connect Titanium LWB
2018 Tesla Model 3 - Electricity can be fun!
Retired Club Racer & National PCA Instructor
Past Flames:
1994 RS America Club Racer
2004 GT3 Track Car
1984 911 Carrera Club Racer
1974 914/4 2.0 Track Car
CLICK HERE to see some of my ancient racing videos.
#34
Rennlist Member
I have added nitrogen to various of mine a total of 3 times in 18 months, and I think one of those times was because the damn schrader valves on the pressure gagues are uber-weaksauce & leak like sieves.
#35
The fronts no. The rears yes. I already had to pull the left rear shock off bc it was leaking at the bottom of the tube where the heim joint (I guess it would be called) end screws into the body. I don't want to go through pulling 2 more off and returning them. It's good to know that once corrected I won't have to do that each day. Pretty bad to pay that much for new equipment only to have it leak but I have heard these stories before.
#36
It is helpful if you have someone with knowledge of chassis tuning to help you set up a base line
for rebound and compression, based on your car's weight, power, balance, sprigning etc..
Then you can customize the settings from there for your particular needs.
As Larry said there is no -0-, just the initial base line, and then the adjustments that are dictated by
each individual and track, i.e. rough, smooth, undulating, etc...
Keep a log book with those initial base line settings, and then note each change you make, so you
have a frame of reference and qualify what the car is doing.
The Moton Motorsports is just able to do more fine tuning and be more precise for the application.
Generally, your cars characteristics dictate where the base line is, you don't really vary much from that. But, Moton GIVES you a lot of variable because the settings for a 2000 lb car will be on the opposite end of a 3000 lb car, spring rates etc considered.
As VR said, if you street drive the car too, Motons will allow you to have a amazingly smooth ride
on very stiff springing, just because of that adjustability.
for rebound and compression, based on your car's weight, power, balance, sprigning etc..
Then you can customize the settings from there for your particular needs.
As Larry said there is no -0-, just the initial base line, and then the adjustments that are dictated by
each individual and track, i.e. rough, smooth, undulating, etc...
Keep a log book with those initial base line settings, and then note each change you make, so you
have a frame of reference and qualify what the car is doing.
The Moton Motorsports is just able to do more fine tuning and be more precise for the application.
Generally, your cars characteristics dictate where the base line is, you don't really vary much from that. But, Moton GIVES you a lot of variable because the settings for a 2000 lb car will be on the opposite end of a 3000 lb car, spring rates etc considered.
As VR said, if you street drive the car too, Motons will allow you to have a amazingly smooth ride
on very stiff springing, just because of that adjustability.
#37
Race Car
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: With A Manual Transmission
Posts: 4,728
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
With any Moton product comes increased maintenance. I transitioned from JIC Cross to 3-way Motons. I now have to jack up each side of the car (the only way to get an accurate pressure reading) in the AM to check canister pressures and carry along all the amenities to add N2, if needed.
As far as turns 3 and 5 at Road Atlanta (I presume those are the 2 of which you spoke) there should be a much better transition through compression and rebound with the Motons. I haven't had a good test day at RA to determine that but hope to get some answers first part of March with BMW.
My current settings are middle of the road, for the most part, and the ride on the expressway is surprisingly comfortable, even with 20 and 26kg springs.
Car is a 996 turbo and weighs about 3650 with driver.
As far as turns 3 and 5 at Road Atlanta (I presume those are the 2 of which you spoke) there should be a much better transition through compression and rebound with the Motons. I haven't had a good test day at RA to determine that but hope to get some answers first part of March with BMW.
My current settings are middle of the road, for the most part, and the ride on the expressway is surprisingly comfortable, even with 20 and 26kg springs.
Car is a 996 turbo and weighs about 3650 with driver.
Who is this? I have to know you if you track a 996 TT at Road Atlanta. John Bridges, Al Norton? Sounds eerily like something Al Norton would do but he hasn't had his long enough for it to be leaking. I least I hope so.
#38
#40
Do I know you?
#42
Hi Dez,
Maybe someone can direct us to a highly technical article that will give good info on adjustment of high-speed compression HSC and low-speed compression LSC as well as rebound HSR. Would be nice to have a guide that says when the car does this, do that. As I mentioned to you earlier, I have Carroll Smith's Engineer in your Pocket which I find useful but I would like a more complete and possibly more up to date treatise on the interactions of all the suspension components. I've Googled every way I can think of and haven't come up with much. I suspect the article you sent to me was the one VR is sending to those requesting it.
Any of you hard-core racers out there have any suggestions? Soft core also accepted.
Maybe someone can direct us to a highly technical article that will give good info on adjustment of high-speed compression HSC and low-speed compression LSC as well as rebound HSR. Would be nice to have a guide that says when the car does this, do that. As I mentioned to you earlier, I have Carroll Smith's Engineer in your Pocket which I find useful but I would like a more complete and possibly more up to date treatise on the interactions of all the suspension components. I've Googled every way I can think of and haven't come up with much. I suspect the article you sent to me was the one VR is sending to those requesting it.
Any of you hard-core racers out there have any suggestions? Soft core also accepted.
#43
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Adjusting shocks is as much Art as it is Science. In fact, if you don't have shock potentiometers and full data aquisition like Geoffrey, it is 100% Art. You have to be able to feel exactly what the car is doing, then understand what the shock settings do, and then apply that information. For example, I had a high speed front brake lockup problem (+130 mph) in braking zones that fell away from the car. I fixed it by increasing the low speed compression in the front by one click. How do I communicate that scenario in a guide?
Want your car setup right? You may not know what right is. Get a pro like Chris Cervelli to set it up, and then you can play with it from there. $1k invested like that can save a lot of mistakes and can be well worth it in the long run.
Want your car setup right? You may not know what right is. Get a pro like Chris Cervelli to set it up, and then you can play with it from there. $1k invested like that can save a lot of mistakes and can be well worth it in the long run.
#44
Nordschleife Master
For example, I had a high speed front brake lockup problem (+130 mph) in braking zones that fell away from the car. I fixed it by increasing the low speed compression in the front by one click.
Even with the damper position sensors I find I rely more on a logical approach of evaluating what the car is doing vs what I want it to do in every part of the corner. Data Engineer experts will tell you that the compression and rebound should be equal when looking at the damper histograms (not equally set on the damper adjusters) which show the time spent at each damper velocity. I've adjusted the dampers by just using data and I've adjusted them just by feel. My opinion is that the feel is a better approach, however, the data has provided me additional input and caused me to think about things I wouldn't have if I didn't have the data. In addition to simple histograms, I look at roll rates and roll frequency which has helped me select spring rates and adjust anti roll bars. After the WGI club race where Chris and I were comparing data (which was very interesting), I ended up doing some significant suspension changes (Lowered the car, measured the toe change over suspension movements and fixed the bump steer, changed main sprnigs at all 4 corners, changed the tender springs in the rear) and was able to knock 1 second off my WGI times. All of this was to fix one specific problem in high speed corners. The data was extremely helpful with this exercise. And, FWIW, my car with spring rates approximately 1/4 of Chris's had the same amount of roll. It took awhile to figure that one out...
#45
King of Cool
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
The Clubsport dampers have a slightly different construction than the comparable 2 way motorsports version. Some parts are steel rather than aluminum so the unsprung weight is more. The dampers function the same as the motorsports version and parts are interchangable. They also have the same range of adjustablity, just not the level of refinement (15 clicks vs 7 as mentioned above). I think that at the club level, the clubsport dampers are a good choice for someone just getting into adjustable suspension and learning how it works. They are about 2/3rd the price of the motorsport 2 way and about 1/2 the price of the motorsport 3 way. More importantly than the difference between the two level of dampers is the spring package (tender & main) choice for your driving skill and your application.
I remember one pro race once adjusted on of our bikes and after he just but some kind of basic, quick set-up, you could go over this nasty washboard sections twice the speed as before and the bike hardly moved.
It takes A LOT of trial and error before you even start to know what you're doing:
You need to make one SINGLE adjustment, go out, time your lap, come back change SOMETHING ELSE, do another timed lap, compare times and repeat, repeat, repeat, repeat, repeat...
If you have 3 way adjustment on front & back, do the math how many combinations you'll have in order to have tried them ALL...
And obviously you need to do that all again when you go to the next rack...
If I ever get enough time to go to track, I'm going to beg Greg, Larry, Chris or some experienced racer (best if he has experience with a similar 993 as mine) to share his "notebook" since it would save a ton of my time to get the basic set-up close to what's good.
With that said, those of you who already offered to do that in this thread, if you don't mind, please send it to my as well. badass993@gmail.com is my e-mail. THAAAANKK YOOUUU!