Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums

Rennlist - Porsche Discussion Forums (https://rennlist.com/forums/)
-   Racing & Drivers Education Forum (https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-and-drivers-education-forum-65/)
-   -   Suspension (Moton Clubsport vs Moton Motorsport) (https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-and-drivers-education-forum/483299-suspension-moton-clubsport-vs-moton-motorsport.html)

wanna911 02-17-2009 08:30 PM

Suspension (Moton Clubsport vs Moton Motorsport)
 
What is the advantage of the 2-way motor sport suspension over the Moton club sport if any?

I'm not considering the 2 -way, but if they are that much better than the CS then I'll go 3-way. I have no clue what the difference is.

Larry Herman 02-17-2009 08:46 PM

IIRC the Motorsport shocks are more durable and have a finer gradation in the settings (15 vs 7). Having had a car with Moton 3 ways, and being able to adjust them to dial in the car to the track, I wouldn't want anything else. The 3 way shock gives you high speed compression and rebouind settings, and low speed compression. The "speed" refers to the movement of the shock rod.

93 FireHawk 968 02-17-2009 08:56 PM

I have the CS setup and I'm very pleased. I have more adjustability than I really need. I guess if your an extremely advanced racer having the limitless adjustment capability might be appealing.

FredC 02-17-2009 09:05 PM

The clubsports are 2-way adjustable. The motorsports are 3+ way adjustable. As Larry indicated, the motorsports have twice the gradation, which is enormously more when considering 3 instead of 2 ways adjustability. Good luck.

wanna911 02-17-2009 09:09 PM

Those first two responses summarize the conflict in my mind.

I love the idea of the adjustability, but I will be racing by 2010 and not in the same car, though I will occasionally track it still. Chewing on if I'd really get the use out of a 3-way. If it's REALLY worth it, then I'm willing, but I always like to do more with less.

BTW I'm moving up from entry level coilovers (JIC) and I actually really liked them, they are just horrible when you want to use any curbs. I have two curbs in my mind already that expose them heavily.

If the difference in improvement is greater from JIC to Clubsport than Clubsport to Motorsport, then I go Clubsport, and vice versa.

onefastviking 02-17-2009 09:32 PM

From JIC to Clubsport you will love the difference, then going from Clubsport to Motorsport you will love the difference even more, provided you have the proper time to properly set up the 15way 3 adjusts.

wanna911 02-17-2009 09:49 PM

How often do you have to set it up? I will be frequenting 4-5 tracks ( Barber, RA, CMP and VIR) Surely one size doesn't fit all. I need something that's low maintenance, I'm not the arrive and drive type, I sometimes decide the day before if I'm going (based on weather).

Larry Herman 02-17-2009 09:53 PM


Originally Posted by wanna911 (Post 6296645)
How often do you have to set it up? I will be frequenting 4-5 tracks ( Barber, RA, CMP and VIR) Surely one size doesn't fit all. I need something that's low maintenance, I'm not the arrive and drive type, I sometimes decide the day before if I'm going (based on weather).

THAT is the purpose of adjustable shocks. I changed mine for just about every track. Sometimes it was subtle ( a click or two on maybe one way) or sometimes it was pretty drastic. All depends on the roughness and elevation changes of the track. I also kept a log book so that once I developed settings for each track, I could "pre-set" the car for the next time.

Jerseybean 02-17-2009 10:02 PM

anyone got any motorsport moton they dont want - PM me?

Veloce Raptor 02-17-2009 10:38 PM


Originally Posted by Larry Herman (Post 6296662)
THAT is the purpose of adjustable shocks. I changed mine for just about every track. Sometimes it was subtle ( a click or two on maybe one way) or sometimes it was pretty drastic. All depends on the roughness and elevation changes of the track. I also kept a log book so that once I developed settings for each track, I could "pre-set" the car for the next time.

+1

Dez, email me at the email address I gave you. I went thru this 2 years ago.

Geoffrey 02-18-2009 08:26 AM

The Clubsport dampers have a slightly different construction than the comparable 2 way motorsports version. Some parts are steel rather than aluminum so the unsprung weight is more. The dampers function the same as the motorsports version and parts are interchangable. They also have the same range of adjustablity, just not the level of refinement (15 clicks vs 7 as mentioned above). I think that at the club level, the clubsport dampers are a good choice for someone just getting into adjustable suspension and learning how it works. They are about 2/3rd the price of the motorsport 2 way and about 1/2 the price of the motorsport 3 way. More importantly than the difference between the two level of dampers is the spring package (tender & main) choice for your driving skill and your application.

wanna911 02-18-2009 08:42 AM

Thanks for the help guys, I'm leaning towards the Clubsports right now. If they don't do the trick then I'll move on up to the 3 way, but no way will I go for the 2-way motorsports. I think if I'm going to spend that kind of money, may as well get the 3 ways and have the high and low speed bump adjustments.

I also agree that finding the right spring rates is going to be important. My JIC had some weak ones (480 and 640 or something like that) and my car is almost 3500 lbs with me (225) in it, so you can guess how much pitch and roll I was getting, even on full stiff. I want a spring that can be driven on the street (not needing to be comfy), but will not compromise on the track. I'm thinking ~ 700 front ~1000 rear.

Veloce Raptor 02-18-2009 09:40 AM


Originally Posted by wanna911 (Post 6297606)
Thanks for the help guys, I'm leaning towards the Clubsports right now. If they don't do the trick then I'll move on up to the 3 way, but no way will I go for the 2-way motorsports. I think if I'm going to spend that kind of money, may as well get the 3 ways and have the high and low speed bump adjustments.

I also agree that finding the right spring rates is going to be important. My JIC had some weak ones (480 and 640 or something like that) and my car is almost 3500 lbs with me (225) in it, so you can guess how much pitch and roll I was getting, even on full stiff. I want a spring that can be driven on the street (not needing to be comfy), but will not compromise on the track. I'm thinking ~ 700 front ~1000 rear.

As my latest email to you indicated, I agree with this approach. Also, realize that, on full soft, Motons will give you a surprisingly cushy ride on the street, even with super duty springs. You will be pleasantly surprised. ;)

Mark in Baltimore 02-18-2009 11:11 AM

I have the Moton Clubsports and think they are just fine for my level of driving, as well as, more importantly my set-up "expertise". It's hard enough to figure out how to set-up double adjustables (had to hire Chris Cervelli to get me fully dialed-in), despite the fact that I am someone who takes notes down detailed notes at every track day. I think triples would be like adding a fourth dimension to the Rubik's cube and would have been complete overkill for me. Besides, the price was much friendlier than the triple adjustable motorsports.

wanna911 02-18-2009 12:09 PM

With that said, I understand bump adjustments for the most part, but what about rebound, when do you want higher rebound vs lower? And which one does what exactly?

I will be doing a lot of the adjusting so scenarios would be good to know. For example a bumpy high speed track like Sebring, or a baby butt smooth one like Barber, or one with some big curbs. I know there will be specifics, but I'm talking general rules of thumb of where to start.



Of course if it's going to turn out like hp vs torque then nevermind. LOL.


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 07:13 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands