Centerlocks - A Cautionary Tale
#106
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Now over 13K miles and 18 track days with CLs. I just had my front brake pads (set 2) and tires (set 3) flipped for wear. After 4 track days on the new stock front rotors (with the nubs reused from my first set), they are starting to show cracks. I am going to be test fitting PF floating rotors in a week as a potential replacement for the fronts.
I have hit my first issue with CLs, but it is not any of the BS listed throughout this thread. I have recently noticed that my CLs have been shifting color from light Gray to light Purple. It looks like the finish is sensitive to brake heat.
No problem getting parts from them. Just don't send one in for repair. You will be lucky if you can get it back in 6 weeks. Been through it twice previously with some of their 2-piece welded wheels where the welds cracked and had to be repaired.
For comparison, I had a tire lose air and pop off a rim in a corner grind down the outside on one of my 3 piece CCWs about a year and a half ago. I shipped it on Monday from TX to CCW in FL. It arrived on Wednesday. John rebuilt the wheel and shipped it back to me the same day as it arrived back in my hands on Friday the same week (out and back in 4 days). He replace both rim halves and the total cost was just $345 with shipping. When it comes to servicing wheels, no one is better than John. It is just taking him forever to make CL wheels.
I have hit my first issue with CLs, but it is not any of the BS listed throughout this thread. I have recently noticed that my CLs have been shifting color from light Gray to light Purple. It looks like the finish is sensitive to brake heat.
For comparison, I had a tire lose air and pop off a rim in a corner grind down the outside on one of my 3 piece CCWs about a year and a half ago. I shipped it on Monday from TX to CCW in FL. It arrived on Wednesday. John rebuilt the wheel and shipped it back to me the same day as it arrived back in my hands on Friday the same week (out and back in 4 days). He replace both rim halves and the total cost was just $345 with shipping. When it comes to servicing wheels, no one is better than John. It is just taking him forever to make CL wheels.
#107
GT3 player par excellence
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
for track use, it's really hard to beat CCW. and he always get them to me so i dont miss my DE or races.
#108
GT3 player par excellence
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
#109
Admin
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Now over 13K miles and 18 track days with CLs. I just had my front brake pads (set 2) and tires (set 3) flipped for wear. After 4 track days on the new stock front rotors (with the nubs reused from my first set), they are starting to show cracks. I am going to be test fitting PF floating rotors in a week as a potential replacement for the fronts.
I have hit my first issue with CLs, but it is not any of the BS listed throughout this thread. I have recently noticed that my CLs have been shifting color from light Gray to light Purple. It looks like the finish is sensitive to brake heat.
No problem getting parts from them. Just don't send one in for repair. You will be lucky if you can get it back in 6 weeks. Been through it twice previously with some of their 2-piece welded wheels where the welds cracked and had to be repaired.
For comparison, I had a tire lose air and pop off a rim in a corner grind down the outside on one of my 3 piece CCWs about a year and a half ago. I shipped it on Monday from TX to CCW in FL. It arrived on Wednesday. John rebuilt the wheel and shipped it back to me the same day as it arrived back in my hands on Friday the same week (out and back in 4 days). He replace both rim halves and the total cost was just $345 with shipping. When it comes to servicing wheels, no one is better than John. It is just taking him forever to make CL wheels.
I have hit my first issue with CLs, but it is not any of the BS listed throughout this thread. I have recently noticed that my CLs have been shifting color from light Gray to light Purple. It looks like the finish is sensitive to brake heat.
No problem getting parts from them. Just don't send one in for repair. You will be lucky if you can get it back in 6 weeks. Been through it twice previously with some of their 2-piece welded wheels where the welds cracked and had to be repaired.
For comparison, I had a tire lose air and pop off a rim in a corner grind down the outside on one of my 3 piece CCWs about a year and a half ago. I shipped it on Monday from TX to CCW in FL. It arrived on Wednesday. John rebuilt the wheel and shipped it back to me the same day as it arrived back in my hands on Friday the same week (out and back in 4 days). He replace both rim halves and the total cost was just $345 with shipping. When it comes to servicing wheels, no one is better than John. It is just taking him forever to make CL wheels.
BS?
They are just sharing their experiences and opinions.. just like you do.
Try to respect that, even if you disagree..
#110
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I had originally theorized at the beginning of this thread that maybe I had lost a washer in the CL nut assembly. That was not the case. I found it was still on there some time ago.
I did note that nearly every red nipple now has gauling, so next time I change rotors, I'll have to change that hardware. So, the root cause of my problem was the fact that the new wheels had paint where they shouldn't (all the mating surfaces to the hub).
The interesting thing I learned today that I want to share with you all is in regards to the locking mechanism. I had ample time to put everything back together, so I futzed with the locking mechanism for a long while. Porsche documentation tells you that the mechanism needs to come out flush with the outer portion of the splines. I'd only rarely had mine come out all that way. I started to carry a 1/2" socket extension in my track tool bag to jiggle the mechanism. Well, today I didn't give up jiggling and trying until all 4 CL locking mechanisms came out flush exactly as specified. All of them took a good 30 or 40 seconds to get them right.
I did note that nearly every red nipple now has gauling, so next time I change rotors, I'll have to change that hardware. So, the root cause of my problem was the fact that the new wheels had paint where they shouldn't (all the mating surfaces to the hub).
The interesting thing I learned today that I want to share with you all is in regards to the locking mechanism. I had ample time to put everything back together, so I futzed with the locking mechanism for a long while. Porsche documentation tells you that the mechanism needs to come out flush with the outer portion of the splines. I'd only rarely had mine come out all that way. I started to carry a 1/2" socket extension in my track tool bag to jiggle the mechanism. Well, today I didn't give up jiggling and trying until all 4 CL locking mechanisms came out flush exactly as specified. All of them took a good 30 or 40 seconds to get them right.
I have a 3R breaker bar. I found that the entire square "head" was twisted - a lot! The damn thing is about to break. I suppose the mfg didn't use an appropriate high-grade steel and the new, higher torque spec that Porsche now requires is simply too much for the product.
I'm a fan of the centerlock idea, but a critic of this "version 1.0" implementation. I think it needs a steel nut that can take an impact tool. It's also preposterously expensive. And the "Dosey Doe" torquing procedure along with lathering grease makes for an obvious "this needs more thought" situation for Porsche to resolve in future versions. The "mystery" recall that's going on in some parts of the world is also disconcerting. Not what I expect from Porsche. Still, as ever with Porsche, by about version 1.5 or 2.0, these things will be great. They need to replace the cheap metal dust caps with some sort of carbon fiber "cool and light" cap that's held in place with a mechanical device, not a rubber o-ring friction/suction idea ... and a way to quickly and easily remove it without it being damaged at all.
But for now, the centerlock is functionally reliable and trouble free in my experience given 18 months of track use and now three sets of wheels on the car with no drama.
The 3R products have turned out the be pretty weak. The alignment pin isn't durable (it scratches and looks cheap after light use, now their breaker bar isn't strong enough.)
The Porsche telescopic breaker is great and convenient. The Armstrong torque multiplier is a "swiss watch precision" device that I enjoy using just because I really appreciate "no compromise" engineering and a device that simply does what it promises to do -- it turns a gymnastics routine of a "giant" breaker bars and bulky torque wrenches into a rapid procedure that I can do precisely to the factory instructions, in the paddock, no sweat, no drama, torquing the wheels with the car off the ground (pedal depressor is ample for 600nm at the centerlock) and a wheel swap is something I can do during a regular track day without power tools. Not bad.
#111
Drifting
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Black Sheep Racing World HQ
Posts: 3,278
Likes: 0
Received 25 Likes
on
14 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Jeez, after reading all these threads, I keep asking "why me?"
And speaking of bad luck, I've had really bad luck with my one-man-brake-tool from Lisle. It worked O.K. (not great) for the first few tries. Now, it doesn't want to hold its spot (extension) any longer. I assume that the spring loaded tab near the union is no longer sharp and not biting into the extension shaft. Can I simply tear it apart and resharpen it?
Has anyone found a better tool for this purpose? I'm a one-man show at home and at the track. I really need a good, reliable tool for this purpose.
And speaking of bad luck, I've had really bad luck with my one-man-brake-tool from Lisle. It worked O.K. (not great) for the first few tries. Now, it doesn't want to hold its spot (extension) any longer. I assume that the spring loaded tab near the union is no longer sharp and not biting into the extension shaft. Can I simply tear it apart and resharpen it?
Has anyone found a better tool for this purpose? I'm a one-man show at home and at the track. I really need a good, reliable tool for this purpose.
#112
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Jeez, after reading all these threads, I keep asking "why me?"
And speaking of bad luck, I've had really bad luck with my one-man-brake-tool from Lisle. It worked O.K. (not great) for the first few tries. Now, it doesn't want to hold its spot (extension) any longer. I assume that the spring loaded tab near the union is no longer sharp and not biting into the extension shaft. Can I simply tear it apart and resharpen it?
Has anyone found a better tool for this purpose? I'm a one-man show at home and at the track. I really need a good, reliable tool for this purpose.
And speaking of bad luck, I've had really bad luck with my one-man-brake-tool from Lisle. It worked O.K. (not great) for the first few tries. Now, it doesn't want to hold its spot (extension) any longer. I assume that the spring loaded tab near the union is no longer sharp and not biting into the extension shaft. Can I simply tear it apart and resharpen it?
Has anyone found a better tool for this purpose? I'm a one-man show at home and at the track. I really need a good, reliable tool for this purpose.
The tool -- do you mean this:
http://www.lislecorp.com/divisions/products/?product=91
![](http://www.lislecorp.com/uploads/products/21520c2.jpg)
... or this:
http://www.lislecorp.com/divisions/p...s/?product=404
![](http://www.lislecorp.com/uploads/products/75000L.jpg)
I use the pedal depressor, but they can wear out.
I bought one of these because there's a Home Depot on the way to Laguna and I needed it for a wheel swap ... and it's ideal:
http://www.irwin.com/tools/clamps/xp...amps-spreaders
![](http://www.irwin.com/uploads/products/large/xp600-one-handed-bar-clamps-spreaders-67.jpg)
And for brake flush and bleed, I think just about everyone uses a PowerBleeder now:
http://store.motiveproducts.com/blac...-0109-p21.aspx
![](http://cdn.nexternal.com/motive/images/black_label_sm.jpg)
![](http://cdn.nexternal.com/motive/images/catch1.jpg)
#113
Nordschleife Master
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Now over 13K miles and 18 track days with CLs. I just had my front brake pads (set 2) and tires (set 3) flipped for wear. After 4 track days on the new stock front rotors (with the nubs reused from my first set), they are starting to show cracks. I am going to be test fitting PF floating rotors in a week as a potential replacement for the fronts.
I have hit my first issue with CLs, but it is not any of the BS listed throughout this thread. I have recently noticed that my CLs have been shifting color from light Gray to light Purple. It looks like the finish is sensitive to brake heat.
No problem getting parts from them. Just don't send one in for repair. You will be lucky if you can get it back in 6 weeks. Been through it twice previously with some of their 2-piece welded wheels where the welds cracked and had to be repaired.
For comparison, I had a tire lose air and pop off a rim in a corner grind down the outside on one of my 3 piece CCWs about a year and a half ago. I shipped it on Monday from TX to CCW in FL. It arrived on Wednesday. John rebuilt the wheel and shipped it back to me the same day as it arrived back in my hands on Friday the same week (out and back in 4 days). He replace both rim halves and the total cost was just $345 with shipping. When it comes to servicing wheels, no one is better than John. It is just taking him forever to make CL wheels.
I have hit my first issue with CLs, but it is not any of the BS listed throughout this thread. I have recently noticed that my CLs have been shifting color from light Gray to light Purple. It looks like the finish is sensitive to brake heat.
For comparison, I had a tire lose air and pop off a rim in a corner grind down the outside on one of my 3 piece CCWs about a year and a half ago. I shipped it on Monday from TX to CCW in FL. It arrived on Wednesday. John rebuilt the wheel and shipped it back to me the same day as it arrived back in my hands on Friday the same week (out and back in 4 days). He replace both rim halves and the total cost was just $345 with shipping. When it comes to servicing wheels, no one is better than John. It is just taking him forever to make CL wheels.
I have seen johns cl wheel
He needs a car for test fit, couple of days
Send me beer and can use mine
#114
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
There's been other posts/threads about CCW wheels turning purple. I have a set of purple "tie died" CCWs. Sadly, their response was to ask to be paid to have them refinished as if these wheels were abnormal.
#115
Drifting
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Black Sheep Racing World HQ
Posts: 3,278
Likes: 0
Received 25 Likes
on
14 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Driving on the track invites any number of "why me?" experiences.
The tool -- do you mean this:
http://www.lislecorp.com/divisions/products/?product=91
![](http://www.lislecorp.com/uploads/products/21520c2.jpg)
The tool -- do you mean this:
http://www.lislecorp.com/divisions/products/?product=91
![](http://www.lislecorp.com/uploads/products/21520c2.jpg)
I never thought about using a trigger-grip bar clamp. Great idea! I suppose you just flip the clamp parts to face outwards and you're good to go.
Thanks, Carrera GT!
#116
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I noted that the spring loaded ball wasn't protruding as it should. Upon closer inspection, I found that the entire square "head" was twisted - a lot! The damn thing is about to break. I suppose the mfg didn't use an appropriate high-grade steel and the new, higher torque spec that Porsche now requires is simply too much for the product.
For those of you who might have this breaker bar, please take a good look at it next time before you use it. I've already written the mfg to alert them and ask for a replacement part.
For those of you who might have this breaker bar, please take a good look at it next time before you use it. I've already written the mfg to alert them and ask for a replacement part.
The Armstrong torque multiplier is a "swiss watch precision" device that I enjoy using just because I really appreciate "no compromise" engineering and a device that simply does what it promises to do -- it turns a gymnastics routine of a "giant" breaker bars and bulky torque wrenches into a rapid procedure that I can do precisely to the factory instructions, in the paddock, no sweat, no drama, torquing the wheels with the car off the ground (pedal depressor is ample for 600nm at the centerlock) and a wheel swap is something I can do during a regular track day without power tools. Not bad.
![Confused](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/confused.gif)
I'll show it to Lar this weekend too since he is a mechanical engineer.
#117
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Last year I converted a trigger grip clamp and it was a bit of a PITA to "flip" it. Have to dissasemble the mechanism which is fussy to reassemble and grind off the tit on the I-beam. So possible but not easy. At least for me.
#118
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
well, i HAD two sets for sale, you only took one!
now, good luck matching my prices ;=)
now, good luck matching my prices ;=)
Nobody beats your prices. Call me I'll send you a deposit for the 4.0 now.