Notices
997 Forum 2005-2012
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

997.2 3.8 Engine Failure

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 02-07-2019, 01:33 AM
  #331  
sandwedge
Nordschleife Master
 
sandwedge's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Florida
Posts: 8,455
Received 1,008 Likes on 716 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Flat6 Innovations
Guys, the used oil analysis is critical, but you have to use a quality service. www.speeddiagnostix.com is a premier service that is fast, and offers excellent commentary. often they will send "problem" data to Charles and I for additional commentary to help the owner understand what the elements are.

A lot of great info Jake. Many thanks. Just a quick yes/no question. Do you consider used oil analysis "critical" for both the 997.1's and 997.2's? Asking since there are quiet a few differences between the two engines.
Old 02-07-2019, 02:40 AM
  #332  
qikqbn
Rennlist Member
 
qikqbn's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 1,293
Received 529 Likes on 294 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Flat6 Innovations
No Porsche sits outdoors here. At most a car will sit outside for a few hours, on a clear day while we shuffle cars in the storage building for new arrivals. We have vehicles scheduled in a manner that when one arrives, another is leaving.
Bronz is lucky, too many times when we accept a failed engine, the car is dead here for a whole year. In some of those extreme cases we own an off- site storage facility where the vehicles are kept in their own holding cell for the long term..
No car sits outdoors and your security setup is great to hear!. We had a thread on "OCD" issues and many of us here don't have enough medication to bear the thought of our cars sitting out in the elements and God forbid it is a rainy day

It is great to hear that you are super busy. Bitter sweet for some of us thinking about upgrading to 4.0 some day in the future and knowing the wait is so long. So if a customer has a car that is running perfectly fine, but would like the upgrade, is there a smaller window of drop off and return based on your scheduling? Could you pre-order the "nickies" , do a core exchange, and just have all the parts ready to go? Basically drop the car off when work is ready to start. What would the turn around time wise look for a situation like that?

Last edited by qikqbn; 02-07-2019 at 03:18 AM.
Old 02-07-2019, 05:37 AM
  #333  
cwheeler
Three Wheelin'
 
cwheeler's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2013
Posts: 1,627
Received 372 Likes on 268 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by qikqbn
No car sits outdoors and your security setup is great to hear!. We had a thread on "OCD" issues and many of us here don't have enough medication to bear the thought of our cars sitting out in the elements and God forbid it is a rainy day

It is great to hear that you are super busy. Bitter sweet for some of us thinking about upgrading to 4.0 some day in the future and knowing the wait is so long. So if a customer has a car that is running perfectly fine, but would like the upgrade, is there a smaller window of drop off and return based on your scheduling? Could you pre-order the "nickies" , do a core exchange, and just have all the parts ready to go? Basically drop the car off when work is ready to start. What would the turn around time wise look for a situation like that?
Great question. I was looking for the same answer.

Cw
Old 02-07-2019, 10:54 AM
  #334  
docdrs
Rennlist Member
 
docdrs's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Ontario, Canada 2011 C4S
Posts: 1,156
Received 72 Likes on 48 Posts
Default

Or, can I put a deposit down now to hold a spot for when it needs it or I could sell that spot with the car if I ever sell it or better yet to a friend for almost free. Just like it is for the new GT3’s. sorry, in Mexico with nothing to do but lay in the sun and too much time on my hands
Old 02-07-2019, 10:15 PM
  #335  
Flat6 Innovations
Former Vendor
 
Flat6 Innovations's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Cleveland Georgia
Posts: 6,968
Received 2,282 Likes on 899 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by qikqbn
No car sits outdoors and your security setup is great to hear!. We had a thread on "OCD" issues and many of us here don't have enough medication to bear the thought of our cars sitting out in the elements and God forbid it is a rainy day

It is great to hear that you are super busy. Bitter sweet for some of us thinking about upgrading to 4.0 some day in the future and knowing the wait is so long. So if a customer has a car that is running perfectly fine, but would like the upgrade, is there a smaller window of drop off and return based on your scheduling? Could you pre-order the "nickies" , do a core exchange, and just have all the parts ready to go? Basically drop the car off when work is ready to start. What would the turn around time wise look for a situation like that?
We are blessed to stay “super busy”. For over a decade we have maintained a 9+ month backlog. Before that my aircooled program was typically 15 months backlogged. Today my aircooled program is my therapy..

That said, we know how to manage this backlog, and its all about scheduling, and a 64 step spreadsheet that governs each engine as it’s sole builder takes it through all the steps. Here, the person that extracts the engine from the car is the same person who disassembles it, inspects it, machines it, balances it, re- assembles it, re-installs it back into the car, and fires it up for the first time. This is NOT a team effort. One pair of hands, and one mind performs all the work on each engine. l assign the builder when the proposal is signed, and l base the builder l choose on the engine application, and etc. There’s 4 builders under the roof, including me, and the “newest” one of them has been here 13 years, the oldest has been here 21 years. The person that’s been here 21 years has been sent home early one time due to a lack of work.. Like l said, l have been blessed.

I try very hard not to have an engine exchange program. Why? Well, thats what mass producers do. We will never become mass producers, and this business will never grow larger than it is today. With higher volumes always comes a lack of quality, and today’s workforce sucks so bad that l don’t want to hire any new employees. As each one retires, we’ll scale things back until its my turn...l’m the youngest person here!

Last year some “business guy” showed up and said he wanted to speak to me about buying the business. The fact that he felt like he was important enough to sit at the gate and blow his horn pissed me off from the beginning... Then he followed the UPS truck into the gate, and I went into “mode”. His first question was “have you considered growing the business?”
My response: “Have you considered minding your own damn business?” Then l kicked him off the property.
His hands looked like he gets a weekly manicure, so there’s no way in hell he could run this place. l own this place so l can build engines and do them my way, not to sit at a desk, and rake in cash.

That said, typically an elective build only requires us to have the car on site for 3 months. That is a small price to pay time wise to have your existing, matching numbers engine reconstructed, and installed back into your car with a complete new character.

I refuse to rush. You can rush failure, but you cannot rush success. It takes as long as it takes, and the two things you will not find in my work space is a calendar, and a clock. Time does not matter here.

Although there are times when people just can’t wait... So sometimes l prepare engines in advance, fully spec them out, photo document the assembly, and give them full blueprints. l keep these engines on hand for the guy that can’t wait, and is willing to pay a +15% price of admission to have the car back in action in less than 2 weeks. These usually sell out by mid- spring, and the only 9a1 l have in stock is a Cayman spec 3.4 based engine. The Canadians love this program...

We always work from a “pre- order” perspective. The calendar starts the day the proposal is executed. We are always on- time, or early with completions. Three equal payments of 1/3 occur, one at the onset of the project, one at mid- term, and one at maturity.

If you have an elective build, things are easy, and you can drive the car for most of you are waiting. The modern human has a problem with waiting for good things to happen, but l never designed this program to be for everyone. Instant gratification doesn’t really happen here. This is how we end up with the results that we have.

So, l have one 2019 completion date available, in November. After that l am booked till March 15, 2020 for a completion. Who wants November?
Old 02-07-2019, 10:25 PM
  #336  
black997er
Instructor
 
black997er's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2018
Posts: 228
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes on 4 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Flat6 Innovations


We are blessed to stay “super busy”. For over a decade we have maintained a 9+ month backlog. Before that my aircooled program was typically 15 months backlogged. Today my aircooled program is my therapy..

That said, we know how to manage this backlog, and its all about scheduling, and a 64 step spreadsheet that governs each engine as it’s sole builder takes it through all the steps. Here, the person that extracts the engine from the car is the same person who disassembles it, inspects it, machines it, balances it, re- assembles it, re-installs it back into the car, and fires it up for the first time. This is NOT a team effort. One pair of hands, and one mind performs all the work on each engine. l assign the builder when the proposal is signed, and l base the builder l choose on the engine application, and etc. There’s 4 builders under the roof, including me, and the “newest” one of them has been here 13 years, the oldest has been here 21 years. The person that’s been here 21 years has been sent home early one time due to a lack of work.. Like l said, l have been blessed.

I try very hard not to have an engine exchange program. Why? Well, thats what mass producers do. We will never become mass producers, and this business will never grow larger than it is today. With higher volumes always comes a lack of quality, and today’s workforce sucks so bad that l don;t want to hire any new employees. As each one retires, we’ll scale things back until its my turn...l’m the youngest person here!

That said, typically an elective build only requires us to have the car on site for 3 months. That is a small price to pay time wise to have your existing, matching numbers engine reconstructed, and installed back into your car with a complete new character.

I refuse to rush. You can rush failure, but you cannot rush success. It takes as long as it takes, and the two things you will not find in my work space is a calendar, and a clock. Time does not matter here.

Although there are times when people just can’t wait... So sometimes l prepare engines in advance, fully spec them out, photo document the assembly, and give them full blueprints. l keep these engines on hand for the guy that can’t wait, and is willing to pay a +15% price of admission to have the car back in action in less than 2 weeks. These usually sell out by mid- spring, and the only 9a1 l have in stock is a Cayman spec 3.4 based engine. The Canadians love this program...

We always work from a “pre- order” perspective. The calendar starts the day the proposal is executed. We are always on- time, or early with completions. Three equal payments of 1/3 occur, one at the onset of the project, one at mid- term, and one at maturity.

If you have an elective build, things are easy, and you can drive the car for most of you are waiting. The modern human has a problem with waiting for good things to happen, but l never designed this program to be for everyone. Instant gratification doesn’t really happen here. This is how we end up with the results that we have.

So, l have one 2019 completion date available, in November. After that l am booked till March 15, 2020 for a completion. Who wants November?
I like your system Jake. When I’ve saved up enough for an elective 4.0L build I’ll hit you up. Will not in 2019 though, most likely 2020. Hoping to learn from this thread how to better take care of our engines in the meantime from your report / video.
Old 02-08-2019, 03:07 AM
  #337  
sandwedge
Nordschleife Master
 
sandwedge's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Florida
Posts: 8,455
Received 1,008 Likes on 716 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Flat6 Innovations


We are blessed to stay “super busy”. For over a decade we have maintained a 9+ month backlog. Before that my aircooled program was typically 15 months backlogged. Today my aircooled program is my therapy..

That said, we know how to manage this backlog, and its all about scheduling, and a 64 step spreadsheet that governs each engine as it’s sole builder takes it through all the steps. Here, the person that extracts the engine from the car is the same person who disassembles it, inspects it, machines it, balances it, re- assembles it, re-installs it back into the car, and fires it up for the first time. This is NOT a team effort. One pair of hands, and one mind performs all the work on each engine. l assign the builder when the proposal is signed, and l base the builder l choose on the engine application, and etc. There’s 4 builders under the roof, including me, and the “newest” one of them has been here 13 years, the oldest has been here 21 years. The person that’s been here 21 years has been sent home early one time due to a lack of work.. Like l said, l have been blessed.

I try very hard not to have an engine exchange program. Why? Well, thats what mass producers do. We will never become mass producers, and this business will never grow larger than it is today. With higher volumes always comes a lack of quality, and today’s workforce sucks so bad that l don’t want to hire any new employees. As each one retires, we’ll scale things back until its my turn...l’m the youngest person here!

Last year some “business guy” showed up and said he wanted to speak to me about buying the business. The fact that he felt like he was important enough to sit at the gate and blow his horn pissed me off from the beginning... Then he followed the UPS truck into the gate, and I went into “mode”. His first question was “have you considered growing the business?”
My response: “Have you considered minding your own damn business?” Then l kicked him off the property.
His hands looked like he gets a weekly manicure, so there’s no way in hell he could run this place. l own this place so l can build engines and do them my way, not to sit at a desk, and rake in cash.

That said, typically an elective build only requires us to have the car on site for 3 months. That is a small price to pay time wise to have your existing, matching numbers engine reconstructed, and installed back into your car with a complete new character.

I refuse to rush. You can rush failure, but you cannot rush success. It takes as long as it takes, and the two things you will not find in my work space is a calendar, and a clock. Time does not matter here.

Although there are times when people just can’t wait... So sometimes l prepare engines in advance, fully spec them out, photo document the assembly, and give them full blueprints. l keep these engines on hand for the guy that can’t wait, and is willing to pay a +15% price of admission to have the car back in action in less than 2 weeks. These usually sell out by mid- spring, and the only 9a1 l have in stock is a Cayman spec 3.4 based engine. The Canadians love this program...

We always work from a “pre- order” perspective. The calendar starts the day the proposal is executed. We are always on- time, or early with completions. Three equal payments of 1/3 occur, one at the onset of the project, one at mid- term, and one at maturity.

If you have an elective build, things are easy, and you can drive the car for most of you are waiting. The modern human has a problem with waiting for good things to happen, but l never designed this program to be for everyone. Instant gratification doesn’t really happen here. This is how we end up with the results that we have.

So, l have one 2019 completion date available, in November. After that l am booked till March 15, 2020 for a completion. Who wants November?

No discussion. You've built an impressive business with a reputation second to nobody. Hat's off to you. The only thing that pops into my head when I read about your backlog is.....are these engines really failing at a rate creating this kind of backlog or are most repaired by dealerships and you only get those who want the very best and something special and are willing to wait and pay for it? Plus,your focus is clearly on quality rather than quantity so I imagine a rather limited staff in your shop contributing to the long wait.
Old 02-08-2019, 09:14 AM
  #338  
Wayne Smith
Rennlist Member
 
Wayne Smith's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2014
Posts: 5,018
Received 1,150 Likes on 730 Posts
Default

Doing the rough math ...

ONE mechanic assigned to a car to do all work including all R&R requiring three months per car times FOUR three month period per year times FOUR mechanics equals SIXTEEN cars per year.

Add in ancillary projects like videos, schools, quotes, scheduling, billing, and answering questions on this Forum and that number could be lower ...

The above ous crude. I'm sure Jake might have a different way to calculate this, especially if mechanics are assigned to multiple cars so they remain busy in between processes.

The sad thing is we all get older. Talent is lost. Hopefully there is a transition plan in the future so if or when Jake has had enough of this there will still be somewhere for enthusiasts to turn.
Old 02-08-2019, 11:13 AM
  #339  
Flat6 Innovations
Former Vendor
 
Flat6 Innovations's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Cleveland Georgia
Posts: 6,968
Received 2,282 Likes on 899 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by sandwedge
No discussion. You've built an impressive business with a reputation second to nobody. Hat's off to you. The only thing that pops into my head when I read about your backlog is.....are these engines really failing at a rate creating this kind of backlog or are most repaired by dealerships and you only get those who want the very best and something special and are willing to wait and pay for it? Plus,your focus is clearly on quality rather than quantity so I imagine a rather limited staff in your shop contributing to the long wait.
Thank you. It was easier to attain the reputation, than it has been to retain the reputation.

The backlog isn’t so great because the engines are failing at a great pace. The fact is l don’t accept many failed engines these days to work with. The vast majority of our work is elective builds, and failures take away my abiity to give the owner an absolute final price for the work at the very beginning. If we are performing elective work, we know eactly what recipe will used, and know exactly what that will cost frm day #1.

Something like a failed cylinder is about the only failure l will accept to work with these days.

The focus here is on the quality of the product, and also the quality of the process for the vehicle owner. We over- communicate, and set realistic timelines for completion. If we are “on time” with a build, l consider that we are already late. l take the most pride in doing what l say that l will do, and being done on- time, every time.

@Wayne Smith
Keep in mind that the 3 months that the car is here is not al spent working on this one engine. The preparation of the car owner’s engine block is what takes the longest amount of time during this 3 month period. The engine block is at LN Engineering for just over two of these three months. The work flow here is worked out so the builder will remove an engine, and disassemble it, then send the block out. Once the block is gone, he will then spend 2 weeks assembling an engine that just returned from LN, and has all it’s components ready to be assembled- by schedule. After that engine is finished, he will then install it into the car, and my testing process begins. While l am testing that vehicle, he will disassemble another project, and send it away, then the process starts all over again.The three other builders do things the same way, and everything is staggered, so lifts and the engine, and chassis dynos are not clogged with engines. This all works like one well- oiled machine, over and over again.

On average we complete 24 engines per year, and have maintained this average for around a decade. Personally l build about 5 engines per year, none of them are normal, and sane.. Keep in mind that my work day is 15-18 hours, not 8 hours. l don’t quit when l am tired, l quit when l am done.

Yes, we all get older, and things change. My longest time employee told me. few months ago that he’d be retiring in 6 years, and would be here until then. l looked at him and told him that we’d go out together, since he has been here since my first year in business, and he was my first employee. As for transition, well this work isn’t the target of younger talent, and l’d hate to see what l have created go to someone who would run it by trying to “make more money”. At the end of the day that person would have bought a business, and not earned it. They won’t ever respect it like l do. Perhaps when the time comes the other employees will take over to finish their time, time will tell.
l started this business in a barn with a dirt floor, and a crate of old VW engine parts. it had no power, except the extension cord that ran almost 200’ to the nearest power source. By the time the power got to the barn all that could be powered was a broken lamp tossed over a rafter. My work bench was an old chest type freezer, and the broken lamp hung right above it. l built my first 914 engine for a customer at the age of 13. Today that barn isn’t the same.... Its the building on the right side of Petza914’s photo... Yes, thats the same building 30 years later, minus the hogs and chickens.
The following 2 users liked this post by Flat6 Innovations:
bentrod (12-25-2019), TheUnscented (11-01-2020)
Old 02-08-2019, 04:31 PM
  #340  
Mike Murphy
Rennlist Member
 
Mike Murphy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 8,711
Received 1,580 Likes on 987 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Flat6 Innovations
As for transition, well this work isn’t the target of younger talent, and l’d hate to see what l have created go to someone who would run it by trying to “make more money”.
If marketed correctly, there are 1 in 500 millennials - you know, the artsy-fartsy types - whose souls were from a different generation, who would be totally into rebuilding engines of high quality. Kind of like the new mellenial audiophiles out there. Rare indeed, but they are out there.
Old 02-08-2019, 05:32 PM
  #341  
black997er
Instructor
 
black997er's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2018
Posts: 228
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes on 4 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by murphyslaw1978


If marketed correctly, there are 1 in 500 millennials - you know, the artsy-fartsy types - whose souls were from a different generation, who would be totally into rebuilding engines of high quality. Kind of like the new mellenial audiophiles out there. Rare indeed, but they are out there.
And I would argue there are more than 1 in 500. I think millennials catch a lot of flak for a lot of things and unfairly so, but that’s an argument for another forum. As for Flat 6 (and I don’t mean any disrespect) if the company goes away someone will step in to fill the gap. LN Engineering is not going anywhere I don’t think. There’s Hartech across the pond and I wouldn’t rule out new players. It’ll also be the age of the electric 911, hopefully less of a burden to carry by that time.
Old 02-08-2019, 05:56 PM
  #342  
Flat6 Innovations
Former Vendor
 
Flat6 Innovations's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: Cleveland Georgia
Posts: 6,968
Received 2,282 Likes on 899 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by black997er


And I would argue there are more than 1 in 500. I think millennials catch a lot of flak for a lot of things and unfairly so, but that’s an argument for another forum. As for Flat 6 (and I don’t mean any disrespect) if the company goes away someone will step in to fill the gap. LN Engineering is not going anywhere I don’t think. There’s Hartech across the pond and I wouldn’t rule out new players. It’ll also be the age of the electric 911, hopefully less of a burden to carry by that time.
The copy cats will try to “fill the gap”. The issue is that they can’t, just like they can’t compete today. Their businesses are ran sloppily, they don’t communicate, they change names 3 times in one year, and they are in debt up to their ears. They try to do more volume, and the caveat to that is a less than pleasurable experience for the buyer, and poor performance all around as the end result. They don’t develop, and they imitate, rather than originate.

l have one millennial assistant that has been here for 4 years. He works directly under me, and is a great employee. We work hand in hand everyday. He learns a lot every week, and l constantly challenge and quiz him. He must pass a 250 answer, practical application, and written test before l will let him move on to any assembly tasks. It must be passed with 100% effectiveness. l don’t accept a “99 percenter”.

We’ll see where things are in 7 years.. If l never had to deal with business, and people l’d be here till the day l died, and you couldn’t beat me away with a stick. My place is in the shop, way, way, way away from the things that are associated with modern business, marketing, and interaction.
The following users liked this post:
bentrod (12-25-2019)
Old 02-08-2019, 06:33 PM
  #343  
wildbilly32
Drifting
 
wildbilly32's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Flyover Country
Posts: 3,094
Received 774 Likes on 496 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by Flat6 Innovations


The copy cats will try to “fill the gap”. The issue is that they can’t, just like they can’t compete today. Their businesses are ran sloppily, they don’t communicate, they change names 3 times in one year, and they are in debt up to their ears. They try to do more volume, and the caveat to that is a less than pleasurable experience for the buyer, and poor performance all around as the end result. They don’t develop, and they imitate, rather than originate.

l have one millennial assistant that has been here for 4 years. He works directly under me, and is a great employee. We work hand in hand everyday. He learns a lot every week, and l constantly challenge and quiz him. He must pass a 250 answer, practical application, and written test before l will let him move on to any assembly tasks. It must be passed with 100% effectiveness. l don’t accept a “99 percenter”.

We’ll see where things are in 7 years.. If l never had to deal with business, and people l’d be here till the day l died, and you couldn’t beat me away with a stick. My place is in the shop, way, way, way away from the things that are associated with modern business, marketing, and interaction.
Regardless of what the future holds, you are appreciated today...
Old 02-08-2019, 07:33 PM
  #344  
qikqbn
Rennlist Member
 
qikqbn's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 1,293
Received 529 Likes on 294 Posts
Default

I have taught some of those "artsy-fartsy" types at a few "prestigious" colleges. When I mention the words "strong work ethic" some of them look at me like a deer in headlights about to get hit by a mac truck. Yet out of every class there are a "few" who have the real potential to make it. One of the first questions I get is "what's the fastest way to become successful?"... My response.... "Well, the first one to do a specific task correctly... and do it correctly 1000 times will be much closer to success than the person who has done it only 10 times correctly." Again... deer in headlights. Then I say... "The person who has done it 20 years and 10,000 times is probably even better then the person with 1,000 times under his belt." Now the realization sinks in... To be successful takes a heck of a lot of work, proper training, repetition, and determination to do it correctly. I totally understand that the hardest aspect of building a team is finding high quality people with high standards, wisdom, and strong work ethics. They are hard to come by.
Old 02-08-2019, 08:26 PM
  #345  
wildbilly32
Drifting
 
wildbilly32's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Flyover Country
Posts: 3,094
Received 774 Likes on 496 Posts
Default

Originally Posted by qikqbn
I have taught some of those "artsy-fartsy" types at a few "prestigious" colleges. When I mention the words "strong work ethic" some of them look at me like a deer in headlights about to get hit by a mac truck. Yet out of every class there are a "few" who have the real potential to make it. One of the first questions I get is "what's the fastest way to become successful?"... My response.... "Well, the first one to do a specific task correctly... and do it correctly 1000 times will be much closer to success than the person who has done it only 10 times correctly." Again... deer in headlights. Then I say... "The person who has done it 20 years and 10,000 times is probably even better then the person with 1,000 times under his belt." Now the realization sinks in... To be successful takes a heck of a lot of work, proper training, repetition, and determination to do it correctly. I totally understand that the hardest aspect of building a team is finding high quality people with high standards, wisdom, and strong work ethics. They are hard to come by.
Wait...you mean just designing an app won't make me successful???


Quick Reply: 997.2 3.8 Engine Failure



All times are GMT -3. The time now is 08:21 AM.