Sports Cars Instead Of A 911...
#46
How about the last gen Viper? V10 manual trans RWD and I think they aged very well aesthetically . If you could stretch for the ACR, not sure it’s a worse value than a 997 RS. I would love me one; even the base
#47
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#48
Rennlist Member
Nice thing about the 911 is that Porsche offers so many flavors... And especially if you include time as a variable, you can build quite a diverse collection of 911 variants. I only have 3 and they feel completely different to me in terms of feel, use case, looks, etc...
For new cars, as a manual guy, there just aren't a lot of options out there. I'll keep buying 911s until they stop offering a manual ICE option. I'm also trying out an Emira - not really a 911 competitor but I think it will be a fun car in its own right, probably more of a mid-range Cayman competitor and with a completely different and beautiful (IMO) look.
For new cars, as a manual guy, there just aren't a lot of options out there. I'll keep buying 911s until they stop offering a manual ICE option. I'm also trying out an Emira - not really a 911 competitor but I think it will be a fun car in its own right, probably more of a mid-range Cayman competitor and with a completely different and beautiful (IMO) look.
#49
The AMG cars are just insanely heavy, and the BMW M cars are getting there. Anything that gets over 3500/3600 pounds limits the overall driving experience, I don't care how powerful the engine is.
Other manufacturers don't want to compete in this segment - Corvette sales dominate, Porsche is there, no one else really wants to make an affordable sports car for the "mass" market. Manufacturers like Lotus can't produce enough cars to have any meaningful impact in the market. Other makers like Alfa would rather produce $250K+ halo supercar competitors.
Other manufacturers don't want to compete in this segment - Corvette sales dominate, Porsche is there, no one else really wants to make an affordable sports car for the "mass" market. Manufacturers like Lotus can't produce enough cars to have any meaningful impact in the market. Other makers like Alfa would rather produce $250K+ halo supercar competitors.
Paraphrasing, he said that in the future, weight reduction will be more
important than HP for sports cars, because there is already an abundance, if not
overabundance of power.
I have the same weight cutoff point for a sporting car.
Last edited by Tompoodie; 02-16-2023 at 07:08 PM.
#50
I'd consider a McLaren GT, since it seems to have a really good balance between pretty outlandish performance and some semblance of comfort and practicality. The tricky part is just the image that's associated with exotic brands. Base price for the GT is about $250k CAD, and it's not that hard to get some variants of the 911 to that price, but the Porsche is just so much more discrete and less of a "look at me" car than the McLaren (or Ferrari and Aston Martin). The nail in the coffin is the reputation McLaren has for reliability, and the crazy depreciation.
#51
The only option I'd consider is the Maserati MC20.
It's Evo's Car of the Year for a reason and impressed Henry Catchpole and Rory Reid...and they've pretty much driven everything of interest.
It's Evo's Car of the Year for a reason and impressed Henry Catchpole and Rory Reid...and they've pretty much driven everything of interest.
#52
That Maserati is very appealing-just a shame that Maserati cheapened their image with their line of poorly rated 80K vehicles.
#53
Rennlist Member
I'd consider a McLaren GT, since it seems to have a really good balance between pretty outlandish performance and some semblance of comfort and practicality. The tricky part is just the image that's associated with exotic brands. Base price for the GT is about $250k CAD, and it's not that hard to get some variants of the 911 to that price, but the Porsche is just so much more discrete and less of a "look at me" car than the McLaren (or Ferrari and Aston Martin). The nail in the coffin is the reputation McLaren has for reliability, and the crazy depreciation.
I would describe it as elegant but understated IMO:
The following 3 users liked this post by RudyP:
#54
Agree and the 911s discreet looks and ability to fly under the radar are a big draw for me as someone who enjoys sports cars for the experience of driving them but very much do not want any attention/status (I have a silver GT3 Touring because it has the highest ratio of experience/look-at-me of anything on the market IMO - and both of my other 911s are also silver). But I would argue that Astons, at least the VH platform ones like my 2010 Vantage are also very discreet - at least in the silver/gray colors that the majority are in..
I would describe it as elegant but understated IMO:
I would describe it as elegant but understated IMO:
Of course, it's loud as hell and being under the radar doesn't last very long once I get on it.
The following 3 users liked this post by rk-d:
#55
Rennlist Member
<major generalization coming> I think you can tell a lot about how much the core group of owners value attention vs. experience by the common colors that a car model is ordered in... I.e. Lamborghinis and McLarens are bright purple, green, orange, etc... Ferraris are almost always red, Porsches span the gamut but you see a lot of black, white, silver and Astons has 17 different shades of gray/silver on offer...
I know color is a subjective choice and at the individual level does not necessarily mean anything about the owner, I'm speaking in generalities here. And BTW I have a red Ferrari (because you kind of have to...) and I'd love to have an orange long hood 911...
I know color is a subjective choice and at the individual level does not necessarily mean anything about the owner, I'm speaking in generalities here. And BTW I have a red Ferrari (because you kind of have to...) and I'd love to have an orange long hood 911...
#56
Unrelated question - looks your lift is not bolted the the floor - at least that post on the pic? Any concerns?
#58
Burning Brakes
I sometimes miss my 2017 Nissan GT-R. The interior was not as nice as a Porsche. The tuning and modding options are unlimited and much less $$$ than Porsche. I had that car doing 0-60 in 2.7 seconds on cheap E85 gas. Never had a mechanical problem with it in spite of all the tuning (occasional check engine light). Way more people stopped me at gas stations and parking lots to talk about the car than any Porsche I have ever owned. Teen boys idolized me, lol.
The following users liked this post:
Tupper (02-17-2023)
#59
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
^ Rarity and flair do make a difference.
I guess I’m a tad different than many Porsche owners. My BMW is a rocket ship and is my daily driver, although relatively* understated.
But I like my “fun” car to have a bit of flair and personality. I like it to stand out a bit and make good sounds. I like my spirited driving to be accompanied by some drama. That’s probably why I’m so turned off by EV’s. Heck, my 992 was guards red and got a lot of comments.
* Relative to supercars. But the 8 series BMW is a beauty in its own right
I guess I’m a tad different than many Porsche owners. My BMW is a rocket ship and is my daily driver, although relatively* understated.
But I like my “fun” car to have a bit of flair and personality. I like it to stand out a bit and make good sounds. I like my spirited driving to be accompanied by some drama. That’s probably why I’m so turned off by EV’s. Heck, my 992 was guards red and got a lot of comments.
* Relative to supercars. But the 8 series BMW is a beauty in its own right
Last edited by Tupper; 02-17-2023 at 06:31 PM.
#60
Rennlist Member
I think I'm getting these articles to cancel my T order and buy something else but I don't think there's anything appealing on the list for me. Maybe M3 (instead of M8) but thats not even on the list.
Why so much hate on 911?
Link: https://www.hotcars.com/sports-cars-...f-porsche-911/
Why so much hate on 911?
Link: https://www.hotcars.com/sports-cars-...f-porsche-911/