991.2 Base/S/GTS Modification & Race Track Prep Thread
#227
Can we discuss Spring rates whilst we are waiting?
I still have not been able to find what the GTS spring rates are.
Carrera S 33/108 N/mm
991.2 GT3 45/120 (Same as most older GT3-RS)
991.2 GT3-RS 100/160
Ohlins recommend up grading your GT3 to 100/160.
The Tarmac guys I spoke to said the most they would run for Tarmac would be 70/130. (They ran 70/120 and said great on road, but unstable on track) Then they recommeded 100/180 for mainly Track use.
My car is more of an all rounder. So I am thinking more along the lines of 80/150. Anyone have any thoughts on this?
I still have not been able to find what the GTS spring rates are.
Carrera S 33/108 N/mm
991.2 GT3 45/120 (Same as most older GT3-RS)
991.2 GT3-RS 100/160
Ohlins recommend up grading your GT3 to 100/160.
The Tarmac guys I spoke to said the most they would run for Tarmac would be 70/130. (They ran 70/120 and said great on road, but unstable on track) Then they recommeded 100/180 for mainly Track use.
My car is more of an all rounder. So I am thinking more along the lines of 80/150. Anyone have any thoughts on this?
Speak to the guys at Porsche Melbourne - they look after the Cup cars and Matt Closes car - discuss what you are trying to achieve and which events you are getting set for and they'll put you right. One option is to get in touch with Proflex (Alister McRae is in Oz at the moment) they do great set ups ~20k and there is a group out of Brisbane that do the set up for about 50% of the Australian Targa Series cars (Murray Coote at MCA Suspension - gold series 5k to 10k). Also I know the Manthey generally uses and prefers KW set ups (I think the last Adac winner was on the new 4 ways).
The GT3 set up would be as far as I would go - and that is a very, very well set up car (although there is a difference in weight distribution that needs to be considered). The critical variables are the ratio of the thickness of the front and rear sway bar and the ratio of the front spring rates to rear spring rates assuming damping rates and valving are paired to the spring rates.
Have a look at the sway bars and end-links before the springs/coil overs. Keep in mind the Porsche S-PASM is very very good - in terms of Porsche suspension I'm of the frame "if it ain't broke don't fix it"
Last edited by groundhog; 08-22-2018 at 04:59 AM.
#228
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Thread Starter
Can we discuss Spring rates whilst we are waiting?
I still have not been able to find what the GTS spring rates are.
Carrera S 33/108 N/mm
991.2 GT3 45/120 (Same as most older GT3-RS)
991.2 GT3-RS 100/160
Ohlins recommend up grading your GT3 to 100/160.
The Tarmac guys I spoke to said the most they would run for Tarmac would be 70/130. (They ran 70/120 and said great on road, but unstable on track) Then they recommeded 100/180 for mainly Track use.
My car is more of an all rounder. So I am thinking more along the lines of 80/150. Anyone have any thoughts on this?
I still have not been able to find what the GTS spring rates are.
Carrera S 33/108 N/mm
991.2 GT3 45/120 (Same as most older GT3-RS)
991.2 GT3-RS 100/160
Ohlins recommend up grading your GT3 to 100/160.
The Tarmac guys I spoke to said the most they would run for Tarmac would be 70/130. (They ran 70/120 and said great on road, but unstable on track) Then they recommeded 100/180 for mainly Track use.
My car is more of an all rounder. So I am thinking more along the lines of 80/150. Anyone have any thoughts on this?
Basic Carrera Chassis: 24 / 48
Carrera / Carrera S PASM Chassis: 28 / 62
Carrera / Carrera S PASM Sport Chassis: 33 / 108
There is no specific mention of spring rates in my 991.2 bible which would leave me to believe they're carried over because that's how these books are usually written. Your numbers would confirm this so for this argument let's assume that the 991.2 GTS is still 33/108 in n/mm or 188/617 in lb/in, like the 991.1; given that you told me that your car is way too loose, you're going to want more FRONT springrate on your car. I understand that the GT3s are set up differently, have aero and different bars but some of these things can be close enough to the window to improve the overall balance of the car. I personally don't think that the front bar on the 991.1 GT3 is beefy enough but we run it on some cars because it's an improvement over stock and that's what i will run on this car but since i don't think it's stiff enough, I am going to want more front spring rate. Those 100/160 rates on the .2 GT3 and RS cars are big numbers but if im not mistaken, those cars also run "tender" springs which allow you to run big rates for the main spring while still maintaining compliance over bumps and harsh curbs. The 991 is rather well balanced and i don't think you'd create too much understeer or tighten the car up too much by increasing the front spring rate without a proportionate increase to the rear. I am going to try this H&R VTF kit at Sebring in 3 weeks and report back but i already know that the front rate isn't stiff enough.
H&R VTF Adjustable Lowering Springs for 991 PASM
#230
Which tarmac guys did you talk to? 100N/mm front and 160N/mm is 10kgf and 16kgf respective which I would consider brutal on a road car even with exceptional damping.
The GT3 set up would be as far as I would go - and that is a very, very well set up car (although there is a difference in weight distribion that needs to be considered). The critical variables are the ratio of the thickness of the front and rear sway bar and the ratio of the front spring rates to rear spring rates assuming damping rates and valving are paired to the spring rates.
Have a look at the sway bars and end-links before the springs/coil overs. Keep in mind the Porsche S-PASM is very very good - in terms of Porsche suspension I'm of the frame "if it ain't broke don't fix it"
The GT3 set up would be as far as I would go - and that is a very, very well set up car (although there is a difference in weight distribion that needs to be considered). The critical variables are the ratio of the thickness of the front and rear sway bar and the ratio of the front spring rates to rear spring rates assuming damping rates and valving are paired to the spring rates.
Have a look at the sway bars and end-links before the springs/coil overs. Keep in mind the Porsche S-PASM is very very good - in terms of Porsche suspension I'm of the frame "if it ain't broke don't fix it"
I have all the Elephant racing adjustable bars. As well as the End links. I still haven't fitted the OEM GT3 adjustable anti-sway bars yet, But I have them and the upgraded bushings. So by the time I upgrade the Springs, my car will be more RS than S. I am thinking 80/150
According to my 991.1 bible, rates for the 991.1 Carrera in n/mm were as follows:
Basic Carrera Chassis: 24 / 48
Carrera / Carrera S PASM Chassis: 28 / 62
Carrera / Carrera S PASM Sport Chassis: 33 / 108
Those 100/160 rates on the .2 GT3 and RS cars are big numbers but if im not mistaken, those cars also run "tender" springs which allow you to run big rates for the main spring while still maintaining compliance over bumps and harsh curbs. The 991 is rather well balanced and i don't think you'd create too much understeer or tighten the car up too much by increasing the front spring rate without a proportionate increase to the rear. I am going to try this H&R VTF kit at Sebring in 3 weeks and report back but i already know that the front rate isn't stiff enough.
H&R VTF Adjustable Lowering Springs for 991 PASM
Basic Carrera Chassis: 24 / 48
Carrera / Carrera S PASM Chassis: 28 / 62
Carrera / Carrera S PASM Sport Chassis: 33 / 108
Those 100/160 rates on the .2 GT3 and RS cars are big numbers but if im not mistaken, those cars also run "tender" springs which allow you to run big rates for the main spring while still maintaining compliance over bumps and harsh curbs. The 991 is rather well balanced and i don't think you'd create too much understeer or tighten the car up too much by increasing the front spring rate without a proportionate increase to the rear. I am going to try this H&R VTF kit at Sebring in 3 weeks and report back but i already know that the front rate isn't stiff enough.
H&R VTF Adjustable Lowering Springs for 991 PASM
Seeing as though I will have the same OEM adjustable sway bars and I have all the elephant stuff, I don't think I need 100/160 or 100/180 . Whilst that would be great on the track, I think it would be too harsh for a street Porsche.
I am considering the Tractive Active coilovers. So that they use upgraded software on my DSC module. (They react 17x faster than GT3-RS, and it is the only shock that can adjust mid stroke. Impreseive stuff.) But I really want to get the Spring rates right.
That's why I am going with AKRA. They are 300 Cell cats. (No engine lights)
#231
Oh Hey, I just noticed your number 355, I usually run 357 LOL. Great minds.
He John, What spring rates are those H&R's?
Whilst I want to get the full tractive coilovers, I thought about just up grading the front springs to 80 N/m as a test just to see if I like it? Thoughts?
He John, What spring rates are those H&R's?
Whilst I want to get the full tractive coilovers, I thought about just up grading the front springs to 80 N/m as a test just to see if I like it? Thoughts?
#232
So what's the latest BGB? I enjoy reading your updates
#233
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by flsupraguy
So what's the latest BGB? I enjoy reading your updates
Car will have:
Cobb Stage I Flash
IPD Plenum
Cargraphic catless or catted bypass pipe
BMC Filter
PWR Radiators
AMS Intercoolers
H&R VVT Springs & Coilovers
Tarett Monoball everything
Upgraded GT3 sway bars & drop links
DSC PASM controller
MSI Wheel Studs & Lug Nuts
15mm / 7mm wheel spacers
BGB 4-point harness bar (yellow)
Schroth enduro belts (black & yellow)
Porsche GT2 carbon fiber bucket seats
I'm sure I'm forgetting something but if you know anyone looking for a track oriented 991.2 GTS with 5-lugs, no sunroof and RAS delete, there might be a commission in it for you.
#234
Nice. Very similar.
Car will have:
Cobb Stage I Flash - Tick
IPD Plenum -Tick
Cargraphic catless or catted bypass pipe - (still thinking Akra)
BMC Filter - (Not yet)
PWR Radiators - (Not yet)
AMS Intercoolers - Tick
H&R VVT Springs & Coilovers - (Thinking Tractive Coilovers 80/150)
Tarett Monoball everything - Elephant racing everything
Upgraded GT3 sway bars & drop links - Tick and Elephant racing drop links
DSC PASM controller - Tick
MSI Wheel Studs & Lug Nuts - I have Centre Locks
15mm / 7mm wheel spacers - Centre Locks
BGB 4-point harness bar (yellow) - (Might consider this)
Schroth enduro belts (black & yellow) - (Nice, may consider)
Porsche GT2 carbon fiber bucket seats - ( I like the 18 way lol. Bad ribs.)
I have tint, PPF and MPSC2.
Any pics of the tarett monoballs?
Any pics of the tarett monoballs?
#235
I just ordered the kitchen sink with the intention of taking the car to Sebring in 2 weeks and then COTA in October for a DE where it will sit with a FOR SALE sticker. I'm at 6K on the odometer.
Car will have:
Cobb Stage I Flash
IPD Plenum
Cargraphic catless or catted bypass pipe
BMC Filter
PWR Radiators
AMS Intercoolers
H&R VVT Springs & Coilovers
Tarett Monoball everything
Upgraded GT3 sway bars & drop links
DSC PASM controller
MSI Wheel Studs & Lug Nuts
15mm / 7mm wheel spacers
BGB 4-point harness bar (yellow)
Schroth enduro belts (black & yellow)
Porsche GT2 carbon fiber bucket seats
I'm sure I'm forgetting something but if you know anyone looking for a track oriented 991.2 GTS with 5-lugs, no sunroof and RAS delete, there might be a commission in it for you.
Car will have:
Cobb Stage I Flash
IPD Plenum
Cargraphic catless or catted bypass pipe
BMC Filter
PWR Radiators
AMS Intercoolers
H&R VVT Springs & Coilovers
Tarett Monoball everything
Upgraded GT3 sway bars & drop links
DSC PASM controller
MSI Wheel Studs & Lug Nuts
15mm / 7mm wheel spacers
BGB 4-point harness bar (yellow)
Schroth enduro belts (black & yellow)
Porsche GT2 carbon fiber bucket seats
I'm sure I'm forgetting something but if you know anyone looking for a track oriented 991.2 GTS with 5-lugs, no sunroof and RAS delete, there might be a commission in it for you.
#236
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Thread Starter
Are you sure? I feel like it would be really hard to find someone like that, especially in the state of Florida.
#237
Drifting
Just thought I'd chime in and mention that I've done ~1000 track miles/15.75 hrs of track time in my 2018 Carrera C2 (PDK/PSE/SC)
Have done the above + 3900 street miles on the stock tires...with careful pressure management they are somehow still holding on.
One set of rear pads roasted, but to be fair I ran the car in "SPORT PLUS" with PSM ON up until the last two track days. I started turning PSM OFF at that point to try and save the pads a bit.
Front pads roughly at 1/4-1/5 OEM thickness now.
Car has been solid in terms of temps...as far as what I can see on the stock gauges is concerned. Rear brake calipers are starting to discolor a bit.
Plenty of rock chips and a nice 2 inch road rash scrape on the front pass. fender from a chunk of tire...for those who care about those things
Looking forward to 2 more track days this season...and then winter prep for next season! (Caliper/wheel studs, fresh fluids (again) and researching some more tires!)
Have done the above + 3900 street miles on the stock tires...with careful pressure management they are somehow still holding on.
One set of rear pads roasted, but to be fair I ran the car in "SPORT PLUS" with PSM ON up until the last two track days. I started turning PSM OFF at that point to try and save the pads a bit.
Front pads roughly at 1/4-1/5 OEM thickness now.
Car has been solid in terms of temps...as far as what I can see on the stock gauges is concerned. Rear brake calipers are starting to discolor a bit.
Plenty of rock chips and a nice 2 inch road rash scrape on the front pass. fender from a chunk of tire...for those who care about those things
Looking forward to 2 more track days this season...and then winter prep for next season! (Caliper/wheel studs, fresh fluids (again) and researching some more tires!)
#238
I just ordered the kitchen sink with the intention of taking the car to Sebring in 2 weeks and then COTA in October for a DE where it will sit with a FOR SALE sticker. I'm at 6K on the odometer.
Car will have:
Cobb Stage I Flash
IPD Plenum
Cargraphic catless or catted bypass pipe
BMC Filter
PWR Radiators
AMS Intercoolers
H&R VVT Springs & Coilovers
Tarett Monoball everything
Upgraded GT3 sway bars & drop links
DSC PASM controller
MSI Wheel Studs & Lug Nuts
15mm / 7mm wheel spacers
BGB 4-point harness bar (yellow)
Schroth enduro belts (black & yellow)
Porsche GT2 carbon fiber bucket seats
I'm sure I'm forgetting something but if you know anyone looking for a track oriented 991.2 GTS with 5-lugs, no sunroof and RAS delete, there might be a commission in it for you.
Car will have:
Cobb Stage I Flash
IPD Plenum
Cargraphic catless or catted bypass pipe
BMC Filter
PWR Radiators
AMS Intercoolers
H&R VVT Springs & Coilovers
Tarett Monoball everything
Upgraded GT3 sway bars & drop links
DSC PASM controller
MSI Wheel Studs & Lug Nuts
15mm / 7mm wheel spacers
BGB 4-point harness bar (yellow)
Schroth enduro belts (black & yellow)
Porsche GT2 carbon fiber bucket seats
I'm sure I'm forgetting something but if you know anyone looking for a track oriented 991.2 GTS with 5-lugs, no sunroof and RAS delete, there might be a commission in it for you.
Four point harness? (potentially very dangerous if not fitted correctly which is common e.g. buckle too high) - just go straight to a six point.
Brakes?
Suspension - stiffer/lower is not better - this is a major fallacy with the modding scene. When you start using adjustable sway bars and adjustable coil overs you waste more time trying to work out which is the best setup for any given track than you do racing. SPASM is very, very effective.
The only items on this list that resonate with me are the cooling mods (intercoolers and radiators) and, even then I haven't run into cooling problems as yet (although I'm not involved in endurance wheel to wheel).
What were you trying to achieve and more importantly has it worked e.g. significant change in lap times?
Last edited by groundhog; 09-08-2018 at 10:57 PM.
#239
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by groundhog
Why would you delete RAS, it (in effect) delivers an extra 1.5 degrees of slip angle. This is the reason why the GTS is competitive with GT3/RS through corners.
Four point harness???? waste of time and potentially very dangerous if not fitted correctly (which is common e.g. buckle too high)
Four point harness???? waste of time and potentially very dangerous if not fitted correctly (which is common e.g. buckle too high)
I purchased the car used from Porsche and it didn't have RAS. I'm not a fan of tuning on cars with rear axle steering nor do I like driving them on the race track so I saw it as a plus. I don't doubt it's faster...within 102% of the limit of the car, computer aids will always produce better lap times. I'm not some purist hater of vehicle aids. I like them.
As for the harness, it's a 4-point bar NOT a 4 point harness. I don't agree in referring to 4-point bolt in bars as "roll bars" so I call them 4-point harness bars given that they're bolted to the rear shock towers AND lower sheet steel rocker. I really only believing in weld in cages to be honest.
I do agree 100% with you that if that stuff isn't installed properly it can be dangerous but I'd never suggest anyone's using less than 5 points and I know the harness bar height is right because I oversaw the design of it. We made it in house and it's in several 991 GT3s around the country. Car owners have a responsibility to select the correct sized seat slider / mount combo to always double check appropriate shoulder harness angles based on seat back height.
Cheers mate!
#240
^^^ RAS delete your words not mine.
Why don't you like driving RAS, it delivers, free of charge 1.5 degrees of slip angle - thats a lot. I'll take that plus SPASM over unmatched sway bars and coilovers.
I suspect harness bars will be banned (unless built into a cage, obviously) - too many poorly installed - delivering the wrong angle at the shoulders.
So you have modded a car, all of which is unproven through testing on the car, will drive it at Sebring and then sell it?
Where is the track testing in all of this? The feed back loop?
What happened to the BGB approach as applied to the GT4?
To deliver a much improved suspension set up that delivers results on the clock requires a lot of work and testing - slap it in and hope is not the way I would do it.
Not trying to be a PITA, just curious as to why the apparent change in direction and the spray and wipe approach.
Why don't you like driving RAS, it delivers, free of charge 1.5 degrees of slip angle - thats a lot. I'll take that plus SPASM over unmatched sway bars and coilovers.
I suspect harness bars will be banned (unless built into a cage, obviously) - too many poorly installed - delivering the wrong angle at the shoulders.
So you have modded a car, all of which is unproven through testing on the car, will drive it at Sebring and then sell it?
Where is the track testing in all of this? The feed back loop?
What happened to the BGB approach as applied to the GT4?
To deliver a much improved suspension set up that delivers results on the clock requires a lot of work and testing - slap it in and hope is not the way I would do it.
Not trying to be a PITA, just curious as to why the apparent change in direction and the spray and wipe approach.
Last edited by groundhog; 09-09-2018 at 01:18 AM.