A 86.5 Timing Belt / Water Pump Picture Thread from a first-timer
#46
Rennlist Member
Great work, Scott! We likes shiny parts!
Stan has done a lot more of these that I have, and I respect his opinion greatly. But I think this is worthy of discussion: The purpose of the oil is lubrication, heat transfer and also dampening-- that's what the little check-valve is for, on the part with the o-ring.
Porsche specifies engine oil or gear lube, depending on the reference-- those are about the same viscosity. STP is quite a bit thicker, and while it is true that it will leak out more slowly, I also don't think it will provide the same dampening effect. Having no oil doesn't provide any dampening either, of course.
So my approach is to make a serious effort to make the tensioner not leak (sealer on the boot as you did, clean the gasket surfaces carefully, sealer on the adjuster bolt, etc) and then use the specified oil.
Them's my thoughts, there are no wrong answers, and YMMV.
Mrmerlin suggests in this thread to use STP oil treatment to fill the tensioner. I am going to try this method.
Porsche specifies engine oil or gear lube, depending on the reference-- those are about the same viscosity. STP is quite a bit thicker, and while it is true that it will leak out more slowly, I also don't think it will provide the same dampening effect. Having no oil doesn't provide any dampening either, of course.
So my approach is to make a serious effort to make the tensioner not leak (sealer on the boot as you did, clean the gasket surfaces carefully, sealer on the adjuster bolt, etc) and then use the specified oil.
Them's my thoughts, there are no wrong answers, and YMMV.
#47
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
If you didn't remove the bleed nipples and clean the holes in it and the bore they ride in, that needs to be done. The goop tends to clog the bleed nipple at the inside, and the seat. I can't tell from the pics if you did that, but if not, do it before reassembly in the car.
Oh, and I disagree with using STP or another highly viscous fluid in the tensioner. The valve orifice is calibrated for a certain viscosity when warm to provide the correct damping force. STP doesn't have the same thermal coef as gear oil. I used gear oil in the two that I did and they work ok, but I'm in hot TX. I might use straight SAE 40wt or 50wt if I lived in a more genteel climate.
Oh, and I disagree with using STP or another highly viscous fluid in the tensioner. The valve orifice is calibrated for a certain viscosity when warm to provide the correct damping force. STP doesn't have the same thermal coef as gear oil. I used gear oil in the two that I did and they work ok, but I'm in hot TX. I might use straight SAE 40wt or 50wt if I lived in a more genteel climate.
#48
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Hi Doc and Jim,
Two thoughts:
- Neither bleed screw had rubber boots on them. (!) I cleaned both bleed screws very thoroughly before installing.
- John Kelly's manual cites the higher (i.e. left) bleed screw as the oil "filler" screw, and the lower (i.e. right) bleed screw as the drain. Logic tells me it should be the opposite- to get more oil in there. Am I wrong?
Questions:
- When should I fill the tensioner- now, or when the tensioner is installed?
- Since my bleed screw is missing the rubber boots, do I need to order the Porsche ones, or can I use rubber vacuum caps, of which I have an assortment of colors and sizes?
BTW, here are some of the threads I read on the subject.
Confused: What oil to use in tensioner?
Can a leaking tensioner be the sole reason for loss of timing belt tension?
Tensioner rebuild question
Getting Oil into the TB Tensioner
Gear Oil - T/B Tensioner
Thoughts / methods on filling T-belt tensioner w/ oil?
Filling Tensioner Oil - question
Two thoughts:
- Neither bleed screw had rubber boots on them. (!) I cleaned both bleed screws very thoroughly before installing.
- John Kelly's manual cites the higher (i.e. left) bleed screw as the oil "filler" screw, and the lower (i.e. right) bleed screw as the drain. Logic tells me it should be the opposite- to get more oil in there. Am I wrong?
Questions:
- When should I fill the tensioner- now, or when the tensioner is installed?
- Since my bleed screw is missing the rubber boots, do I need to order the Porsche ones, or can I use rubber vacuum caps, of which I have an assortment of colors and sizes?
BTW, here are some of the threads I read on the subject.
Confused: What oil to use in tensioner?
Can a leaking tensioner be the sole reason for loss of timing belt tension?
Tensioner rebuild question
Getting Oil into the TB Tensioner
Gear Oil - T/B Tensioner
Thoughts / methods on filling T-belt tensioner w/ oil?
Filling Tensioner Oil - question
Last edited by syoo8; 12-17-2013 at 05:31 PM.
#49
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Higher one is correct and any good fitting cap will work.
Fill after the tensioner is installed as the oil flows from the tensioner into the cavity in the block and back to the tensioner
Fill after the tensioner is installed as the oil flows from the tensioner into the cavity in the block and back to the tensioner
__________________
Does it have the "Do It Yourself" manual transmission, or the superior "Fully Equipped by Porsche" Automatic Transmission? George Layton March 2014
928 Owners are ".....a secret sect of quietly assured Porsche pragmatists who in near anonymity appreciate the prodigious, easy going prowess of the 928."
Does it have the "Do It Yourself" manual transmission, or the superior "Fully Equipped by Porsche" Automatic Transmission? George Layton March 2014
928 Owners are ".....a secret sect of quietly assured Porsche pragmatists who in near anonymity appreciate the prodigious, easy going prowess of the 928."
#50
Rennlist Member
BTW, here are some of the threads I read on the subject.
Confused: What oil to use in tensioner?
Can a leaking tensioner be the sole reason for loss of timing belt tension?
Tensioner rebuild question
Getting Oil into the TB Tensioner
Gear Oil - T/B Tensioner
Confused: What oil to use in tensioner?
Can a leaking tensioner be the sole reason for loss of timing belt tension?
Tensioner rebuild question
Getting Oil into the TB Tensioner
Gear Oil - T/B Tensioner
Cheers, Jim
#51
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
I did a lot of cleaning (two hours) and the left side is looking a bit better.
I pulled the water pump.
I see some radial 'wear' in the cavity, in the path where the impeller would spin. Is this normal?
I pulled the water pump.
I see some radial 'wear' in the cavity, in the path where the impeller would spin. Is this normal?
#52
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Scott,
Did the pump you removed have a metal impeller?
As long as you do not feel a deep ridge where the impeller was touching the cavity in the block you will be fine.
What was the pump make? Any movement in the bearing? Just interested.
Roger
Did the pump you removed have a metal impeller?
As long as you do not feel a deep ridge where the impeller was touching the cavity in the block you will be fine.
What was the pump make? Any movement in the bearing? Just interested.
Roger
#53
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Hi Roger- yes, the pump I removed was a rebuilt Porsche pump with a metal impeller. There was no "play" in the bearing whatsoever- it was solid. However, it makes a slight noise as you turn it- a very faint scraping noise one every three revolutions or so. The noise is similar to scraping your fingernail on a piece of cardboard.
No, there was not a deep ridge. It felt relatively smooth.
No, there was not a deep ridge. It felt relatively smooth.
#54
Supercharged
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Back in Michigan - Full time!
Posts: 18,925
Likes: 0
Received 59 Likes
on
33 Posts
That looks normal to me. Looks like machining marks from the factory...
You'll want to take a razor blade to the WP surface to clean off the old gasket - tedious crappy job, but it has to be done.
Great effort. Keep it up.
You'll want to take a razor blade to the WP surface to clean off the old gasket - tedious crappy job, but it has to be done.
Great effort. Keep it up.
#55
Drifting
Following up on AO's advice of using a razor blade to clean the mating surface of the block to water pump. Make sure the razor blade is 90 degrees to the mating surface at all times. You will have some material left, do not use the razor blade to try and take that out as you might gouge the surface. Just scrape the surface with the razor blade at 90 degrees.
#56
You'll want to replace that washer behind the crank gear. Chances are that gear won't come off easily and you'll need to get an extractor to grip behind that washer to pull off the whole thing.
Took me 3 days to get it off. Mine was rusted onto the crankshaft.
Buy some engine assembly lube (or anti-seize) and apply it to any shaft where a gear is as well as the inside of the gears. Makes pulling them off less of a pain in whatever future.
Took me 3 days to get it off. Mine was rusted onto the crankshaft.
Buy some engine assembly lube (or anti-seize) and apply it to any shaft where a gear is as well as the inside of the gears. Makes pulling them off less of a pain in whatever future.
#57
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Scott - what amazes me is how competent you have become in your mechanical skills on the 928 and your posts are up there with the likes of Stan (Mr. Merlin), Dwayne and others who give so much back to the 928 community. Your ability to record the process and pose just the right questions to establish a working document for other "newbies" needs special thanks.
I bookmark your threads for the benefit of my "newbie" customers.
Your skills are much wider in scope and without wanting to embarrass you I am sure others would enjoy the following as I and my family do - thank you.
I bookmark your threads for the benefit of my "newbie" customers.
Your skills are much wider in scope and without wanting to embarrass you I am sure others would enjoy the following as I and my family do - thank you.
#59
Team Owner
Talk about cuttin the rug,
Those are the kind of hands you need to work on a 928.
I suggest to wear blue gloves.
Well done Scott, your supremely talented.
Roger thanks for posting this link.
Those are the kind of hands you need to work on a 928.
I suggest to wear blue gloves.
Well done Scott, your supremely talented.
Roger thanks for posting this link.
#60
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
You are all very kind. Thank you for your kind comments about the Tchaikovsky. I am honored to be included in this forum.