Fatal Bore Scoring - Cheap fix, dump or rebuild?
#1
Fatal Bore Scoring - Cheap fix, dump or rebuild?
Hey guys. I overpaid for a cayenne turbo with bore scoring. All cylinders have moderate scoring I found using a cheap boresope, however all hold compression expect for #8 after doing a compression test. It doesn't even pressurize.
I want to dump it and cut my losses. I paid 15k cad and the vehicle is emaculate otherwise with 100000km. I'm in a cash crunch and wod lucky to get 12k at an auction. I dont think anyone wouldnd willingly pay 15000 for an engine that severely misfires.
My 4 options are (or arent):
1. Dump it at the auction and cut my losses
2. Put some restore teflon oil additive and hope the scoring fills temporarily so it makes it down the highway to the auction auction.
3.teardown the engine and put new piston rings (cant afford honing and new pistons or sleeping the cylinders (unless this can be done with $2000k )
My questions are
1.Is it possible to put something in the oil to make the knock quieter and make the engine run smoother temporarily so that I can get decent cash at the auction (maybe restore)?
2.how long for an average guy to teardown the engine , install rings, hone cylinders, install new pistons and put it back together. My biggest job had been a clutch in a 986 took me a weekend.
3. Anyone have a cheap cayenne turbo engine?
4. Anyone looking to take this off my hands?
5. What would someone be willing to pay if I fix it properly?
6. Is it possible that the cylinder holds no pressure because of bore scoring or is it more likely that I have a broken valve spring or stuck valve, maybe a head gasket as the coolant was low ?
I did a cold compression test today so I'm going to warm the engine tomorrow and try testing the compression on #8 again. If a wet test holds any pressure I will lean to option #1
Thanks for the input
Last edited by derksma11; 05-18-2019 at 01:16 PM. Reason: Add photo
#3
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Be forthright - sell it as roller with a known bad motor and move on. Lesson learned by you.
#4
What year Cayenne?
Think Karma. Passing the buck will get back to you. Maybe this is it getting back?
Personal feelings aside, you only have two repair options.
1. New engine/ have one built. 8k+ minimum if you go with a Nichrome plating, new guts, and assemble/install it all yourself.
2. Used engine.
You cant quickly repair this engine due to the block material. I have a good used engine for sale.
What year?
Think Karma. Passing the buck will get back to you. Maybe this is it getting back?
Personal feelings aside, you only have two repair options.
1. New engine/ have one built. 8k+ minimum if you go with a Nichrome plating, new guts, and assemble/install it all yourself.
2. Used engine.
You cant quickly repair this engine due to the block material. I have a good used engine for sale.
What year?
#5
What year Cayenne?
Think Karma. Passing the buck will get back to you. Maybe this is it getting back?
Personal feelings aside, you only have two repair options.
1. New engine/ have one built. 8k+ minimum if you go with a Nichrome plating, new guts, and assemble/install it all yourself.
2. Used engine.
You cant quickly repair this engine due to the block material. I have a good used engine for sale.
What year?
Think Karma. Passing the buck will get back to you. Maybe this is it getting back?
Personal feelings aside, you only have two repair options.
1. New engine/ have one built. 8k+ minimum if you go with a Nichrome plating, new guts, and assemble/install it all yourself.
2. Used engine.
You cant quickly repair this engine due to the block material. I have a good used engine for sale.
What year?
#6
I'm sorry to hear about your misfortune but scamming someone else is the wrong way to go about it.
Now, was it a private sale or dealership purchase? If you bought it from a dealership you might be able to return it. If it's a private sale.. then the previous owner just screwed you and you don't really have any recourse.
Now, was it a private sale or dealership purchase? If you bought it from a dealership you might be able to return it. If it's a private sale.. then the previous owner just screwed you and you don't really have any recourse.
#7
Burning Brakes
#3 is definitely possible with that budget, even if it's only CAD. J'sWorld might even do it for you at that price.
Trending Topics
#8
Burning Brakes
Why would you even care about #8? Even if you had compression in #8, the engine itself is TRASH due to the scoring. This isn't something you'll eke an extra 20K to 30K miles out of...it'll become useless in less than 1,000 miles, and I'm betting you're at that point right now because of no compression in #8.
No one will give you $12,000 for a rolling paperweight. It's worth a few thousand if you sell outright or maybe a bit more if you take the time to part it out and sell piece by piece. Basically, YOU are out $12,000 based on your purchase price.
Your $2,000 "repair" budget won't come close to the cost of a used engine (which may also be scored), it won't cover the while you're in there things and it probably won't cover the labor you'd pay someone to remove and replace the engine.
I also see you edited out a lot of the things you said in your original post. Adding snake oil to cover up major engine damage reeks of scumbag used car salesman tactics dating back to putting sawdust in transmissions. Do that to the wrong guy and you'll end up in a world of hurt.
No one will give you $12,000 for a rolling paperweight. It's worth a few thousand if you sell outright or maybe a bit more if you take the time to part it out and sell piece by piece. Basically, YOU are out $12,000 based on your purchase price.
Your $2,000 "repair" budget won't come close to the cost of a used engine (which may also be scored), it won't cover the while you're in there things and it probably won't cover the labor you'd pay someone to remove and replace the engine.
I also see you edited out a lot of the things you said in your original post. Adding snake oil to cover up major engine damage reeks of scumbag used car salesman tactics dating back to putting sawdust in transmissions. Do that to the wrong guy and you'll end up in a world of hurt.
#9
Quickly checked eBay. A replacement motor from a 2009 Turbo (I think among the least likely to have the issue in the future) is about $5000 usd shipped. Add about another thousand for miscellaneous things and assuming you do the labor yourself, you can maybe get away with $6000. At that point you can dump it or keep it. You could recover about $8-10,000 if you dump it then (after subtracting the cost of repair)?
#10
I appreciate all the passion but I am not trying to scam anyone. If it is not worth much I will tear down my gts engine and swap blocks / pistons . I just want to get what it is worth. I come across salvage cayenne turbos selling for 10k all the time, so one in mint condition must be worth at least that. I had a 2004 cct with worse bore scoring and it ran for 7 years (still running well), so if I can fix the compression issue on my 08 I will keep it for myself. I feel many owners jump the gun on the bore scoring issue without doing complete research. In my experience, while you can have severely score cylinders, It doesn't mean you have a compression issue and proper oil changes will limit wear well beyond you think.
#11
Might be worth the time for a complete rebuild. You cant find a cct in my area for less than 25k with less than 140000km. Would resleeving and new stock pistons ne a better option than machining and oversized pistons/rings ?
#12
I'm gonna make this my last post here. My used is a 4.5 so that won't help you. Either dump it honestly for a loss or next best option is 928 Motorsports service. Talk to Carl. Do it yourself. Enjoy your Cayenne for many years to come and when the time comes sell with confidence and the attraction of the engine work you invested in to the buyer. It will actually increase the value over others IMO. lessons learned. You live in a cold climate. I doubt you will make it much longer. I can see metal flakes/ chunks in the poor res. pic. It's toast. Don't be an idiot and ruin everything else in the engine too. Good luck.
#13
Burning Brakes
All P Cars thrive on native high oil hop pellets
I suggest a Tettnanger
https://www.simplyhops.com/hops/hop-...ellet-5kg.html
Start with not more than 500g
Awesome exhaust notes too
#14
I had a 2004 cct with worse bore scoring and it ran for 7 years (still running well), so if I can fix the compression issue on my 08 I will keep it for myself. I feel many owners jump the gun on the bore scoring issue without doing complete research. In my experience, while you can have severely score cylinders, It doesn't mean you have a compression issue and proper oil changes will limit wear well beyond you think.
I think you should tear down your gts and try to use the parts to fix your turbo....LOL That demonstrates a complete lack of understanding what you are up against. Based on that last sentence, I think you should show us all and run it till it dies, which will probably be sometime in the next 1000 miles as mentioned.
You gambled and lost on the Porsche engine lotto, time to suck it up.
#15
Burning Brakes
But he got 7 years out of another one with scored cylinders...and it's still running!
Sad part is that someone will run across a post like his in a Google search, believe the bull**** and end up buying a ticking time bomb, thinking it's no big deal.
Sad part is that someone will run across a post like his in a Google search, believe the bull**** and end up buying a ticking time bomb, thinking it's no big deal.