Nick Murray on the T: Less is More
(And the side decals.)
Funny - I passed on a GTS allocation and ended up with a T.
I had first visited the dealer in July 2021 to ask about the Carrera T but since it was over a year away from being announced, they had me do a useless "demand order" for an S. I didn't want a GTS because I couldn't get a wheel color I liked (i.e., not black or body color or bright silver) or sport tex seat centers. And I didn't really want to spend that much. So I was annoyed when they offered me a GTS allocation last December after I'd specifically said T or S. At any rate, with no PTS, I preferred the T over the S so I leave room for an upgrade if I am ever so inclined. Maybe I try for an S with PTS in the future, though prob not worth the massive leap in price of 2024 models (if I bought a 2024 S w/PTS it'd be about $40k more than my 2023 T w/o PTS!).
I had first visited the dealer in July 2021 to ask about the Carrera T but since it was over a year away from being announced, they had me do a useless "demand order" for an S. I didn't want a GTS because I couldn't get a wheel color I liked (i.e., not black or body color or bright silver) or sport tex seat centers. And I didn't really want to spend that much. So I was annoyed when they offered me a GTS allocation last December after I'd specifically said T or S. At any rate, with no PTS, I preferred the T over the S so I leave room for an upgrade if I am ever so inclined. Maybe I try for an S with PTS in the future, though prob not worth the massive leap in price of 2024 models (if I bought a 2024 S w/PTS it'd be about $40k more than my 2023 T w/o PTS!).
@Wilder My apologies for misunderstanding. I agree that the T is more than enough for street driving. Yeah, I moved to the GTS. Dealer held it for me until I was able to do a Porsche Experience and decide. I wasn't sure the power would be too much, but it wasn't and I'd be happy with the T or the GTS. With the price hikes, it made even more sense since I got a 23 and the difference was about 17K going from T to GTS. Also able to do ED with the GTS, which wasn't opened up yet with the T. 

It's no tied to a model. I wasn't trying to imply that. But, when I was given the option to buy the T, ED was not available. For this and other reasons, I gave away the allocation to wait for another. The GTS came along and they had an ED slot, so I took it. For me it was between the T and S/GTS. I'll be happy with any of those as long as they are optioned the way I want. Super excited for the GTS though.
I do find him entertaining to a point . I also do like that he's kind to animals and is a decent guy . Thats not enough to convince me that a 144K T is "the one" for me.
If you or anyone else bought one I would be happy for you . I like the car . I just feel that when Porsche rose all the prices it changed things . In 2018 a friend bought a T for under 110K . So now that the prices are up its even more important to get it right because there are no bargains . The 18 T was a bargain . So now it comes down to looking at the choices and picking the one suits you best in your life . Then the price pill slides down easier even its more money .
If you or anyone else bought one I would be happy for you . I like the car . I just feel that when Porsche rose all the prices it changed things . In 2018 a friend bought a T for under 110K . So now that the prices are up its even more important to get it right because there are no bargains . The 18 T was a bargain . So now it comes down to looking at the choices and picking the one suits you best in your life . Then the price pill slides down easier even its more money .
T, S, or GTS. It's a win, win, win situation. I'd be happy with any of the three as long as it's configured the way I want it. I did go all leather this time, because if I keep it for more than ten years, I don't want the race-tex showing signs of wear. Leather on the other hand will patina nicely. 

Well unfortunately because Rennlist = egos. And the profound conformation bias on here ends up with constant posts in these types of threats about why my car is better than your car and I'm better at making decisions.
Funny - I passed on a GTS allocation and ended up with a T.
I had first visited the dealer in July 2021 to ask about the Carrera T but since it was over a year away from being announced, they had me do a useless "demand order" for an S. I didn't want a GTS because I couldn't get a wheel color I liked (i.e., not black or body color or bright silver) or sport tex seat centers. And I didn't really want to spend that much. So I was annoyed when they offered me a GTS allocation last December after I'd specifically said T or S. At any rate, with no PTS, I preferred the T over the S so I leave room for an upgrade if I am ever so inclined. Maybe I try for an S with PTS in the future, though prob not worth the massive leap in price of 2024 models (if I bought a 2024 S w/PTS it'd be about $40k more than my 2023 T w/o PTS!).
I had first visited the dealer in July 2021 to ask about the Carrera T but since it was over a year away from being announced, they had me do a useless "demand order" for an S. I didn't want a GTS because I couldn't get a wheel color I liked (i.e., not black or body color or bright silver) or sport tex seat centers. And I didn't really want to spend that much. So I was annoyed when they offered me a GTS allocation last December after I'd specifically said T or S. At any rate, with no PTS, I preferred the T over the S so I leave room for an upgrade if I am ever so inclined. Maybe I try for an S with PTS in the future, though prob not worth the massive leap in price of 2024 models (if I bought a 2024 S w/PTS it'd be about $40k more than my 2023 T w/o PTS!).T, S, or GTS. It's a win, win, win situation. I'd be happy with any of the three as long as it's configured the way I want it. I did go all leather this time, because if I keep it for more than ten years, I don't want the race-tex showing signs of wear. Leather on the other hand will patina nicely. 

What I find inconsistent with Nick is that with both the Macan GTS and the 992 GTS he didn't feel that the bundle package made the car a value . With both cars he preferred the S (deep down I think its because he hates race tex enough to make a solo video on it ). But with the T he goes out and drives a bloated expensive base car (but it has a manual) and it tickles his fancy .
Just a note on you tube journalists - Its a very different thing to hook up some cameras and spend an hour with a car and another period editing than a actually owning the car . Nicks best videos were/ are about the cars that he owns .
I bought my nicely optioned manual 2018 991.2 T off the showroom floor in Dec 2018, with a hefty discount and a bunch of freebees thrown in (inc a set of winter tires!). The car was unsold new and they wanted it gone by end of year. Crazy to think of that now - those days are long gone and prob won't ever come back.
I agree with Nick Murray's opinion on the 992 T. I am one that prefers driving a slow car fast versus a fast car slow. I believe the 992 T has all the performance I'd want and is the right new 911 for me. The problem for me is the price. A medium optioned 24 T is around $140k now. That's a lot of money (to me) and really takes away from the value proposition of the new T. I understand how Porsche is cashing in on the brand value and moving up market, but it does feel a bit like I'm being taken advantage of. I officially backed out of my T order when they raised the MSRP on the 24s. I'm still kicking around the idea of getting back in though, largely because it seems like this might be the last chance to get a base model manual Carrera (non-hybrid). Meanwhile, I'll continue to enjoy my 997.2 C2 manual, which most days feels like all the 911 I want!
I agree with Nick Murray's opinion on the 992 T. I am one that prefers driving a slow car fast versus a fast car slow. I believe the 992 T has all the performance I'd want and is the right new 911 for me. The problem for me is the price. A medium optioned 24 T is around $140k now. That's a lot of money (to me) and really takes away from the value proposition of the new T. I understand how Porsche is cashing in on the brand value and moving up market, but it does feel a bit like I'm being taken advantage of. I officially backed out of my T order when they raised the MSRP on the 24s. I'm still kicking around the idea of getting back in though, largely because it seems like this might be the last chance to get a base model manual Carrera (non-hybrid). Meanwhile, I'll continue to enjoy my 997.2 C2 manual, which most days feels like all the 911 I want!
I bought my nicely optioned manual 2018 991.2 T off the showroom floor in Dec 2018, with a hefty discount and a bunch of freebees thrown in (inc a set of winter tires!). The car was unsold new and they wanted it gone by end of year. Crazy to think of that now - those days are long gone and prob won't ever come back.
I agree with Nick Murray's opinion on the 992 T. I am one that prefers driving a slow car fast versus a fast car slow. I believe the 992 T has all the performance I'd want and is the right new 911 for me. The problem for me is the price. A medium optioned 24 T is around $140k now. That's a lot of money (to me) and really takes away from the value proposition of the new T. I understand how Porsche is cashing in on the brand value and moving up market, but it does feel a bit like I'm being taken advantage of. I officially backed out of my T order when they raised the MSRP on the 24s. I'm still kicking around the idea of getting back in though, largely because it seems like this might be the last chance to get a base model manual Carrera (non-hybrid). Meanwhile, I'll continue to enjoy my 997.2 C2 manual, which most days feels like all the 911 I want!
I agree with Nick Murray's opinion on the 992 T. I am one that prefers driving a slow car fast versus a fast car slow. I believe the 992 T has all the performance I'd want and is the right new 911 for me. The problem for me is the price. A medium optioned 24 T is around $140k now. That's a lot of money (to me) and really takes away from the value proposition of the new T. I understand how Porsche is cashing in on the brand value and moving up market, but it does feel a bit like I'm being taken advantage of. I officially backed out of my T order when they raised the MSRP on the 24s. I'm still kicking around the idea of getting back in though, largely because it seems like this might be the last chance to get a base model manual Carrera (non-hybrid). Meanwhile, I'll continue to enjoy my 997.2 C2 manual, which most days feels like all the 911 I want!
I sold it at the beginning of the pandemic, when everyone was concerned the market would tank. Sold it for close to what I paid, but looking back that was probably the biggest car mistake I've ever made. It was a great car and I should have kept it.
The 2018 T is the car that got me seriously thinking about making a future 911 purchase. I rem building them on the configurator to around $111k at the time, My cheapskate (aka "poverty spec") 2023 T only came to $125k - and I got everything I wanted (except unavailable PTS!). Now I think that feels like a bargain, since if I were ordering a 2024 T, the build would come to $149k (assuming PTS is actually available, which I would not bet on).
I can see why someone would have a blast driving the car for a few days . However there would quickly come a point when the novelty erodes and 3, 5, and 7 with a manual mated to a turbo just isn't going to cut it and the T really did have a manual in mind . Theres also the day my wife's Macan GTS beats me and I'd say "need more power" . After all if light, nimble , agile was the premise why not save the money into a 718 GTS or Gt4 ? It will, run right through a T in auto cross and become an NA engine with a manual at a lower price to boot.
Rennlist Member

Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 5,233
Likes: 3,647
From: Newport Beach, CA and Melbourne, Australia
But don’t fret over ‘having’ to stick with a manual 997.2; one of the best 911’s and apart from the tech a match or even better than a 992 in many ways.



