Notices
992 2019-Present The Forum for the Non-Turbo 911
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

Nick Murray Compares the C8 to 911

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 11-18-2022 | 03:10 AM
  #46  
Bluehighways's Avatar
Bluehighways
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Aug 2020
Posts: 2,883
Likes: 2,756
From: Orange County California
Default

Originally Posted by Smirnoff67
Man that is wicked cool! I sure wish we had something like that in Florida! That would be a blast. Scary as hel! but definitely a rush to be able to go flat out on a nice long highway with no fear of going to jail. Thanks for sharing that!
FWIW, "Two other Open Road Racing events happen annually in the U.S. the Big Bend Open Road Racing organization happens in West Texas every April, and the Sandhills Open Road Challenge happens in Arnold, Nebraska every August." Source is Wikipedia
https://bborr.com/
https://sorcrace.com/

Last edited by Bluehighways; 11-18-2022 at 03:12 AM.
The following users liked this post:
Smirnoff67 (11-18-2022)
Old 11-18-2022 | 12:27 PM
  #47  
garthg's Avatar
garthg
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Jun 2021
Posts: 581
Likes: 263
From: Winchester MA
Default

Originally Posted by ron4sc
I took my Audi S4 to ~115mph once. Visions of being thrown in jail flashed in my head as a backed off of the accelerator.

ED is the one chance that most of us in the US get to legally drive at speeds that are unthinkable. If I take my 911 on the autobahn and get to 140-150, I’ll make sure the GoPro captures it and save the memory forever. Anything above that are speeds I’m not willing to consider….for now
I've done 130mph/210Kph on the Autobahn (in a Ford Mondeo Estate behind a Porsche 930 Turbo) but on my most recent trip to Germany we never topped 117mph because of traffic and speed limits, despite having an Audi S5 Sportback, 3.0 TDI that would easily have reached 150.
Speaking to a Munchener on a flight home recently, he said you have to drive at night to find clear roads. Doing 150mph at night is not my thing.
Old 11-18-2022 | 01:49 PM
  #48  
Ontheboost's Avatar
Ontheboost
Intermediate
 
Joined: Jun 2022
Posts: 32
Likes: 36
From: NorCal
Default

Originally Posted by A Nonce
I don't agree with Nick on a lot of Porsche related issues but I am not certain why fully functioning adults love bashing him when he expresses an opinion that goes against theirs. 🤷

The Porsche community would be a quite dreary place 💤💤💤 if we all agreed with each other and there would be no dissent. He has changed my opinion on a lot of issues (biggest I can think of is Alcantara)!

I love the fact that the C8 & other variants exist! I wish it would fit my lifestyle but it has no rear seats! I am jealous & thankful of the value they provide. Without the competition I am sure Porsche would charge yet even more 💸💸💸💸💸 than they already do!
I agree. I have always disliked corvettes and would never consider owning one as they are just not my style.

But as an auto enthusiast, this the fact that GM copied a Ferrari and pretty much nailed it should be celebrated. If you don’t like knock offs and prefer the real deal, totally understand that but that is a very expensive proposition which most can’t attain. Having the performance at a fraction of the cost available to a wider audience is a good thing for humanity.

BTW, I also bought the gas cap.
The following users liked this post:
minn19 (11-18-2022)
Old 11-18-2022 | 03:10 PM
  #49  
ipse dixit's Avatar
ipse dixit
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 17,320
Likes: 12,262
Default

More and better competition is good for all of us.
The following users liked this post:
SBAD (11-24-2022)
Old 11-19-2022 | 02:21 PM
  #50  
bhvrdr's Avatar
bhvrdr
Pro
 
Joined: Aug 2017
Posts: 578
Likes: 40
Default

I had never considered buying a Corvette in my 40+ year lifetime. The interior quality and general front engine rear drive limitations kept me from it.

Ive owned 5 porsches, 12 Audis, 4 bmws and 40 or so other random cars.

When the c8 was introduced it really peaked my attention. GM had wanted the last generation car to be this one but the engineers never could get the green light. The engineers said they had reached the limits of the front engine rear wheel drive platform. The last generation zr1 super Corvette was no faster to 60mph than the z06 because it was severely traction limited.

The c8 changed all that. The 500hp stingray is sitting on a chassis that can handle 1000hp and still be usable.

Since 2020 ive purchased 3 c8 Corvettes now. I still have several German and Italian cars.

The c8 is a no excuses car imo. I honestly cannot find fault in the interior quality anymore. I can see not liking the design language (i didn't at first but once living with it the ergonomics are incredible. I actually reach out less than in my 911 for settings). There aren't cheap playskool looking plastics anywhere anymore.

The actual track performance is absolutely outstanding. I did a two day racing school in one and the car has outstanding limits and handling characteristics and the gm magnetic ride control that is licensed by Ferrari because of how good it is simply cannot be compared to PASM. Not that the Porsche has bad handling by any means but the actual shock control on mag ride vs pasm is another playing field.

I have zero thoughts that the stingray is "better" or "worse" than my pcar. Its different. Both have outstanding characteristics that shine imo. The pcar is magic in its handling. The chassis is so mature that cornering is at least as enjoyable as the c8. The straight line stability is better in the c8 imo. They both sound so different and so awesome at full song i like both equally. The idea the c8 has a pushrod v8 in it from Chevy means if i blow one on the track some day there will likely be 5 thousand dollar used ones i can put in whereas it was 25k on the pcar. The pcar has other worldly visibility and driving position imo. It shrinks around you. The c8, like a supercar, does not. Theyre just different imo but i have to say im proud of gm for producing a performance car that for the fist time in my life has been an American car that i really wanted to buy (outside perhaps a new ford gt (gt40).

Last edited by bhvrdr; 11-19-2022 at 09:44 PM.
The following 3 users liked this post by bhvrdr:
Einmalig (11-19-2022), minn19 (11-19-2022), Tireman (02-01-2024)
Old 11-19-2022 | 05:44 PM
  #51  
chance6's Avatar
chance6
Race Car
 
Joined: Jun 2018
Posts: 3,807
Likes: 1,506
From: Somewhere out East
Default

Originally Posted by ron4sc
I took my Audi S4 to ~115mph once. Visions of being thrown in jail flashed in my head as a backed off of the accelerator.

ED is the one chance that most of us in the US get to legally drive at speeds that are unthinkable. If I take my 911 on the autobahn and get to 140-150, I’ll make sure the GoPro captures it and save the memory forever. Anything above that are speeds I’m not willing to consider….for now
In 2011 I remember taking my 997.2 C2S to 140 mph on winter tires...to which my g/f at the time exclaimed "slow down" ! lol

Up here in Chicagoland suburb highways, I see these jackals ***-houses going 110-120 mph routinely in cars that approach instability at those speeds. Chevy Malibus and the like. It's the f* Wild West up here.

Hence the need for the vaunted Turbo S.
Old 11-19-2022 | 07:18 PM
  #52  
icanthelpit's Avatar
icanthelpit
Burning Brakes
 
Joined: Jun 2018
Posts: 1,112
Likes: 878
Default

Originally Posted by EZ E
Buy 2 C8's for one 992!
But then you wouldn’t have the 992.
Old 11-19-2022 | 08:58 PM
  #53  
992.Turbo.S's Avatar
992.Turbo.S
Racer
 
Joined: May 2022
Posts: 307
Likes: 187
Default

Originally Posted by bhvrdr
I had never considered buying a Corvette in my 40+ year lifetime. The interior quality and general front engine rear drive limitations kept me from it.

Ive owned 5 porsches, 12 Audis, 4 bmws and 40 or so other random cars.

When the c8 was introduced it really peaked my attention. GM had wanted the last generation car to be this one but the engineers never could get the green light. The engineers said they had reached the limits of the front engine rear wheel drive platform. The last generation zr1 super Corvette was no faster to 60mph than the z06 because it was severely traction limited.

The c8 changed all that. The 500hp stingray is sitting on a chassis thst can handle 1000hp and still be usable.

Since 2020 ive purchased 3 c8 Corvettes now. I still have several German and Italian cars.

The c8 is a no excuses car imo. I honestly cannot find fault in the interior quality anymore. I can see not liking the design language (i didn't at first but once living with it the ergonomics are incredible. I actually reach out less than in my 911 for settings). There aren't cheap playschool looking plastics anywhere anymore.

The actual track performance is absolutely outstanding. I did a two day racing school in one and the car has outstanding limits and handling characteristics and the gm magnetic ride control that is licensed by Ferrari because of how good it is simply cannot be compared to PASM. Not that the Porsche has bad handling by any means but the actual shock control on mag ride vs pasm is another playing field.

I have zero thoughts that the stingray is "better" or "worse" than my pcar. Its different. Both have outstanding characteristics that shine imo. The pcar is magic in its handling. The chassis is so mature that cornering is at least as enjoyable as the c8. The straight line stability is better in the c8 imo. They both sound so different and so awesome at full song i like both equally. The idea the c8 has a pushrod v8 in it from Chevy means if i blow one on the track some day there will likely be 5 thousand dollar used ones i can put in whereas it was 25k on the pcar. The pcar has other worldly visibility and driving position imo. It shrinks around you. The c8, like a supercar, does not. Theyre just different imo but i have to say im proud of gm for producing a performance car that for the fist time in my life has been an American car that i really wanted to buy (outside perhaps a new ford gt (gt40).

I enjoyed your description. You make me wish I could wrap my head around owning one.
The following users liked this post:
bhvrdr (11-19-2022)
Old 11-19-2022 | 11:18 PM
  #54  
Einmalig's Avatar
Einmalig
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 345
Likes: 160
From: DFW
Default

Originally Posted by bhvrdr
I had never considered buying a Corvette in my 40+ year lifetime. The interior quality and general front engine rear drive limitations kept me from it.

Ive owned 5 porsches, 12 Audis, 4 bmws and 40 or so other random cars.

When the c8 was introduced it really peaked my attention. GM had wanted the last generation car to be this one but the engineers never could get the green light. The engineers said they had reached the limits of the front engine rear wheel drive platform. The last generation zr1 super Corvette was no faster to 60mph than the z06 because it was severely traction limited.

The c8 changed all that. The 500hp stingray is sitting on a chassis that can handle 1000hp and still be usable.

Since 2020 ive purchased 3 c8 Corvettes now. I still have several German and Italian cars.

The c8 is a no excuses car imo. I honestly cannot find fault in the interior quality anymore. I can see not liking the design language (i didn't at first but once living with it the ergonomics are incredible. I actually reach out less than in my 911 for settings). There aren't cheap playskool looking plastics anywhere anymore.

The actual track performance is absolutely outstanding. I did a two day racing school in one and the car has outstanding limits and handling characteristics and the gm magnetic ride control that is licensed by Ferrari because of how good it is simply cannot be compared to PASM. Not that the Porsche has bad handling by any means but the actual shock control on mag ride vs pasm is another playing field.

I have zero thoughts that the stingray is "better" or "worse" than my pcar. Its different. Both have outstanding characteristics that shine imo. The pcar is magic in its handling. The chassis is so mature that cornering is at least as enjoyable as the c8. The straight line stability is better in the c8 imo. They both sound so different and so awesome at full song i like both equally. The idea the c8 has a pushrod v8 in it from Chevy means if i blow one on the track some day there will likely be 5 thousand dollar used ones i can put in whereas it was 25k on the pcar. The pcar has other worldly visibility and driving position imo. It shrinks around you. The c8, like a supercar, does not. Theyre just different imo but i have to say im proud of gm for producing a performance car that for the fist time in my life has been an American car that i really wanted to buy (outside perhaps a new ford gt (gt40).
Your post is as accurate as it is honest, even if it may never be fully appreciated on a Porsche Forum. Similar to you, I’ve owned 5 Porsche, 3 BMW, 2 Mercedes and 10 Audis over the past 30 years. In fact, virtually every performance car I’ve owned has been German with the exception of a 2006 Corvette Z06. It was a reluctant purchase from a friend who owned an exotic car dealership in NY.

It was bright yellow, had a 7.0L V8, a six speed manual and was a hard to find model at the time. I didn’t really want the car but my friend said “ everyone should own a Corvette at least once before they die” and I couldn’t refute his logic. I bought the car in March, drove it all Summer and sold it for a $5K profit that Fall. It was the first car in a long time that made me smile while I was behind the wheel. It was a 3100 lbs. with a 505 HP 427 and the handling was far better than I had expected. That said, the interior was crap, the seats inadequate and the run flat tires were terrible.

In 2020, my 75 year old father in law ordered a new C8 Stingray and I helped him pick it up at the Bowling Green Factory Museum. After 500 or so miles behind the wheel, it occurred to me that this $75K Coupe did some things as well as my 2018 GT3 and a few things even better. The only flaw I could find was a lack of steering feel compared to the feedback of the excellent electric steering on my 991.2. Otherwise, I was so impressed that I called a Chevrolet Dealer that week and asked to be put on his list for the next Z06.

That was more than two years ago and thanks to supply chain challenges I’m still a year from getting my car. When it arrives, it will be a mid-mounted 670 HP, 5.5L Flat Plane DOHC with an 8 Speed DCT and World Class handling for less than $150K. My Dealer is holding more than 4,000 customer deposits and the car will likely be out of production before his 3000th customer is served. Who would have ever thought ten years ago that buying a Chevrolet and a Ferrari would be such a similar experience?
The following users liked this post:
minn19 (11-19-2022)
Old 11-19-2022 | 11:24 PM
  #55  
minn19's Avatar
minn19
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Dec 2020
Posts: 903
Likes: 637
From: Minnesota
Default

If didn’t need back seats (yes even the worthless 911 ones) I’d definitely be seriously looking at a C8 to see if I really liked it.
Old 11-20-2022 | 01:51 AM
  #56  
ipse dixit's Avatar
ipse dixit
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 17,320
Likes: 12,262
Default

Originally Posted by bhvrdr
I had never considered buying a Corvette in my 40+ year lifetime. The interior quality and general front engine rear drive limitations kept me from it.

Ive owned 5 porsches, 12 Audis, 4 bmws and 40 or so other random cars.

When the c8 was introduced it really peaked my attention. GM had wanted the last generation car to be this one but the engineers never could get the green light. The engineers said they had reached the limits of the front engine rear wheel drive platform. The last generation zr1 super Corvette was no faster to 60mph than the z06 because it was severely traction limited.

The c8 changed all that. The 500hp stingray is sitting on a chassis that can handle 1000hp and still be usable.

Since 2020 ive purchased 3 c8 Corvettes now. I still have several German and Italian cars.

The c8 is a no excuses car imo. I honestly cannot find fault in the interior quality anymore. I can see not liking the design language (i didn't at first but once living with it the ergonomics are incredible. I actually reach out less than in my 911 for settings). There aren't cheap playskool looking plastics anywhere anymore.

The actual track performance is absolutely outstanding. I did a two day racing school in one and the car has outstanding limits and handling characteristics and the gm magnetic ride control that is licensed by Ferrari because of how good it is simply cannot be compared to PASM. Not that the Porsche has bad handling by any means but the actual shock control on mag ride vs pasm is another playing field.

I have zero thoughts that the stingray is "better" or "worse" than my pcar. Its different. Both have outstanding characteristics that shine imo. The pcar is magic in its handling. The chassis is so mature that cornering is at least as enjoyable as the c8. The straight line stability is better in the c8 imo. They both sound so different and so awesome at full song i like both equally. The idea the c8 has a pushrod v8 in it from Chevy means if i blow one on the track some day there will likely be 5 thousand dollar used ones i can put in whereas it was 25k on the pcar. The pcar has other worldly visibility and driving position imo. It shrinks around you. The c8, like a supercar, does not. Theyre just different imo but i have to say im proud of gm for producing a performance car that for the fist time in my life has been an American car that i really wanted to buy (outside perhaps a new ford gt (gt40).
One a year?

May I ask why?

Seems like a lot in a 3 year time span.
The following users liked this post:
SBAD (11-24-2022)
Old 11-20-2022 | 02:14 AM
  #57  
bhvrdr's Avatar
bhvrdr
Pro
 
Joined: Aug 2017
Posts: 578
Likes: 40
Default

Originally Posted by ipse dixit
One a year?

May I ask why?

Seems like a lot in a 3 year time span.
yes i more or less got on one list after another knowing i could drive the car for a bit and see if i really liked the color and options and still sell it and pocket some money. Im pretty happy with the options i have now although Im not usually a cheesy sticker guy but they do add value and i e gotten to kind of dig them

The following 3 users liked this post by bhvrdr:
Noah Fect (11-20-2022), Ohio Performance (11-23-2022), OliverK68 (11-20-2022)
Old 11-20-2022 | 03:46 AM
  #58  
rouxeny's Avatar
rouxeny
Pro
 
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 615
Likes: 398
From: Hawaii
Default

C8 looks fantastic and has the performance to meet its looks. We’re lucky in this day of turbo engines and increasing electrification that a car like that still exists.
Old 11-20-2022 | 07:59 AM
  #59  
90sundevil's Avatar
90sundevil
7th Gear
 
Joined: Feb 2014
Posts: 7
Likes: 2
From: Scottsdale
Default

I am a Porsche guy and have owned many different models, Cayenne, Cayman, Taycan, Macan and 30 911's of various flavors. I am also a Corvette guy and have owned around a dozen different Corvette's, but the difference is I would never own any other GM product as they are all crap.

Old 11-20-2022 | 08:57 AM
  #60  
yrralis1's Avatar
yrralis1
Burning Brakes
 
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 1,157
Likes: 760
From: South Florida
Default

A few years ago I drove by the pre launch party hosted at a large dealership . I stopped in to look at the cars , talked with a few repeat corvette buyers , and was more welcomed than a few of the replies I read on the thread , I found the car interesting but wish it was the V8 mid engine PDK that Porsche could have built . I did learn a lot about the car and its design that Nick had not shared .

Fast forward to present the Z06 is a beast . I started looking at 1/4 times and quickly saw that. young woman named Emelia Hartford broke all the records . Shes young, talks fast , and brings a lot of enthusiasm to breaking those records . Since she is lighter and can drive it makes sense that beat the chevy drivers (mostly men) who weigh more in the same car .

Here she is in the Z06 . Car sounds great !!
The following 5 users liked this post by yrralis1:
balucipher (11-20-2022), dhirm5 (11-20-2022), minn19 (11-20-2022), OliverK68 (11-20-2022), Staffie Guy (11-20-2022)


Quick Reply: Nick Murray Compares the C8 to 911



All times are GMT -3. The time now is 11:34 AM.