Anyone else hesitant on 991 prices?
#61
![Question](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon5.gif)
Don't want to get into a tax debate with you or anyone but your'e way off the mark. Australia has a massive population of Euro cars. People here do have the money to buy and are buying new cars by the boatload. Take BM. Their prices have come off 10 to 20k....as have MB. Porsche on the other hand have taken the opposite direction and are paying the price here. Maybe not in China or US where you can buy these cars for a song, but here in Aus for sure. If they want to move 991's here they will have to meet the market.....their call.
Don't know where you get your information for Porsche prices in China but you are way off the mark in thinking that you can get Porsches for a song there. The pricing there is at least 2x US prices and after all the hidden costs involved with registration, it gets pretty high. The same applies to the rest of Asia where prices in those markets make the Australian prices look down right reasonable. For example, a base 991 in Singapore with minimal options retails at US$500k.
Australia, as a market, in the last 10 years has ballooned into an over priced market place. Almost everything in that market is now over priced or over valued.
#62
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I think the 991 is a better car than yhe 997TT, so I sold the TT. I an anxiously awaiting the new TT. Anything past a 6 year old Toyota is just something you want.
#63
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: West Los Angeles & Truckee, CA
Posts: 4,018
Received 862 Likes
on
588 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I think the 991 is a better car than yhe 997TT, so I sold the TT. I an anxiously awaiting the new TT. Anything past a 6 year old Toyota is just something you want.
#64
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Gary,
I wish it was just the government that was taking us for a ride. Unfortuantely it isnt. Porsche head office and Porsche Cars Australia are treating its customers with contempt. My invoice, on a car that is similarly configured to yours has a sticker price of AUD$315K -> USD$328K. Breakdown is $92K taxes $223K car. Yeah I am pi$$ed but I still ended up paying for it like the idiot I am. In contrast the parent company VW is slashing their pricing out here like it is going out of fashion and having a firesale on their line up.
You talk about tarrifs and protectionism in Australia, the current levels are at 5%. Europe and the US are actually higher. The main difference is the number of units sold into the US market vs the Australian market.
I wish it was just the government that was taking us for a ride. Unfortuantely it isnt. Porsche head office and Porsche Cars Australia are treating its customers with contempt. My invoice, on a car that is similarly configured to yours has a sticker price of AUD$315K -> USD$328K. Breakdown is $92K taxes $223K car. Yeah I am pi$$ed but I still ended up paying for it like the idiot I am. In contrast the parent company VW is slashing their pricing out here like it is going out of fashion and having a firesale on their line up.
You talk about tarrifs and protectionism in Australia, the current levels are at 5%. Europe and the US are actually higher. The main difference is the number of units sold into the US market vs the Australian market.
So while I agree that Aussies are shafted in the price of these cars, the wherewithal is clearly there. Many punters in Pt Piper, Toorak etc who can pay for a 911.
Meanwhile in the US we had the greatest financial collapse since the 1930s. But then, if one can purchase a 911 here you have done better than average folks since 2007. A 911 is clearly an indulgent purchase and while it's annoying that prices are high -especially in Oz etc - it's not that you are an 'idiot'. No, you choose to spend your hard-earned money as you see fit, and it's very annoying that prices are so expensive there relative to the US.
Each market's dynamics is distinct and the pricing reflects that reality. Don't like it, then 2 options:
(1) Don't buy - be more value conscious
(2) Move countries where you can 'arb' prices [some do when they become frustrated, but then the offset are property taxes and health care]
All this being said, the pricing [Downunder] is 'cheeky'. They do so, because they can. And the lux tax reflects both the local ideology as well as the ability to extract a consumption tax. The US is relatively unbalanced in its tax basis in that nearly 50% of revenues derive from income; in Oz in income taxes are ~ 30% of revs, then there's consumption tax which includes the lux tax (~ 10% revs). Pay to consume is the message. The US could learn from that
![ducking](https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/icon107.gif)
Last edited by 917k; 12-23-2012 at 03:14 PM.
#65
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Southern California
Posts: 1,429
Likes: 0
Received 15 Likes
on
15 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Gary,
I wish it was just the government that was taking us for a ride. Unfortuantely it isnt. Porsche head office and Porsche Cars Australia are treating its customers with contempt. My invoice, on a car that is similarly configured to yours has a sticker price of AUD$315K -> USD$328K. Breakdown is $92K taxes $223K car. Euro vs AUD is stronger than ever. AUD vs USD is even stronger. So where do they get off on charging twice for the car here in Oz vs the US. The AUD has virtually doubled its value in the last ten years to the USD. So lets see Germany would have been banking on a 65-70 EUR to AUD conversion, yet we sit at 83. 20% better off then they add a further 10% to the new price so an upside of 30% from previous model. Is it the government or Porsche that is screwing us now? Yeah I am pi$$ed but I still ended up paying for it like the idiot I am. In contrast the parent company VW is slashing their pricing out here like it is going out of fashion and having a firesale on their line up.
You talk about tarrifs and protectionism in Australia, the current levels are at 5%. Europe and the US are actually higher. The main difference is the number of units sold into the US market vs the Australian market. When the US accounts for what 60% of their sales and Australia is something like 400-500 units a year I do expect to pay a premium but not twice the base cost.
I wish it was just the government that was taking us for a ride. Unfortuantely it isnt. Porsche head office and Porsche Cars Australia are treating its customers with contempt. My invoice, on a car that is similarly configured to yours has a sticker price of AUD$315K -> USD$328K. Breakdown is $92K taxes $223K car. Euro vs AUD is stronger than ever. AUD vs USD is even stronger. So where do they get off on charging twice for the car here in Oz vs the US. The AUD has virtually doubled its value in the last ten years to the USD. So lets see Germany would have been banking on a 65-70 EUR to AUD conversion, yet we sit at 83. 20% better off then they add a further 10% to the new price so an upside of 30% from previous model. Is it the government or Porsche that is screwing us now? Yeah I am pi$$ed but I still ended up paying for it like the idiot I am. In contrast the parent company VW is slashing their pricing out here like it is going out of fashion and having a firesale on their line up.
You talk about tarrifs and protectionism in Australia, the current levels are at 5%. Europe and the US are actually higher. The main difference is the number of units sold into the US market vs the Australian market. When the US accounts for what 60% of their sales and Australia is something like 400-500 units a year I do expect to pay a premium but not twice the base cost.
Moreover, I have to point out that the customs document cited applied to the general case of importation of goods for resale. That is not always the same as importation by the dealer network of a manufacturer of automobiles. I don't assert a difference, I just suspect one. If you could have my Cabrio by paying the Porsche factory $140k in Europe and then bringing it back home and 'only' paying $60k in taxes, instead of paying $300 plus to a dealer, then it's safe to say you would be discussing that option.
Granted, Porsche is under no obligation to sell cars at the same price in all markets. You may be right that they hope for an extra U$100k in margin in your market. In which case, they would charge you the price for the Australian market even if you used European Delivery.
It is... ironic? entertaining? sad? that an Italian is over on 6speedonline expressing his delight at learning that he can get a basic S for around a $100k here in the states because he would pay twice that in Europe.
Gary
#66
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
There is not really an entry level new Ferrari. I own a 991 C2S and a 458. The 991 does not outperform it. Have you read any tests? I also owned a 997 TT at the same time as the 991. So far the 991 has had 5 campaigns and has been in the shop for 2 weeks. The 458 nada. Most people are clueless about actuall Ferrari ownership they repeat what they heard.
I think the 991 is a better car than yhe 997TT, so I sold the TT. I an anxiously awaiting the new TT. Anything past a 6 year old Toyota is just something you want.
I think the 991 is a better car than yhe 997TT, so I sold the TT. I an anxiously awaiting the new TT. Anything past a 6 year old Toyota is just something you want.
Although I do not share your opinion often..this time I agree
![Smilie](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
To say that a 991S can beat a 458 is for me the joke of the year..the 997.2turbo S clearly smokes the best 911S..that I know..
#67
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Speed,
Don't know where you get your information for Porsche prices in China but you are way off the mark in thinking that you can get Porsches for a song there. The pricing there is at least 2x US prices and after all the hidden costs involved with registration, it gets pretty high. The same applies to the rest of Asia where prices in those markets make the Australian prices look down right reasonable. For example, a base 991 in Singapore with minimal options retails at US$500k.
Australia, as a market, in the last 10 years has ballooned into an over priced market place. Almost everything in that market is now over priced or over valued.
Don't know where you get your information for Porsche prices in China but you are way off the mark in thinking that you can get Porsches for a song there. The pricing there is at least 2x US prices and after all the hidden costs involved with registration, it gets pretty high. The same applies to the rest of Asia where prices in those markets make the Australian prices look down right reasonable. For example, a base 991 in Singapore with minimal options retails at US$500k.
Australia, as a market, in the last 10 years has ballooned into an over priced market place. Almost everything in that market is now over priced or over valued.
I recall seeing Lamborhini Aus going broke just recently. One of their special model Gallardo cars sold under the hammer for 430K at Auction and was nearly a 700K car. Where were all the "rich" Aussies then? If Aussies are as able to pay the high prices as what is being assumed here then why didn't that car fetch its 700K? I mean it was a special one of a kind. I'll tell you. It's because Aussies in general are getting fed up with the BS from these rip off merchants. The worlds mindset is changing with paying stupid prices for cars. Listen to yourselves. Moaning about paying 140K for a car that used to be 80. Sure you guys have a point, as we do down here. But some of you US guys are making me laugh.
#68
Race Car
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Hi Carcommander,
Although I do not share your opinion often..this time I agree
. The 458 is cheap to own with regard to running costs, has almost no issues, in fact I dont know any. The only thing you cannot really do with it is track it for hours like a GT3 or GT2.
To say that a 991S can beat a 458 is for me the joke of the year..the 997.2turbo S clearly smokes the best 911S..that I know..
Although I do not share your opinion often..this time I agree
![Smilie](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
To say that a 991S can beat a 458 is for me the joke of the year..the 997.2turbo S clearly smokes the best 911S..that I know..
All that said. Had I the space and the $$, I would have a 458 in a heartbeat to go with my 991 not instead, for performance, looks and every other thing about it. Red please, with a tan interior.
The Turbo S was produced specifically to cover the GTR (at around a $60k premium). See below.
#69
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Case in point. Take the GTR as an example. If the importer is getting taxed to death as some of you are imagining then why is it the GTR can be bought new for 170K and a TTS 450K. Where is the parody. Look at your own pricing on these two cars. Much closer.
I don't know which is responsible, the importer or PAG, but whoever it is has become so drunk in their arrogance toward the customers here they will drown in one day if they are not careful. A GTR for 170 and a TTS for 450K? C'mon. It isn't 280K better.
I don't know which is responsible, the importer or PAG, but whoever it is has become so drunk in their arrogance toward the customers here they will drown in one day if they are not careful. A GTR for 170 and a TTS for 450K? C'mon. It isn't 280K better.
Last edited by speed21; 12-23-2012 at 05:28 PM.
#70
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Jun 2012
Location: Pensacola, Florida
Posts: 1,227
Likes: 0
Received 257 Likes
on
159 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
There is not really an entry level new Ferrari. I own a 991 C2S and a 458. The 991 does not outperform it. Have you read any tests? I also owned a 997 TT at the same time as the 991. So far the 991 has had 5 campaigns and has been in the shop for 2 weeks. The 458 nada. Most people are clueless about actuall Ferrari ownership they repeat what they heard.
I think the 991 is a better car than yhe 997TT, so I sold the TT. I an anxiously awaiting the new TT. Anything past a 6 year old Toyota is just something you want.
I think the 991 is a better car than yhe 997TT, so I sold the TT. I an anxiously awaiting the new TT. Anything past a 6 year old Toyota is just something you want.
#72
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Then from an everyday driving perspective there is the reality the 997TT blows the 991S to the weeds and, looks more expensive as a car in the process. It can even be said the 997 has a more connected feel to it....which I personally find it has, even though the 991 is a brilliant car in every way. So it's kinda funny when i see someone in a 991 knowing just how much they paid for it, and, for what. LOL.
I take my hat off to anyone swapping out a 997TT for a 991. It's a very brave move. You've really got to "love it" (and I mean really got to love it) to do that or, be one of those guys that has plenty of tear up $ to be seen in the latest and greatest. If it were changing out a Carrera for a newer Carrera then I can (maybe) see the sense in that, although again when you look a the price it's virtually new Turbo money and, you are also talking more money than what a good used low K turbo or GT2 would cost you. So the logic is once again defeated. No matter which way you look at it the 991 is simply way overpriced for what it is.....and lacks the presence against it's better performing predecessors.
#73
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I do agree with your sentiment about the OP's post about the cost of the new 991. Instead of taking his 997 purchase as an aberration due to various market factors and recognising that he got the deal of the century on his 997, he is complaining about having to pay normal market price for the 991.
In objective terms, 140k for a highly specc'ed Porsche is quite reasonable, considering the quality and specs of the car you get for the money. In my opinion, Porsches are about the best bang for buck sports car you can get in the market.
#74
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Well, mate, and I *am* a mate: you're no idiot. Clearly you have been successful enough to pay nosebleed Oz prices - but then, let's have someone from Singapore or HK weigh in on that point. It's inequitable but ... they sell every car. Oz now has the highest *median* wealth in the world on a per cap basis [Source: Credit Suisse Global Wealth Report 2012]. Oz has outgrown all other countries in the OECD over the last 20 years. Consequently Aussies have had a growth of wealth that is unsurpassed for the last 10 years or so (leaving aside some small Mid-East enclaves; very much an aside: Oz has much higher tax rates ... Supply-siders take note, growth is not entirely a function of marginal tax rates).
So while I agree that Aussies are shafted in the price of these cars, the wherewithal is clearly there. Many punters in Pt Piper, Toorak etc who can pay for a 911.
Meanwhile in the US we had the greatest financial collapse since the 1930s. But then, if one can purchase a 911 here you have done better than average folks since 2007. A 911 is clearly an indulgent purchase and while it's annoying that prices are high -especially in Oz etc - it's not that you are an 'idiot'. No, you choose to spend your hard-earned money as you see fit, and it's very annoying that prices are so expensive there relative to the US.
Each market's dynamics is distinct and the pricing reflects that reality. Don't like it, then 2 options:
(1) Don't buy - be more value conscious
(2) Move countries where you can 'arb' prices [some do when they become frustrated, but then the offset are property taxes and health care]
All this being said, the pricing [Downunder] is 'cheeky'. They do so, because they can. And the lux tax reflects both the local ideology as well as the ability to extract a consumption tax. The US is relatively unbalanced in its tax basis in that nearly 50% of revenues derive from income; in Oz in income taxes are ~ 30% of revs, then there's consumption tax which includes the lux tax (~ 10% revs). Pay to consume is the message. The US could learn from that![ducking](https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/icon107.gif)
So while I agree that Aussies are shafted in the price of these cars, the wherewithal is clearly there. Many punters in Pt Piper, Toorak etc who can pay for a 911.
Meanwhile in the US we had the greatest financial collapse since the 1930s. But then, if one can purchase a 911 here you have done better than average folks since 2007. A 911 is clearly an indulgent purchase and while it's annoying that prices are high -especially in Oz etc - it's not that you are an 'idiot'. No, you choose to spend your hard-earned money as you see fit, and it's very annoying that prices are so expensive there relative to the US.
Each market's dynamics is distinct and the pricing reflects that reality. Don't like it, then 2 options:
(1) Don't buy - be more value conscious
(2) Move countries where you can 'arb' prices [some do when they become frustrated, but then the offset are property taxes and health care]
All this being said, the pricing [Downunder] is 'cheeky'. They do so, because they can. And the lux tax reflects both the local ideology as well as the ability to extract a consumption tax. The US is relatively unbalanced in its tax basis in that nearly 50% of revenues derive from income; in Oz in income taxes are ~ 30% of revs, then there's consumption tax which includes the lux tax (~ 10% revs). Pay to consume is the message. The US could learn from that
![ducking](https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/icon107.gif)
My gripe is not the tax system lets get that right. I understand and am willing to pay the ludicrous amounts of tax on the income I earn. This is my choice and where I chose to live. What I don’t like is what Porsche Cars Australia is doing to the local market. I am under no illusion that I have a right to be complaining about spending 315K and crying poor over it. I just believe it should be a fairer and more level playing field. I understand there needs to be a "premium" for a smaller market but make it reasonable. Why should the car cost more than the RHD UK model?
A Euro MD was once asked "How can you charge what you charge for you cars?" the answer was, "because we can and they still buy them". Really what type of attitude is that? Similarly PCA is now reflecting on their pricing and realising they have gone too far. They are second guessing where they have positioned the car and price bracket. Sales are slow.
I would be quite content if the price of the car was within 30% of the US market without the local taxes. Don’t get me wrong it’s not only Porsche that is doing this it’s all lux euro brands. $750K for a 458 well they can keep that one.......
At the end of the day it is what it is and as you rightly pointed out it’s my decision as to whether I hand over the cash or not. As a sucker for the brand I have and I will continue to do so.
#75
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Maybe my grasp of the English language is slightly skewed but I read the above and thought I would correct your misperception about the Chinese market.
I do agree with your sentiment about the OP's post about the cost of the new 991. Instead of taking his 997 purchase as an aberration due to various market factors and recognising that he got the deal of the century on his 997, he is complaining about having to pay normal market price for the 991.
In objective terms, 140k for a highly specc'ed Porsche is quite reasonable, considering the quality and specs of the car you get for the money. In my opinion, Porsches are about the best bang for buck sports car you can get in the market.
I do agree with your sentiment about the OP's post about the cost of the new 991. Instead of taking his 997 purchase as an aberration due to various market factors and recognising that he got the deal of the century on his 997, he is complaining about having to pay normal market price for the 991.
In objective terms, 140k for a highly specc'ed Porsche is quite reasonable, considering the quality and specs of the car you get for the money. In my opinion, Porsches are about the best bang for buck sports car you can get in the market.
And on the 140k for a highly spec'd 991? I'd pay that in a heartbeat. But then I'm an Aussie lol. For a lot of you guys your options are unlimited with the small dollars you have become so used to paying. I mean where else on the planet could you buy a brand new TTS for 160K......and that my friend is what makes the highly optioned 991 so unpalatable at 140 even in your own country. I can see what old guy is on about. Everyone around the world is asking the same question....
As I said earlier, with BM, MB lowering prices accepting the global market realities, you've got Porsche going the other way and, they are now a mass manufacturer unlike say lambo, buggati, ferrari and so forth. I call it greed, arrogance, or a combination of both. Sure there will always be a percentage that goes with the flow, but the mainstream is thinking.