Base vs S for frequent track use
#31
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
There are a few guys in PCA HPDE that have a ton of experience, but intentionally stay down in the intermediate run group. They would rather be one of the faster drivers in a moderate speed group than a moderate speed driver in a group loaded with fast drivers and fast cars.
#34
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I had a base and a GTS Cayman 981. The extra 50 to 65 horsepower in the S and GTS is transformative. I now have a GTS 4.0. I wouldn’t consider a Cayman with much less than 350 HP. I kick myself for spending 8 years in a base 987 and 981. Great cars but just too docile.
#36
Instructor
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
There was a guy that used to come out every year to one PCA HPDE event that was held in conjunction with the PCA club races. He had an early '90's Nissan Sentra, caged and maybe some suspension mods (though maybe not), but stock engine. I think he had Nitto NT01's, but not slicks for sure. He would run in the intermediate run group. The dude could drive the crap out of that car. He would go around corners on 3 wheels, the inside back wheel would be a couple inches off the ground. Impressed the hell out of me knowing he had probably 110HP in that thing but could turn lap times faster than me in my Boxster S. Made me realize I still had a lot to learn.
The following users liked this post:
ledbette (08-08-2022)
#37
#38
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Owner of a 15 Base, moving to a Cayman S (hopefully) for PDK, better suspension, and simply more power. The Base was fine on track, and kept up fine in the corners, but lacked straight line speed
#39
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Nice move. S over base will give you more top-end speed but be aware, PDK over S 6SM will not.
#40
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Thought I would add to this thread in 2023.
I have tracked modded 996 turbos, 981 GT4, 991 GT3 and air cooled 993 cars and now have a simple 718 Cayman Base 6MT.
I’ve learned that 300hp is probably
my lowest limit personally lol for both street and track. The base car is great and worth learning on for anyone interested in track work. It also feels better knowing it’s not a $200K car lol. The turbo lag down low is a bit annoying but I’m sure a tune can figure out some more responsiveness including power. After all those GT cars, I think track pads/ fluid and stickier tires and you can have a blast and keep up with lots of “better” cars (which some I have already owned but were above my skill level at the time.)
But, the flat 6 sound……
Hope this helps for anyone in 2023
I have tracked modded 996 turbos, 981 GT4, 991 GT3 and air cooled 993 cars and now have a simple 718 Cayman Base 6MT.
I’ve learned that 300hp is probably
my lowest limit personally lol for both street and track. The base car is great and worth learning on for anyone interested in track work. It also feels better knowing it’s not a $200K car lol. The turbo lag down low is a bit annoying but I’m sure a tune can figure out some more responsiveness including power. After all those GT cars, I think track pads/ fluid and stickier tires and you can have a blast and keep up with lots of “better” cars (which some I have already owned but were above my skill level at the time.)
But, the flat 6 sound……
Hope this helps for anyone in 2023
Last edited by jabwind51; 08-06-2023 at 02:01 PM.
#41
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
My experience is that you can have fun in almost any car as long as you don't care what other cars you are running w/ or lap times. I do and I do so a base Cayman would not float my boat; indeed, my 981 S really doesn't either but that's just me coming out of a 987.1 w/ 3.8 and 987.2 w/ TPC turbo.
That said, I recently instructed a guy in a mostly stock older Miata and we had a blast! Everywhere except the straights it felt like we were flying - tires squealing, back end coming around, 4-wheel drifts, insane recoveries, 10/10ths - just a hoot. And we actually passed some much faster Porsches, BMWs, etc. The last session I took my iPhone w/ lap timer and was shocked that we were going almost 20 secs. slower than my 981 S. But more pure fun.
That said, I recently instructed a guy in a mostly stock older Miata and we had a blast! Everywhere except the straights it felt like we were flying - tires squealing, back end coming around, 4-wheel drifts, insane recoveries, 10/10ths - just a hoot. And we actually passed some much faster Porsches, BMWs, etc. The last session I took my iPhone w/ lap timer and was shocked that we were going almost 20 secs. slower than my 981 S. But more pure fun.
#42
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
My experience is that you can have fun in almost any car as long as you don't care what other cars you are running w/ or lap times. I do and I do so a base Cayman would not float my boat; indeed, my 981 S really doesn't either but that's just me coming out of a 987.1 w/ 3.8 and 987.2 w/ TPC turbo.
That said, I recently instructed a guy in a mostly stock older Miata and we had a blast! Everywhere except the straights it felt like we were flying - tires squealing, back end coming around, 4-wheel drifts, insane recoveries, 10/10ths - just a hoot. And we actually passed some much faster Porsches, BMWs, etc. The last session I took my iPhone w/ lap timer and was shocked that we were going almost 20 secs. slower than my 981 S. But more pure fun.
That said, I recently instructed a guy in a mostly stock older Miata and we had a blast! Everywhere except the straights it felt like we were flying - tires squealing, back end coming around, 4-wheel drifts, insane recoveries, 10/10ths - just a hoot. And we actually passed some much faster Porsches, BMWs, etc. The last session I took my iPhone w/ lap timer and was shocked that we were going almost 20 secs. slower than my 981 S. But more pure fun.
I know did care at first and I think that is why I went the direction of GT cars and searched for more power and mechanical grip but they were well above my skill level.
#43
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
My experience is that you can have fun in almost any car as long as you don't care what other cars you are running w/ or lap times. I do and I do so a base Cayman would not float my boat; indeed, my 981 S really doesn't either but that's just me coming out of a 987.1 w/ 3.8 and 987.2 w/ TPC turbo.
That said, I recently instructed a guy in a mostly stock older Miata and we had a blast! Everywhere except the straights it felt like we were flying - tires squealing, back end coming around, 4-wheel drifts, insane recoveries, 10/10ths - just a hoot. And we actually passed some much faster Porsches, BMWs, etc. The last session I took my iPhone w/ lap timer and was shocked that we were going almost 20 secs. slower than my 981 S. But more pure fun.
That said, I recently instructed a guy in a mostly stock older Miata and we had a blast! Everywhere except the straights it felt like we were flying - tires squealing, back end coming around, 4-wheel drifts, insane recoveries, 10/10ths - just a hoot. And we actually passed some much faster Porsches, BMWs, etc. The last session I took my iPhone w/ lap timer and was shocked that we were going almost 20 secs. slower than my 981 S. But more pure fun.
The following users liked this post:
jabwind51 (08-07-2023)
#44
Racer
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I own a base but it’s not tracked. I want to whine it out on the street and enjoy those higher rpm’s. Great weekend canyon carver.
if I was tracking it is an S with at least sport chrono, and then update the suspension to x73, ohlins or another package pending your needs on the track. Definitely need some upgrade in sways.
if I was tracking it is an S with at least sport chrono, and then update the suspension to x73, ohlins or another package pending your needs on the track. Definitely need some upgrade in sways.
#45
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
The S is .5 seconds faster at 0-60 and 5 mph faster at top speed. Do you really want to spend $10K more for that? You could put race headers and an upgraded ECU tune on a Base for $3-5K and there would be no S that would beat you on the track. Just my 2cents
The following users liked this post:
edmaverik (06-27-2024)