Dry sleeve v Alusil ?.
#61
Drifting
Thread Starter
Are you implying iron is equal or superior to Alusil or Nikasil for a 944 cylinder surface?
#62
Race Car
The pre-send requirement for the Swain is to glass bead the piston to bare aluminum surface.
My top running engine in the Sp2 I show here in race vids is stock cast pistons coated with Swain PC9.
It's the last engine I will do with cast but all you have to do is use the factory clearance since it's the exact same piston still.
When you move to forged, you have to pay attention to any difference in piston/cylinder clearance recommended by the manufacturer, taking into account them film build thickness of the coating you use when fitting to final cylinder dimension.
What I would do additional to skirts, is have DLC or equivalent done to the ring groove area.
This lessens the stiction of the rings when transitioning between between upward and downward moments where they otherwise might not keep optimum ring seal with only ring tension to keep them expanded.
Ring mass can have an effect here and I don't see anyone talking about the SB Chevy piston rings being 25% more mass than the 944 stock rings @ 1.5mm v 2.0mm for the top ring and 1.2mm v 1.5mm for the #2 ring.
Gas porting the piston either vertically or radially and/or adding a machined semicircle void between the top two ring lands adds an insurance margin against ring flutter (less than optimum sealing, increased wear) which is a product of engine speed + stiction + ring mass - ring tension.
Adding ring tension is counter productive...
T
#65
Drifting
Thread Starter
#66
Drifting
How much power are you wanting? That would be the deciding factor I would think and how long do expect it to last between rebuilds? The more power the less time between rebuilds regardless. Dry sleeves offer more potential power benefits but with more power other items are the weak link. I would think alusi would handle up to 450hp in a 104mm block and would last a good 60 to 100 thousand miles depending on how much your foot is into it. But like stated before there is a point where aluminum will egg shape the cylinder walls with lots of boost.
#67
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Hotlanta - NE of the Perimeter
Posts: 12,269
Received 266 Likes
on
153 Posts
What I'd prefer is to better duplicate the experience documented. My apologies for reviving your old thread that I thought may prove beneficial for information regarding recent sleeving experience.
#68
Drifting
Thread Starter
No apology necessary. If the plated ali liners than Penguinracer mentioned work, I learned something new. I'm still interested what your preferred cylinder material is though?
#69
Race Car
Just a follow up because I mentioned but didn't have full info at home.
PoyDyn (Polymer Dynamics) is the piston skirt coating company that CP/Carillo recommends for their forged piston to be compatible in Nik/Alusil.
In Houston.
http://www.polydyn.com/pistons
T
PoyDyn (Polymer Dynamics) is the piston skirt coating company that CP/Carillo recommends for their forged piston to be compatible in Nik/Alusil.
In Houston.
http://www.polydyn.com/pistons
T
#71
Developer
Two things:
Arias has been sold to CP Carillo. We used to get all our piston forgings from Arias, but they are Carillo forgings now. That is an improvement. We were surprised to find that some metric pistons sizes were no longer available to us after the switch. We use Wiseco pistons now and are happier than we were with the Arias ones. Coatings for Alusil (usually none) and Nikasil are different.
Same with pistons rings. Because the Nikasil has a harder surface, the piston rings for it need to be softer and are usually a form of cast iron. Alusil, although tough, is easily scratched and relatively "soft". Because of this, rings for Alusil are harder, and often chromed. Order your rings when you order your pistons, from the same supplier and at the same time. That's the best way to get it right IMO..
Arias has been sold to CP Carillo. We used to get all our piston forgings from Arias, but they are Carillo forgings now. That is an improvement. We were surprised to find that some metric pistons sizes were no longer available to us after the switch. We use Wiseco pistons now and are happier than we were with the Arias ones. Coatings for Alusil (usually none) and Nikasil are different.
Same with pistons rings. Because the Nikasil has a harder surface, the piston rings for it need to be softer and are usually a form of cast iron. Alusil, although tough, is easily scratched and relatively "soft". Because of this, rings for Alusil are harder, and often chromed. Order your rings when you order your pistons, from the same supplier and at the same time. That's the best way to get it right IMO..
#72
Race Car
Total Seal
Ductile-moly top ring, cast second ring, and a chrome faced 3 piece oil control ring.
By "generic" if you mean @ 100mm bore, part number for above at EBS Racing Don Weaver (don@ebsracing.com) should be -
Ductile-moly top ring, cast second ring, and a chrome faced 3 piece oil control ring.
By "generic" if you mean @ 100mm bore, part number for above at EBS Racing Don Weaver (don@ebsracing.com) should be -
Total Seal 100 944 - 944 SET 100mm - 100x1.5-1.75-3.0
T
T
#73
Instructor
Just a follow up because I mentioned but didn't have full info at home.
PoyDyn (Polymer Dynamics) is the piston skirt coating company that CP/Carillo recommends for their forged piston to be compatible in Nik/Alusil.
In Houston.
http://www.polydyn.com/pistons
T
PoyDyn (Polymer Dynamics) is the piston skirt coating company that CP/Carillo recommends for their forged piston to be compatible in Nik/Alusil.
In Houston.
http://www.polydyn.com/pistons
T
#74
Rainman
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Total Seal
Ductile-moly top ring, cast second ring, and a chrome faced 3 piece oil control ring.
By "generic" if you mean @ 100mm bore, part number for above at EBS Racing Don Weaver (don@ebsracing.com) should be -
Ductile-moly top ring, cast second ring, and a chrome faced 3 piece oil control ring.
By "generic" if you mean @ 100mm bore, part number for above at EBS Racing Don Weaver (don@ebsracing.com) should be -
Total Seal 100 944 - 944 SET 100mm - 100x1.5-1.75-3.0
T
T
if there's an easy way to buy an off the shelf SBC piston and ring set, coat it and stick it in alusil barrels.