Low cost MINI-STARTER
#106
#107
#108
Hi Alex,
The starter has been fine. It does sound a little different, but I've forgotten exactly how the old one sounded. I got the diode on Amazon. The starter comes with a pigtail, so you won't need the female spade in my diagram. I also used the starter power terminal right angle adapter pictured earlier in the thread. I had to buy 20 diodes for $7, so if you want a couple, just PM your address.
Good luck,
Dave
The starter has been fine. It does sound a little different, but I've forgotten exactly how the old one sounded. I got the diode on Amazon. The starter comes with a pigtail, so you won't need the female spade in my diagram. I also used the starter power terminal right angle adapter pictured earlier in the thread. I had to buy 20 diodes for $7, so if you want a couple, just PM your address.
Good luck,
Dave
#109
So I took up Dave's offer for the diode's (thanks again!) and after at least twenty starts over the past two months I can confidently say that the mini starter works great. I think the common failure of the stock starter is that the solenoid gets gummed up and stuck because I can only extend it out with a pry bar. Here is the harness I made. My only mistake is that the large ring terminal should go with the diode. I fastened the terminals to the engine harness with a 4mm and 5mm nut and bolt.
#110
So I took up Dave's offer for the diode's (thanks again!) and after at least twenty starts over the past two months I can confidently say that the mini starter works great. I think the common failure of the stock starter is that the solenoid gets gummed up and stuck because I can only extend it out with a pry bar. Here is the harness I made. My only mistake is that the large ring terminal should go with the diode. I fastened the terminals to the engine harness with a 4mm and 5mm nut and bolt.
#113
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 20,506
Likes: 549
From: Bend, Oregon
Wired the way you show it, that diode install is a waste. Absent the aux terminal that offers switched battery voltage while the solenoid is engaged, you need a relay to duplicate the function. It's essentially wired in parallel with the starter solenoid, so the trigger 50 lead closes the relay as it engages the solenoid. Then battery lead connects to the relay contact (30), other contact is the connection to the ignition resistors.
#114
Wired the way you show it, that diode install is a waste. Absent the aux terminal that offers switched battery voltage while the solenoid is engaged, you need a relay to duplicate the function. It's essentially wired in parallel with the starter solenoid, so the trigger 50 lead closes the relay as it engages the solenoid. Then battery lead connects to the relay contact (30), other contact is the connection to the ignition resistors.
#115
I just found an old post of yours that explains the function: https://rennlist.com/forums/928-foru...l#post13245721
During normal engine running the coil is fed from the transistor unit through BOTH resistors.
During cranking the black/yellow wire is energized and bypasses the 0.4 ohm resistor but is still feeding the coil through the 0.6 ohm resistor.
With that said, I don't see how my little harness does not accomplish the same thing?
When the starter is engaged the blk/yel wire is energized through the diode is it not?
During normal engine running the coil is fed from the transistor unit through BOTH resistors.
During cranking the black/yellow wire is energized and bypasses the 0.4 ohm resistor but is still feeding the coil through the 0.6 ohm resistor.
With that said, I don't see how my little harness does not accomplish the same thing?
When the starter is engaged the blk/yel wire is energized through the diode is it not?
#116
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 20,506
Likes: 549
From: Bend, Oregon
The original system dumped current to the ignition without all the voltage drop between the starter end of the battery terminal and the end of the wire from the 50 circuit that you are using, plus the 0.7 Volt drop through the silicon diode. The idea of using the same source through a small relay means the ignition box and coil see the same voltage while cranking that they would in normal run condition.
For grins, connect your better DMM to measure coil voltage. Take a reading with and without your piece connected, and see if the volts while cranking are any different. I predict that there will be virtually no difference. Now run a short heavy jumper between the battery terminal on the starter directly to the black/yellow wire, and test again while cranking. Voltage at the coil will be higher than the previous readings. Now install the relay to duplicate the bypass function but only while the starter is engaged.
For grins, connect your better DMM to measure coil voltage. Take a reading with and without your piece connected, and see if the volts while cranking are any different. I predict that there will be virtually no difference. Now run a short heavy jumper between the battery terminal on the starter directly to the black/yellow wire, and test again while cranking. Voltage at the coil will be higher than the previous readings. Now install the relay to duplicate the bypass function but only while the starter is engaged.
#118
I just found an old post of yours that explains the function: https://rennlist.com/forums/928-foru...l#post13245721
During normal engine running the coil is fed from the transistor unit through BOTH resistors.
During cranking the black/yellow wire is energized and bypasses the 0.4 ohm resistor but is still feeding the coil through the 0.6 ohm resistor.
With that said, I don't see how my little harness does not accomplish the same thing?
When the starter is engaged the blk/yel wire is energized through the diode is it not?
During normal engine running the coil is fed from the transistor unit through BOTH resistors.
During cranking the black/yellow wire is energized and bypasses the 0.4 ohm resistor but is still feeding the coil through the 0.6 ohm resistor.
With that said, I don't see how my little harness does not accomplish the same thing?
When the starter is engaged the blk/yel wire is energized through the diode is it not?
Dave
#119
The original system dumped current to the ignition without all the voltage drop between the starter end of the battery terminal and the end of the wire from the 50 circuit that you are using, plus the 0.7 Volt drop through the silicon diode. The idea of using the same source through a small relay means the ignition box and coil see the same voltage while cranking that they would in normal run condition.
For grins, connect your better DMM to measure coil voltage. Take a reading with and without your piece connected, and see if the volts while cranking are any different. I predict that there will be virtually no difference. Now run a short heavy jumper between the battery terminal on the starter directly to the black/yellow wire, and test again while cranking. Voltage at the coil will be higher than the previous readings. Now install the relay to duplicate the bypass function but only while the starter is engaged.
For grins, connect your better DMM to measure coil voltage. Take a reading with and without your piece connected, and see if the volts while cranking are any different. I predict that there will be virtually no difference. Now run a short heavy jumper between the battery terminal on the starter directly to the black/yellow wire, and test again while cranking. Voltage at the coil will be higher than the previous readings. Now install the relay to duplicate the bypass function but only while the starter is engaged.
Done properly, instead of a diode, that wire on my harness should be a trigger for a relay between the blk/yel wire and a new wire run to the battery cable stud on the starter. Got it.
That should be simple enough to do but for now it starts just fine though it could be a problem with a lower battery charge. I will revisit.
#120
OK. Thanks for the explanation. It works as is though, but will follow. That's a tough area for a relay, so might need to run from starter up to engine bay. OTOH with a waterproof relay, I could make a short lead and locate the device very near the starter. Like this:
Thanks,
Dave
Thanks,
Dave
Last edited by j.kenzie@sbcglobal.net; 10-25-2018 at 01:21 PM.