Notices
928 Forum 1978-1995
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by: 928 Specialists

5 speed vs auto

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 08-01-2012 | 01:10 AM
  #61  
86'928S MeteorGrey's Avatar
86'928S MeteorGrey
Three Wheelin'
 
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 1,914
Likes: 0
From: Surprise, Arizona
Default

Originally Posted by dprantl
My 5-speed transmission has been doing just fine running 8.5psi boost for oh, about 75k miles supercharged now. Can't say the same for the single-disc clutch, but a dual-disc retrofit cured that.

And if you prefer an auto 928 to a 5-speed one, you are either old, or too young to have ever learned to drive 5-speed

Dan
'91 928GT S/C 475hp/460lb.ft
Or maybe you use your shark as a daily driver in Los Angeles traffic... Like me!
Old 08-01-2012 | 01:18 AM
  #62  
tailpipe's Avatar
tailpipe
Burning Brakes
 
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 1,025
Likes: 6
From: Thorndale Ontario Canada
Default

I own and drive both.. All 78/79 they are both great but for different reasons and different jobs. If i'm driving to work or driving with a passenger I usually take the auto its just easier to deal with and smoother to drive easily. If i'm going on a long road trip or for a fun drive around the country I take the standard. I find the auto more relaxing to drive especially in traffic. But I agree the auto is really lacking in power low in the rpm range....
Old 08-01-2012 | 09:43 AM
  #63  
GlenL's Avatar
GlenL
Nordschleife Master
 
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 7,666
Likes: 34
From: Minneapolis, Minnesota
Default

Originally Posted by Hacker-Pschorr
Knock it off....or you will awaken The Kraken..I mean Kibort.
I need to have The Kibort Equation explained to me every few months.
Old 08-01-2012 | 09:54 AM
  #64  
Shark Attack's Avatar
Shark Attack
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,013
Likes: 66
From: Southern Utah
Default

Well, My 7 928's had 5 speeds. And I have to say now after having my 911, the 928 really fits best with an AT. When both cars sat in my garage and I had the pleasure of driving both any time I wanted, It became VERY clear both cars had a goal. I can not explain the feeling. But when you got in the 928, it wraps around you for the long haul. You can tell the car was built to get in and go 500 miles where the 911 was built to go around a track. The 911 beats you up while the 928 is comfort. My next 928 will be a 4 spd AT. It will be used for my long trips. And really until you get to drive both one a daily basis you will never understand where I am coming from.

Kyle
Old 08-01-2012 | 11:10 AM
  #65  
Gary Knox's Avatar
Gary Knox
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 3,409
Likes: 470
From: West Chester, PA
Default

This question is always nearly as much fun as "what oil should I use"!!

Sixty Fifth post on a subject that has been covered numerous times. Perhaps we should have ALL just said "Do a Search"!!

Gary--
Old 08-01-2012 | 11:29 AM
  #66  
GlenL's Avatar
GlenL
Nordschleife Master
 
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 7,666
Likes: 34
From: Minneapolis, Minnesota
Default

Originally Posted by Gary Knox
This question is always nearly as much fun as "what oil should I use"!!
That'd be "What's the best oil" to get the most vigorous debate.

What's odd is that it's not February and we are all not trapped indoors and engaging in "silly season."

The curious thing about 928 ownership is that, for a sporting breed, so many are automatics. This leads to long discussions when the correct answer ("Get what you like") is obvious.
Old 08-01-2012 | 11:38 AM
  #67  
Tom. M's Avatar
Tom. M
Deleted
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 5,472
Likes: 201
Default

might as well settle for the Automatic....since...production numbers are not in your favor if you want a 5sp....and resales of 5spds are rare since most will require prying from their owners "cold dead hands".

Good luck in your hunt
Old 08-01-2012 | 11:55 AM
  #68  
AO's Avatar
AO
Supercharged
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 18,925
Likes: 63
From: Back in Michigan - Full time!
Default

Originally Posted by Hacker-Pschorr
Some "flappy paddle" cars have a hydraulic clutch, others have a traditional torque converter.
My "flappy paddle" has two clutches... still no joy.
Old 08-01-2012 | 12:00 PM
  #69  
hacker-pschorr's Avatar
hacker-pschorr
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
 
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 1,627
Likes: 2,243
From: Up Nort
Default

Originally Posted by AO
My "flappy paddle" has two clutches... still no joy.
Which car is that? Not all do though.

A few, like an early Aston Martin, used a traditional torque converter and a computer controlled automatic transmission.

At the time (early 2000's) Clarkson said it was one of the best "flappy paddle" boxes out there. Especially compared to the clutch box Aston had in a different model at the same time.

The early Ferrari boxes like the 355 are 100% identicle to the "stick" car, except a hydraulic pump system replaces the clutch pedal. They may still be like this, I haven't kept up to date with their systems.

Bottom line.....some people just want a stick to play with
Old 08-01-2012 | 01:27 PM
  #70  
inactiveuser1's Avatar
inactiveuser1
Burning Brakes
 
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 909
Likes: 0
From: NY
Default

I always liked the MT excuses at the drags......I would of beat you if I didn't miss a gear!
Old 08-01-2012 | 02:11 PM
  #71  
rgs944's Avatar
rgs944
Drifting
 
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 3,334
Likes: 8
From: Nebraska
Default

Originally Posted by Gary Knox
This question is always nearly as much fun as "what oil should I use"!!


Gary--
My thought exactly, I prefer the 5speed for various reasons but I also understand some very good reasons why some people prefer autos.
Old 08-01-2012 | 02:52 PM
  #72  
Speedtoys's Avatar
Speedtoys
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 13,582
Likes: 1,034
From: Boulder Creek, CA
Default

Jim hall says nothing to me..so you are right. But then again, I dont manage Jim's races either. Just my own organizations.

But..the list of road race classes that do not specifically require manual transmissions, would be much shorter to list out.
Old 08-01-2012 | 04:15 PM
  #73  
AO's Avatar
AO
Supercharged
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 18,925
Likes: 63
From: Back in Michigan - Full time!
Default

Originally Posted by Hacker-Pschorr
Which car is that?
VW Jetta Wagon with the DSG gearbox. It shifts super fast and I hear it's capable of even faster shifts. Regardless, while there is a fun hitting the paddles, it just doesn't compare to the stick!

I'm pretty sure that was the plan for this shirt...

Old 08-01-2012 | 04:32 PM
  #74  
Bill Ball's Avatar
Bill Ball
Under the Lift
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
 
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 18,647
Likes: 49
From: Buckeye, AZ
Default

I believe those who seem to hate the 928 automatic and claim it is sluggish don't know how to drive it. Let me take you for a ride sometime. Even at 244K miles, the autobox is pretty amazing. You have to row the shifter to appreciate it. If you leave it in "D", it will bore you to tears, but it's good to have that option. When I had the supercharger it was terrifyingly fast, especially with the torque multiplication off the line. George has done 203 MPH in his blown S4 with a stock used, unrebuilt 88 autobox off the shelf from 928 Intl - no worries. Even at that speed, the tranny was only running a temp of 160F with no extra coolers. I've beat the living crap out of mine. My only problem came from listening to a few people who said I should do some preventative seal replacements. Had I just left it alone, it would still never had to come out of the car. I can't help but appreciate what a good tranny it has been.
Old 08-01-2012 | 04:54 PM
  #75  
GlenL's Avatar
GlenL
Nordschleife Master
 
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 7,666
Likes: 34
From: Minneapolis, Minnesota
Default

Nothing to see here

Last edited by GlenL; 08-01-2012 at 06:03 PM. Reason: One copy is enough!


Quick Reply: 5 speed vs auto



All times are GMT -3. The time now is 10:13 AM.