Crank drilling, why bother?
#1
Crank drilling, why bother?
Oiling trouble on the 928 seems to be related to high rpm in turns, air getting into the oil stream. Nobody has any trouble with straight line high rpm, so what is the point with drilling the crank? I can't figure out how it makes any difference to a G force related oil issue.
#5
IIRC the issue for non-g-loaded rpm is
- that at high-rpm the stock crank starves the 2/6 bearing no matter what you do
AND/OR
- at high-rpm oil foam is pumped to all the bearings and the 2/6 dies first.
That's my recollection. Waiting now for folks that really know to come along....
EDIT: 928s have died under sustained high-rpm conditions due to 2/6 bearing failure. IIRC this is almost-exclusively a phenomenon reported from Germany - where they have roads that allow them to run flat-out for many minutes at a time.
- that at high-rpm the stock crank starves the 2/6 bearing no matter what you do
AND/OR
- at high-rpm oil foam is pumped to all the bearings and the 2/6 dies first.
That's my recollection. Waiting now for folks that really know to come along....
EDIT: 928s have died under sustained high-rpm conditions due to 2/6 bearing failure. IIRC this is almost-exclusively a phenomenon reported from Germany - where they have roads that allow them to run flat-out for many minutes at a time.
Trending Topics
#8
Flogged yes, illuminated no.
Tried search, may use the Visit function tomorrow.
BTW I actually think I understand the physics, pressure, rpm, etc., which is what led me to the question why bother? Its a high rpm fix for a G force issue.
Tried search, may use the Visit function tomorrow.
BTW I actually think I understand the physics, pressure, rpm, etc., which is what led me to the question why bother? Its a high rpm fix for a G force issue.
#10
#11
the poor oiling system is the achilles heel of 928's......sure timing belt & thrust bearing failures get more attention....but the bottom line is if you plan on operating the 928 engine at high RPM....you better upgrade it....... I've proven this THREE TIMES
#12
The 2/6 bearing does seem like where problems show up, but that doesn't mean fixing the 2/6 is a preferred option to fixing the root problem of air in the oil.
#13
(4 )928 engines with no mods have been race more than any 928 engines out there, and no issues. I wonder why? Oh yeah, that has been discussed already too.
(i.e. scots 4.5 liter, scots 5 liter, my US 4.7 liter, my 5 liter part euro , and the holbert engine which had 5000laps alone!)
mk
(i.e. scots 4.5 liter, scots 5 liter, my US 4.7 liter, my 5 liter part euro , and the holbert engine which had 5000laps alone!)
mk
#14
I don't think it is a G force issue in the sump. It is a centrifugal force issue, as the oil has to travel the wrong way against the centrifugal force of the crank spinning. Cross drilling is supposed to redirect the flow so as to go with the direction of the G forces of the spinning crank. High RPMs = higher G force = oil starvation.
Oil starvation is a separate problem as I understand it.
Someone correct me if I am wrong.
Oil starvation is a separate problem as I understand it.
Someone correct me if I am wrong.
#15
I don't think it is a G force issue in the sump. It is a centrifugal force issue, as the oil has to travel the wrong way against the centrifugal force of the crank spinning. Cross drilling is supposed to redirect the flow so as to go with the direction of the G forces of the spinning crank. High RPMs = higher G force = oil starvation.
Oil starvation is a separate problem as I understand it.
Someone correct me if I am wrong.
Oil starvation is a separate problem as I understand it.
Someone correct me if I am wrong.
Porsche had to completely redesign the cranks for the 944GTRs, because of this problem....once they started running them at higher rpms. They are "surface" drilled, not "center" drilled.
Part of the reason that Kibort has had so little problems is that he has limited the rpms on his engines. He doesn't go near 7,000rpms.