which is more reliable, 951 or 928?
#61
Rainman
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
There is already a 928 with 951 pistons with a supercharger pushing 22-24psi. The blower ran out of steam so a new one was fitted this past weekend to raise the boost past 30psi.
Todd (owner / builder of the car) has been unable to fit the proper sized turbo's for this much boost without radically modifying the car.
Not to mention the efficiency of these new blowers is so high, he’s not even looking into the turbo option anymore.
Todd (owner / builder of the car) has been unable to fit the proper sized turbo's for this much boost without radically modifying the car.
Not to mention the efficiency of these new blowers is so high, he’s not even looking into the turbo option anymore.
#62
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
#63
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
But on the subject of insults I don't remember ever insulting you, on the contrary it was you who was hypocritically talking behind my back and other listers putting us down on the hybrid board, who is the two face cynical individual?
Hacker and the 928 guys I can take their comments because he is actually one of the smartest guys on rennlist, I do enjoy reading his posts and look forward to his responses, he is honest and truthful and has my respect, but you with the one and only rice 944, just the looks not performance what a shame, Tifo D’ricer man, I have no respect only my pitty, hey but look at the bright side at least you got lart's pitty. rolf.
Can someone quote me please so tifo can read my message.
#64
Tifo, talking about insulting I am the one the gets the insults, by putting the facts together, check hacker's post how many of those are 951's ?
But on the subject of insults I don't remember ever insulting you, on the contrary it was you who was hypocritically talking behind my back and other listers putting us down on the hybrid board, who is the two face cynical individual?
Hacker and the 928 guys I can take their comments because he is actually one of the smartest guys on rennlist, I do enjoy reading his posts and look forward to his responses, he is honest and truthful and has my respect, but you with the one and only rice 944, just the looks not performance what a shame, Tifo D’ricer man, I have no respect only my pitty, hey but look at the bright side at least you got lart's pitty. rolf.
Can someone quote me please so tifo can read my message.
But on the subject of insults I don't remember ever insulting you, on the contrary it was you who was hypocritically talking behind my back and other listers putting us down on the hybrid board, who is the two face cynical individual?
Hacker and the 928 guys I can take their comments because he is actually one of the smartest guys on rennlist, I do enjoy reading his posts and look forward to his responses, he is honest and truthful and has my respect, but you with the one and only rice 944, just the looks not performance what a shame, Tifo D’ricer man, I have no respect only my pitty, hey but look at the bright side at least you got lart's pitty. rolf.
Can someone quote me please so tifo can read my message.
#66
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I feel like this is a boring convo because I'm just seeing a bunch of "this message is hidden" and then Hacker talking about stuff.
#67
Race Car
Luis, how many 928s have you owned and how many miles have you logged in one? a 951 is not the best car in the world and if someone prefers a 928 over a 951, its not directed against you personally and it doesn't mean that a 951 is inferior. Hacker, the 951 and 928 timing belt is not the same as the early 928 has an advantage in that a broken timing belt does not bend valves even though it will disable the car in both cases. The 928 clutch takes almost no effort while the 951 clutch takes an act of god to replace. The 944/951 has a US DOT MANDATORY FACTORY RECALL on hoses which cause many documented cases which is several hundred percent over a normal car probability of engine fire (which is includes a 928) and I think the US department of transportation has more accurate data than a few paying members of the rennlist community. I think they know how to do beta testing on a bell curve to determine what is truly a significant finding statistically.
Luis here it is.
For the 85
Recall Date:
APR 02, 1990
Model Affected:
1985 PORSCHE 944
Summary:
THE HOSE MATERIAL USED IN THE SHORT SECTION OF THE HIGH PRESSURE FUEL LINE HOSE, BETWEEN THE FUEL RAIL AND FUEL PRESSURE REGULATOR, IS SUBJECT TO HARDENING, AND COULD CAUSE FUEL LEAKS BETWEEN THE HOSE AND THE METAL PIPE FITTINGS.
Consequence:
FUEL LEAKS COULD IGNITE ON THE HOT EXHAUST SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER SOURCE OF IGNITION, RESULTING IN AN ENGINE COMPARTMENT FIRE.
Remedy:
REPLACE FUEL LINE HOSE WITH HOSES MADE OF IMPROVED MATERIAL.
Potential Units Affected:
53427
Notes:
PORSCHE CARS N.A. INC.
Recall Date:
JUN 12, 1986
Model Affected:
1986 PORSCHE 944
Summary:
THE PROTECTIVE SLEEVE COVERING OF THE RETURN FUEL HOSE BETWEEN THE PRESSURE REGULATOR AND FUEL RETURN PIPE WAS SHORTENED LEAVING PART OF THE HOSE EXPOSED. IN SOME INSTANCES THIS PART OF THE HOSE BECOMES KINKED DUE TO THE ENGINE COMPARTMENT HEAT AND/OR THE ROUTING OF THE HOSE. CONSEQUENCE OF DEFECT: IF THIS OCCURS IT COULD RESTRICT AND DAMAGE THE RETURN FUEL HOSE WHICH COULD LEAD TO FUEL LEAKAGE AND CAUSE AN ENGINE COMPARTMENT FIRE.
Consequence:
Remedy:
NEW HOSE WILL BE INSTALLED WITH A LONGER PREFORMED SLEEVE DESIGNED TO PREVENT KINKING. THE REPLACEMENT HOSE WILL BE SECURED WITH SCREW TIGHTENED CLAMPS ON EACH END.
Potential Units Affected:
17717
Notes:
PORSCHE CARS N.A. INC. G01
Back to list of 1986 Porsche 944 recalls
For the 87
Recall Date:
APR 02, 1990
Model Affected:
1987 PORSCHE 944
Summary:
THE HOSE MATERIAL USED IN THE SHORT SECTION OF THE HIGH PRESSURE FUEL LINE HOSE, BETWEEN THE FUEL RAIL AND FUEL PRESSURE REGULATOR, IS SUBJECT TO HARDENING, AND COULD CAUSE FUEL LEAKS BETWEEN THE HOSE AND THE METAL PIPE FITTINGS.
Consequence:
FUEL LEAKS COULD IGNITE ON THE HOT EXHAUST SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER SOURCE OF IGNITION, RESULTING IN AN ENGINE COMPARTMENT FIRE.
Remedy:
REPLACE FUEL LINE HOSE WITH HOSES MADE OF IMPROVED MATERIAL.
Potential Units Affected:
53427
Notes:
PORSCHE CARS N.A. INC.
For the 88
Recall Date:
APR 02, 1990
Model Affected:
1988 PORSCHE 944
Summary:
THE HOSE MATERIAL USED IN THE SHORT SECTION OF THE HIGH PRESSURE FUEL LINE HOSE, BETWEEN THE FUEL RAIL AND FUEL PRESSURE REGULATOR, IS SUBJECT TO HARDENING, AND COULD CAUSE FUEL LEAKS BETWEEN THE HOSE AND THE METAL PIPE FITTINGS.
Consequence:
FUEL LEAKS COULD IGNITE ON THE HOT EXHAUST SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER SOURCE OF IGNITION, RESULTING IN AN ENGINE COMPARTMENT FIRE.
Remedy:
REPLACE FUEL LINE HOSE WITH HOSES MADE OF IMPROVED MATERIAL.
Potential Units Affected:
53427
Notes:
PORSCHE CARS N.A. INC.
We are talking 60+ THOUSAND 944s involved in the recall. Luis, do you understand what you type can send someone wrong information that may cause them financial damage?
Luis here it is.
For the 85
Recall Date:
APR 02, 1990
Model Affected:
1985 PORSCHE 944
Summary:
THE HOSE MATERIAL USED IN THE SHORT SECTION OF THE HIGH PRESSURE FUEL LINE HOSE, BETWEEN THE FUEL RAIL AND FUEL PRESSURE REGULATOR, IS SUBJECT TO HARDENING, AND COULD CAUSE FUEL LEAKS BETWEEN THE HOSE AND THE METAL PIPE FITTINGS.
Consequence:
FUEL LEAKS COULD IGNITE ON THE HOT EXHAUST SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER SOURCE OF IGNITION, RESULTING IN AN ENGINE COMPARTMENT FIRE.
Remedy:
REPLACE FUEL LINE HOSE WITH HOSES MADE OF IMPROVED MATERIAL.
Potential Units Affected:
53427
Notes:
PORSCHE CARS N.A. INC.
Recall Date:
JUN 12, 1986
Model Affected:
1986 PORSCHE 944
Summary:
THE PROTECTIVE SLEEVE COVERING OF THE RETURN FUEL HOSE BETWEEN THE PRESSURE REGULATOR AND FUEL RETURN PIPE WAS SHORTENED LEAVING PART OF THE HOSE EXPOSED. IN SOME INSTANCES THIS PART OF THE HOSE BECOMES KINKED DUE TO THE ENGINE COMPARTMENT HEAT AND/OR THE ROUTING OF THE HOSE. CONSEQUENCE OF DEFECT: IF THIS OCCURS IT COULD RESTRICT AND DAMAGE THE RETURN FUEL HOSE WHICH COULD LEAD TO FUEL LEAKAGE AND CAUSE AN ENGINE COMPARTMENT FIRE.
Consequence:
Remedy:
NEW HOSE WILL BE INSTALLED WITH A LONGER PREFORMED SLEEVE DESIGNED TO PREVENT KINKING. THE REPLACEMENT HOSE WILL BE SECURED WITH SCREW TIGHTENED CLAMPS ON EACH END.
Potential Units Affected:
17717
Notes:
PORSCHE CARS N.A. INC. G01
Back to list of 1986 Porsche 944 recalls
For the 87
Recall Date:
APR 02, 1990
Model Affected:
1987 PORSCHE 944
Summary:
THE HOSE MATERIAL USED IN THE SHORT SECTION OF THE HIGH PRESSURE FUEL LINE HOSE, BETWEEN THE FUEL RAIL AND FUEL PRESSURE REGULATOR, IS SUBJECT TO HARDENING, AND COULD CAUSE FUEL LEAKS BETWEEN THE HOSE AND THE METAL PIPE FITTINGS.
Consequence:
FUEL LEAKS COULD IGNITE ON THE HOT EXHAUST SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER SOURCE OF IGNITION, RESULTING IN AN ENGINE COMPARTMENT FIRE.
Remedy:
REPLACE FUEL LINE HOSE WITH HOSES MADE OF IMPROVED MATERIAL.
Potential Units Affected:
53427
Notes:
PORSCHE CARS N.A. INC.
For the 88
Recall Date:
APR 02, 1990
Model Affected:
1988 PORSCHE 944
Summary:
THE HOSE MATERIAL USED IN THE SHORT SECTION OF THE HIGH PRESSURE FUEL LINE HOSE, BETWEEN THE FUEL RAIL AND FUEL PRESSURE REGULATOR, IS SUBJECT TO HARDENING, AND COULD CAUSE FUEL LEAKS BETWEEN THE HOSE AND THE METAL PIPE FITTINGS.
Consequence:
FUEL LEAKS COULD IGNITE ON THE HOT EXHAUST SYSTEM, OR ANY OTHER SOURCE OF IGNITION, RESULTING IN AN ENGINE COMPARTMENT FIRE.
Remedy:
REPLACE FUEL LINE HOSE WITH HOSES MADE OF IMPROVED MATERIAL.
Potential Units Affected:
53427
Notes:
PORSCHE CARS N.A. INC.
We are talking 60+ THOUSAND 944s involved in the recall. Luis, do you understand what you type can send someone wrong information that may cause them financial damage?
#68
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
I have parted over fourteen 951's and I have never seen a craked block.
Most of the 951's that I have seen the hoses in question had been replaced by the dealer, so Frank honestly I missed your point.
Last edited by lart951; 02-22-2008 at 04:29 AM.
#69
Race Car
I have. Ask Danno of Guru racing. I gave him the replacement block. You know Henry with the 600hp 968 turbo in Glendale also has a 951 cracked block from a 951 I sold him. These are only the ones I have owned personally. I have fixed more than 30 head gaskets on a 944/951 but none on a 928. As for the fuel problem, I replaced many of them so I know how easy it is to do. The original question is "which is more reliable, 951 or 928?" and not which car has problems that are easy to fix for someone who knows the car intimately. My car has caught fire while I was driving and another one sprung a leak but luckily I smelled it and pulled over immediately. Not many people will do that.
#70
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
I have. Ask Danno of Guru racing. I gave him the replacement block. You know Henry with the 600hp 968 turbo in Glendale also has a 951 cracked block from a 951 I sold him. These are only the ones I have owned personally. I have fixed more than 30 head gaskets on a 944/951 but none on a 928. As for the fuel problem, I replaced many of them so I know how easy it is to do. The original question is "which is more reliable, 951 or 928?" and not which car has problems that are easy to fix for someone who knows the car intimately. My car has caught fire while I was driving and another one sprung a leak but luckily I smelled it and pulled over immediately. Not many people will do that.
#71
Race Director
Tifo, talking about insulting I am the one the gets the insults, by putting the facts together, check hacker's post how many of those are 951's ?
But on the subject of insults I don't remember ever insulting you, on the contrary it was you who was hypocritically talking behind my back and other listers putting us down on the hybrid board, who is the two face cynical individual?
Hacker and the 928 guys I can take their comments because he is actually one of the smartest guys on rennlist, I do enjoy reading his posts and look forward to his responses, he is honest and truthful and has my respect, but you with the one and only rice 944, just the looks not performance what a shame, Tifo D’ricer man, I have no respect only my pitty, hey but look at the bright side at least you got lart's pitty. rolf.
Can someone quote me please so tifo can read my message.
lol that was for you tifosiman.
But on the subject of insults I don't remember ever insulting you, on the contrary it was you who was hypocritically talking behind my back and other listers putting us down on the hybrid board, who is the two face cynical individual?
Hacker and the 928 guys I can take their comments because he is actually one of the smartest guys on rennlist, I do enjoy reading his posts and look forward to his responses, he is honest and truthful and has my respect, but you with the one and only rice 944, just the looks not performance what a shame, Tifo D’ricer man, I have no respect only my pitty, hey but look at the bright side at least you got lart's pitty. rolf.
Can someone quote me please so tifo can read my message.
lol that was for you tifosiman.
You are single-handedly the biggest agitator on the 944/951/928 boards. I'm not going to bother looking up old threads to post examples but anyone who has 1/3 of a working brain can see that you enjoy stirring up crap. Your posts consist of insults, infantile pics, or selling your parts (or some combination there-of).
To call my "two-faced" because I spend time on the V8 board is rather hilarious. If you recall the only people I had anything bad to say about were you and NZ (because at the time NZ was the second biggest instigator on the boards, of course since then he has cleaned up his act and frankly he has much more technical contribution to these forums than you EVER will). There's a reason the V8 guys formed there own forum. Anyone who can't recognize the amount of tech knowlege they have and can contribute is a fool. And to simply dismiss them, antagonize them, and call them knuckle-draggers and rednecks is just wrong. Did someone drop a V8 on your head as a child? If so that does explain a lot. You seem to hate all v8cars and their users/owners. You might want to seek therapy.
You seem to enjoy judging people based on what they drive. To your "ricer" comments aimed at me, all I can say is I am not pretending to be anything with my car and its looks. What I do with my car, its suspension, drivetrain, and body panels is my business. If you can't grasp what my design theory is on it (which I have stated many times) that's your loss. I won't be giving you my pity though because I don't pity people who are malicious.
Frankly, the fact that you and some other specific post-****** are allowed to run rampant on these forums is rather disappointing. Most of Renn is a good group of guys, but to quote an old saying "one bad apple spoils the bunch". You are one of those bad apples.
Smell ya later.
#72
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
So miracles can happen
Last edited by hacker-pschorr; 02-22-2008 at 03:53 PM.
#73
Defending the Border
Rennlist Member
Rest In Peace
Rennlist Member
Rest In Peace
Asking about 928 maintanance in a non-928 area is sure to bring false comments by ignorant people who have never owned one. Why not ask on the 928 board? You'll get some honest advice, it wont be all cheerleading.
There are a few of us here that have some 928 experience.
Tifo, see ya around the campus.
#74
Drifting
Thread Starter
so the clutch takes much less labour to replace on a 928?
I thought the early 928s had twin disk clutches and looks like the clutch kit costs double what the clutch kit for 944 costs.
I was looking at 928international for parts prices and especially for the early 16 valve 928s the prices aren't so bad for the parts.
except the radiator which isn't something you replace often, and the manual transmissions (rebuild / used) are pretty expensive. Other maintenance stuff like the belts/ water pump/ cap and rotor/ wires are around the same price as as 951 parts.
now no one has answered this, which car is easier to work on? Considering I'm not a mechanic and just learn how to do things by reading sites like clark-garage which is really helpful for the 944 /951. 928 international also has a repair guid like Clarks but not sure if it is as good.
I thought the early 928s had twin disk clutches and looks like the clutch kit costs double what the clutch kit for 944 costs.
I was looking at 928international for parts prices and especially for the early 16 valve 928s the prices aren't so bad for the parts.
except the radiator which isn't something you replace often, and the manual transmissions (rebuild / used) are pretty expensive. Other maintenance stuff like the belts/ water pump/ cap and rotor/ wires are around the same price as as 951 parts.
now no one has answered this, which car is easier to work on? Considering I'm not a mechanic and just learn how to do things by reading sites like clark-garage which is really helpful for the 944 /951. 928 international also has a repair guid like Clarks but not sure if it is as good.