987 Spyder : MT vs PDK?
#16
Rennlist Member
My first Porsche was a brand new, special ordered 981 Cayman Base with PDK. This was followed by an almost new 981 Cayman GTS with ... PDK. Next was a Carrara White 987 Spyder with ...... PDK. Currently I own a Aqua Blue 987 Spyder with (wait for it) ......... PDK. Enuf said...
#17
Racer
185 km from new, gold digger seller I guess
another one, in Germany, more reasonably priced at € 75k and nicely specced,,. and Porsche approved…and pdk, AC, sport exhaust, buckets, sport chrono, red stitching
German red
Last edited by bassie81; 08-06-2023 at 03:23 PM.
#19
Advanced
Thread Starter
another one, in Germany, more reasonably priced at € 75k and nicely specced,,. and Porsche approved…and pdk, AC, sport exhaust, buckets, sport chrono, red stitching
German red
German red
#20
Racer
With the Porsche approved included, yes if no accident history, all original paint.
it is a very nicely optioned car in the colour you prefer, with the PDK you prefer. As you have noticed they are rare, most of the spyders are white, so finding a different colour in the preferred spec…
it is a very nicely optioned car in the colour you prefer, with the PDK you prefer. As you have noticed they are rare, most of the spyders are white, so finding a different colour in the preferred spec…
#21
Racer
My opinion is very subjective, since I've own a manual spyder, but maybe will help to you:
Beside the spyder I have a 997.2gt3 and a 993, both manual (of course). These cars have heavy clutch, which makes stop&go traffic for workout for your leg.
However the spyder has a fantastic smooth clutch and a great shifter feel (with some upgrades) which gives you a ton of fun on weekend drive, canyon carving, etc. You don't have to fight with the shifting but it gives the extra connection with the car. I won't miss it.
As I've mentioned at the beginning, it's my subjective opinion, but as I know the 7.2 gt3 quite well as well., maybe it gives you some relevance
Beside the spyder I have a 997.2gt3 and a 993, both manual (of course). These cars have heavy clutch, which makes stop&go traffic for workout for your leg.
However the spyder has a fantastic smooth clutch and a great shifter feel (with some upgrades) which gives you a ton of fun on weekend drive, canyon carving, etc. You don't have to fight with the shifting but it gives the extra connection with the car. I won't miss it.
As I've mentioned at the beginning, it's my subjective opinion, but as I know the 7.2 gt3 quite well as well., maybe it gives you some relevance
The following 2 users liked this post by RP993:
Spyderblack (08-27-2023),
Zeus993 (08-08-2023)
#22
Advanced
Thread Starter
My opinion is very subjective, since I've own a manual spyder, but maybe will help to you:
Beside the spyder I have a 997.2gt3 and a 993, both manual (of course). These cars have heavy clutch, which makes stop&go traffic for workout for your leg.
However the spyder has a fantastic smooth clutch and a great shifter feel (with some upgrades) which gives you a ton of fun on weekend drive, canyon carving, etc. You don't have to fight with the shifting but it gives the extra connection with the car. I won't miss it.
As I've mentioned at the beginning, it's my subjective opinion, but as I know the 7.2 gt3 quite well as well., maybe it gives you some relevance
Beside the spyder I have a 997.2gt3 and a 993, both manual (of course). These cars have heavy clutch, which makes stop&go traffic for workout for your leg.
However the spyder has a fantastic smooth clutch and a great shifter feel (with some upgrades) which gives you a ton of fun on weekend drive, canyon carving, etc. You don't have to fight with the shifting but it gives the extra connection with the car. I won't miss it.
As I've mentioned at the beginning, it's my subjective opinion, but as I know the 7.2 gt3 quite well as well., maybe it gives you some relevance
Thanks for your feedback, and helpful.
I have to be patient, this car is so rare that it is a difficult to find the one who matchs my requirements (not white, bucket, sport mode, park assist, light wheels and ideally leather).
#23
Drifting
With a 7.2GT3 and a Spyder, you have the perfect garage !!
Thanks for your feedback, and helpful.
I have to be patient, this car is so rare that it is a difficult to find the one who matchs my requirements (not white, bucket, sport mode, park assist, light wheels and ideally leather).
Thanks for your feedback, and helpful.
I have to be patient, this car is so rare that it is a difficult to find the one who matchs my requirements (not white, bucket, sport mode, park assist, light wheels and ideally leather).
#24
Advanced
Thread Starter
#25
Drifting
#26
Three Wheelin'
mt is the way to go but pdk spyder still got that spyder magic feel so take your pick!
The following users liked this post:
alemaniac (08-11-2023)
#27
I would say it really depends on usage as others have already eluded.
If the primary purpose is a fun engaging weekend car that won’t be used regularly in high traffic areas then I would suggest the MT will be more engaging and it weighs 40 lbs less. Once you address the shift linkage and poorly designed cable you are left with a really nice shifting MT mated perfect to the engines power which begs you to downshift and rev match even when its not necessary. 😎.
If however the car will be driven in high traffic areas, longer road trips that involve lots of stop/go etc. it’s hard to argue that the PDK would be far more palatable. It’s also the faster shifting transmission so quicker off the line and faster around a track if thats the intended purpose. Personally I’ve found that many choose PDK for more personal reasons such as making the car more accessible to other drivers in the family that can’t or don’t want to drive manual. Age and previous injuries etc. also could steer you in the direction of PDK.
Regarding reliability, other than the shifter cable issue the MT’s have proven very reliable on the 987 Spyder. There are a handful of people who’ve had catastrophic failures and more minor electrical issues with the PDK transmission but not enough to say it’s problematic. The biggest difference I see with the MT vs PDK is that an MT can be repaired by any tech familiar with Porsches and manuals which there are many. PDK repair shops are few and far between with Porsche keeping tight control on repairs/replacements. That will likely change in time but for now the MT is definitely an easier transmission to repair should it be needed.
Again you asked for an opinion so YMMV
If the primary purpose is a fun engaging weekend car that won’t be used regularly in high traffic areas then I would suggest the MT will be more engaging and it weighs 40 lbs less. Once you address the shift linkage and poorly designed cable you are left with a really nice shifting MT mated perfect to the engines power which begs you to downshift and rev match even when its not necessary. 😎.
If however the car will be driven in high traffic areas, longer road trips that involve lots of stop/go etc. it’s hard to argue that the PDK would be far more palatable. It’s also the faster shifting transmission so quicker off the line and faster around a track if thats the intended purpose. Personally I’ve found that many choose PDK for more personal reasons such as making the car more accessible to other drivers in the family that can’t or don’t want to drive manual. Age and previous injuries etc. also could steer you in the direction of PDK.
Regarding reliability, other than the shifter cable issue the MT’s have proven very reliable on the 987 Spyder. There are a handful of people who’ve had catastrophic failures and more minor electrical issues with the PDK transmission but not enough to say it’s problematic. The biggest difference I see with the MT vs PDK is that an MT can be repaired by any tech familiar with Porsches and manuals which there are many. PDK repair shops are few and far between with Porsche keeping tight control on repairs/replacements. That will likely change in time but for now the MT is definitely an easier transmission to repair should it be needed.
Again you asked for an opinion so YMMV
Last edited by Spyder_2011; 08-07-2023 at 04:15 PM.
The following 5 users liked this post by Spyder_2011:
Dana R (08-07-2023),
islaTurbine (08-07-2023),
Spyderblack (08-07-2023),
Yc911Kid (08-08-2023),
Zeus993 (08-08-2023)