I would go with the 09, it is better on many levels.

 

997.2 non S performs similarly to 997.1 S. If manual vs PDK doesn't matter, then get a manual as it will be cheaper.

 

I not too long ago bought my first 911 and landed on an '08 997.1 C2S manual coupe. I drove a few 997.2 with PDK but just couldn't pull the trigger. What it came down to is that for a DD the manual just has the feel I want and love in a car, but I know that if I were to regularly be on the track the PDK would be very nice to have.

 

997.2 without doubt. Try and work the warranty in there. If not, just buy a Fidelity warranty later. Best of luck.

 

09 for me but the 08 would not be a bad runner-up. Having the CPO is really nice.

 

Get the 2009. No question. Direct injected engine, 40% fever parts ie no IMS, more horsepower, better insulated starter cable so no more failure there, newer and improved dash and ergonomics.

For only a few thousands more, get the newer car just for the fact that there is no IMS and it has the upgraded starter cable (a $1000 fix).
Added hp is a bonus.

 

Given the prices and details I'd go with the 09. Assuming a manual doesn't matter. A manual first porsche is a great experience though.

 

There are many upgrades on 997.2 but does it worth $10k more to you. Nothing wrong with a manual 997.1S Cab. I had 2008 997S Cab and love it, it was a great car with tons of attraction after I put body kit and wheels on it. Good luck

 

997.2...roll the dice with an engine in a 997.1 car besides IMS and starter cable issues there is a far more common problem effecting all M97 engine cars. Bore Scoring and it is popping up a lot lately...
10k difference will not get you a new or rebuilt M97

 

997.2 because of revised suspension and pcm unit. Quality seems better

 

Ok. Going with the 997.2. After some back forth dealer finally agreed to add the warranty which he initially wanted $2500 for.

 

Thanks for the help.

 

Post some pics when you get it!

 

That is a sweet deal and a great ride. Enjoy each and every mile. Remember that these "pets" get ill if there are stuck in the garage for too long. They yearn to be driven ...

 

The 09 has the latest engine...but try to find an 09 without the sport crono package and all the pasm or whatever it is called. Try to find a base Carrera w/ PDK and 18" wheels. All the other S add ons are useless puffery.