Is the 997 the last real 911?
#31
I think that the factual history is a little bit different than you've remembered it.
VW took control of Porsche after Porsche's attempt to take over control of VW failed (this was 2009.) See this article for the details...
https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a1...ng-forced-out/
VW took control of Porsche after Porsche's attempt to take over control of VW failed (this was 2009.) See this article for the details...
https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a1...ng-forced-out/
#35
Last summer an employee delivered my 997.2 6 sp and picked up their loaner Cayenne. He went on about what a beautiful car it was, and he sees new ones every day.
The following users liked this post:
SpeedyD (01-17-2020)
#37
I'd say its a sweet spot...why?
Based on what ThomasCarreraGTS said above "Well, you have the financial details down but I have to disagree about the influence that VW Group has on Porsche now. VW is the largest auto manufacturer in the world and as a public, shareholder owned company, it has an obligation and primary goal to provide the highest possible return for its shareholders. Yes, Porsche certainly wanted to make money before, but history shows that the product / price balance was different before Porsche was folded into the larger company. So effective with Porsche being part of the VW Group, product did change. Even our beloved 911 went from excellence being the goal to excellence at a price and the amount of parts bin content increased dramatically. There is now so much shared with VW and Audi and the next 911 platform will be shared across brands as well, instead of being a dedicated rear engine design. And all the new cost-cutting measures that the 992 buyers are complaining about are largely attributable to the VW Group influence"
You'd be naive to say that Porsches processes/engineering and final choices are not based on some kind of move to satisfy VW/shareholders....which means, everything that happened during/after that is going to be a little different. You know Porsche HQ tries its hardest to produce "pure" enjoyable Porsche.... but at the end of the day, cross platforms with other manufactures and satisfying customers/numbers and shareholders is the goal. Even if the die hard Porsche guys dont want that direction... so maybe the 997 was made at a different point/time of Porsches influence and goal..and thats why it may be a sweet spot?
Based on what ThomasCarreraGTS said above "Well, you have the financial details down but I have to disagree about the influence that VW Group has on Porsche now. VW is the largest auto manufacturer in the world and as a public, shareholder owned company, it has an obligation and primary goal to provide the highest possible return for its shareholders. Yes, Porsche certainly wanted to make money before, but history shows that the product / price balance was different before Porsche was folded into the larger company. So effective with Porsche being part of the VW Group, product did change. Even our beloved 911 went from excellence being the goal to excellence at a price and the amount of parts bin content increased dramatically. There is now so much shared with VW and Audi and the next 911 platform will be shared across brands as well, instead of being a dedicated rear engine design. And all the new cost-cutting measures that the 992 buyers are complaining about are largely attributable to the VW Group influence"
You'd be naive to say that Porsches processes/engineering and final choices are not based on some kind of move to satisfy VW/shareholders....which means, everything that happened during/after that is going to be a little different. You know Porsche HQ tries its hardest to produce "pure" enjoyable Porsche.... but at the end of the day, cross platforms with other manufactures and satisfying customers/numbers and shareholders is the goal. Even if the die hard Porsche guys dont want that direction... so maybe the 997 was made at a different point/time of Porsches influence and goal..and thats why it may be a sweet spot?
The following 2 users liked this post by Vince Vincent:
Ironman88 (01-17-2020),
ThomasCarreraGTS (01-18-2020)
#38
I'd say its a sweet spot...why?
Based on what ThomasCarreraGTS said above "Well, you have the financial details down but I have to disagree about the influence that VW Group has on Porsche now. VW is the largest auto manufacturer in the world and as a public, shareholder owned company, it has an obligation and primary goal to provide the highest possible return for its shareholders. Yes, Porsche certainly wanted to make money before, but history shows that the product / price balance was different before Porsche was folded into the larger company. So effective with Porsche being part of the VW Group, product did change. Even our beloved 911 went from excellence being the goal to excellence at a price and the amount of parts bin content increased dramatically. There is now so much shared with VW and Audi and the next 911 platform will be shared across brands as well, instead of being a dedicated rear engine design. And all the new cost-cutting measures that the 992 buyers are complaining about are largely attributable to the VW Group influence"
You'd be naive to say that Porsches processes/engineering and final choices are not based on some kind of move to satisfy VW/shareholders....which means, everything that happened during/after that is going to be a little different. You know Porsche HQ tries its hardest to produce "pure" enjoyable Porsche.... but at the end of the day, cross platforms with other manufactures and satisfying customers/numbers and shareholders is the goal. Even if the die hard Porsche guys dont want that direction... so maybe the 997 was made at a different point/time of Porsches influence and goal..and thats why it may be a sweet spot?
Based on what ThomasCarreraGTS said above "Well, you have the financial details down but I have to disagree about the influence that VW Group has on Porsche now. VW is the largest auto manufacturer in the world and as a public, shareholder owned company, it has an obligation and primary goal to provide the highest possible return for its shareholders. Yes, Porsche certainly wanted to make money before, but history shows that the product / price balance was different before Porsche was folded into the larger company. So effective with Porsche being part of the VW Group, product did change. Even our beloved 911 went from excellence being the goal to excellence at a price and the amount of parts bin content increased dramatically. There is now so much shared with VW and Audi and the next 911 platform will be shared across brands as well, instead of being a dedicated rear engine design. And all the new cost-cutting measures that the 992 buyers are complaining about are largely attributable to the VW Group influence"
You'd be naive to say that Porsches processes/engineering and final choices are not based on some kind of move to satisfy VW/shareholders....which means, everything that happened during/after that is going to be a little different. You know Porsche HQ tries its hardest to produce "pure" enjoyable Porsche.... but at the end of the day, cross platforms with other manufactures and satisfying customers/numbers and shareholders is the goal. Even if the die hard Porsche guys dont want that direction... so maybe the 997 was made at a different point/time of Porsches influence and goal..and thats why it may be a sweet spot?
To me the 997.2 is the sweet spot because it still retains at least the appearance of an analog machine, I can do most of the maintenance myself, and it doesn't have the problems of the earlier water cooled engines. The 997.2 doesn't have the panache of the air cooled versions ( it will), but it has better performance and I don't have to replace half the car. It also has good head restraints and air bags. I can just get in and drive it.
Last edited by bheit1; 01-17-2020 at 03:03 PM.
#39
The 'little fish' actually is the big fish. Porsche Holdings owns the majority of the Volkswagen Group, and it already did when Porsche the car company was rolled into VW.
#40
#41
Kind of... for the following reasons:
- Last car you can still access the engine
- Mostly still mechanical
- Rear-bias similar to old models (991 moved engine forward)
- Less luxury, more raw feel
- Hydraulic steering
- Most maintenance items still could be done by owner
- Last car you can still access the engine
- Mostly still mechanical
- Rear-bias similar to old models (991 moved engine forward)
- Less luxury, more raw feel
- Hydraulic steering
- Most maintenance items still could be done by owner
The following users liked this post:
ThomasCarreraGTS (01-18-2020)
#42
It's pretty messy. I find it hard to understand if one should consider Porsche AG, owned by VW, whose dominant shareholder is Porsche Holdings, which is controlled by the Porsche/Piëch families, to have management approaches and objectives that are the same or different from when Porsche was "independent" of VW. That would take some real inside baseball to know. Glad they still make cars.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porsche_SE
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porsche_SE
#43
I don't know nor care if the 997 is "the last real 911," but I do believe I will be the "last real owner of THIS 997." {Love}
Also, if someone gave me a 991 or 992 or 99X, I would gleefully accept and probably keep that one, too. May I please stay on this forum, anyway?
Also, if someone gave me a 991 or 992 or 99X, I would gleefully accept and probably keep that one, too. May I please stay on this forum, anyway?
#44
#45
I'd say its a sweet spot...why?
You'd be naive to say that Porsches processes/engineering and final choices are not based on some kind of move to satisfy VW/shareholders....which means, everything that happened during/after that is going to be a little different. You know Porsche HQ tries its hardest to produce "pure" enjoyable Porsche.... but at the end of the day, cross platforms with other manufactures and satisfying customers/numbers and shareholders is the goal. Even if the die hard Porsche guys dont want that direction... so maybe the 997 was made at a different point/time of Porsches influence and goal..and thats why it may be a sweet spot?
You'd be naive to say that Porsches processes/engineering and final choices are not based on some kind of move to satisfy VW/shareholders....which means, everything that happened during/after that is going to be a little different. You know Porsche HQ tries its hardest to produce "pure" enjoyable Porsche.... but at the end of the day, cross platforms with other manufactures and satisfying customers/numbers and shareholders is the goal. Even if the die hard Porsche guys dont want that direction... so maybe the 997 was made at a different point/time of Porsches influence and goal..and thats why it may be a sweet spot?
The following users liked this post:
Doug H (01-18-2020)