Notices
997 Forum 2005-2012
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

This forum is scaring me away from a 997.1

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 03-06-2018 | 02:17 PM
  #31  
Fined's Avatar
Fined
Three Wheelin'
 
Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 1,650
Likes: 210
From: Denver
Default

Originally Posted by GPGolden
Fined - This car did come up in my search. My initial reaction is why is it at a Nissan dealer? Someone trade it in on a Sentra?? Also the Carfax has almost no service history. So I moved on.

More important is the actual car. My GTS came from a Toyota dealer in Memphis.. when I live in Raleigh. I had a thorough PPI done (at a very highly recommended Porsche race shop) and drove the car 800 miles home. That was 2 years ago (and 25k miles) and so far the only thing I have repaired was a window regulator.
Old 03-06-2018 | 02:19 PM
  #32  
DesmoSD's Avatar
DesmoSD
Three Wheelin'
 
Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 1,870
Likes: 361
From: San Diego <->Knoxville
Default

Originally Posted by j beede
If reading about others' P-car woes diminishes your 997 experience--I suggest you stop visiting this forum or look for an alternative to the 997.

The 997.1 provides a wonderful driving experience, no doubt. After three years I still smile every time I fire mine up (Fister-style exhaust mods) and back out of the garage. I stopped visiting this forum for two years and simply enjoyed the car. Nice. I recently dropped by to see what's new... Next thing I know I am wiping traces black dust off my bumper wondering if my bores are scored
OT but j beede, Carrara White 997.1 here checking in. No doubt, I know that feeling. I drive her like how she was intended for and I hate having to pull into the garage after a canyon sprint.

Is that your car in your avatar? If so, that's a clean and happy looking front end.
Old 03-06-2018 | 03:11 PM
  #33  
stronbl's Avatar
stronbl
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 1,029
Likes: 13
From: SF Bay Area
Default

Originally Posted by GPGolden
This forum is scaring me away from a 997.1 Hopefully I am overreacting. I joined to become and educated consumer, but I feel there is too much of a chance I can drop $44k on a nice, low mileage 997.1 and 2 years later spend $7k on a clutch and $25k on an engine. say it aint so. I think I need to talk to humans instead of reading all the horror stories.
OP - I think you are getting a good array of practical advice thus far. You've read about some serious issues with the 997.1 which a small percentage of [vocal] owners have experienced, and even smaller percentages with a late model 997.1. The 997.1's are at a good price point but will require you to spend some time looking for the right one - sounds like you may have already found a likely candidate - good for you. If the high expense but low probability event (I have no idea what the actual probability is but if I was in the market now, I'd figure less than 5% chance) has you concerned, then budget for it if possible. Continue to read on throughout this 997 forum and you'll find most of the money being spent on 997.1 / 997.2 is on mods and/or track consumables - that's where you have to watch your wallet. Good luck with the search and drive in good health!
Old 03-06-2018 | 03:39 PM
  #34  
GPGolden's Avatar
GPGolden
Thread Starter
Advanced
 
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
From: Delaware
Default

Originally Posted by DC911S
Well the timing chain guides and tensioners are a ticking time bomb on the B6 S4. If you have been living with that lurking, then a 997.1 should not bother you at all, with its potential problems.
Very True!!!
Old 03-06-2018 | 04:02 PM
  #35  
HenryPcar's Avatar
HenryPcar
Three Wheelin'
 
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 1,971
Likes: 234
From: Northern California
Thumbs up

[QUOTE=For most, if not all used car purchases, overall condition trumps mileage[/QUOTE]

Fully agree with you. I would be leery of low mileage garage queens that never saw the daylight. High mileage Porsches that are well maintained gets thumbs up for me.
Old 03-06-2018 | 04:11 PM
  #36  
GPGolden's Avatar
GPGolden
Thread Starter
Advanced
 
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
From: Delaware
Default

Originally Posted by henryting
Fully agree with you. I would be leery of low mileage garage queens that never saw the daylight. High mileage Porsches that are well maintained gets thumbs up for me.
these are the things that scare me. I have seen folks say that numerous times. What kind of car craps out because it has low mileage?
Old 03-06-2018 | 04:13 PM
  #37  
larrysb's Avatar
larrysb
Racer
 
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 303
Likes: 60
From: Silicon Valley
Default

I backed away from a 997.1 that was a sweet price and a super, super clean, low mileage car. The deal just wasn't timing out right, though not anyone's fault. I had not fully researched the IMS bearing issue because I had not at that point, considered a car of that age. In the end, I would have been fine with the car, and I would have simply arranged to have the IMS Solution installed as soon as I bought it. Had already budgeted it out and it made sense to do it that way. Only caveat being that it needed to pass the inspection that LN requires for warranting the IMS Solution, though it almost certainly would have. If it had been a higher miles car, I'd have just installed one of the less-expensive IMS bearing upgrades and a new clutch just because it was there.

Or get one that already has the fix installed. They're out there too.

It just happened to work out that I bought a newer vehicle, a 997.2 2S Cabrio more because of how things were timing out and it had PDK and some other stuff that made it a little more ideal as a daily driver.

The pricing of 996 and 997.1 vehicles reflects the issues. You can buy a super, super clean and low mileage car for a low price. Then the choice is yours, drive the snot out of it and hope it does fine, or do the fix and drive the snot out of it and sleep a little easier at night. I mean, it's a LOT of car for the money either way. Buy and drive it or buy, fix and drive it. It only amounts to a small amount of differential dollars.
Old 03-06-2018 | 04:14 PM
  #38  
GPGolden's Avatar
GPGolden
Thread Starter
Advanced
 
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
From: Delaware
Default

When I was researching my Audis, I never cam across someone telling others to beware of low mileage Audis...
Old 03-06-2018 | 04:22 PM
  #39  
HenryPcar's Avatar
HenryPcar
Three Wheelin'
 
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 1,971
Likes: 234
From: Northern California
Default

Originally Posted by GPGolden
these are the things that scare me. I have seen folks say that numerous times. What kind of car craps out because it has low mileage?
Never gets driven much and all the mechanics are in long-term dormant state. Out of good intention, the owner starts it once a week believing it does the engine good. The irony is the constant rich fuel that gets dumped into the cylinder never gets a chance to warm up. Hence, whatever lubricants stay put in the engine gets diluted and then during startups, cylinder scoring potentially happens. Not to mention, water pump, coolants, power steering, transmission fluid never gets a chance to work efficiently. The bottom line is that your car is not designed to operate in such environment.
Old 03-06-2018 | 04:35 PM
  #40  
GPGolden's Avatar
GPGolden
Thread Starter
Advanced
 
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
From: Delaware
Default

Originally Posted by henryting
Never gets driven much and all the mechanics are in long-term dormant state. Out of good intention, the owner starts it once a week believing it does the engine good. The irony is the constant rich fuel that gets dumped into the cylinder never gets a chance to warm up. Hence, whatever lubricants stay put in the engine gets diluted and then during startups, cylinder scoring potentially happens. Not to mention, water pump, coolants, power steering, transmission fluid never gets a chance to work efficiently. The bottom line is that your car is not designed to operate in such environment.
Henryting - would you consider an '08 with 30,000 miles too low?
Old 03-06-2018 | 04:59 PM
  #41  
voodoo's Avatar
voodoo
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Jun 2012
Posts: 421
Likes: 61
From: Newport Beach, CA
Default

997.1 and grin ear to ear every time I drive it. If something breaks I will fix it. Life's too short to drive boring cars....
Old 03-06-2018 | 05:08 PM
  #42  
DesmoSD's Avatar
DesmoSD
Three Wheelin'
 
Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 1,870
Likes: 361
From: San Diego <->Knoxville
Default

Originally Posted by henryting
Fully agree with you. I would be leery of low mileage garage queens that never saw the daylight. High mileage Porsches that are well maintained gets thumbs up for me.
Originally Posted by henryting
Never gets driven much and all the mechanics are in long-term dormant state. Out of good intention, the owner starts it once a week believing it does the engine good. The irony is the constant rich fuel that gets dumped into the cylinder never gets a chance to warm up. Hence, whatever lubricants stay put in the engine gets diluted and then during startups, cylinder scoring potentially happens. Not to mention, water pump, coolants, power steering, transmission fluid never gets a chance to work efficiently. The bottom line is that your car is not designed to operate in such environment.
Henry, you have to look at the other supporting factors as well. I did mention that condition trumps mileage. The 997.1 that I picked up only had 14,372 miles, is an 06 and was from the original owner. The car spent it's entire life in Southern California (annual temps avg 60-80), which means he drove approx 1197 miles a year. The service records show that it only had 4 oil changes; 400 miles, 4400, 7K and 12K miles. I bet the car only went to PCA events and drives around town.

Was it a garage queen, yes to a certain extent. Is it doomed b/c it sat instead of being driven, unlikely. My 25 yr old 93.5 Supra TT has 66K miles and still has most of the original parts when it left the factory.

I'm going through the car to bring the maintenance up to date. I'm finding some OEM parts (cabin filter, front tires, air filter, rad cap) that have been back dated to 2006 and have never been replaced.
Old 03-06-2018 | 05:27 PM
  #43  
HenryPcar's Avatar
HenryPcar
Three Wheelin'
 
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 1,971
Likes: 234
From: Northern California
Default

Originally Posted by GPGolden
Henryting - would you consider an '08 with 30,000 miles too low?
I think we are all conditioned to think all high mileage cars will have some inherent problems. This is just not the case. To put things into perspective, I had a daily driver. Its a BMW E30 and I use it driving from LA to SF once a week back in the 1990s. The day I sold it, it has accumulated 1/2 million miles on the origin engine. As far as maintenance it was all commonsense and I never ever got stuck in the middle of I-5. I put in about 1000 miles every week and oil gets changed every 2 months. Yes I do need to replace tires on a yearly basis.
I'm not to saying high-mileage cars are more reliable. What I am saying is I would rather get a high-mileage car that has been well maintained than a barely driven car by some clueless owner.
Old 03-06-2018 | 05:35 PM
  #44  
SoCal C2S's Avatar
SoCal C2S
Three Wheelin'
 
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 1,469
Likes: 130
From: Kalifornistan for now....
Default

Bought my 06S with 48k.....now has 61k almost 5 years later. Spend about $3k in preventative maintenance and the annual oil change and biannual brake fluid change. Would not hesitate driving it coast to coast. I had a full PPI with borescope....clean bill of health. Its always been a warm weather car with lots of records that it was and now is being treated well.

The most important maintenance is at least 2 or 3 track days....cleans it out and does the owner some good as well.
Old 03-06-2018 | 06:10 PM
  #45  
j beede's Avatar
j beede
Racer
 
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 484
Likes: 3
From: NorCal
Default

Originally Posted by larrysb
[...] You can buy a super, super clean and low mileage car for a low price. Then the choice is yours, drive the snot out of it and hope it does fine, or do the fix and drive the snot out of it and sleep a little easier at night. I mean, it's a LOT of car for the money either way. Buy and drive it or buy, fix and drive it. It only amounts to a small amount of differential dollars.
Careful. Not every 997 IMS bearing is a candidate for the "fix", assuming you are referring to LN Eng products (which you almost certainly are). In most cases you will not know if your candidate 997 has a LNE serviceable IMS bearing without dropping the transmission and visually inspecting it.

If you can put up with the styling of the 996... a Raby 3.8 in a cheap 996 roller with some techart goodies would make for a fun car.

OP: If it says so on the interwebs, it has to be true. Not.


Quick Reply: This forum is scaring me away from a 997.1



All times are GMT -3. The time now is 05:25 PM.