Driver's Ed Crash
#76
Instructor
Originally Posted by dave1200
If its a Real DE with intructors... your car is coverd with your insurance..
The following is EXCLUDED from coverage:
"Any pre-arranged event on a temporary or permanent racing surface".
Now in my case the event was certainly pre-arranged, and it was held on a permanent racing surface - so with Progressive, I was definately flying solo.
#77
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: New York, USA
Posts: 257
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
OK here's a scenario for you. Guy goes to a DE and someone hits him. He goes to his insurance company and the company pays him but sues the guy who hit him. Now you either pay up or have to pay possible high legal fees. I still say the whole thing is not clean because any jerk can sue you if he wants to.
#78
Ironman 140.6
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by Dave S
OK here's a scenario for you. Guy goes to a DE and someone hits him. He goes to his insurance company and the company pays him but sues the guy who hit him. Now you either pay up or have to pay possible high legal fees. I still say the whole thing is not clean because any jerk can sue you if he wants to.
#79
Burning Brakes
Here's another perspective. I would be tempted to pay for damage I believe I caused to another car, but my attorney would go nuts if I did.
Here’s why; let’s say I come up to you after the incident and we agree that the damage is $3k, so I write you a check. I’ve now admitted fault. You turn out to be a jerk and decide to sue me later for more damages, pain and suffering or whatever. In court you’re going to produce the check I wrote as my admission of being at fault. I’m now probably going to lose the law suit and be on the hook for serious $.
I’m not saying this is what would happen in this case, but just one more thing to keep in mind in our litigious society.
Here’s why; let’s say I come up to you after the incident and we agree that the damage is $3k, so I write you a check. I’ve now admitted fault. You turn out to be a jerk and decide to sue me later for more damages, pain and suffering or whatever. In court you’re going to produce the check I wrote as my admission of being at fault. I’m now probably going to lose the law suit and be on the hook for serious $.
I’m not saying this is what would happen in this case, but just one more thing to keep in mind in our litigious society.
#81
Rennlist Member
I agonized over this liability issue in DE's for several years. Now I race so I know there's no "fault" , I know the potential liability, and I do it anyway because going 150 mph in a Porsche is fun! I just had my 1st bill for a bonehead move(by a BMW M3, btw) and it hurt...real bad!!
I'll be at another race this weekend...quess I got over it
I'll be at another race this weekend...quess I got over it
#82
Race Director
Originally Posted by PJorgen
Here's another perspective. I would be tempted to pay for damage I believe I caused to another car, but my attorney would go nuts if I did.
Here’s why; let’s say I come up to you after the incident and we agree that the damage is $3k, so I write you a check. I’ve now admitted fault. You turn out to be a jerk and decide to sue me later for more damages, pain and suffering or whatever. In court you’re going to produce the check I wrote as my admission of being at fault. I’m now probably going to lose the law suit and be on the hook for serious $.
I’m not saying this is what would happen in this case, but just one more thing to keep in mind in our litigious society.
Here’s why; let’s say I come up to you after the incident and we agree that the damage is $3k, so I write you a check. I’ve now admitted fault. You turn out to be a jerk and decide to sue me later for more damages, pain and suffering or whatever. In court you’re going to produce the check I wrote as my admission of being at fault. I’m now probably going to lose the law suit and be on the hook for serious $.
I’m not saying this is what would happen in this case, but just one more thing to keep in mind in our litigious society.
I suppose I can still offer to help as long as I have the person I'm giving money to sign a liability waiver....
Then again, the fact that the event waiver was signed by both myself and other person, I can argue that my monetary gift was a donation to a charity... or something like that.
-Z-man.
#83
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by M758
Don't expect me to pay for YOU risking a 100k car.
Hell, now I'm not sure I would pay for someone's fixes if I caused an accident. Yeah, I might give them a $100 or buy him and his friends a round of drinks but I'm not paying for some guy's Ferrari F430 $1000 brake light at just because he was willing to risk it.
We know we can't count on your street insurance or the other guy paying. So, there are basically two options - either you are willing to have your car possibly trashed or you get track insurance. That's pretty much the whole thing, right?
#84
Originally Posted by bpoteat
Before I read this response, I was on the middle about this thing, but thinking the BMW guy should've paid at least something. Now, I'm the opposite. This guy's right - it may be the BMW driver's fault that the accident happened, but it's not his fault that the cost to repair is big $$$ (just an example here - I know the real situation wasn't that bad).
Hell, now I'm not sure I would pay for someone's fixes if I caused an accident. Yeah, I might give them a $100 or buy him and his friends a round of drinks but I'm not paying for some guy's Ferrari F430 $1000 brake light at just because he was willing to risk it.
We know we can't count on your street insurance or the other guy paying. So, there are basically two options - either you are willing to have your car possibly trashed or you get track insurance. That's pretty much the whole thing, right?
Hell, now I'm not sure I would pay for someone's fixes if I caused an accident. Yeah, I might give them a $100 or buy him and his friends a round of drinks but I'm not paying for some guy's Ferrari F430 $1000 brake light at just because he was willing to risk it.
We know we can't count on your street insurance or the other guy paying. So, there are basically two options - either you are willing to have your car possibly trashed or you get track insurance. That's pretty much the whole thing, right?
#85
Drifting
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Dallas/FortWorth Texas
Posts: 3,438
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally Posted by Ray S
Hey, this is America. You can sue for millions if your dry cleaner loses your pants, but that does not mean you will win.
#88
Ironman 140.6
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by TR6
Very true. The problem is that by the time it finally gets in front of a judge to get thrown out of court, the legal fees have already financially ruined the person being sued in addition to the ulcer from worrying about it for months.
1) Tort
2) Reform
#89
Originally Posted by Ray S
Two words.
1) Tort
2) Reform
1) Tort
2) Reform
"Be Decent"
#90
Originally Posted by washington dc porsche
Quick question, what racing circuit driver/team pays for damages to other racers who get tangled in collisions?