spare tire and crash protection
#1
Three Wheelin'
Thread Starter
![Question](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon5.gif)
Hi everyone,
I was wondering if there was any validity to thought that the spare tire was part of the structural front end crash protection built-in by Porsche on our 993s?
I always remove the spare tire when auto-crossing.
I am concerned with the safety factor while driving DEs and TTs. If the spare tire is necessary for safety, then I would have to corner balance with the spare in the car. Obviously, I'd like to leave the weight out, but not at the expense of safety.
Thank you.
I was wondering if there was any validity to thought that the spare tire was part of the structural front end crash protection built-in by Porsche on our 993s?
I always remove the spare tire when auto-crossing.
I am concerned with the safety factor while driving DEs and TTs. If the spare tire is necessary for safety, then I would have to corner balance with the spare in the car. Obviously, I'd like to leave the weight out, but not at the expense of safety.
Thank you.
#2
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I leave my spare tire in for the crash protection. I have zero data, but that extra rubber and aluminum have to provide extra energy absorption. I have to make weight anyway, so why not? BTW, I don't think the tire weighs enough to make any significant difference in corner balancing.
#3
Rennlist Member
![Smile](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon7.gif)
I too need to make weight, the spare weighs 30 Lbs. My car needs to weigh 3205 in Impound Pots race. I was a little light, so back went the spare. I also need to have a full tank of gas in the car prior to a race...burn up at least a quarter tank in 30 minutes of racing.
Having some extra weight down low and up front is not so bad.
Having some extra weight down low and up front is not so bad.
#4
Instructor
Join Date: May 2008
Location: sussex United Kingdom
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I've always wondered the same, as run with out the spare wheel.
I was of the opinion that the front of these cars are very well built and by removing the spare wheel the wheel well becomes a extra crumple area, as with the spare wheel in place & the fact that the wheel is effectively two arches put together so despite being only alloy is still very strong and may not crumple and just transfer the impact further back towards the passenger cell, where as with out the spare wheel in place you have a void for the metal to crumple into.
Just my opinion of course and I may be completely wrong.
although I rather hope I need never put it to the test, spare wheel or no spare wheel
I was of the opinion that the front of these cars are very well built and by removing the spare wheel the wheel well becomes a extra crumple area, as with the spare wheel in place & the fact that the wheel is effectively two arches put together so despite being only alloy is still very strong and may not crumple and just transfer the impact further back towards the passenger cell, where as with out the spare wheel in place you have a void for the metal to crumple into.
Just my opinion of course and I may be completely wrong.
although I rather hope I need never put it to the test, spare wheel or no spare wheel
#5
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I've always wondered the same, as run with out the spare wheel.
I was of the opinion that the front of these cars are very well built and by removing the spare wheel the wheel well becomes a extra crumple area, as with the spare wheel in place & the fact that the wheel is effectively two arches put together so despite being only alloy is still very strong and may not crumple and just transfer the impact further back towards the passenger cell, where as with out the spare wheel in place you have a void for the metal to crumple into.
Just my opinion of course and I may be completely wrong.
although I rather hope I need never put it to the test, spare wheel or no spare wheel
I was of the opinion that the front of these cars are very well built and by removing the spare wheel the wheel well becomes a extra crumple area, as with the spare wheel in place & the fact that the wheel is effectively two arches put together so despite being only alloy is still very strong and may not crumple and just transfer the impact further back towards the passenger cell, where as with out the spare wheel in place you have a void for the metal to crumple into.
Just my opinion of course and I may be completely wrong.
although I rather hope I need never put it to the test, spare wheel or no spare wheel
#6
Instructor
Join Date: May 2008
Location: sussex United Kingdom
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Yes you are correct, if it came to the customer with a spare wheel, it would be crash tested as such, at least in european countries, I dont know about other countries. Thats not to say it makes the car safer, its just the car has a spare, it has to be put somewhere and the 911 is a small car and it is crash tested with that spare in place as a requirement of the crash test.
Im sure porsche gave thought to the safety aspect, but that said I'm sure they would have preferred not to have to put the spare in, as 911s of the last few years have no spare wheel at all.
The only thing I would say and its nothing but my observation, is than ive seen a lot of cars hit in the rear (the normal place for the spare wheel to be kept) and always the cars with the spare wheel in place, have the damage carried through closer to the passenger cell and the spare wheel once you cut away the mangled metal is more often than not barely damage if at all, which suggests to me the spare wheel merely transfers the impact across the spare wheel well and further into the car.
Im sure porsche gave thought to the safety aspect, but that said I'm sure they would have preferred not to have to put the spare in, as 911s of the last few years have no spare wheel at all.
The only thing I would say and its nothing but my observation, is than ive seen a lot of cars hit in the rear (the normal place for the spare wheel to be kept) and always the cars with the spare wheel in place, have the damage carried through closer to the passenger cell and the spare wheel once you cut away the mangled metal is more often than not barely damage if at all, which suggests to me the spare wheel merely transfers the impact across the spare wheel well and further into the car.
Trending Topics
#8
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
The only thing I would say and its nothing but my observation, is than ive seen a lot of cars hit in the rear (the normal place for the spare wheel to be kept) and always the cars with the spare wheel in place, have the damage carried through closer to the passenger cell and the spare wheel once you cut away the mangled metal is more often than not barely damage if at all, which suggests to me the spare wheel merely transfers the impact across the spare wheel well and further into the car.
Craig
#11
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
How many of us have seen all manner of headers over the years? I don't think it makes a damned bit of difference through the survivability range. I bought one wreck ~20 years ago that went nose first into a wall at probably 20MPH, no safety equipment, spare removed (was running stock class), and there was no way we were rebuilding it. Similar, a few years earlier, one of my customers wrecked a 2-3 month old 930, amazingly head first at about the same 20-25MPH, and we did put a new front clip on it. But the body guy regretted ever touching the car. It jigged up square, and I aligned it fine, but the bill was $30K+ in 1986 dollars. No one made money on that one............
#12
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
and imagine the lawsuits if a 911 was in a head on collision while using the spare tire...
#13
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Believe me you want that aluminum spare in there when it does happen! Took a header at speed on a
granite curb in the wet and the curb all but stripped the chassis of suspension but while still moving at
an alarming rate say 45/50 the curb acted as a rail and directed the car into a fire hydrant ..which
luckily was of the breakaway variety but still simply crushed the aluminum reinforcement and proceded
to place a perfect U in the spare! Once it had anialated the steering box of course!
that slowed us down and how! no one had as much as a scratch can't say the same for the tub and of
course that spare was toast! Bert
oh this was ten years ago...
granite curb in the wet and the curb all but stripped the chassis of suspension but while still moving at
an alarming rate say 45/50 the curb acted as a rail and directed the car into a fire hydrant ..which
luckily was of the breakaway variety but still simply crushed the aluminum reinforcement and proceded
to place a perfect U in the spare! Once it had anialated the steering box of course!
that slowed us down and how! no one had as much as a scratch can't say the same for the tub and of
course that spare was toast! Bert
oh this was ten years ago...
#15
Instructor
Join Date: May 2008
Location: sussex United Kingdom
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Hi Craig, yes I would of thought that by removing the spare wheel it would help to prevent the passenger cell getting as mangled, but that's only my opinion.
Was explained to me by a body guy like this, if you place a empty coke can on the floor & stamp on it,the metal crushes easily into the void inside the can & very little of the energy is transferred to the floor.
Then fill another coke can with stones & stamp on it, this time the metal of the can has no void to fold into and most of the energy is thus transferred through the can & into the ground.
So by removing the spare wheel their is more space for the metal work of the car to fold into in a crash thus assorbing some of the energy of a crash.
Was explained to me by a body guy like this, if you place a empty coke can on the floor & stamp on it,the metal crushes easily into the void inside the can & very little of the energy is transferred to the floor.
Then fill another coke can with stones & stamp on it, this time the metal of the can has no void to fold into and most of the energy is thus transferred through the can & into the ground.
So by removing the spare wheel their is more space for the metal work of the car to fold into in a crash thus assorbing some of the energy of a crash.