Weight of Carrera S wheels?
#16
Rennlist Member
stupid question but here goes: Why exactly are you so obsessed with unsprung weight? Unless you are a professional racer, I'd bet my last dollar you will never, ever feel the difference between the heaviest and lightest wheel and why obsess over it? You're going to choose a wheel based on weight alone? How about appearance? I'm a hard core driver and these are minutiae I'll never waste my time or effort worrying about.
This is why I went with the Turbo wheels. Forged.
Otherwise save yourself $70k and buy a 4000lb M4.
The following users liked this post:
pkalhan (05-26-2023)
#17
Rennlist Member
Ask the site grand poo bah (Robb) if I'm trolling . . . . It is not an assumption you should be like me rather it is a quest to understand what is in you to undergo such mental gymnastics? I've driven a lot of sports cars on circuits, mostly Watkins Glen. Never have I as a person who loves to drive at the limit been able to tell the difference in weight between vastly different cars driven the same day on the same track. Maybe you can, I doubt it but if so concerned spend the cash and buy non-Porsche aftermarket wheels.
#18
Rennlist Member
stupid question but here goes: Why exactly are you so obsessed with unsprung weight? Unless you are a professional racer, I'd bet my last dollar you will never, ever feel the difference between the heaviest and lightest wheel and why obsess over it? You're going to choose a wheel based on weight alone? How about appearance? I'm a hard core driver and these are minutiae I'll never waste my time or effort worrying about.
The following 4 users liked this post by dixonk:
#19
Rennlist Member
stupid question but here goes: Why exactly are you so obsessed with unsprung weight? Unless you are a professional racer, I'd bet my last dollar you will never, ever feel the difference between the heaviest and lightest wheel and why obsess over it? You're going to choose a wheel based on weight alone? How about appearance? I'm a hard core driver and these are minutiae I'll never waste my time or effort worrying about.
#20
stupid question but here goes: Why exactly are you so obsessed with unsprung weight? Unless you are a professional racer, I'd bet my last dollar you will never, ever feel the difference between the heaviest and lightest wheel and why obsess over it? You're going to choose a wheel based on weight alone? How about appearance? I'm a hard core driver and these are minutiae I'll never waste my time or effort worrying about.
However, when it comes to unsprung weight (wheels, brakes, etc), my opinion is very different. Every time I have swapped out heavy factory wheels for lighter wheels, it can be felt in normal driving to me. The car is more responsive, the bumps are less intrusive in the cabin and the suspension handles them better in terms of chassis control. Lighter wheels/tires make it easier for the suspension to do its job and, for me anyway, is definitely something I can feel. I have driven a number of cars back to back after swapping in lighter wheels and it is immediately noticeable to me. Something in the 6-10lb per wheel range is very noticeable for me.
But, as I said, skipping other options (like a sunroof) is definitely NOT noticeable. I think you would need to shave hundreds of pounds of weight to have the same impact on performance as shaving 6lbs/wheel of unsprung weight. I have no basis for this other than seat of pants feel
Last edited by gthal; 04-17-2023 at 01:51 PM.
#21
Rennlist Member
Every pound of unsprung weight is worth 3-4x static weight, so when you remove 6-10lb per corner or 24-40lb total, it's the equivalent of removing between 72 and 160 lbs from the car.
As for the obsession with weight reduction on street cars, I agree that it doesn't matter on pedestrian cars (I have a Jetta and an XQ80) but my sports cars, even my Macan Turbo DD, are driven hard. I drive canyon roads the same way I drive at the track and I want my cars as agile as possible. Even my 4,400lb Macan felt lighter on its feet just by swapping wheels. It certainly makes a difference on lighter 911s and 718s.
As for the obsession with weight reduction on street cars, I agree that it doesn't matter on pedestrian cars (I have a Jetta and an XQ80) but my sports cars, even my Macan Turbo DD, are driven hard. I drive canyon roads the same way I drive at the track and I want my cars as agile as possible. Even my 4,400lb Macan felt lighter on its feet just by swapping wheels. It certainly makes a difference on lighter 911s and 718s.
#22
Rennlist Member
My C2S allocation locks in about a week and I have my wheel options narrowed to the Carrera Classic and Carrera Exclusive. Can we say with certainty that the Exclusive is lighter than the Classics? The configurator says the Exclusives are forged, but do we know that the Classics are not?
#23
Rennlist Member
My C2S allocation locks in about a week and I have my wheel options narrowed to the Carrera Classic and Carrera Exclusive. Can we say with certainty that the Exclusive is lighter than the Classics? The configurator says the Exclusives are forged, but do we know that the Classics are not?
And yes, they will be lighter.
The following users liked this post:
CZS (04-17-2023)
#24
Rennlist Member
#26
Rennlist Member
With aftermarket you end up with two sets for about the same money as the OEM upgrade. Look up BC Forged.
The following 2 users liked this post by Wilder:
CZS (04-18-2023),
Master Deep (07-02-2023)
#27
Rennlist Member
#28
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Looks like we finally have some numbers thanks to @20C4S. Lighter than I had expected.
thank you both! My guess was off by 0.1 lbs. That goes to show you that if you search on RL enough you can deduce pretty accurately.
Last edited by Purekoryo; 07-02-2023 at 02:51 PM.
#29
Rennlist Member