Crazy good 911 S/T Review - Throttle House
#16
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Between rock and hard place
Posts: 3,639
Received 1,077 Likes
on
592 Posts
The following 3 users liked this post by cosmos:
#17
That's how I see it aswell, just wish they would've incorporated more RS body without the wing. Ducted fenders, carbon double bubble roof as they did with this, and maybe a touch bit more rear flare and boom it'd be more RS-esk...
The following users liked this post:
InfamousS/T (04-04-2024)
#18
This is the review I have been waiting for. They're truly nonbias and just call it how it is(one of the reasons they were low on the list for the press car). My take away from it was don't love it or hate it. Is it the greatest, no. Could it handle better yes. It's alot of parts thrown together which we knew. It's priced to a point where you'd expect a bit more.
The fact "this is what a base Carrera should be" says it all. Its simple, with a bloated price.
These guys are what most all of us are, Overgrown children that just want to have fun in cars. No brand loyalty, and bringing the Subi into the vid was a subtle chide at the price point.
As I have said before, its not the greatest. Not bashing, just repeating others hands on sentiments.
I'm truly shocked the made the steering sloppy. In a 911 of this size without the RWS and soft spring rate(which is obviously the electronic calibration equivalent to the 3rs turned all the way down on the **** and not actually bespoke), this will make it somewhat cumbersome in sharp curves.
Snappy steering to me is the heart of a sports car, take that away and it's just another car. A sports car is supposed to be harsh, rigid, exaggerated, and most of all untamed. The ST tries to blend cushy cruiser up front, race car in the back....
Awesome job Porsche, you created the Mullet of the luxury car world.
The ST is cool in concept, I won't ever have a need or desire to own one. Much as them. I don't love it, nor do I hate it as a machine. I hate how Porsche rolled it out to its customers.
The fact "this is what a base Carrera should be" says it all. Its simple, with a bloated price.
These guys are what most all of us are, Overgrown children that just want to have fun in cars. No brand loyalty, and bringing the Subi into the vid was a subtle chide at the price point.
As I have said before, its not the greatest. Not bashing, just repeating others hands on sentiments.
I'm truly shocked the made the steering sloppy. In a 911 of this size without the RWS and soft spring rate(which is obviously the electronic calibration equivalent to the 3rs turned all the way down on the **** and not actually bespoke), this will make it somewhat cumbersome in sharp curves.
Snappy steering to me is the heart of a sports car, take that away and it's just another car. A sports car is supposed to be harsh, rigid, exaggerated, and most of all untamed. The ST tries to blend cushy cruiser up front, race car in the back....
Awesome job Porsche, you created the Mullet of the luxury car world.
The ST is cool in concept, I won't ever have a need or desire to own one. Much as them. I don't love it, nor do I hate it as a machine. I hate how Porsche rolled it out to its customers.
You can make it more responsive and direct with a stiffer sidewall tire. You can also increase neg. camber and alter the toe to get a more direct feel. More than one way to skin a cat. It is not all in the springs and dampers.
#19
Drifting
This is the review I have been waiting for. They're truly nonbias and just call it how it is(one of the reasons they were low on the list for the press car). My take away from it was don't love it or hate it. Is it the greatest, no. Could it handle better yes. It's alot of parts thrown together which we knew. It's priced to a point where you'd expect a bit more.
The fact "this is what a base Carrera should be" says it all. Its simple, with a bloated price.
These guys are what most all of us are, Overgrown children that just want to have fun in cars. No brand loyalty, and bringing the Subi into the vid was a subtle chide at the price point.
As I have said before, its not the greatest. Not bashing, just repeating others hands on sentiments.
I'm truly shocked the made the steering sloppy. In a 911 of this size without the RWS and soft spring rate(which is obviously the electronic calibration equivalent to the 3rs turned all the way down on the **** and not actually bespoke), this will make it somewhat cumbersome in sharp curves.
Snappy steering to me is the heart of a sports car, take that away and it's just another car. A sports car is supposed to be harsh, rigid, exaggerated, and most of all untamed. The ST tries to blend cushy cruiser up front, race car in the back....
Awesome job Porsche, you created the Mullet of the luxury car world.
The ST is cool in concept, I won't ever have a need or desire to own one. Much as them. I don't love it, nor do I hate it as a machine. I hate how Porsche rolled it out to its customers.
The fact "this is what a base Carrera should be" says it all. Its simple, with a bloated price.
These guys are what most all of us are, Overgrown children that just want to have fun in cars. No brand loyalty, and bringing the Subi into the vid was a subtle chide at the price point.
As I have said before, its not the greatest. Not bashing, just repeating others hands on sentiments.
I'm truly shocked the made the steering sloppy. In a 911 of this size without the RWS and soft spring rate(which is obviously the electronic calibration equivalent to the 3rs turned all the way down on the **** and not actually bespoke), this will make it somewhat cumbersome in sharp curves.
Snappy steering to me is the heart of a sports car, take that away and it's just another car. A sports car is supposed to be harsh, rigid, exaggerated, and most of all untamed. The ST tries to blend cushy cruiser up front, race car in the back....
Awesome job Porsche, you created the Mullet of the luxury car world.
The ST is cool in concept, I won't ever have a need or desire to own one. Much as them. I don't love it, nor do I hate it as a machine. I hate how Porsche rolled it out to its customers.
Last edited by disden; 03-28-2024 at 12:18 AM.
The following 2 users liked this post by disden:
neoprufrok (03-30-2024),
PTS (03-28-2024)
#20
Drifting
Hyyyypppeeee.
Cool car, is it that much different from touring? 100lbs less hmm.
Cool car, is it that much different from touring? 100lbs less hmm.
#21
Interesting review.
Looking at the video, the ride height seems a bit taller than the regular GT3. The wheel gap appears slightly larger. This would make sense given the comments on the ride.
I do agree about the interior - a truly bespoke, radio delete, hardcore but expensively furnished ultra lightweight interior would have been amazing.
The choice to combine a LWFW with a more relaxed steering and handling design is an interesting contrast - seems the reviewers had trouble reconciling that.
It will be interesting to see what the alignment from factory looks like compared to the stock GT3. I went more negative camber, lowered and toed out the front end of my 991.2 Touring and it made a pretty significant difference/improvement.
Looking at the video, the ride height seems a bit taller than the regular GT3. The wheel gap appears slightly larger. This would make sense given the comments on the ride.
I do agree about the interior - a truly bespoke, radio delete, hardcore but expensively furnished ultra lightweight interior would have been amazing.
The choice to combine a LWFW with a more relaxed steering and handling design is an interesting contrast - seems the reviewers had trouble reconciling that.
It will be interesting to see what the alignment from factory looks like compared to the stock GT3. I went more negative camber, lowered and toed out the front end of my 991.2 Touring and it made a pretty significant difference/improvement.
Last edited by rk-d; 03-28-2024 at 12:46 AM.
The following users liked this post:
AlexCeres (03-31-2024)
#22
Intermediate
Very good production quality. They have been improving video-upon-video, and they are one of the few that are not stagnated like other channels such as Doug DeMuro or TheStraightPipes.
#23
Would love to drive one and compare to my Touring. Only way to know if its diff is to drive both. Wish I got the call for one, I would've traded my Touring in a second.
#24
it’s amazing how your bias toward hating a car you have never driven continues to shade your interpretation. His discussion about the S/T being a base model 911 is about what he WISHES a base 911 could be, meaning a lightweight stripped down bare bones car that is accessible for all to buy. A car that provides a pure emotional driving experience. Meaning he would love to have a cheap 911 made of carbon fiber body panels, Mag wheels, PCCBs, and a Motorsports derived engine paired with a single mass flywheel. Who wouldn’t want all that as a base model! Problem is all that stuff is expensive, and hence why the car is expensive. What makes me chuckle concerning your hatred however is that my S/T at MSRP is probably pretty much the same price as your recently ordered Touring which you paid a hefty ADM. Love it
Now the average ST in the US will be 1.75-2x MSRP plus lease. That's 600-650k all in. Will the value hold, likely yes after the end of the 12 months and greater for PTS. Then the actual market Value will speak which still to be 200k Over sticker if trends match the R... after 5+ years.
The Touring will have a sharper driving dynamic, and dare I say it some may regret going to the ST based on this past review.
At the end of the day factoring MSRP scale I'll maybe loose 30-40k within the first couple years then value will flatline and rebound as inflation creeps.
The best part, the Touring delivery got bumped ahead another 10 days yesterday. Meanwhile STs and my PTS 3RS are sitting in a perpetual flying hold pattern with month after month delays hitting.
I like Mullets yes, just not in the form of a 600k car.
#25
#26
Race Car
Would love to know what these 2 guys thought of the Carrera T.
#27
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
With the original 911, you could choose your line through a given corner. In the new RS, you have to concentrate to just keep it between the lines on some narrow roads (like they have in UK and parts of Europe, especially).
Last edited by GrantG; 03-28-2024 at 01:58 PM.
The following users liked this post:
dave2020 (03-28-2024)
#28
I don't think your math is mathing. You're a VIP? If so great! Otherwise, you're spending 70-80k over the ST minimum. Yes larger value after the first year, and assuming yours is PTS even greater. My Touring I have no shame in saying is 320k. 70k over and Ben literally sent me 2-3 texts tops and money well earned. I broke no sweat and made little to no efforts to secure the spot and honestly the ADM to me is literally less than what I received back in manufacturer rebates last year so oh well.
Now the average ST in the US will be 1.75-2x MSRP plus lease. That's 600-650k all in. Will the value hold, likely yes after the end of the 12 months and greater for PTS. Then the actual market Value will speak which still to be 200k Over sticker if trends match the R... after 5+ years.
The Touring will have a sharper driving dynamic, and dare I say it some may regret going to the ST based on this past review.
At the end of the day factoring MSRP scale I'll maybe loose 30-40k within the first couple years then value will flatline and rebound as inflation creeps.
The best part, the Touring delivery got bumped ahead another 10 days yesterday. Meanwhile STs and my PTS 3RS are sitting in a perpetual flying hold pattern with month after month delays hitting.
I like Mullets yes, just not in the form of a 600k car.
Now the average ST in the US will be 1.75-2x MSRP plus lease. That's 600-650k all in. Will the value hold, likely yes after the end of the 12 months and greater for PTS. Then the actual market Value will speak which still to be 200k Over sticker if trends match the R... after 5+ years.
The Touring will have a sharper driving dynamic, and dare I say it some may regret going to the ST based on this past review.
At the end of the day factoring MSRP scale I'll maybe loose 30-40k within the first couple years then value will flatline and rebound as inflation creeps.
The best part, the Touring delivery got bumped ahead another 10 days yesterday. Meanwhile STs and my PTS 3RS are sitting in a perpetual flying hold pattern with month after month delays hitting.
I like Mullets yes, just not in the form of a 600k car.
The following 2 users liked this post by PTS:
BlazinPond (03-29-2024),
EMdoc (03-28-2024)
#29
I am not a fan of his delivery style either, with all that high pitched sentences.
HOWEVER, outside of his video content, he is a really cool guy to listen to. I have not met him in person, but watching interviews and podcasts that he has done, he is easy to listen to and seems to be a pretty down to earth car guy.
#30
Drifting
I don't think your math is mathing. You're a VIP? If so great! Otherwise, you're spending 70-80k over the ST minimum. Yes larger value after the first year, and assuming yours is PTS even greater. My Touring I have no shame in saying is 320k. 70k over and Ben literally sent me 2-3 texts tops and money well earned. I broke no sweat and made little to no efforts to secure the spot and honestly the ADM to me is literally less than what I received back in manufacturer rebates last year so oh well.
Now the average ST in the US will be 1.75-2x MSRP plus lease. That's 600-650k all in. Will the value hold, likely yes after the end of the 12 months and greater for PTS. Then the actual market Value will speak which still to be 200k Over sticker if trends match the R... after 5+ years.
The Touring will have a sharper driving dynamic, and dare I say it some may regret going to the ST based on this past review.
At the end of the day factoring MSRP scale I'll maybe loose 30-40k within the first couple years then value will flatline and rebound as inflation creeps.
The best part, the Touring delivery got bumped ahead another 10 days yesterday. Meanwhile STs and my PTS 3RS are sitting in a perpetual flying hold pattern with month after month delays hitting.
I like Mullets yes, just not in the form of a 600k car.
Now the average ST in the US will be 1.75-2x MSRP plus lease. That's 600-650k all in. Will the value hold, likely yes after the end of the 12 months and greater for PTS. Then the actual market Value will speak which still to be 200k Over sticker if trends match the R... after 5+ years.
The Touring will have a sharper driving dynamic, and dare I say it some may regret going to the ST based on this past review.
At the end of the day factoring MSRP scale I'll maybe loose 30-40k within the first couple years then value will flatline and rebound as inflation creeps.
The best part, the Touring delivery got bumped ahead another 10 days yesterday. Meanwhile STs and my PTS 3RS are sitting in a perpetual flying hold pattern with month after month delays hitting.
I like Mullets yes, just not in the form of a 600k car.
Your continued trashing of the ST is now bordering on mental derangement. I know you have left the winged world and bought a Touring so you are a bit biased, but what makes you honestly believe people will regret selling their Touring for the S/T? Based upon what? Based upon your extensive seat time in both? Numerous reviews have directly compared the cars back to back and have universally stated that the S/T is 100% a more dynamic, emptional and frankly a better car. Nowhere is it mentioned the Touring is a bad car, quite the opposite. The end statement is always that the Touring is an amazing unbelievable car that anyone should be thrilled to own, but the S/T with the changes Porsche has made is simply better. It’s therefor up to the buyers to decide if the cost difference, especially when considering the ADM most people are being forced to pay, is worth it.
I would not be buying my S/T if an ADM was attached. Also, I would not be buying it if Porche didn’t make the changes in ride quality and steering input. I absolutely hated my 992 GT3 on the street, it was a jittery tramlining handful on any pavement that was not perfectly racetrack smooth. When I pick up my S/T in a few months I will honestly give my opinions of the car, whether I like it or not. But I won’t sit here and say it’s awful before driving it as that’s the epitome of being self serving and disingenuous.
The following 4 users liked this post by disden: