French article about 997.2 PSE and 991
#16
Race Director
#17
Instructor
Thread Starter
Just 60 hours left in Europe. I'm happy to get back to the p-car in FL, but sorry about leaving France, and its country roads, to be honest.
With regard to exhaust; the good news is that it seems that enough people care. While I recognize and appreciate all the good the 997.2 has to offer, sound feedback for the pilot just isn't up to par.
I'm going to drive my 997.2 CarreraS to a dealer and have an immediate test drive with a PSE equipped car to see if that's what I'm after.
No doubt Porsche wished they were able to deliver a better exhaust sound; sorry to say they dropped the ball at least with regard to North American standard.
The fact that they admit their Sport exhaust isn't much better than standard isn't satisfactory. When upwards of 100k are spent on a vehicle, the sound compromise should be left in the country (Switzerland) or continent (Euro) delivering these standards.
As for the rest of us US people; let us live up to Cali standards and then blast our ears off if US standards allow us to!!!
With regard to exhaust; the good news is that it seems that enough people care. While I recognize and appreciate all the good the 997.2 has to offer, sound feedback for the pilot just isn't up to par.
I'm going to drive my 997.2 CarreraS to a dealer and have an immediate test drive with a PSE equipped car to see if that's what I'm after.
No doubt Porsche wished they were able to deliver a better exhaust sound; sorry to say they dropped the ball at least with regard to North American standard.
The fact that they admit their Sport exhaust isn't much better than standard isn't satisfactory. When upwards of 100k are spent on a vehicle, the sound compromise should be left in the country (Switzerland) or continent (Euro) delivering these standards.
As for the rest of us US people; let us live up to Cali standards and then blast our ears off if US standards allow us to!!!
#18
Poseur
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
This is precisely why I prefer the 997.1 PSE over the 997.2 PSE--it's a far better sound. I'm hopeful Porsche can pull something off, despite environmental pressures to improve mileage and reduce the noise of the internal combustion engine.
#20
Have not heard the PSE in the 997.2 so can't really compare it to anything but I recently drove the Cayman R and the PSE on that sounded incredible. What a Porsche should sound like.
#21
Nordschleife Master
I drove both which made Tubi an easy choice. When they admit themselves to screwing up all 997.2 exhaust options, what's left to do but to throw out their mistakes and mount something that works?
#22
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Southern California
Posts: 1,429
Likes: 0
Received 15 Likes
on
15 Posts
Personally, I find my standard 997.2 exhaust has had a delightful sound ever since it opened up. If the PSE only adds ten db to the existing sound that would be fine by me. Anything more would require me to be forty years younger to tolerate it, let alone appreciate it. Does that mean your taste is "screwed up"? Or course not. They just built the exhaust on the dot two to satisfy my taste and the loudness regulations of umpteen countries. Your taste differs, but it isn't screwed up.
Is this documentation? Have we documented now that the aftermarket exhausts are a waste of money? Let's not be silly, and let's leave documentation-by-saying-it-six-times to phony news shows.
Gary
#23
Newbies Hospitality Director
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Winston-Salem, NC
Posts: 18,084
Likes: 0
Received 32 Likes
on
32 Posts
I believe the center muffler has a lot to do with the more muted exhaust sound, stock or PSE, on the 997.2.
If.... make that .... WHEN I get my 997.2, I will a) remove the center muffler and install the Sharkwerks by-pass pipes, and b) install PSE if the car does not already have them.
If.... make that .... WHEN I get my 997.2, I will a) remove the center muffler and install the Sharkwerks by-pass pipes, and b) install PSE if the car does not already have them.
#25
Three Wheelin'
And, if the lack of resonance really bothers anyone, Sharkwerks does a relatively inexpensive and nice job enhancing the GTS/997.2 PSE sound. I think that they have a video on their website (or maybe it was posted as a link here).
#26
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Southern California
Posts: 1,429
Likes: 0
Received 15 Likes
on
15 Posts
Gary
#27
Instructor
Thread Starter
o is it safe to say that I could theoretically install PSE on my 997.2 and if after doing so, I still wasn't happy with the sound, I could go with a Fabspeed or other x-over - center muffler by-pass system - and still retain the on/off option even once the center muffler delete option was chosen?
That would be ideal world for me: PSE on/off option but with a raspier "on" than standard PSE on switch.F
That would be ideal world for me: PSE on/off option but with a raspier "on" than standard PSE on switch.F
#28
Newbies Hospitality Director
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Winston-Salem, NC
Posts: 18,084
Likes: 0
Received 32 Likes
on
32 Posts
o is it safe to say that I could theoretically install PSE on my 997.2 and if after doing so, I still wasn't happy with the sound, I could go with a Fabspeed or other x-over - center muffler by-pass system - and still retain the on/off option even once the center muffler delete option was chosen?
That would be ideal world for me: PSE on/off option but with a raspier "on" than standard PSE on switch.F
That would be ideal world for me: PSE on/off option but with a raspier "on" than standard PSE on switch.F
Here is a link to a relatively new video & sound showing the Sharkwerks center muffler by-pass system on a GTS, with PSE switched ON and OFF. Go to the bottom of the page and click on the Aqua Blue GTS.
Sharkwerks by-pass system with PSE
#29
Race Director
In this context, Alex, I'd have to read that phrase as "a lot of yahoos have been saying it already." I'm afraid I'd have to agree with Mike and GSirm. How the devil would you 'document' that van Gogh screwed up "A Starry Night" because you don't like it? Find a bunch of people who prefer the ceiling of the Cistine Chapel? Or just say so a lot?
Personally, I find my standard 997.2 exhaust has had a delightful sound ever since it opened up. If the PSE only adds ten db to the existing sound that would be fine by me. Anything more would require me to be forty years younger to tolerate it, let alone appreciate it. Does that mean your taste is "screwed up"? Or course not. They just built the exhaust on the dot two to satisfy my taste and the loudness regulations of umpteen countries. Your taste differs, but it isn't screwed up.
Is this documentation? Have we documented now that the aftermarket exhausts are a waste of money? Let's not be silly, and let's leave documentation-by-saying-it-six-times to phony news shows.
Gary
Personally, I find my standard 997.2 exhaust has had a delightful sound ever since it opened up. If the PSE only adds ten db to the existing sound that would be fine by me. Anything more would require me to be forty years younger to tolerate it, let alone appreciate it. Does that mean your taste is "screwed up"? Or course not. They just built the exhaust on the dot two to satisfy my taste and the loudness regulations of umpteen countries. Your taste differs, but it isn't screwed up.
Is this documentation? Have we documented now that the aftermarket exhausts are a waste of money? Let's not be silly, and let's leave documentation-by-saying-it-six-times to phony news shows.
Gary
#30
Race Director
I just installed the Shark Werks center by-pass on my GTS.....the Sharwerks by pass is THE ONLY WAY to make PSE on the .2 cars sound really good.
I still like the Tubi system I had on my 2009 997.2 better. I will have the Tubi for sale soon when the dealer swaps it out of the stock exhaust on the 997 I traded in.....I have 1 possible buyer from another forum but never know if they will come through.... if anyone is interested let me know.
I still like the Tubi system I had on my 2009 997.2 better. I will have the Tubi for sale soon when the dealer swaps it out of the stock exhaust on the 997 I traded in.....I have 1 possible buyer from another forum but never know if they will come through.... if anyone is interested let me know.