View Poll Results: Should 911R owners be barred from immediate resale?
Yes: these cars were designed for enthusiasts and should be in the right hands
33
55.00%
No: these cars are simply investments and should be viewed as nothing more
27
45.00%
Voters: 60. You may not vote on this poll
Poll: Profiting off 911 R lack of availability: right or wrong?
#46
Somewhat OT: Just saw the 928 GTS avatar... Perfect example of an enthusiast's car. Plenty of cars out there for enthusiasts... Doesn't just have to be the latest and greatest hard-to-get model.
#47
Agree - but those hard to get models reflect the same thing going on with the new hard to get models.
Last edited by nuvolari612; 05-02-2017 at 08:49 AM.
#48
Guys, keeping production numbers low for a reason is nothing new. Study the brand Nike and you'll see why this is done on purpose.
Those that believe Porsche is only building 911R for enthusiasts is missing a huge part of why Porsche does what they do. Don't be fooled. If Porsche wanted these for enthusiasts only, they'd require folks to hold the cars for longer.
Those that double their money in a few weeks with any risky investment are taking a risk that many many other risk takers have lost lots of money on. Just because the car market is hot now doesn't mean that history hasn't proven to be ripe with MOST car purchases over time proving to be losses and not gains. Porsche's may have fared better, but many other brands have been dogs. People who flip real estate have, too, lost lots and lots of money. For every person that flips a house and doubles, there's someone of the other end that lost big time to create the situation that allowed the discount in the first place.
The problem, though, is that some folks just only care about money, and don't care if someone else suffers as long as they gain. But that argument is a tough one to sell to the general public when the item under discussion is a quarter million dollar Porsche. If it were food or water or gasoline in time of crisis, the argument might be different.
There was study about supply and demand in New York during massive flooding and power outages not that long ago where New York previously did not cap fuel prices, and gas stations were thought to be gouging customers with $33/gal pricing. People thought that was unfair, so the next time around, New York decided that capping gas at $5/gal was smart. The result was the some folks could afford to buy 50 gallons at $5/gal and re-sell on the open market at a much higher premium. And some gas stations ran out of fuel. Sometimes putting a cap on pricing due to supply/demand concerns backfires.
Those that believe Porsche is only building 911R for enthusiasts is missing a huge part of why Porsche does what they do. Don't be fooled. If Porsche wanted these for enthusiasts only, they'd require folks to hold the cars for longer.
Those that double their money in a few weeks with any risky investment are taking a risk that many many other risk takers have lost lots of money on. Just because the car market is hot now doesn't mean that history hasn't proven to be ripe with MOST car purchases over time proving to be losses and not gains. Porsche's may have fared better, but many other brands have been dogs. People who flip real estate have, too, lost lots and lots of money. For every person that flips a house and doubles, there's someone of the other end that lost big time to create the situation that allowed the discount in the first place.
The problem, though, is that some folks just only care about money, and don't care if someone else suffers as long as they gain. But that argument is a tough one to sell to the general public when the item under discussion is a quarter million dollar Porsche. If it were food or water or gasoline in time of crisis, the argument might be different.
There was study about supply and demand in New York during massive flooding and power outages not that long ago where New York previously did not cap fuel prices, and gas stations were thought to be gouging customers with $33/gal pricing. People thought that was unfair, so the next time around, New York decided that capping gas at $5/gal was smart. The result was the some folks could afford to buy 50 gallons at $5/gal and re-sell on the open market at a much higher premium. And some gas stations ran out of fuel. Sometimes putting a cap on pricing due to supply/demand concerns backfires.
#49
They do now (or are starting to) but they're still somewhat affordable and were really affordable just a few years ago, but nobody wanted them because they weren't cool. Plenty of room in some of these cars.
#50
It's just a shame that a great and coveted drivers car gets garaged because it's too valuable to drive. Boardwalk in dallas just sold a white with red stripe R $460k. A dealer friend of mine in Kansas sold the same white car with green stripe to a customer for $700k a month ago. The dealership owner sold the car for $700k.
#51
That is exactly what Porsche is doing, they are deciding how to sell "their" asset, in this case a 911 R. That does not make it a closed system, just what they believe is the best practice on how to run their business.
If they want to sell it to a customer who is on a VIP list, that they sold another asset to, who got VIP status with that purchase, in order to assure those assets all sold (918's in that case), then that is their prerogative, as it is "their" asset to sell. They invested the dollars to create the asset to sell and are free to sell it as they see fit, to best operate their business.
So get what you can and be happy with it and don't worry if you did not get a shot at at a 911 R or any other car. This is a free market and one of the things, like it or not, is those with the most capital get the best opportunities.
Last edited by supercup; 05-02-2017 at 01:47 PM.
#52
I feel very strongly that anyone ordering a small-batch, enthusiast-based car such as the 911R should, as a requirement for placing an order, be obligated to drive it and not sell it for above purchase price for 3 years. These cars are near and dear to many people's hearts, and yet they can't get their hands on one due to collector and investor stockpiling. Re-selling the car with only delivery miles should be forbidden, doing so should black-list that buyer from buying a Porsche within 5 years. These cars are built with enthusiasts in mind, no? If so, only enthusiasts should be allowed to purchase them new.
To suggest this is ridiculous.
#53
Exactly. Once I have the keys to my car you have no right to tell me what I can or cannot do with it. Park it. Race it. Cruise it. Flip it. It's none of your business.
#54
#59
If someone wants to invest in cars they better be able to withstand a few ups n downs - timing is luck and luck always runs out.
The R - who knows what Porsche small parts bin change car will be next I think people have lost it due to their ego for a second hand R which is fine but it's the ego that will bite one in the buttox. Older cars are much more stable everyone knows after a period of time if it's going to age well but these new cars going for multiples is what it is.
#60
I always tell my kids that life isn't fair.
Not part of the 918 VIP program but lucky enough to get offered cars.
Got offered R, not really the car I was looking for at the moment. If I would have accepted and flipped the car I can guarantee that I would have no chance of getting gt2rs.
Am I sure to get gt2rs? I would hope so. Always believed in doing the right thing.
If I get screwed over I get pissed off. Gives it straight to face. And move on.
Human greed is a bad thing. This hype in the market has attracted a lot of new people that I haven't met before.
One thing is for sure. As soon as the hype dies these people go look for the next thing.
Not part of the 918 VIP program but lucky enough to get offered cars.
Got offered R, not really the car I was looking for at the moment. If I would have accepted and flipped the car I can guarantee that I would have no chance of getting gt2rs.
Am I sure to get gt2rs? I would hope so. Always believed in doing the right thing.
If I get screwed over I get pissed off. Gives it straight to face. And move on.
Human greed is a bad thing. This hype in the market has attracted a lot of new people that I haven't met before.
One thing is for sure. As soon as the hype dies these people go look for the next thing.