Rear Pinch Bolts, check 'em.
#61
Rennlist Member
Thanks to Sean for again bringing this to the forefront. Many of us newer owners <4 years are aware of the front flex plate issue due to all the press on it. It seems that all the focus is on correcting that issue and I don't recall the rear bolt being addressed as serious. PPI does not mention it, or maybe I overlooked it.
I for one, replaced all my components with Constantine's products a couple of years ago. I also replaced the "rivets" with bolts in the rear plate as well and tightened the rear pinch to 80ft lbs. Overtighting a bolt probably contributes to bolt stretch and is more than likely just as bad as under tightening especially in this application.
Having C's components gave me a false sense of security so I have been lax on checking the front flex plate. ( did check 6 months after install and it was perfect).
Based on this post I am going to check EVERYTHING front and rear. PITA but worth it.
My question is what about the bolts that replaced the rivets. Any ideas on the possibility that they could loosen up. We are dealing with multiple bolts with lock washer and red lock tite.
Lon
I for one, replaced all my components with Constantine's products a couple of years ago. I also replaced the "rivets" with bolts in the rear plate as well and tightened the rear pinch to 80ft lbs. Overtighting a bolt probably contributes to bolt stretch and is more than likely just as bad as under tightening especially in this application.
Having C's components gave me a false sense of security so I have been lax on checking the front flex plate. ( did check 6 months after install and it was perfect).
Based on this post I am going to check EVERYTHING front and rear. PITA but worth it.
My question is what about the bolts that replaced the rivets. Any ideas on the possibility that they could loosen up. We are dealing with multiple bolts with lock washer and red lock tite.
Lon
Last edited by marine928; 06-20-2015 at 08:15 AM. Reason: more
#62
Rennlist Member
I for one, replaced all my components with Constantine's products a couple of years ago. I also replaced the "rivets" with bolts in the rear plate as well and tightened the rear pinch to 80ft lbs. Overtighting a bolt probably contributes to bolt stretch and is more than likely just as bad as under tightening especially in this application.
Lon
Lon
Overtorquing a bolt may not plastically deform it immediately but one has to be mindful of "creep" [cold deformation] that may be induced as a consequence.
Now that our cars are getting somewhat old highly stressed components are more likely to be vulnerable to this phenomena and some items more susceptible than others.
Rgds
Fred
#63
Rennlist Member
Dave, thank you. That's perfect, I'm pasting that verbatim into my ever-growing to-do list!
Here's an abbreviated summary ...
1. Remove the access plug and you can see the clamp.
2. Transmission in neutral and clutch depressed, will allow you to rotate the shaft to see/access the bolt head.
3. Loosen the bolt. Highly likely it will be difficult to rotate from pressure on the side of the shaft groove.
4. Remove the clutch lower bell housing cover, and pry the shaft back to align/centre the rear clamp/bolt, and then the rear bolt will easily come out.
5. Slide rear clamp out of the way and carefully check gearbox input shaft for cracks.
6. Align rear clamp, fit new bolt and torque to 66 ft/lbs.
7. Remove front clamp bolts.
8. Check alignment and location of front clamp, and that stub shaft is at correct position into pilot bearing.
9. Fit new front bolts and torque.
I agree with Bruce that loktite shouldn't be used on the bolt (post #43), as that would give you a false sense of security that it is still correctly torqued, if it stretches.
Here is the access plug on a 5 speed ...
1. Remove the access plug and you can see the clamp.
2. Transmission in neutral and clutch depressed, will allow you to rotate the shaft to see/access the bolt head.
3. Loosen the bolt. Highly likely it will be difficult to rotate from pressure on the side of the shaft groove.
4. Remove the clutch lower bell housing cover, and pry the shaft back to align/centre the rear clamp/bolt, and then the rear bolt will easily come out.
5. Slide rear clamp out of the way and carefully check gearbox input shaft for cracks.
6. Align rear clamp, fit new bolt and torque to 66 ft/lbs.
7. Remove front clamp bolts.
8. Check alignment and location of front clamp, and that stub shaft is at correct position into pilot bearing.
9. Fit new front bolts and torque.
I agree with Bruce that loktite shouldn't be used on the bolt (post #43), as that would give you a false sense of security that it is still correctly torqued, if it stretches.
Here is the access plug on a 5 speed ...
#65
Rennlist Member
Porsche advised me some 16 years ago to renew and over tighten the front bolt by 10% when we could not get the front clamp to hold- needless to say it did not work but the Loctite on the splines [not the bolt] did.
Presumably there is some mechanical margin in the bolt design but whether using that up is a good idea may be another thing altogether.
Rgds
Fred
#67
Roger does them [see his earlier post]. I think replacing this bolt every so often is a good policy. Remember that these things in most cases are still original and there is only one of them.
Porsche advised me some 16 years ago to renew and over tighten the front bolt by 10% when we could not get the front clamp to hold- needless to say it did not work but the Loctite on the splines [not the bolt] did.
Presumably there is some mechanical margin in the bolt design but whether using that up is a good idea may be another thing altogether.
Rgds
Fred
Porsche advised me some 16 years ago to renew and over tighten the front bolt by 10% when we could not get the front clamp to hold- needless to say it did not work but the Loctite on the splines [not the bolt] did.
Presumably there is some mechanical margin in the bolt design but whether using that up is a good idea may be another thing altogether.
Rgds
Fred
From memory, didn't Porsche also advise your mechanics to change out the front clamp/flexplate piece with a new one, besides the 10% over value of the torque for the front pinch bolt?
Cheers,
#68
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Gatineau, Québec, Canada
Posts: 5,194
Received 1,347 Likes
on
511 Posts
I'm sure it will be very use full in the future for anybody looking for some info on this subject.
Don't worry, Rennlist is the best place to post great info like this.
... Someone once told me I was an imbecile because I didn't want to pay 35$ for shipping for a t-shirt, so...
Keep up the good work my friend.
#69
Drifting
+1 re what Bertrand said. Sean, Stan, Greg, and a few others on here are the only ones who work on (many) 928s enough to observe failure trends first hand, and provide examples like this.
#70
Rennlist Member
I cannot remember the specific sequence of events but invariably they recommended changing everything.
When the drive shaft failed [1999] there were no signs of slippage at the flexplate but I suspect it had occurred and was the prime cause of failure- slippage- longer length- pressure on the flex plate- induced vibrations - leading to fatigue failure. One of their chumps actually had the audacity to tell me there was nothing wrong with the transmission design and that he could break such a shaft in 10 seconds! Well I suppose you could if you were an utter tw*t - but there again he was from L.....! I came very close to physical violence with him for implying it was my driving style that caused the problem.
We inspected the flex plate carefully for signs of damage- there were non and the same unit is still in service in my current driveline. With the new torque tube installled they could stop the clamp migrating along the shaft. Amazing how the parent company denied there was any problem but within 10 minutes of being approached for a solution Stuttgart came back with the replace the bolt and over torque by 10% solution- and that did not work either. I took Earl's Loctite 290 solution to them and it is still working for me today albeit second application after I lost the 90 S4.
Regards
Fred
#71
Racer
Sean,
Thank you for getting it all fixed up. I knew the risk something like this could pop up when I bought the car. I had no inkling of any problem until it broke. It is shifting better than it ever did now so I am happy.
Thank you for getting it all fixed up. I knew the risk something like this could pop up when I bought the car. I had no inkling of any problem until it broke. It is shifting better than it ever did now so I am happy.
#72
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
DO NOT! Check your rear pinch bolt!!!
No, no, no.
Call Roger, order it, and replace it then have it torqued to 10% over factory(or take it to Sean, hehe).
Mine was evaluated today and after 27 years, it only had ~20ft lb of torque left and it had stretched about .4-.6 mm. Just replace it darn thing. Pay $12 now, or $4000 later.
No, no, no.
Call Roger, order it, and replace it then have it torqued to 10% over factory(or take it to Sean, hehe).
Mine was evaluated today and after 27 years, it only had ~20ft lb of torque left and it had stretched about .4-.6 mm. Just replace it darn thing. Pay $12 now, or $4000 later.
#73
Rennlist Member
DO NOT! Check your rear pinch bolt!!!
No, no, no.
Call Roger, order it, and replace it then have it torqued to 10% over factory(or take it to Sean, hehe).
Mine was evaluated today and after 27 years, it only had ~20ft lb of torque left and it had stretched about .4-.6 mm. Just replace it darn thing. Pay $12 now, or $4000 later.
No, no, no.
Call Roger, order it, and replace it then have it torqued to 10% over factory(or take it to Sean, hehe).
Mine was evaluated today and after 27 years, it only had ~20ft lb of torque left and it had stretched about .4-.6 mm. Just replace it darn thing. Pay $12 now, or $4000 later.
I found all the old bolts that I referred to in an earlier post, and can confirm that measurement trends of those, back up my previous measurement of 0.45 mm extra length of old bolts compared to new ... which parallels what Doc reports.
Average of new bolts 54.60 mm ... old bolts 55.05 mm.
Is it stretch? ... as the old saying goes 'if it quacks like a duck, and waddles like a duck ... it's probably a duck'
Can you post a pic of the old bolt if you have it Doc? Anyone else have pics or measurements?
#74
Rennlist Member
DO NOT! Check your rear pinch bolt!!!
No, no, no.
Call Roger, order it, and replace it then have it torqued to 10% over factory(or take it to Sean, hehe).
Mine was evaluated today and after 27 years, it only had ~20ft lb of torque left and it had stretched about .4-.6 mm. Just replace it darn thing. Pay $12 now, or $4000 later.
No, no, no.
Call Roger, order it, and replace it then have it torqued to 10% over factory(or take it to Sean, hehe).
Mine was evaluated today and after 27 years, it only had ~20ft lb of torque left and it had stretched about .4-.6 mm. Just replace it darn thing. Pay $12 now, or $4000 later.
And thank you Sean for sharing this extreme failure example. Sorry I blew up.
#75
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
^^^ THIS!!
I found all the old bolts that I referred to in an earlier post, and can confirm that measurement trends of those, back up my previous measurement of 0.45 mm extra length of old bolts compared to new ... which parallels what Doc reports.
Average of new bolts 54.60 mm ... old bolts 55.05 mm.
Is it stretch? ... as the old saying goes 'if it quacks like a duck, and waddles like a duck ... it's probably a duck'
Can you post a pic of the old bolt if you have it Doc? Anyone else have pics or measurements?
I found all the old bolts that I referred to in an earlier post, and can confirm that measurement trends of those, back up my previous measurement of 0.45 mm extra length of old bolts compared to new ... which parallels what Doc reports.
Average of new bolts 54.60 mm ... old bolts 55.05 mm.
Is it stretch? ... as the old saying goes 'if it quacks like a duck, and waddles like a duck ... it's probably a duck'
Can you post a pic of the old bolt if you have it Doc? Anyone else have pics or measurements?
Man, get those things checked. I saw the bill from the last car that had a failure. Really cheap insurance here.