Is $1,000.00 too much for a '89 928 valve cover gasket replacement?
#16
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Get the car over to Dan Warner at Exotic Motorworks in Phoenix. He's 'the man' for 928 work in the Phoenix area, and one of the very few folks I'd just hand the keys and the credit card to for work like this.
The ugly reality on dealer services on the 928 is that they are so used to getting stuck with huge lists of other things that they either missed going in or broke coming out, that they just set the costs high enough to be sure that those 'aw $hit' things will be covered up front. Plus, they make their braed and butter dollars doing service and warranty work on relatively new cars. Dealers today just don't have 928-trained techs any more either.
Meanwhile, the WYAIT list includes new spark plugs, vent fittings, the cover gaskets, plug hole o-rings, the cam chain tensioner pads, the cam end plugs and the retrofit pins for the unused oil galleys, maybe new chains and the cam end seals. And if you need those seals camshaft drive-end seals, you are in for a TB replacement at minimum, since the front of the heads will be exposed and the gears will be off. If the covers have never been refinished, now's the time while they are off. The oil in the plug wells may have done a number on the plug ends/boots/wires. There's a LOT more to fixing a leaking cover than stuffing in a new gasket. Sean, are we anywhere near the $1k mark yet?
Again, get the car to Dan and get a real expert assessment. He may tell you it's OK to drive to Texas, so that SeanMeister can give it the full treatment.
Good luck with your new toy!
The ugly reality on dealer services on the 928 is that they are so used to getting stuck with huge lists of other things that they either missed going in or broke coming out, that they just set the costs high enough to be sure that those 'aw $hit' things will be covered up front. Plus, they make their braed and butter dollars doing service and warranty work on relatively new cars. Dealers today just don't have 928-trained techs any more either.
Meanwhile, the WYAIT list includes new spark plugs, vent fittings, the cover gaskets, plug hole o-rings, the cam chain tensioner pads, the cam end plugs and the retrofit pins for the unused oil galleys, maybe new chains and the cam end seals. And if you need those seals camshaft drive-end seals, you are in for a TB replacement at minimum, since the front of the heads will be exposed and the gears will be off. If the covers have never been refinished, now's the time while they are off. The oil in the plug wells may have done a number on the plug ends/boots/wires. There's a LOT more to fixing a leaking cover than stuffing in a new gasket. Sean, are we anywhere near the $1k mark yet?
Again, get the car to Dan and get a real expert assessment. He may tell you it's OK to drive to Texas, so that SeanMeister can give it the full treatment.
Good luck with your new toy!
#17
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Way too much. Gaskets cost what, $ 35 for two? That leaves $ 965. Recon labor $50/hour = 18 hours. It should be a few hours each. Then again, when problems arise, such as a broken cam bolt, the hours start adding up. Pick it up with leaking covers if they don't leak much, and bring it over to Sean.
As for parts, there will probably be some inessentials that could easily push parts cost to $100+ for the bill (retail).
As you pointed out, one broken bolt all bets are off (and those bolts are not cheap). The shop could easily be figuring in worst case scenario.
I'm not saying $1,000 for the job is a good deal. But before we start bashing a shop for something, need to take into account how much would you have to charge for a job while paying employees, making money on the parts, paying the light bill, insurance, property taxes etc...
It's easy for all of us to brag about how cheap these jobs are while doing it at a friends garage and drinking a beer. Most of us are not trying to put food on the table with this work.
Not picking on or directing this at you Adrian. Your post was just the easiest to spring-board off of
#19
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Gone. On the Open Road
Posts: 16,552
Received 1,680 Likes
on
1,090 Posts
A FULL set of rubber for both cam covers on an '87+ runs about $150-200 bucks IIRC. You've got 2 cam cover gaskets at $xx each, 26 pressure gaskets at $y each, 8 spark plug gaskets at $z each, four elbow/plug o-rings at $0.zz each. If I was doing the job I'd also put in a new Hall Sensor at $xxx. (Sorry, I don't have current pricing handy.)
It takes me about 8 hours from car in to car out to do a cam cover R&R and to do it thoroughly. About a hour less if I'm not doing prep or clean-up from powder coating (and I never not done powder coating). I could shave a couple of hours off of the job by not doing any cleaning, not checking the oil drain backs, bending some things and "forgetting" to re-install the lift loops and leaving a couple of other items loose. But, that ain't happening.
I wouldn't touch an S3 cam cover with the motor in the car.
It takes me about 8 hours from car in to car out to do a cam cover R&R and to do it thoroughly. About a hour less if I'm not doing prep or clean-up from powder coating (and I never not done powder coating). I could shave a couple of hours off of the job by not doing any cleaning, not checking the oil drain backs, bending some things and "forgetting" to re-install the lift loops and leaving a couple of other items loose. But, that ain't happening.
I wouldn't touch an S3 cam cover with the motor in the car.
#21
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Plug well oil is common. Just flush it out of there, and bring it back to Sean. There's a bunch of WYAIT things that need to be done at the same time. If you just get gaskets, you're wasting both time and money.
Clean out the plug wells and drive.
Clean out the plug wells and drive.
#22
AKA,
Have it shipped, which I assume your going to any way, once its here get it to Denton to Sean.
Im guessing money you would save having Sean do it, would offset most of shipping cost!
I live in Coppell also. Just sold my 84 last night, but am currently looking for an S4. Only one other 928 in Coppell that I know of.
Have it shipped, which I assume your going to any way, once its here get it to Denton to Sean.
Im guessing money you would save having Sean do it, would offset most of shipping cost!
I live in Coppell also. Just sold my 84 last night, but am currently looking for an S4. Only one other 928 in Coppell that I know of.
#23
Burning Brakes
Since you stated that the dealer is paying for it they may not want to take it any where other than their mechanic.
However if you can talk them into taking to Dan Warner at Exoctic Motorworks that would be ideal.
Not only would the work get done right but he could also look it over and prep it for the drive home.
However if you can talk them into taking to Dan Warner at Exoctic Motorworks that would be ideal.
Not only would the work get done right but he could also look it over and prep it for the drive home.
#24
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Alex just drive it home and stop being a whimp.
Best way to bond with the car.
Last one I brought home drank 5 gallons of oil in 1000miles.
Fuel was also spraying onto the exhaust manifold - it would have if the PO had not put a sheet of metal between the hose and the manifold.
I guess if they are paying thats fine but you will probably have to get Sean to do it all over again.
I envy your road trip.
Roger
Best way to bond with the car.
Last one I brought home drank 5 gallons of oil in 1000miles.
Fuel was also spraying onto the exhaust manifold - it would have if the PO had not put a sheet of metal between the hose and the manifold.
I guess if they are paying thats fine but you will probably have to get Sean to do it all over again.
I envy your road trip.
Roger
__________________
Does it have the "Do It Yourself" manual transmission, or the superior "Fully Equipped by Porsche" Automatic Transmission? George Layton March 2014
928 Owners are ".....a secret sect of quietly assured Porsche pragmatists who in near anonymity appreciate the prodigious, easy going prowess of the 928."
Does it have the "Do It Yourself" manual transmission, or the superior "Fully Equipped by Porsche" Automatic Transmission? George Layton March 2014
928 Owners are ".....a secret sect of quietly assured Porsche pragmatists who in near anonymity appreciate the prodigious, easy going prowess of the 928."
#25
This link is good except that it only starts at 1990 and is not for every repair
http://repairpal.com/estimator?checking_cookies=true
Just a guide the others have given better advice.
http://repairpal.com/estimator?checking_cookies=true
Just a guide the others have given better advice.
#27
Range Master
Pepsie Lite
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Pepsie Lite
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
dealers seem to know NOTHING about these cars........... absolutely NOTHING.
#28
And my gosh.....if I had a thousand to spend, I would get the car home, humbly beg the help of any rennlisters within mass transit distance to come over and help pull the intake tubes, breather hoses, injectors, spark plugs. Send the injectors out for refurb to WitchHunter, replace all the rubber components and apply new gaskets. Change the spark plug wires and check the distributor caps. If your thousand has change left over, then Criminy......send the MAF to Kevin at Injectionlabs for calibration. You should be ready to rock for under a thousand bucks.
#29
Nordschleife Master
Not surprising the dealer charges that! . I have done this job many times. Very easy to do. Thankfully I have never had a broken bolt yet. Rennlist is about helping others out, im sure theres someone close enough to give you a hand if need be otherwise I would take it to a local specialist. The Porsche dealer probably hasn't seen a 928 in years.. what do they know?
#30
Rest in Peace
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Bird lover in Sharpsburg
Posts: 9,903
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Not surprising the dealer charges that! . I have done this job many times. Very easy to do. Thankfully I have never had a broken bolt yet. Rennlist is about helping others out, im sure theres someone close enough to give you a hand if need be otherwise I would take it to a local specialist. The Porsche dealer probably hasn't seen a 928 in years.. what do they know?