Oil pan baffle archeological find: totally useless or answer to acillies heel?
#16
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: central cal
Posts: 975
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That is an injection-molded plastic part- I can't believe they would spend the big money on a mold and then not produce it.... but, plastic does not seem like it would survive long in the pan, the windage forces are very powerful. I have seen 1/8" thick stainless parts eventually break from fatigue in drysump pans, so the plastic may have not made it through durability testing.
Still it shows that the factory knew there were problem there...? Very interesting part!
Still it shows that the factory knew there were problem there...? Very interesting part!
#17
Rennlist Member
#19
Nordschleife Master
By broader solution, I mean actually attempting to condense the windage by separating/scraping it from the rotating crank, unlike the GTS one which just aims to keep more oil around the pickup and prevent the oil wave moving back along the pan due to acceleration.
Given the complexity difference, I have to wonder whether the later design was created as a cheaper solution, rather than as a more effective one?
Also - looking at it, I find myself wondering whether it may even work in addition to the GTS baffle? Looks like a fair bit of clearance under it, and as though there wouldn't be interference around the pickup.
Pic of the GTS baffle in my '89's sump attached to see what I mean.
Interesting that this implies Porsche must have been working on a crank scraper for the 928 sometime before the 1992 introduction of the GTS.
#20
Nordschleife Master
Just noticed - this baffle mounts to the six tap-able bosses on the rails that run longitudinally down the pan. Evidently they were thinking about the need for it when they made the pan casting?
#22
Not the sharpest tool in the shed
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
John, you must boat on very flat water, meaning, no waves. A beam wave (from the side) rocks a boat tremendously causing all liquiids on the boat to slosh mightily (fuel, oil, water, head waste, libation).
#23
Owns the Streets
Needs Camber
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Needs Camber
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Wonder what happens to the oil in the pan when the boat is at speed (high revs) and it slams repeatedly on the waves. I've never bothered to be holding onto any libations and just enjoy bouncing on the waves.
#24
Nordschleife Master
If they got as far as making a mold and didn't produce it then it may have failed in testing. That'd be a few bucks each to make after something like $20K to design and make the first one.
I was hoping that Kevin J. would give a technical opinion.
That "GTS" baffle is near worthless. Since it doesn't seal across the back it doesn't hold the oil in the pan. It does shield half of the surface from blowing air but that's not the problem. (IMO) It is very cheap to design, make and install. Had to be a factor in going with the "07" approach instead of "06."
I was hoping that Kevin J. would give a technical opinion.
That "GTS" baffle is near worthless. Since it doesn't seal across the back it doesn't hold the oil in the pan. It does shield half of the surface from blowing air but that's not the problem. (IMO) It is very cheap to design, make and install. Had to be a factor in going with the "07" approach instead of "06."
#25
Rennlist Member
This is an interesting development of the 928 motor, from the Porsche Museum thread. Note the very deep sump. That engine would have serious problems fitting between a 928 hoodline and the pavement...
It is, however, very interesting that the mounting bosses are in the pan, apparently from the earliest pans?
#26
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Thread Starter
Seems the baffle doesn't completely line up with the bosses, the lower left bolt goes through the pan.
#27
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Bosses are probably in all pans just due to casting reasons and they were just used for mounting this version. GTS baffle uses same mounting points as first screen version of oil pick up did.
#28
Aryan,
Were you able to ask the guy that bought it what his plans for it are, is he
going to make a coffee table decoration out of it or is he going to test it &
develop it ? Would he be willing to send it to the US so some of the experts
over here could see it and evaluate it. This piece is the rarest 928 archeological
find to come along in ages, it may be a totally usesless part or it might be the
answer to one of biggest acillies our motors have. I just hope he doesn't stuff
it away like the factory has been doing to us all these years, I hope he shares
the knowledge, good or bad..
Were you able to ask the guy that bought it what his plans for it are, is he
going to make a coffee table decoration out of it or is he going to test it &
develop it ? Would he be willing to send it to the US so some of the experts
over here could see it and evaluate it. This piece is the rarest 928 archeological
find to come along in ages, it may be a totally usesless part or it might be the
answer to one of biggest acillies our motors have. I just hope he doesn't stuff
it away like the factory has been doing to us all these years, I hope he shares
the knowledge, good or bad..
#29
Race Director
Much better pics of this baffle......but I wonder what it was designed to accomplish.....since the primary weakness of the 928 oil pan is the fact that it is wide and shallow....which increases the problems with the pickup getting uncovered in high G turns....and this baffle doesn't seem to control the deep part of the sump very much?
Here is a pic of an early pan with screen and plastic sump insert.....this is the setup I installed in the lemons racer...& it appears to have solved the problem....zero bearing wear-oil starvation in 6 hours on track....
Here is a pic of an early pan with screen and plastic sump insert.....this is the setup I installed in the lemons racer...& it appears to have solved the problem....zero bearing wear-oil starvation in 6 hours on track....
#30
Nordschleife Master
I'd like to see the back of the Porsche windage piece. What'd be cool is to have vanes that direct the swirling air forwards and along the floor of the pan.