Soft brake pedal fixed - Nicole, may be of help to you
#31
Under the Lift
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Yes, many people have done a lot of manipulations. It's been pressure bled a lot at 15 PSI, reverse bled at 20 PSI, pedal bled, bled while cracking the fittings at the master and ABS unit, bled while activating the ABS solenoids, bled with the calipers held up in the air and banged on to eliminate the last hump in the line and free any bubbles that might be trapped in the caliper bores, bled front brakes first many times. How it was bled right after the new master was installed is not clear to me.
#32
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I didn't realize, until I saw Jon's pictures of the MC internals in a separate thread, that the MC piston is actually two pieces.......
If there is a bleeder on the front of the master cylinder, and that should be the THIRD place you bleed if you are using the two-person method, first if you are using the power bleeder...
If there is a bleeder on the front of the master cylinder, and that should be the THIRD place you bleed if you are using the two-person method, first if you are using the power bleeder...
start off with the fronts, RF first, then LF. The order is important here only so you minimize the chance of getting old fluid back from the RF into the LF when done out of order. RHD cars should do this in the reverse order, so you go farthest of the two, then nearest. You are bleeding lines fed by the rear piston in the master cylinder..
proceed to the rears, again doing the farthest caliper first, then the closest. For US and other LHD cars, this would be RR then LR, based on the line routing to the rear brakes under the driver's position on the left side of the car. The RR brake line is slightly longer on LHD cars.
.
.
I'll take some more pics of the MC internals and post them here when I've got dressed (just got out of bed and been under the GT in my dressing gown already)
#33
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Jon--
Going by the instructions that came with the replacement MC of similar construction. The instructions came written from the mfr and verbally from the vendor. Apparently they get back too many 'defective' rebuilts if the bleed instructions aren't followed carefully.
Thanks for the correct details on the LHD. Didn't suspect that Porsche would plumb all the hydraulics across to the left fender, but I guess it was simpler/easier than tooling for ABS where the horns and electricl harness live there on the right. I've seen pictures of cars that are on the wrong side of the steering wheel, and Iwatched a guy work on a Fiat transmission once. Qualifies me as a master mechanic these days.
Going by the instructions that came with the replacement MC of similar construction. The instructions came written from the mfr and verbally from the vendor. Apparently they get back too many 'defective' rebuilts if the bleed instructions aren't followed carefully.
Thanks for the correct details on the LHD. Didn't suspect that Porsche would plumb all the hydraulics across to the left fender, but I guess it was simpler/easier than tooling for ABS where the horns and electricl harness live there on the right. I've seen pictures of cars that are on the wrong side of the steering wheel, and Iwatched a guy work on a Fiat transmission once. Qualifies me as a master mechanic these days.
#34
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Jon--
Going by the instructions that came with the replacement MC of similar construction. The instructions came written from the mfr and verbally from the vendor. Apparently they get back too many 'defective' rebuilts if the bleed instructions aren't followed carefully.
.
Going by the instructions that came with the replacement MC of similar construction. The instructions came written from the mfr and verbally from the vendor. Apparently they get back too many 'defective' rebuilts if the bleed instructions aren't followed carefully.
.
#35
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Some observations following rebuilding the brake MC and Clutch SC.
Bleeding order
MC, Clutch, RF, LF, RR, LR
Calipers - Inside bleeder 1st
Using pressure bleeder at 22psi starting pressure, (pressure comes from connection to tyre valve), bled approx 1.2L of fluid into and through the system (more than needed to get rid of the bubbles but was changing fluid to a diff colour)
After this stage I was reasonably certain that no air in the MC or in the pipework.
Left system pressurised for a day and half.
Did a quick bleed at all points again to check for bubbles - none. about 0.1 L of fluid.
Then did the "wife holding brake pedal down with both feet" open bleeder pedal drops to floor, hold it, close bleeder, let pedal up slowly - repeat, 3? times or until no bubbles method. System still pressurised at ~ 22psi.
On the RF inside caliper - 1st one to be bled - got bubbles out at 3rd, 4th ( lots), 5th (lots) 6th (few) 7th (no bubbles) repetitions. moved on to the remaining calipers but no bubbles of significance.
My thoughts - I just got the air out of the ABS unit. - I will repeat the procedure tommorow leaving the system pressurised in the interim.
Pedal engine not running seems harder/higher to operate.
Other observations - when doing the rear calipers by this method the brake pedal does not go as far down as it does doing the front calipers ????
Bleeding order
MC, Clutch, RF, LF, RR, LR
Calipers - Inside bleeder 1st
Using pressure bleeder at 22psi starting pressure, (pressure comes from connection to tyre valve), bled approx 1.2L of fluid into and through the system (more than needed to get rid of the bubbles but was changing fluid to a diff colour)
After this stage I was reasonably certain that no air in the MC or in the pipework.
Left system pressurised for a day and half.
Did a quick bleed at all points again to check for bubbles - none. about 0.1 L of fluid.
Then did the "wife holding brake pedal down with both feet" open bleeder pedal drops to floor, hold it, close bleeder, let pedal up slowly - repeat, 3? times or until no bubbles method. System still pressurised at ~ 22psi.
On the RF inside caliper - 1st one to be bled - got bubbles out at 3rd, 4th ( lots), 5th (lots) 6th (few) 7th (no bubbles) repetitions. moved on to the remaining calipers but no bubbles of significance.
My thoughts - I just got the air out of the ABS unit. - I will repeat the procedure tommorow leaving the system pressurised in the interim.
Pedal engine not running seems harder/higher to operate.
Other observations - when doing the rear calipers by this method the brake pedal does not go as far down as it does doing the front calipers ????
#36
Rennlist Member
22 psi on a 5-speed? Jon, you're braver than I am, unless you clamped the ends of the blue hose...
Interesting results, We didn't leave Nicole's pressurized that long, but we could. It's not good for the nerves, knowing that there is a risk of spewing brake fluid onto paint.
It will be very interesting to hear how yours feels on the road when you are done.
BTW, the reason the pedal doesn't go as far down when bleeding the rear is, the rear chamber on the MC(front brakes) is a larger bore than the front chamber, and there is a floating piston between the two which only moves via hydraulic pressure from the rear chamber(front brake circuit). When you bleed the fronts you empty that chamber to the end of the stroke. When you bleed the rear, you empty the smaller bore as the floating piston pushes forward, but because of the larger volume of the rear chamber it doesn't have to go as far to do so. There is a cross-section in the ABS tech doc that illustrates the layout pretty clearly.
Interesting results, We didn't leave Nicole's pressurized that long, but we could. It's not good for the nerves, knowing that there is a risk of spewing brake fluid onto paint.
It will be very interesting to hear how yours feels on the road when you are done.
BTW, the reason the pedal doesn't go as far down when bleeding the rear is, the rear chamber on the MC(front brakes) is a larger bore than the front chamber, and there is a floating piston between the two which only moves via hydraulic pressure from the rear chamber(front brake circuit). When you bleed the fronts you empty that chamber to the end of the stroke. When you bleed the rear, you empty the smaller bore as the floating piston pushes forward, but because of the larger volume of the rear chamber it doesn't have to go as far to do so. There is a cross-section in the ABS tech doc that illustrates the layout pretty clearly.
#37
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
22 psi on a 5-speed? Jon, you're braver than I am, unless you clamped the ends of the blue hose...
Interesting results, We didn't leave Nicole's pressurized that long, but we could. It's not good for the nerves, knowing that there is a risk of spewing brake fluid onto paint.
Interesting results, We didn't leave Nicole's pressurized that long, but we could. It's not good for the nerves, knowing that there is a risk of spewing brake fluid onto paint.
I have no idea if leaving it pressured up does any good - more just laziness not undoing it. Same reason for leaving it a day or so then having another go - PITA taking putting the wheels on and off etc. And I've got other jobs I need to like removing the upper A arms and putting bigger washers on the inboard end of the PU bushings - current ones are trying to work their way into the bushes.
The highest pressure I've used was about 36 psi on a car I bought very cheaply that had sat on the street for a few years and then in the pound for 5 or 6 years - only way to clean out the system - pressure it up then remove a bleed nipple completely - once it's squirting high in the air the system is clean.
#38
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: SC, USA
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
FWIW, when I finally got decent brakes from bleeding 2-person method, the car was on a slight inclined surface (maybe a couple of degrees) and had just come off of jack stands, meaning the nose was tilted up.
#39
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Update
I redid the hold the pedal down then crack the bleeder valves method yesterday and got a little more air out of the front right. Put the car back on it's wheels and went for a short test drive......
Pedal is still uninspiring (compared to my 88SE) but is about the same as where it was after the last fluid change two years ago. (When all the fluid in the system was emptied) With cold (air temp about 20C) tyres I can make the ABS work on a decent road surface - all 4 wheels , but the pedal travel is too soft and too long.
I was going to have a look at the pedal pushrod location to check if there was any preload but pulled muscles prevented the contortions neccessary to do this. However I do recall (from previously overhauling the pedal system to cure a squeaking clutch pedal) that the brake pedal doesn't have a physical "stop" other than the brake light switch which is adjustable. Which effectively means that you can set the brake pedal height then set the preload on the pushrod - doesn't seem right to me.
Not knowing if my cleaned up but no seals replaced M/C could be the cause of the problem I am going to buy a LHD M/C and convert the pipework to fit - (Can't justify the US $550 for a RHD M/C when a LHD is $125) to eliminate one possible issue. I will probably reverse bleed after installation to avoid blowing more air through the system as I will loose some fluid out of the lines from the MC to the ABS unit.
I redid the hold the pedal down then crack the bleeder valves method yesterday and got a little more air out of the front right. Put the car back on it's wheels and went for a short test drive......
Pedal is still uninspiring (compared to my 88SE) but is about the same as where it was after the last fluid change two years ago. (When all the fluid in the system was emptied) With cold (air temp about 20C) tyres I can make the ABS work on a decent road surface - all 4 wheels , but the pedal travel is too soft and too long.
I was going to have a look at the pedal pushrod location to check if there was any preload but pulled muscles prevented the contortions neccessary to do this. However I do recall (from previously overhauling the pedal system to cure a squeaking clutch pedal) that the brake pedal doesn't have a physical "stop" other than the brake light switch which is adjustable. Which effectively means that you can set the brake pedal height then set the preload on the pushrod - doesn't seem right to me.
Not knowing if my cleaned up but no seals replaced M/C could be the cause of the problem I am going to buy a LHD M/C and convert the pipework to fit - (Can't justify the US $550 for a RHD M/C when a LHD is $125) to eliminate one possible issue. I will probably reverse bleed after installation to avoid blowing more air through the system as I will loose some fluid out of the lines from the MC to the ABS unit.
#40
Cottage Industry Sponsor
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Thanks for the update!
Bill and I tried the bleeding with the front of the car lifted up, and we got a few bubbles on the right side where we had put the old caliper last time (to see, if it makes any difference - it didn't).
Bill and I tried the bleeding with the front of the car lifted up, and we got a few bubbles on the right side where we had put the old caliper last time (to see, if it makes any difference - it didn't).
#41
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Some more update observations
Back end of last week i did two complete rounds of reverse bleeding. Used my pressure bleeder but connected to the caliper using a short length of double flared 3/16th copper and an M10x1 Tube nut with the feed from the pressure bleeder on t'other end of the short length of copper. Removing the bleeder and installing the copper+tube nut doesn't risk air ingress as the gravity pushes fluid out of the caliper as soon as you remove the bleeder. Do have to wait about 5 minutes after connecting the pressure bleeder so that air in the feed line is pushed out before applying pressure.
Using about 25psi I reverse bled through about 1/3 litre of fluid per caliper and repeated (By now I'm reusing the fluid which has only been in the system a few weeks.)
It's really difficult by yourself to see if any air comes out of the MC. I'm using the cap normally used to pressurise the reservoir connected to my collection bottle so the air (if there was any) bubbles will only show in the reservoir not in any visible pipework.
I haven't driven the GT yet but the pedal feels a little firmer (but not like I want it) - just put it back on it's wheels - but I hope to be able to get it inspected tommorow am and re-registered as I'm on a flight back to the UK tomorrow pm for at the moment an indeterminate length of time.
Back end of last week i did two complete rounds of reverse bleeding. Used my pressure bleeder but connected to the caliper using a short length of double flared 3/16th copper and an M10x1 Tube nut with the feed from the pressure bleeder on t'other end of the short length of copper. Removing the bleeder and installing the copper+tube nut doesn't risk air ingress as the gravity pushes fluid out of the caliper as soon as you remove the bleeder. Do have to wait about 5 minutes after connecting the pressure bleeder so that air in the feed line is pushed out before applying pressure.
Using about 25psi I reverse bled through about 1/3 litre of fluid per caliper and repeated (By now I'm reusing the fluid which has only been in the system a few weeks.)
It's really difficult by yourself to see if any air comes out of the MC. I'm using the cap normally used to pressurise the reservoir connected to my collection bottle so the air (if there was any) bubbles will only show in the reservoir not in any visible pipework.
I haven't driven the GT yet but the pedal feels a little firmer (but not like I want it) - just put it back on it's wheels - but I hope to be able to get it inspected tommorow am and re-registered as I'm on a flight back to the UK tomorrow pm for at the moment an indeterminate length of time.
#42
Cottage Industry Sponsor
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Thanks for the update!
My car is still in the shop, getting a new brake bias valve now. I still hope that'll solve the issue; otherwise I won't take it to the Sharktoberfest.
My car is still in the shop, getting a new brake bias valve now. I still hope that'll solve the issue; otherwise I won't take it to the Sharktoberfest.
#43
Cottage Industry Sponsor
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Good news: I visited my baby at the RennShop tonight, and got to drive it up and down the street.
After a thorough inspection, Marvin had replaced the brake bias valve, and then vacuum bled the system (three times, starting at the master cylinder, but he said there was no significant bubbles the third time).
When I drove the car, the brakes felt totally transformed. While I still feel the pedal travel is rather long and the pressure point a bit soft, the brakes respond like never before.
I did not have to push very far to get a response, and it was possible to engage the ABS without crazy stomping on the pedal. Deceleration felt better than ever.
So, I am very optimistic now. We discussed the pedal feel, and since we had not kept track of the positions of the pads before we removed them for the initial rebuilt, there is still a possibility that the feel might firm up when the pads are bedded-in again.
We agreed that the car is safe to drive to Sharktoberfest, and that we should see, if actually driving it (what a concept!) will firm up the pedal feel a bit.
The other good news: The bill came-in under the estimate. Awesome!!!
After a thorough inspection, Marvin had replaced the brake bias valve, and then vacuum bled the system (three times, starting at the master cylinder, but he said there was no significant bubbles the third time).
When I drove the car, the brakes felt totally transformed. While I still feel the pedal travel is rather long and the pressure point a bit soft, the brakes respond like never before.
I did not have to push very far to get a response, and it was possible to engage the ABS without crazy stomping on the pedal. Deceleration felt better than ever.
So, I am very optimistic now. We discussed the pedal feel, and since we had not kept track of the positions of the pads before we removed them for the initial rebuilt, there is still a possibility that the feel might firm up when the pads are bedded-in again.
We agreed that the car is safe to drive to Sharktoberfest, and that we should see, if actually driving it (what a concept!) will firm up the pedal feel a bit.
The other good news: The bill came-in under the estimate. Awesome!!!
#44
Team Owner
Nicole,.............. Motor!
Thats great news, I hope the brakes work well, and you can start enjoying your car
Thats great news, I hope the brakes work well, and you can start enjoying your car
#45
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Excellent news Nicole. lets hope they improve even more when the pads bed in.
Did your mechanic think the bias valve was part of the problem ? or an unrelated issue ?
update on the GT - it passed it's rego inspection pulling 1.27G max decelleration in the brake test. but the tester commented that he didn't think the brakes were particularly inspiring - I agree.
When I get back to OZ whenever that is I'll have to try vacuum bleeding - I have a mity vac but it may be time to buy one of those air powered venturi vacuum pumps.
Did your mechanic think the bias valve was part of the problem ? or an unrelated issue ?
update on the GT - it passed it's rego inspection pulling 1.27G max decelleration in the brake test. but the tester commented that he didn't think the brakes were particularly inspiring - I agree.
When I get back to OZ whenever that is I'll have to try vacuum bleeding - I have a mity vac but it may be time to buy one of those air powered venturi vacuum pumps.