Water pumps - Porsche & General Motors - I'm missing something here
#46
Three Wheelin'
Originally Posted by Adam C
Sure Lag,
And look at a 15 year old corvette - everyone and their dog has one,
And look at a 15 year old corvette - everyone and their dog has one,
...their looks age prematurely
...and they are plentiful on the resale market.
A vette is still a vette and no matter what the performance is like, it will never have the allure of a Porsche. Plastic fantastic.
Do you mean to say that it'll never have the same allure of the discontinued and forever frowned-upon 'Porsche' 928? Are you saying that it won't have the allure of a car where in 18 years they only produced 60,000 units since sales were so ...lackluster?
Aren't you aware that within the 'PORSCHE' community, the 928 is pretty much laughed upon? So much for your 'allure'!
Since you appear to be someone who's hung up on owning a name, 'PORSCHE', unfortunately for you, the model you chosen is not too highly regarded outside of our small rabid community. To me, I like the 928 because it's a good car, and not because it happens to be a 'PORSCHE'.
And BTW - here in south orange county, I can see a handful of Z06s every day, and enough C5s to choke a horse. Hardly an exclusive club.
#47
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Gone. On the Open Road
Posts: 16,329
Received 1,543 Likes
on
1,007 Posts
Originally Posted by heinrich
Dave I know you're a truthful guy ... but please post the source of that quote. That is news to me and I make it my business to read everything I can on 911's and Porsche factory history.
Also, again if memory serves, the article described that when the execs walked into the factory fresh off the plane they saw parts shelves than ran all the way to the ceiling. The very first thing they did was order the parts shelves cut down to man-height. Inventory costs were out of control. The time spent hunting up and down the shelves for parts was wasted. And, by forcing more of a just-in-time inventory paradigm the Porsche folks had no choice but to begin a program of supplier and supply-chain management.
I have no doubt that you consume Porsche history. Your memory may be better than mine. So, if you remember any more tidbits I'd love to read them.
I have C&D and Autoweek back to about 1990. So, if someone can narrow down the dates I can pull the mag. But, I'm a bit too lazy right now to look through 20 years of mags. Actually, I'm not too lazy, but in a few minutes I'm going to go out to the garage and .... work on the '89 some more.
EDIT: I just searched through Autoweek's and C&D's sites. I didn't find the article on either site. However, neither site seems to have too much on-line content prior to 2000.
#48
928 Collector
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Lagavullin if your dog doesn't own a Corvette I wouldn't so blatantly publicise the fact ... shhhhh .... wouldn't want to fall behind the Joneses now
Note to all:
The928 is not laughed-at, scorned, frowned-on. Nowehere I can see. I *am* in the Porsche community. I am an active PCA member and spend a lot of time around other Porsche drivers and owners. I have done that since I was born, literally. 37 years. My fellow Porsche 944 and 911 and other owners have never laughed or scorned or otherwise. In fact, I keep getting very enthused comments from them. When I drive my 911 or the 944's, I have never heard a scornful comment aout the 928.
My dad drove 911's and 356's all his life. I don't think I ever remember him managing to outrun, or even try outrunning, a 928 back in the day .... the '70's and '80's and '90's. No chance.
The only people with a chip on their shoulder about 928's are .... 928 owners.
Note to all:
The928 is not laughed-at, scorned, frowned-on. Nowehere I can see. I *am* in the Porsche community. I am an active PCA member and spend a lot of time around other Porsche drivers and owners. I have done that since I was born, literally. 37 years. My fellow Porsche 944 and 911 and other owners have never laughed or scorned or otherwise. In fact, I keep getting very enthused comments from them. When I drive my 911 or the 944's, I have never heard a scornful comment aout the 928.
My dad drove 911's and 356's all his life. I don't think I ever remember him managing to outrun, or even try outrunning, a 928 back in the day .... the '70's and '80's and '90's. No chance.
The only people with a chip on their shoulder about 928's are .... 928 owners.
#49
Rennlist Member
Porsche uses the marketplace as engineering test bed for their technologys...if they perfromed half the testing I did on the Ford Escort, they would be out of business.
We strife tested that poor little Escort for almost a full year on every omponent...millions of cycles of testing, hours and hours or dyno testing, NVH, paint, etc. I ran the Ip program for that vehicle and had over 200 engineers and folks dedicated to the design, engineering and testing of just the IP. More than Porsche had on the whole 928 project!
Bottom line, the excort sold millions of units, went 0-60 in about a minute, get to about 90 in a day, and handled like a small truck. BUT, was reliable as salt.
The 928 sold 30000 units, goes form 0-60 quick, can top 170 mph at will, and can be raced against newer vehicles successfully. And it has support systems reliability issues...the core design is bullet proof....the details leave alot to be desired.
Porsche is small car company, and auto revenue is not its primary source of income....building cars is an "expression" first and a business second.
We strife tested that poor little Escort for almost a full year on every omponent...millions of cycles of testing, hours and hours or dyno testing, NVH, paint, etc. I ran the Ip program for that vehicle and had over 200 engineers and folks dedicated to the design, engineering and testing of just the IP. More than Porsche had on the whole 928 project!
Bottom line, the excort sold millions of units, went 0-60 in about a minute, get to about 90 in a day, and handled like a small truck. BUT, was reliable as salt.
The 928 sold 30000 units, goes form 0-60 quick, can top 170 mph at will, and can be raced against newer vehicles successfully. And it has support systems reliability issues...the core design is bullet proof....the details leave alot to be desired.
Porsche is small car company, and auto revenue is not its primary source of income....building cars is an "expression" first and a business second.
Last edited by Fastest928; 12-30-2004 at 03:02 PM.
#50
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by heinrich
The only people with a chip on their shoulder about 928's are .... 928 owners.
#51
928 Collector
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Hacker think about it. Maybe my experiences are different from yours, but have you ever heard others run the 928 down? Not me. Even some of the staunchest 951 racers I've encountered have been very respectful and impressed with the car as the excellent Porsche it is. Lagavullin, I was pulling your dog's leg
#53
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by Red UFO
The only time I ever see people talk down a 928 is because they are 911 snobs. Never see a 924/951 people throw them under the bus.
There have been a few journalists that bash the 928, usually the US mags, the European editors (and the top gear staff) love the 928.
Bottom line is the 928 could have and should have replaced the 911 back in 1977. Porsche showed how weak their marketing skills were on this one. IMO Mark Anderson continues to embarrass the Porsche factory who wouldn't take the 928 racing. I can only dream of what a 928GTS class car would be like (oh wait, Kelly Moss has one, just doesn't run it very often)
I stopped by K-Moss few months ago to check out the 944/928 race car. It was 3 shelves up on the back corner. Has not moved in a while. There was a red 928 convertible outside. I've been meaning to post pictures.
#54
928 Collector
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Well that's a whole different kind of scorn Hacker ..... those that so scorn are truly not qualified. Look at the greater Porsche community and there is no scorn. Only appreciation, or ignorance.
#55
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by heinrich
Note to all:
The928 is not laughed-at, scorned, frowned-on. Nowehere I can see. I *am* in the Porsche community. I am an active PCA member and spend a lot of time around other Porsche drivers and owners. I have done that since I was born, literally. 37 years. My fellow Porsche 944 and 911 and other owners have never laughed or scorned or otherwise. In fact, I keep getting very enthused comments from them. When I drive my 911 or the 944's, I have never heard a scornful comment aout the 928.
The928 is not laughed-at, scorned, frowned-on. Nowehere I can see. I *am* in the Porsche community. I am an active PCA member and spend a lot of time around other Porsche drivers and owners. I have done that since I was born, literally. 37 years. My fellow Porsche 944 and 911 and other owners have never laughed or scorned or otherwise. In fact, I keep getting very enthused comments from them. When I drive my 911 or the 944's, I have never heard a scornful comment aout the 928.
#56
Three Wheelin'
Originally Posted by worf928
However, on the road - these Roads in Yankee Land - the suspension does not inspire confidence. Drop down to 2nd or 3rd on the highway, punch it, and get ready for a handful. The transient squat in that situation unweights the front, the tires grab the ruts, and it's like being strapped to the nose-cone of a poorly controlled rocket. The motor in that car is too much for the chassis.
I really learned alot about the car when I went to Road America for the first time with a healthy car last October, and was timed at 2:52 completely stock including the tires. That is by far the most fun I've had outdoors, and I can't wait to go back in the spring! Since the track day, the car isn't nearly as fun to drive on the street anymore since one can only use 5% of it's potential compared to running it wide open on the track and sligning it through corners at high speed.
And don't even get me started on the seats...
I'll be addressing the driver seating this winter, as well as put an engine oil and tranny coolers on the car.
Originally Posted by heinrich
Lagavullin, I was pulling your dog's leg
#57
Originally Posted by SharkSkin
When I went on the NorCal Pizza Run right after Thanksgiving.... mostly 4 cylinder watercoolers... I heard nothing but compliments about my shark, as well as Ron and Nicole's. The other Porsche events I've been to have been about the 928, so no fair bringing all of those kind words into it. We shark owners are prejudiced, no doubt about it... but I love that about us.
Perhaps they are leasing the badge but not in love with the company.
Sure you'll have a few 951 turbo junkies that like to raz the 928 but they still respect it, they're just talking shIIt. To me the 911 people really mean it at heart that our cars are crap and it shows by them. I think the only ones to like the 928. Are in fact 928 owners who also own a 911.
#58
Water pumps are a metal plate, a metal or plastic (ugh) impellar, a pully, a shaft, bearing and seal. Leaking is no concern of mine - thats not a problem nearly as much as a stoppage of some sort that could affect the cams.