Crosspost -- a peitition for a very worthy man
#31
Jane Bond 007
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by fty
...uhh liberals are ruining this country...
...uhh liberals are ruining this country...
![Roll Eyes (Sarcastic)](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/rolleyes.gif)
Last edited by MichelleJD; 11-20-2003 at 05:08 PM.
#32
Addict
Rennlist
Lifetime Member
Rennlist
Lifetime Member
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Some people try to sound educated in saying that the "ends don't justify the means" -- you are wrong. It is my contention that if you can honestly say that you would not have done the exact same thing giving the events that unfolded, that you are UN-AMERICAN and do not deserve to set foot on this country. If you would truly lose your soldiers to protect the short term hearing of some scumbag prisoner who would at any given chance kill you and your men? But after you make that decision, I wonder if you would be man enough or philosophical enough to tell those soldiers family and friends that you had a chance to prevent their death, but didn't.
That is how I determine this to be just and right. I would at least hope I would have the courage to do what the Col. did, and anyone who says they wouldn't I believe is no better then the Iraqi who Col. West scared.
That is how I determine this to be just and right. I would at least hope I would have the courage to do what the Col. did, and anyone who says they wouldn't I believe is no better then the Iraqi who Col. West scared.
#33
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 919
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by Matt Olde
But after you make that decision, I wonder if you would be man enough or philosophical enough to tell those soldiers family and friends that you had a chance to prevent their death, but didn't.
But after you make that decision, I wonder if you would be man enough or philosophical enough to tell those soldiers family and friends that you had a chance to prevent their death, but didn't.
#34
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I think the question comes down to would he have gone further if the prisoner hadn't **** himself then? Would he have used more physical methods to get the information he needed? I think that him firing the gun was a 'bluff' and the prisoner bought it. I honestly don't see the harm in that, firing a gun near the guy.
Now if he had shot him in the foot or something, then that would be a whole different story. But I think that what he did caused no harm to anyone, and saved the lives of American soldiers.
Although I am going to have to agree with michelle on the "liberals are ruining the country." Come on, that's like saying Bush ruined the economy when he stepped into office. Naive and ignorant. Who knows how long ago these rules were even written.
Now if he had shot him in the foot or something, then that would be a whole different story. But I think that what he did caused no harm to anyone, and saved the lives of American soldiers.
Although I am going to have to agree with michelle on the "liberals are ruining the country." Come on, that's like saying Bush ruined the economy when he stepped into office. Naive and ignorant. Who knows how long ago these rules were even written.
#35
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Schenectady, NY
Posts: 1,567
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by ahofam123
I personally feel that saving the lives of a group of soldiers is of much greater importance than the temporary hearing loss of another soldier.
I personally feel that saving the lives of a group of soldiers is of much greater importance than the temporary hearing loss of another soldier.
#36
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
My credentials to speak my mind on this: I spent just shy of 10 years in the Army. I was an enlisted man, a non-commissioned officer, and then a commissioned officer. I served in combat arms and in support roles. I served in conventional units and in special operations. I got out only after sustaining an injury that was not consistent with continued military service.
That being said...if this guy was a career, field-grade officer, which he was, he should have been smarter than that. You can't have ***** or do what is truly morally right and/or logical in many situations in today's millitary. Should he have used whatever methods were needed to get the info? Sure. Can you do that in today's military? Hell no.
So this situation should be no surprise to anyone who knows how business is conducted in today's military - but, unfortunately, most don't. I do. But, please don't get me started....
YMMV Al
That being said...if this guy was a career, field-grade officer, which he was, he should have been smarter than that. You can't have ***** or do what is truly morally right and/or logical in many situations in today's millitary. Should he have used whatever methods were needed to get the info? Sure. Can you do that in today's military? Hell no.
So this situation should be no surprise to anyone who knows how business is conducted in today's military - but, unfortunately, most don't. I do. But, please don't get me started....
YMMV Al
#37
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by 91S2
My credentials to speak my mind on this: I spent just shy of 10 years in the Army. I was an enlisted man, a non-commissioned officer, and then a commissioned officer. I served in combat arms and in support roles. I served in conventional units and in special operations. I got out only after sustaining an injury that was not consistent with continued military service.
That being said...if this guy was a career, field-grade officer, which he was, he should have been smarter than that. You can't have ***** or do what is truly morally right and/or logical in many situations in today's millitary. Should he have used whatever methods were needed to get the info? Sure. Can you do that in today's military? Hell no.
So this situation should be no surprise to anyone who knows how business is conducted in today's military - but, unfortunately, most don't. I do. But, please don't get me started....
YMMV Al
My credentials to speak my mind on this: I spent just shy of 10 years in the Army. I was an enlisted man, a non-commissioned officer, and then a commissioned officer. I served in combat arms and in support roles. I served in conventional units and in special operations. I got out only after sustaining an injury that was not consistent with continued military service.
That being said...if this guy was a career, field-grade officer, which he was, he should have been smarter than that. You can't have ***** or do what is truly morally right and/or logical in many situations in today's millitary. Should he have used whatever methods were needed to get the info? Sure. Can you do that in today's military? Hell no.
So this situation should be no surprise to anyone who knows how business is conducted in today's military - but, unfortunately, most don't. I do. But, please don't get me started....
YMMV Al
The Army has always been infested with bureaucrats. No surprise, as military action is an extension of politics, that politics extends throughout the military. Genuine warfighters have always clashed with pencil-necked paper pushers, and LTC West had to have known he was setting himself up for problems with the geeks. Careerism in the Army is sickening, if you've ever experienced it firsthand. Oop, sorry, was about to rant....
I emailed my congressional reps a couple weeks ago when I first heard about it. From my understanding, an upstanding officer is about to get shafted, and I just wanted my elected reps to understand I feel that it sucks. (I did get a response from one of the staffers, so I know SOMEBODY read it)
#38
Race Car
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I am torn on this issue. In the situation, I would have done the same to save the butts of my own men. However what if the colonel shooting a bullet was Iraqi and the victim was an American? The American soldier talks in fear of his life and gives away our troop position and they kill more of our troops.
In the same situation, I probably would have even tortured the guy to get information but I guess I would accept the punishment that comes with my actions. The scary thing is, at what point is it not acceptable? What if it takes taking a knife to skin somebody to make them talk?
In the same situation, I probably would have even tortured the guy to get information but I guess I would accept the punishment that comes with my actions. The scary thing is, at what point is it not acceptable? What if it takes taking a knife to skin somebody to make them talk?
#39
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
"[The enemy detainee] and his accomplices were a threat to our soldiers and the method was not right, but why should I...be forced into prison for protecting my men?," Col. West asks. Patriot Petitions poses the same question: How can we expect our frontline officers to fight wars the Bush administration calls "preemptive" if they are not given the latitude to respond -- preemptively -- to the asymmetric threats of terrorist aggressors
Signed as well! Bush and his lame-*** cronies need to wake the f%#k-up! Col.West is a hero, plain and simple, regardless of his tactics, he did what was called for at that time! Every American should sign and support Col. West's situation!
How the hell can we even consider prison time for a man who willingly risked his life for our country??? WTF?????
Signed as well! Bush and his lame-*** cronies need to wake the f%#k-up! Col.West is a hero, plain and simple, regardless of his tactics, he did what was called for at that time! Every American should sign and support Col. West's situation!
How the hell can we even consider prison time for a man who willingly risked his life for our country??? WTF?????
#40
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by jsonnen
[BBush and his lame-*** cronies need to wake the f%#k-up! Col.West is a hero, plain and simple, regardless of his tactics, he did what was called for at that time! Every American should sign and support Col. West's situation!
How the hell can we even consider prison time for a man who willingly risked his life for our country??? WTF????? [/B]
[BBush and his lame-*** cronies need to wake the f%#k-up! Col.West is a hero, plain and simple, regardless of his tactics, he did what was called for at that time! Every American should sign and support Col. West's situation!
How the hell can we even consider prison time for a man who willingly risked his life for our country??? WTF????? [/B]
So, Bush only has so much political capital he can spend. Shoot, his approval ratings would still be at 75% if he just did the "I feel your pain" thing instead of taking action.
I am sure that public pressure will do some good in this case.
#41
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Originally posted by 89magic98
So, Bush only has so much political capital he can spend. Shoot, his approval ratings would still be at 75% if he just did the "I feel your pain" thing instead of taking action.
.
So, Bush only has so much political capital he can spend. Shoot, his approval ratings would still be at 75% if he just did the "I feel your pain" thing instead of taking action.
.
11/4/2003 — Exonerate Lt. Col. Allen B. West from Criminal Prosecution
Signers: 116256
To President George Bush, Speaker of the House Dennis Hastert, Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, and acting Secretary of the Army Secretary Les Brownlee
Petition Text:
To President George Bush, Speaker of the House Dennis Hastert, Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, and acting Secretary of the Army Secretary Les Brownlee
#42
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I mean to say, he spent a lot of so-called "policital capital" getting us involved in Iraq. He's getting hammered in the press all the time. But I think that, right or wrong, I would rather have a president try to do something rather than the "I feel your pain" hand-wringing.
I think this means that he needs to tell some underling to make it go away (resolve the issue in Lt.Col. West's favor), rather than say anything officially about it itself. He could act on this privately himself. I wouldn't expect him to have a press conference about this in public. In front of the media, he needs to appear to be only working on the "big-picture" stuff.
I think this means that he needs to tell some underling to make it go away (resolve the issue in Lt.Col. West's favor), rather than say anything officially about it itself. He could act on this privately himself. I wouldn't expect him to have a press conference about this in public. In front of the media, he needs to appear to be only working on the "big-picture" stuff.