do we really need tensioning tool
#1
Instructor
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2002
Location: geordie in spain
Posts: 145
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
do we really need tensioning tool
I have done many major rebuilds on lot of different types of engine and have lost count of how many belts I have changed and havent lost one yet. I recently rebelted my newly aquired 944,without any form of tensioner.During my brain picking expeditions on this great forum I discovered on a couple of occasions that people had used this fancy porsche tool and discovered the belts to be making undue whining ie over adjusted, so they had knocked back adjustment,till the whining stopped.In which case tool was pointless. What I did was used the 90 deg twist method to get an initial adjustment( I think it would take a lot more than a small twist to damage fibres in the belt) and as it happened the belt appeared a little tight ie whining I backed off the adjustment a little and it cured the problem, this procedure is similar to using the tool and ignoring the result! if you understand what i mean. I dont think there is any difference between porsche belt adjustment and say honda legend v6, jensen healey lotus twin cam engine, celica twin cams, honda accord twin cams, To name but a few that have been under my spanners. I think it is true to say that experience gives you a certain feel for these sort of things but everything has to be learned!! hope this helps Steve Elliott
#2
Instructor
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: San Diego, CA
Posts: 225
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Sounds like your touch is good, as well as your mechanical intuition.
However, gambling with belt tension, especially on motors that can strike and break valves with a snapped belt, is risky, in my opinion.
Additionally, slightly over-tensioned belts can lead to premature wearing of the roller and tensioner bearings, and water pump bearings (but, you knew that). With only one bearing set in the water pump, overtensioned belts can lead to a blown/frozen water pump (as happened to me by a mechanic who "didn't think he needed to use that silly gauge"), and a complete replacement of belts, rollers, tensioners, seals, water pump. (And, he wanted to charge me for the job!)
So, how's your skill at blackjack, roullett, and craps? It's your gamble and your money. ;-) Personally, I'll use the tool.
My 2 pesos. <img src="graemlins/beerchug.gif" border="0" alt="[cheers]" />
However, gambling with belt tension, especially on motors that can strike and break valves with a snapped belt, is risky, in my opinion.
Additionally, slightly over-tensioned belts can lead to premature wearing of the roller and tensioner bearings, and water pump bearings (but, you knew that). With only one bearing set in the water pump, overtensioned belts can lead to a blown/frozen water pump (as happened to me by a mechanic who "didn't think he needed to use that silly gauge"), and a complete replacement of belts, rollers, tensioners, seals, water pump. (And, he wanted to charge me for the job!)
So, how's your skill at blackjack, roullett, and craps? It's your gamble and your money. ;-) Personally, I'll use the tool.
My 2 pesos. <img src="graemlins/beerchug.gif" border="0" alt="[cheers]" />
#3
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Posts: 1,199
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
1 Post
I'm trying to figure out a safe way to do this without the special tool, I don't think it's needed either however I would like to use some reference point to determine belt tension. It may require me renting the tool from toolmaster and measuring belt deflection.
#6
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
On the 16 valve cars the balance belt still needs to be tensioned.
The Auto tensioner does not adjust itself, it has to be loosened and re-tightened while the engine is at TDC. Also I have heard that the automatic tensioner is not always accurate.
About an alternative tool, check out this past thread:
<a href="http://forums.rennlist.com/cgi-bin/rennforums/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=15&t=005248&p=" target="_blank">Cricket Belt Tension Tool ( anyone used it?)</a>
The Auto tensioner does not adjust itself, it has to be loosened and re-tightened while the engine is at TDC. Also I have heard that the automatic tensioner is not always accurate.
About an alternative tool, check out this past thread:
<a href="http://forums.rennlist.com/cgi-bin/rennforums/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=15&t=005248&p=" target="_blank">Cricket Belt Tension Tool ( anyone used it?)</a>
#7
Instructor
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2002
Location: geordie in spain
Posts: 145
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Didnt mean to get anyones back up, If you read and understood my post what I was saying was that I have worked on many high tech engines (see above) and dont see why this tool is neccessary in this case !!
Trending Topics
#8
I am not all that certain that it is absolutely necessary but it is NOT one of those things I would personally like to risk. $400 for the tool versus $5000 for a new head??? I'd spend the money on the tool. You can even rent the damned things. I would not trust an "auto" tensioner with a 15-20 year old design. Even with the 16 valvers I would set the tension of both belts using the tool.
As always YMMV. Do whatever you think is best for you but if Porsche says use the tool that is good enough for me. Since I have never designed my own sports car I will default to the engineers that have and use the tool.
Max
As always YMMV. Do whatever you think is best for you but if Porsche says use the tool that is good enough for me. Since I have never designed my own sports car I will default to the engineers that have and use the tool.
Max
#9
I agree with muso58 that a belt is a belt (made by gates in most cases). The caveat here is that the 944 is an all aluminum engine as are some of the others that he mentions. This adds an extra thermal expansion issue that makes belt tension more important.
I did mine by feel, and have no idea if it is right, but I have around 3k on it with no problems. It does seem awfully tight when hot, though...
A friend recently told me about a tool that measures the torque required to twist the belt. I guess it is simpler that the porsche tool. He used it on his 928.
Art
I did mine by feel, and have no idea if it is right, but I have around 3k on it with no problems. It does seem awfully tight when hot, though...
A friend recently told me about a tool that measures the torque required to twist the belt. I guess it is simpler that the porsche tool. He used it on his 928.
Art
#10
I agree with muso58 that a belt is a belt (made by gates in most cases). The caveat here is that the 944 is an all aluminum engine as are some of the others that he mentions. This adds an extra thermal expansion issue that makes belt tension more important.
I did mine by feel, and have no idea if it is right, but I have around 3k on it with no problems. It does seem awfully tight when hot, though...
A friend recently told me about a tool that measures the torque required to twist the belt. I guess it is simpler that the porsche tool. He used it on his 928.
Art
I did mine by feel, and have no idea if it is right, but I have around 3k on it with no problems. It does seem awfully tight when hot, though...
A friend recently told me about a tool that measures the torque required to twist the belt. I guess it is simpler that the porsche tool. He used it on his 928.
Art
#11
Instructor
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Southern California
Posts: 184
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I used the kricket tool on my $500 944 and it works fine so far.
I do get the whining noise, but I've also heard that noise on 2 other 944's tensioned by mechanics with factory tools.
The whinning noise always goes away.
Is it bad to have that noise? Anyone who really knows?
I do get the whining noise, but I've also heard that noise on 2 other 944's tensioned by mechanics with factory tools.
The whinning noise always goes away.
Is it bad to have that noise? Anyone who really knows?
#12
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I tensioned my 84 944 by hand twice, and put a total of around 30k on it with 'my tension' on the belts. It was on the loose side, lasted fine.
I just did the belts on my turbo, due to another leak the belts only have 10 miles on them, we shall see what it does.
Whine is normal when the belt is (intentionally) a little over tight for breaking in the belt. After 2k miles the noise should subdue, but if not it is due for an adjustment anyway.
Ahmet
I just did the belts on my turbo, due to another leak the belts only have 10 miles on them, we shall see what it does.
Whine is normal when the belt is (intentionally) a little over tight for breaking in the belt. After 2k miles the noise should subdue, but if not it is due for an adjustment anyway.
Ahmet
#13
Instructor
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Southern California
Posts: 184
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
ok, I guess I should loosen it.
I notice that the car heats up when it comes to an idle somtimes, but if I rev the engine and get more water going through it then it cools down.
Could this be because of not enough tension on the belt at the point of the water pump pulley?
I notice that the car heats up when it comes to an idle somtimes, but if I rev the engine and get more water going through it then it cools down.
Could this be because of not enough tension on the belt at the point of the water pump pulley?
#14
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: CT, USA
Posts: 1,440
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i have an S
i just got the belts/pump/rollers/seals done 2k miles ago and my mech did the tension by "feel" and it hasnt exploded yet
i guess ill be going in for that 2k retension soon eh?
i just got the belts/pump/rollers/seals done 2k miles ago and my mech did the tension by "feel" and it hasnt exploded yet
i guess ill be going in for that 2k retension soon eh?
#15
Jordan:
It may be just the nature of the beast. All water cooled VWs do the somewhat the same thing...230 degrees in traffic, down to 200-205 at speed. Your revving of the engine does increase the flow of the coolant which is half the added cooling (in addition to the forward motion at speed). Of course, if the problem is severe enough, this could also indicate a failing water pump (someone here had one with a loose impeller..don't remember who). At what point do your cooling fans cut in? (where on the gauge?) Should be between the second and third mark.
Good luck
Bob S.
It may be just the nature of the beast. All water cooled VWs do the somewhat the same thing...230 degrees in traffic, down to 200-205 at speed. Your revving of the engine does increase the flow of the coolant which is half the added cooling (in addition to the forward motion at speed). Of course, if the problem is severe enough, this could also indicate a failing water pump (someone here had one with a loose impeller..don't remember who). At what point do your cooling fans cut in? (where on the gauge?) Should be between the second and third mark.
Good luck
Bob S.