No Start part 2: Electric Boogaloo
#1
Advanced
Thread Starter
No Start part 2: Electric Boogaloo
Howdy. I was told I should start a new thread because the old one was getting difficult to keep track of what I’ve done so far. I’m in a bitter battle with a no/weak spark condition that I can’t seem to crack the code on. Ruled out a vacuum leak, fixed the fuel issue I was having, a weak spark appears to be the final obstacle to keep my ‘84 944 from moving. It was firing briefly, before sputtering to a stop, but now the spark has gotten to weak to even make that happen.
So far…
I’ve cleaned and tested fuel injectors
Checked fuel pressure
Sprayed starting fluid
Compression seems to be good
Smoke test for vacuum leak
I’ve replaced the spark plugs
I’ve replaced the ignition coil from MSD back to Bosch, it’s getting 12v everywhere it should
Swapped out the distributor cap and rotor
I’ve made sure the timing was perfect
I’ve checked/cleaned/fixed all the grounds
I believe the speed/reference sensors are gapped properly, as the car was running briefly before and I was pretty careful with gapping them
Ummmmmm… I think that’s all— it is getting tough to keep track of everything hahaha
So far…
I’ve cleaned and tested fuel injectors
Checked fuel pressure
Sprayed starting fluid
Compression seems to be good
Smoke test for vacuum leak
I’ve replaced the spark plugs
I’ve replaced the ignition coil from MSD back to Bosch, it’s getting 12v everywhere it should
Swapped out the distributor cap and rotor
I’ve made sure the timing was perfect
I’ve checked/cleaned/fixed all the grounds
I believe the speed/reference sensors are gapped properly, as the car was running briefly before and I was pretty careful with gapping them
Ummmmmm… I think that’s all— it is getting tough to keep track of everything hahaha
#3
Advanced
Thread Starter
#4
Advanced
Thread Starter
I will add, that since the car has stopped firing completely. The tach isn't bouncing as much. Previously, I'd start it and the tach would move a lot, like the car was starting. Now, it's just barely wiggling when I turn the key and the MPG gauge kind of slowly raises to the middle position.
Also, dropping this video here again so everyone can see the spark:
Also, dropping this video here again so everyone can see the spark:
Last edited by calebPH; 02-05-2023 at 01:48 PM.
#5
Rennlist Member
I don't remember the year of your car, but is there any chance it's a factory alarm issue?
ETA: One other thing that is critical in all of that is, are you able to test things out with a known good DME? If you have someone that will let you borrow one for testing, that may help narrow things down.
Good luck
ETA: One other thing that is critical in all of that is, are you able to test things out with a known good DME? If you have someone that will let you borrow one for testing, that may help narrow things down.
Good luck
Last edited by Zirconocene; 02-05-2023 at 02:02 PM.
#6
Rennlist Member
You would think that since it ran at one time, the DME is ruled out but stranger things have happened. I did have a no start issue once that was a bad DME unit.
You might want to edit your profile to list the city where you live. Help may be right around the corner. And yes, also do a signature line that lists the year car you are dealing with. You probably mentioned it in the other thread but that is the first thing folks need to know. They are not all the same.
OK, just saying. Are you sure the spark plug wires are sound and are hooked up correctly? Double verify that they follow the correct firing order and that #1 is firing at TDC. TDC from the mark on your cam housing that you use to align the timing belt.
You might want to edit your profile to list the city where you live. Help may be right around the corner. And yes, also do a signature line that lists the year car you are dealing with. You probably mentioned it in the other thread but that is the first thing folks need to know. They are not all the same.
OK, just saying. Are you sure the spark plug wires are sound and are hooked up correctly? Double verify that they follow the correct firing order and that #1 is firing at TDC. TDC from the mark on your cam housing that you use to align the timing belt.
#7
Advanced
Thread Starter
You would think that since it ran at one time, the DME is ruled out but stranger things have happened. I did have a no start issue once that was a bad DME unit.
You might want to edit your profile to list the city where you live. Help may be right around the corner. And yes, also do a signature line that lists the year car you are dealing with. You probably mentioned it in the other thread but that is the first thing folks need to know. They are not all the same.
OK, just saying. Are you sure the spark plug wires are sound and are hooked up correctly? Double verify that they follow the correct firing order and that #1 is firing at TDC. TDC from the mark on your cam housing that you use to align the timing belt.
You might want to edit your profile to list the city where you live. Help may be right around the corner. And yes, also do a signature line that lists the year car you are dealing with. You probably mentioned it in the other thread but that is the first thing folks need to know. They are not all the same.
OK, just saying. Are you sure the spark plug wires are sound and are hooked up correctly? Double verify that they follow the correct firing order and that #1 is firing at TDC. TDC from the mark on your cam housing that you use to align the timing belt.
I think I am going to pull the DME to inspect the solder joints today. But before I try that I’m gonna swap the DME relay and reverse the speed/reference connectors— just to see what happens!
Spark plug wires are 100% connected correctly, I’ve checked 20 times thinking surely I’ve done something simple wrong, but nope. My only hesitation is that I don’t technically know the age of the wires. They could be old, but they do look fine (the 3rd wire has a small little indention in the middle of it, but it’s receiving the exact same spark as the rest of them). I forgot to mention that I did swap out the wire going from the coil to the distributor cap, but that didn’t change anything.
Last edited by calebPH; 02-05-2023 at 04:19 PM.
Trending Topics
#8
Rennlist Member
You might want to start a thread "Need to borrow a DME for an early 944, in LA"
I know where one is near San Diego.
I know where one is near San Diego.
#9
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Oct 2021
Location: Southern WI - 89S2 Megasquirt PNP
Posts: 1,316
Received 288 Likes
on
251 Posts
You still have not ruled out speed and reference sensors (despite this being mentioned on numerous occasions) - have these previously been replaced with new?
See engine speed/running signals (check the resistance, check the wiring and connections):
https://www.clarks-garage.com/shop-manual/fuel-16.htm
I can appreciate that you said you checked the gap on the sensors - but thats not going to help you much if the sensors/wiring/connections are bad.
See engine speed/running signals (check the resistance, check the wiring and connections):
https://www.clarks-garage.com/shop-manual/fuel-16.htm
I can appreciate that you said you checked the gap on the sensors - but thats not going to help you much if the sensors/wiring/connections are bad.
Last edited by walfreyydo; 02-06-2023 at 10:26 AM.
#10
Rennlist Member
@walfreyydo I agree that the speed and reference sensors are always an area of suspicion, especially without a tach bounce. That said, I would be surprised that they are the problem if he is getting a spark.
Whatever, Clarks test is intimidating, as it requires an oscilliscope. A simpler method, if one has a decent automotive meter, is to check for AC voltage while cranking the engine. More specifically, go to the 36 pin plug, insert small leads at the two terminals for say the speed sensor, set the meter on AC voltage, set the meter on the closest range above 2 volts, and set it on Peak Capture. Crank the engine. You should catch a peak AC voltage of 1 to 2 volts. Repeat for the reference sensor.
Whatever, Clarks test is intimidating, as it requires an oscilliscope. A simpler method, if one has a decent automotive meter, is to check for AC voltage while cranking the engine. More specifically, go to the 36 pin plug, insert small leads at the two terminals for say the speed sensor, set the meter on AC voltage, set the meter on the closest range above 2 volts, and set it on Peak Capture. Crank the engine. You should catch a peak AC voltage of 1 to 2 volts. Repeat for the reference sensor.
#11
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Oct 2021
Location: Southern WI - 89S2 Megasquirt PNP
Posts: 1,316
Received 288 Likes
on
251 Posts
@walfreyydo I agree that the speed and reference sensors are always an area of suspicion, especially without a tach bounce. That said, I would be surprised that they are the problem if he is getting a spark.
Whatever, Clarks test is intimidating, as it requires an oscilliscope. A simpler method, if one has a decent automotive meter, is to check for AC voltage while cranking the engine. More specifically, go to the 36 pin plug, insert small leads at the two terminals for say the speed sensor, set the meter on AC voltage, set the meter on the closest range above 2 volts, and set it on Peak Capture. Crank the engine. You should catch a peak AC voltage of 1 to 2 volts. Repeat for the reference sensor.
Whatever, Clarks test is intimidating, as it requires an oscilliscope. A simpler method, if one has a decent automotive meter, is to check for AC voltage while cranking the engine. More specifically, go to the 36 pin plug, insert small leads at the two terminals for say the speed sensor, set the meter on AC voltage, set the meter on the closest range above 2 volts, and set it on Peak Capture. Crank the engine. You should catch a peak AC voltage of 1 to 2 volts. Repeat for the reference sensor.
He says he barely (or has none) has tach bounce and has never actually tested them. I have not seen a confirmation of spark, only switching around spark plugs somehow helped? This is something that should be sorted before making assumptions about faulty DME's and less common issues. Its part of the diagnostic procedure on Clarks (which everyone should follow before coming to the forums and making assumptions about this part or that part).
He can at least run the very simple resistance checks (without needing an oscilliscope) and verify the speed/ref connectors aren't disintegrating (common for the plastic connectors to fall apart). We also know the OP "re-gapped" the sensors but unsure if it was done correctly - incorrect gapping could correlate with the weak or no tach bounce, and given the OP's knowledge this is certainly a possibility. Bad/failing sensors would also correlate with this.
Diagnose and verify the critical systems first. Speed/ref sensors are critical to both spark and fueling.
Also it wouldnt be a bad idea to replace spark plugs just to be sure (they're cheap).
Last edited by walfreyydo; 02-06-2023 at 10:42 AM.
#12
Burning Brakes
If it is sparking, the reference sensors and wiring are good enough. The DME is processing the input and driving the transistor that grounds the coil.
Since you have both weak spark, and low tach bounce, I would suggest looking at the common area.
1) The green wire between DME pin 1 and the splice for the wire that goes to the tachometer.
2) The connection at DME pin 1
3) The splice
4) The entire ground path for the DME (DME connector pins 5, 16, 17, 19,) condition of wires, and ground connection to the frame.
5) And, it could be the DME itself. Specifically, the output driver transistor could be damaged or have a bad connection internal to the DME, like solder cracks.
Since you have both weak spark, and low tach bounce, I would suggest looking at the common area.
1) The green wire between DME pin 1 and the splice for the wire that goes to the tachometer.
2) The connection at DME pin 1
3) The splice
4) The entire ground path for the DME (DME connector pins 5, 16, 17, 19,) condition of wires, and ground connection to the frame.
5) And, it could be the DME itself. Specifically, the output driver transistor could be damaged or have a bad connection internal to the DME, like solder cracks.
#13
Burning Brakes
Also, check the black wire to terminal 15 of the coil from the fuse panel. It should stay at battery voltage while cranking. Since the battery voltage drops while cranking and you are going to be looking for pulses, it would be difficult to find them looking at just the voltage. A better way is to look at the voltage differential from the battery positive. To do this, put your voltmeter negative lead at the coil pin, and the positive lead at the battery positive terminal. Since this will be pulses as it cranks, an old analog meter would be better, if available (an oscilloscope would be ideal.) Small voltage pulses (maybe half a volt) are expected due to resistance in the wiring. If you get big ones, there is something wrong with that wire path. Actually, I would do this before the above, since this is much easier than getting under the dash.
Also, also, if your car has a key in the body next to the driver's door, it has an alarm system. If so, I would jumper it out per Clark's instructions just in case. It is unlikely to be the problem, but the green wire leads there as well.
Good Luck!
Also, also, if your car has a key in the body next to the driver's door, it has an alarm system. If so, I would jumper it out per Clark's instructions just in case. It is unlikely to be the problem, but the green wire leads there as well.
Good Luck!
Last edited by orig944; 02-06-2023 at 12:24 PM.
#14
Advanced
Thread Starter
He says he barely (or has none) has tach bounce and has never actually tested them. I have not seen a confirmation of spark, only switching around spark plugs somehow helped? This is something that should be sorted before making assumptions about faulty DME's and less common issues. Its part of the diagnostic procedure on Clarks (which everyone should follow before coming to the forums and making assumptions about this part or that part).
He can at least run the very simple resistance checks (without needing an oscilliscope) and verify the speed/ref connectors aren't disintegrating (common for the plastic connectors to fall apart). We also know the OP "re-gapped" the sensors but unsure if it was done correctly - incorrect gapping could correlate with the weak or no tach bounce, and given the OP's knowledge this is certainly a possibility. Bad/failing sensors would also correlate with this.
Diagnose and verify the critical systems first. Speed/ref sensors are critical to both spark and fueling.
Also it wouldnt be a bad idea to replace spark plugs just to be sure (they're cheap).
He can at least run the very simple resistance checks (without needing an oscilliscope) and verify the speed/ref connectors aren't disintegrating (common for the plastic connectors to fall apart). We also know the OP "re-gapped" the sensors but unsure if it was done correctly - incorrect gapping could correlate with the weak or no tach bounce, and given the OP's knowledge this is certainly a possibility. Bad/failing sensors would also correlate with this.
Diagnose and verify the critical systems first. Speed/ref sensors are critical to both spark and fueling.
Also it wouldnt be a bad idea to replace spark plugs just to be sure (they're cheap).
@orig944 thanks for the diagram, gonna inspect all of that when I get some free time.
Took yesterday off from working on the car because I needed a break, but gonna pull the DME now to inspect for cracked solders. Good idea on the thread for borrowing a DME, gonna do that now.
#15
Rennlist Member
If your feeling brave, since you already have it out, you can reflow the joints. I just did this with my cruise control board last night and fixed my 6+ year old issues with the cruise. But of course, there is always risks using extreme heat on boards. I would for sure try it before buying a new DME however.
Have you tried reinstalling the MSD coil to see if your tach starts acting right again? Seems strange that swapping the stock coil back in caused new issues.
Since it was running, and just stopped, I have a feeling some wire somewhere shorted/melted. Something the DME needs. My rear wiper switch melted and burned about 6" of the ground wire insulation off. Burned the carpet as well under the shifter trim. I'm lucky it didn't start a fire. My 28 fuse (I think it was 28, the one for the rear defrost) I found MELTED into the fuse box the other day. Yet, it wasn't blown. These things are getting old and doing crazy things. And there is something about German wire insulation, as my BMW has the same issues with wire insulation crumbling. And it's a 2001!
Have you tried reinstalling the MSD coil to see if your tach starts acting right again? Seems strange that swapping the stock coil back in caused new issues.
Since it was running, and just stopped, I have a feeling some wire somewhere shorted/melted. Something the DME needs. My rear wiper switch melted and burned about 6" of the ground wire insulation off. Burned the carpet as well under the shifter trim. I'm lucky it didn't start a fire. My 28 fuse (I think it was 28, the one for the rear defrost) I found MELTED into the fuse box the other day. Yet, it wasn't blown. These things are getting old and doing crazy things. And there is something about German wire insulation, as my BMW has the same issues with wire insulation crumbling. And it's a 2001!