91 S4 Failed Emissions - Hi Nox
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
91 S4 Failed Emissions - Hi Nox
Will a disconnected EGR valve cause high nox?
In addition to a gross leak under the manifold that results in an high idle (~1000), I noticed there was no vacuum line going to the EGR valve.
Read the High Idle Suggestions thread last night. Mandatory reading in my opinion. Great stuff. Will have to pull the intake anyway.
Want to pass emissions so I can the car in for paint.
Kevin
In addition to a gross leak under the manifold that results in an high idle (~1000), I noticed there was no vacuum line going to the EGR valve.
Read the High Idle Suggestions thread last night. Mandatory reading in my opinion. Great stuff. Will have to pull the intake anyway.
Want to pass emissions so I can the car in for paint.
Kevin
#2
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
There is no EGR valve.
Fix the vacuum leaks. Those alone will easily cause the high NOx numbers. Plus you are doing the engine no good by running it so lean.
Look for a couple recent threads on high NOx for more hints if fixing the vacuum leaks doesn't solve the issue.
Fix the vacuum leaks. Those alone will easily cause the high NOx numbers. Plus you are doing the engine no good by running it so lean.
Look for a couple recent threads on high NOx for more hints if fixing the vacuum leaks doesn't solve the issue.
#3
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Then I guess I have to pull the intake. Feh. I guess I must have been referring to the carbon canister valve.
#5
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Gone. On the Open Road
Posts: 16,572
Received 1,691 Likes
on
1,099 Posts
#6
Rennlist Member
infact, the leaner the better for gas mileage...
#7
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Even at idle and just-off-idle loads, even small vacuum leaks can be enough to give hot-spots and high local flame temperatures. The high NOx reading is a telltale of high combustion temps.
"The leaner the better for gas mileage" holds up to the point where you have lean misfire. It may be a once-in-a-while misfire, and at low loads you probably won't even notice it. There's poorer cylinder scavenging on the misfiring cylinder, so the next cycle has enough fuel to make the mixture rich enough to support full charge combustion.
Trending Topics
#8
Rennlist Member
Not worried about light or part throttle damage. But realistically, only you and I drive the cars gently. And I'm not so sure about you...
Even at idle and just-off-idle loads, even small vacuum leaks can be enough to give hot-spots and high local flame temperatures. The high NOx reading is a telltale of high combustion temps.
"The leaner the better for gas mileage" holds up to the point where you have lean misfire. It may be a once-in-a-while misfire, and at low loads you probably won't even notice it. There's poorer cylinder scavenging on the misfiring cylinder, so the next cycle has enough fuel to make the mixture rich enough to support full charge combustion.
Even at idle and just-off-idle loads, even small vacuum leaks can be enough to give hot-spots and high local flame temperatures. The high NOx reading is a telltale of high combustion temps.
"The leaner the better for gas mileage" holds up to the point where you have lean misfire. It may be a once-in-a-while misfire, and at low loads you probably won't even notice it. There's poorer cylinder scavenging on the misfiring cylinder, so the next cycle has enough fuel to make the mixture rich enough to support full charge combustion.
I don't think you will see any hot spots with even a stoich mixture, as generally, at near idle or part throttle , that's where the mixture is designed to be.... its the most efficient combustion point, but does provide the highest of temps. that's why I would think that a leak would bring you further from that point and cool things down. high NOx seems to be increased as you go leaner, not necessarily hotter. in fact the coolest EGTs you will see will be way lean of stoich. (just before misfiring) And that is the best gas mileage as well, but highest NOx levels.
#9
Drifting
Lambda 1.2+ ratios make for cool combustion charges by diluting the intake mixture with room air. Lambda 0.75 mixture make for cool combustion charges by physically cooling the cylinder by evaporating excess fuel.
#10
Rennlist Member
While this is true, there is a no-mans-land in the middle which is VERY prone to detonation and high in-cylinder temps under load. You can't go through that area. You have to jump to it.
Lambda 1.2+ ratios make for cool combustion charges by diluting the intake mixture with room air. Lambda 0.75 mixture make for cool combustion charges by physically cooling the cylinder by evaporating excess fuel.
Lambda 1.2+ ratios make for cool combustion charges by diluting the intake mixture with room air. Lambda 0.75 mixture make for cool combustion charges by physically cooling the cylinder by evaporating excess fuel.
but, if you have a vacuum leak, and and a bad one at that, I would think NOx would go down. maybe the leaks we see are just enough to put it in no mans land. Plus, we are talking idle and low power throttle settings so knocks are not as likely I would imagine.
#11
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
So NOx is produced where ANY part of the flame exceeds somewhere in the neighborhood of 2300ºF Might be a very small portion of the total combustion chamber volume, might be more depending on charge density and mixture. And chamber shape. At light loads, the total mass of air and fuel passing through is pretty small, so having a hot spot in the flame path won't contribute much to higher EGT's. The knocking from the detonation is inaudible, often "soaked up" by the surrounding metal without being massive enough to ring through to outside the block. At that some low load and low total charge mass, the intake manifold is also at a low pressure, so a small leak brings in a large mass of unmetered air proportional to the total charge. So CO numbers are small with the lean mixture, the HC from the misfire is pretty easily diluted, but the NOx spikes trigger the FAIL on the smog test.
For diesel applications where detonation is the normal combustion mode, NOx is mitigated by adding an amine (ammonia-like) liquid to the exhaust, and the mix is passed over a titanium dioxide-coated ceramic honeycomb, but only after the particulates are filtered out. Sounds like something that we ought to be using with petrol engines, except we really don't want to have the combustion temps that make NOx at any time.
For diesel applications where detonation is the normal combustion mode, NOx is mitigated by adding an amine (ammonia-like) liquid to the exhaust, and the mix is passed over a titanium dioxide-coated ceramic honeycomb, but only after the particulates are filtered out. Sounds like something that we ought to be using with petrol engines, except we really don't want to have the combustion temps that make NOx at any time.