practical ways to measure lift, downforce and drag on a Pcar?
#1
practical ways to measure lift, downforce and drag on a Pcar?
I've recently started a thread with a very similar title in the performance modifications forum, here:
https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-a...l#post13898932
EDIT: I understand this link isn't (always?) working. You should also be able to get there by copy and pasting the following text into this forums search tool: "things you can do to your car that will affect the aerodynamics"
Then someone posted that I should have started it in this forum, and they're probably right.
Too late now, though. I can't move the thread. All I can do is mention it here. So if you're interested, please click on the link!
https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-a...l#post13898932
EDIT: I understand this link isn't (always?) working. You should also be able to get there by copy and pasting the following text into this forums search tool: "things you can do to your car that will affect the aerodynamics"
Then someone posted that I should have started it in this forum, and they're probably right.
Too late now, though. I can't move the thread. All I can do is mention it here. So if you're interested, please click on the link!
Last edited by rs10; 01-29-2017 at 05:41 PM.
#2
Rennlist Member
I've recently started a thread with a very similar title in the performance modifications forum, here:
https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-a...l#post13898932
Then someone posted that I should have started it in this forum, and they're probably right.
Too late now, though. I can't move the thread. All I can do is mention it here. So if you're interested, please click on the link!
https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-a...l#post13898932
Then someone posted that I should have started it in this forum, and they're probably right.
Too late now, though. I can't move the thread. All I can do is mention it here. So if you're interested, please click on the link!
Depending on much you have set up for data collection, you can work with linear gauges on your suspension to measure how changes to aerodynamics effect any given corner on the car under a given set of circumstances.
#3
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I have been successfully working with well calibrated shock pods and AIM math channels over the past two years on lift/downforce measurements. In the wind tunnel you really need a rolling road set-up to deal with boundary layer effects.
It's tough to do reliable drag measurements outside the wind tunnel. We also use flow visualization techniques with tuffs.
It's tough to do reliable drag measurements outside the wind tunnel. We also use flow visualization techniques with tuffs.
#4
Rennlist Hoonigan
which cost no drachmas
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
which cost no drachmas
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
There are ways to do this, but your threads are tough to follow since they are in about 5 forums.
The data systems are not $6k to do this. The sensors would run around $250 each, data logger would be around $1,700, then install on them. You may be able to tap into the stock sensors or decode the CANbus info if you wanted to and then you wouldn't need the sensors. AEM would not be a good choice for this.
A wind tunnel would be the best bet, but would be expensive working through all the configurations. You can rent A2 for $500/hr with a 2 hr minimum. That would be accurate enough to get you info on what works better and worse. http://www.a2wt.com/
The data systems are not $6k to do this. The sensors would run around $250 each, data logger would be around $1,700, then install on them. You may be able to tap into the stock sensors or decode the CANbus info if you wanted to and then you wouldn't need the sensors. AEM would not be a good choice for this.
A wind tunnel would be the best bet, but would be expensive working through all the configurations. You can rent A2 for $500/hr with a 2 hr minimum. That would be accurate enough to get you info on what works better and worse. http://www.a2wt.com/
#5
Otherwise, A2 isn't really an option for me. I'm not a race team, and I can't change the configuration fast enough to use 2 hours of time. Indeed, in many cases I wouldn't be able to change the configuration myself at all ...
Any idea what data loggers would be a good bet to use with the stock height sensors?
Thanks!
#6
Your link doesn't work. The only way that I know to get true empirical data is with a wind tunnel.
Depending on much you have set up for data collection, you can work with linear gauges on your suspension to measure how changes to aerodynamics effect any given corner on the car under a given set of circumstances.
Depending on much you have set up for data collection, you can work with linear gauges on your suspension to measure how changes to aerodynamics effect any given corner on the car under a given set of circumstances.
I don't know how to fix the link. But as I just added to the first post, another way to get there is to seach this forum for some text from that thread, such as:
things you can do to your car that will affect the aerodynamics
#7
Rennlist Hoonigan
which cost no drachmas
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
which cost no drachmas
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Indeed. I did my best to direct all discussion to just one forum, but it didn't quite work that way. Perhaps rim328 is not the only one for whom the link didn't work ... .
Otherwise, A2 isn't really an option for me. I'm not a race team, and I can't change the configuration fast enough to use 2 hours of time. Indeed, in many cases I wouldn't be able to change the configuration myself at all ...
Any idea what data loggers would be a good bet to use with the stock height sensors?
Thanks!
Otherwise, A2 isn't really an option for me. I'm not a race team, and I can't change the configuration fast enough to use 2 hours of time. Indeed, in many cases I wouldn't be able to change the configuration myself at all ...
Any idea what data loggers would be a good bet to use with the stock height sensors?
Thanks!
Let me know if you want to do something along those lines and I'm happy to help you out. I'm an AiM dealer, but I might direct you to someone else depending on where you are.
Trending Topics
#8
Race Car
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: With A Manual Transmission
Posts: 4,728
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Is A2 the one in NC? I've thought about that one. 500/hr isn't bad at all.
You need to make for quick swapping with some low torque power tools and maybe use quick release pins on your wing. An extra set of hands would work wonders.
You need to make for quick swapping with some low torque power tools and maybe use quick release pins on your wing. An extra set of hands would work wonders.
#9
If so, then if 12 guys go together with their cars, each of them different, you can learn a lot in just two hours.
(But please share your data when you do, because I can't join. I'm nowhere close.)
Last edited by rs10; 01-31-2017 at 07:06 PM.
#10
Rennlist Member
I have been successfully working with well calibrated shock pods and AIM math channels over the past two years on lift/downforce measurements. In the wind tunnel you really need a rolling road set-up to deal with boundary layer effects.
It's tough to do reliable drag measurements outside the wind tunnel. We also use flow visualization techniques with tuffs.
It's tough to do reliable drag measurements outside the wind tunnel. We also use flow visualization techniques with tuffs.
#11
I have been successfully working with well calibrated shock pods and AIM math channels over the past two years on lift/downforce measurements. In the wind tunnel you really need a rolling road set-up to deal with boundary layer effects.
It's tough to do reliable drag measurements outside the wind tunnel. We also use flow visualization techniques with tuffs.
It's tough to do reliable drag measurements outside the wind tunnel. We also use flow visualization techniques with tuffs.
#12
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Durham, NC and Virginia International Raceway
Posts: 19,157
Received 3,340 Likes
on
1,895 Posts
Not enough accuracy or resolution, I would imagine.
__________________
-Peter Krause
www.peterkrause.net
www.gofasternow.com
"Combining the Art and Science of Driving Fast!"
Specializing in Professional, Private Driver Performance Evaluation and Optimization
Consultation Available Remotely and at VIRginia International Raceway
-Peter Krause
www.peterkrause.net
www.gofasternow.com
"Combining the Art and Science of Driving Fast!"
Specializing in Professional, Private Driver Performance Evaluation and Optimization
Consultation Available Remotely and at VIRginia International Raceway
#13
Interesting, but I'm not entirely sure how to understand your post. Do you know they do not have enough accuracy or resolution (and imagine this is Frank 993 C4S's reason)? Or do you imagine they might not have enough accuracy or resolution?
(If it turns out that they are not very good height sensors, then my question would be whether they are good enough for me. I would be satisfied if I could reliably pick up a change in lift of as little as 5 kg (possibly a bit more in the rear). This might be tough to measure on my car, as my springs are significantly stiffer then the standard Carrera sport suspension. On the other hand, since I have the opportunity to get up to pretty high speeds on long, flat stretches, 5 kg could result from relatively small changes.)
(If it turns out that they are not very good height sensors, then my question would be whether they are good enough for me. I would be satisfied if I could reliably pick up a change in lift of as little as 5 kg (possibly a bit more in the rear). This might be tough to measure on my car, as my springs are significantly stiffer then the standard Carrera sport suspension. On the other hand, since I have the opportunity to get up to pretty high speeds on long, flat stretches, 5 kg could result from relatively small changes.)
#14
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Durham, NC and Virginia International Raceway
Posts: 19,157
Received 3,340 Likes
on
1,895 Posts
Interesting, but I'm not entirely sure how to understand your post. Do you know they do not have enough accuracy or resolution (and imagine this is Frank 993 C4S's reason)? Or do you imagine they might not have enough accuracy or resolution?
(If it turns out that they are not very good height sensors, then my question would be whether they are good enough for me. I would be satisfied if I could reliably pick up a change in lift of as little as 5 kg (possibly a bit more in the rear). This might be tough to measure on my car, as my springs are significantly stiffer then the standard Carrera sport suspension. On the other hand, since I have the opportunity to get up to pretty high speeds on long, flat stretches, 5 kg could result from relatively small changes.)
(If it turns out that they are not very good height sensors, then my question would be whether they are good enough for me. I would be satisfied if I could reliably pick up a change in lift of as little as 5 kg (possibly a bit more in the rear). This might be tough to measure on my car, as my springs are significantly stiffer then the standard Carrera sport suspension. On the other hand, since I have the opportunity to get up to pretty high speeds on long, flat stretches, 5 kg could result from relatively small changes.)
I also know that the ONLY way you could achieve close to your desired resolution is by strain gauges at the spring perch. I recommend these: http://www.raetech.com/Instrumentati..._Load_Cell.php
#15
I am clear.
I also know that the ONLY way you could achieve close to your desired resolution is by strain gauges at the spring perch. I recommend these: http://www.raetech.com/Instrumentati..._Load_Cell.php
I also know that the ONLY way you could achieve close to your desired resolution is by strain gauges at the spring perch. I recommend these: http://www.raetech.com/Instrumentati..._Load_Cell.php
How about 10 kg differences? With standard Carrera springs? :-)
Well, I can definitely test at high enough speeds that 7.5 kg would tell me what I need to know. Not sure about 10 ...
Last edited by rs10; 02-05-2017 at 07:38 PM.