The future of racing. Automatic or manual.
#1
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
The future of racing. Automatic or manual.
So I imagine this has already generated a thread or two, and honestly I did not research the topic so if the regulars are bored with this discussion and would rather refer me to a previous thread I totally understand, but with all the aside here's the question . . .
Is the future of racing going to be all automatics?
I have another hobby flying RC airplanes, and in that world the advent of electrical motors changed the hobby forever. Many folks adhere to the older technology of gas engines but the clear trend is towards electric airplanes, and if the trend is steady gas planes will be "classics" and not actual competitors.
So from what I understand the current generation of automatic "Tiptronic" style transmissions can outperform manuals hands down so does that mean the future of racing will go fully automatic or has it already done so?
Just a newbie wondering . . .
Is the future of racing going to be all automatics?
I have another hobby flying RC airplanes, and in that world the advent of electrical motors changed the hobby forever. Many folks adhere to the older technology of gas engines but the clear trend is towards electric airplanes, and if the trend is steady gas planes will be "classics" and not actual competitors.
So from what I understand the current generation of automatic "Tiptronic" style transmissions can outperform manuals hands down so does that mean the future of racing will go fully automatic or has it already done so?
Just a newbie wondering . . .
#3
It'll probably be gear-less.
#5
Race Car
I don't think it will be automatics. It will continue to be dual-clutch paddle shift gearboxes with auto-blippers. The drivers will still be in charge of selecting the gears and actuating the paddles to get to them.
#6
Exactly my thoughts on the subject.... Once you have driven a real paddle shift manual (not automatics with paddle actuation) you will never want to go back! That is one of the best parts of driving my Radical.
#7
Drifting
The future is now. I can't think of any modern production race cars that use a clutch pedal for shifting gears. F1 have clutch paddles for launch, GT3 cars have a pedal to get going, but it's not used after the car is rolling.
There are of course us amateurs who race old cars with h-pattern gear boxes with clutch pedals, and Nascar probably still uses hydraulic clutches with 4 speed gearboxes.
There are of course us amateurs who race old cars with h-pattern gear boxes with clutch pedals, and Nascar probably still uses hydraulic clutches with 4 speed gearboxes.
Trending Topics
#9
Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I'm not convinced "Easier" = "Better". Sure the newer shifting mechanisms are faster, but if that's all that matters the human will be removed from racing as well at some point, where the car not only shifts itself, but perhaps drives itself. Even if it doesn't get to the extreme, do we really want real racing to become just like a video game?
I personally enjoy running through the gears and doing heal-toe downshifts on the track and consider it part of the sport. It's definitely more involved than a couple of paddle shifters and a dual clutch transmission.
But then again, even I'm "cheating" a bit as I drive a synchronized box as full on "old school" would require double-clutching and an unsynced box.
-Mike
I personally enjoy running through the gears and doing heal-toe downshifts on the track and consider it part of the sport. It's definitely more involved than a couple of paddle shifters and a dual clutch transmission.
But then again, even I'm "cheating" a bit as I drive a synchronized box as full on "old school" would require double-clutching and an unsynced box.
-Mike
#10
Race Car
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: With A Manual Transmission
Posts: 4,728
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
There are really 4 categories.
Auto -
Dual Clutch -
Single Clutch Paddle -
H-Pattern Manual -
Real torque converter auto's are not advantageous to a good driver with a good manual. Even the new Z06 is faster with the manual vs the auto GM claimed shifted faster than PDK.
Single Clutch Paddle Shifters pretty much are run in all pro series. These are high costs to maintain, so I don't think this will trend into amateur racing.
Dual Clutch - banned in many racing series, but as soon as that is lifted, there will be a bunch of people driving around in auto. Like almost every 991 GT3 or Turbo driver I've seen.
Manual will still rule amateur racing and track days for some years to come because of the much cheaper cost of maintenance and older cars. Series will balance performance with difference classifications and penalties for DCT.
Auto -
Dual Clutch -
Single Clutch Paddle -
H-Pattern Manual -
Real torque converter auto's are not advantageous to a good driver with a good manual. Even the new Z06 is faster with the manual vs the auto GM claimed shifted faster than PDK.
Single Clutch Paddle Shifters pretty much are run in all pro series. These are high costs to maintain, so I don't think this will trend into amateur racing.
Dual Clutch - banned in many racing series, but as soon as that is lifted, there will be a bunch of people driving around in auto. Like almost every 991 GT3 or Turbo driver I've seen.
Manual will still rule amateur racing and track days for some years to come because of the much cheaper cost of maintenance and older cars. Series will balance performance with difference classifications and penalties for DCT.
#11
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Durham, NC and Virginia International Raceway
Posts: 19,152
Received 3,333 Likes
on
1,892 Posts
This is not a bad thing. Both clients I worked with this past weekend had converted paddle shift cars. They made less mistakes, were more often able to focus on areas of safety and performance improvement and, by and large, performed at a higher level than most club-level racers because of this "aid."
Yes, I still like to row a stick every now and then, but good things are not only coming, they're here now!
__________________
-Peter Krause
www.peterkrause.net
www.gofasternow.com
"Combining the Art and Science of Driving Fast!"
Specializing in Professional, Private Driver Performance Evaluation and Optimization
Consultation Available Remotely and at VIRginia International Raceway
-Peter Krause
www.peterkrause.net
www.gofasternow.com
"Combining the Art and Science of Driving Fast!"
Specializing in Professional, Private Driver Performance Evaluation and Optimization
Consultation Available Remotely and at VIRginia International Raceway
#12
Rennlist Member
There are really 4 categories.
Auto -
Dual Clutch -
Single Clutch Paddle -
H-Pattern Manual -
Real torque converter auto's are not advantageous to a good driver with a good manual. Even the new Z06 is faster with the manual vs the auto GM claimed shifted faster than PDK.
Single Clutch Paddle Shifters pretty much are run in all pro series. These are high costs to maintain, so I don't think this will trend into amateur racing.
Dual Clutch - banned in many racing series, but as soon as that is lifted, there will be a bunch of people driving around in auto. Like almost every 991 GT3 or Turbo driver I've seen.
Manual will still rule amateur racing and track days for some years to come because of the much cheaper cost of maintenance and older cars. Series will balance performance with difference classifications and penalties for DCT.
Auto -
Dual Clutch -
Single Clutch Paddle -
H-Pattern Manual -
Real torque converter auto's are not advantageous to a good driver with a good manual. Even the new Z06 is faster with the manual vs the auto GM claimed shifted faster than PDK.
Single Clutch Paddle Shifters pretty much are run in all pro series. These are high costs to maintain, so I don't think this will trend into amateur racing.
Dual Clutch - banned in many racing series, but as soon as that is lifted, there will be a bunch of people driving around in auto. Like almost every 991 GT3 or Turbo driver I've seen.
Manual will still rule amateur racing and track days for some years to come because of the much cheaper cost of maintenance and older cars. Series will balance performance with difference classifications and penalties for DCT.
Agreed.
Many who race PDK Caymans (Caymen?) in the GTB 1.5 class run in full auto with Sport Plus on. They can text their friends, siip a latte, and do their nails on the straightaways, and left foot brake the whole time. Undeniably easier and much faster accelerating (especially when combined with DFI) but wow...totally uninvolving.
#13
Rennlist Member
I have had several of the younger generation who wanted to take my Cayman out for a drive. I would flip them the keys, they would run over to the car, and come slinking back in about 30 seconds because they did not know how to operate a manual transmission.
Automatics are unfortunately the wave of the future.
https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-a...vacuum+cleaner
Automatics are unfortunately the wave of the future.
https://rennlist.com/forums/racing-a...vacuum+cleaner
#14
This is not a bad thing. Both clients I worked with this past weekend had converted paddle shift cars. They made less mistakes, were more often able to focus on areas of safety and performance improvement and, by and large, performed at a higher level than most club-level racers because of this "aid."