944 A-ARM Advice to Newcommer
#1
Pro
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: NJ, USA
Posts: 544
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
944 A-ARM Advice to Newcommer
Looking to evolve a stock 944/951/TS suspension into DE Tracker and eventual Racer.
What is best approach/solution to A-Arm dilema for strength, safety, reliability, durability etc when lowering & stiffening suspension?
Please enlighten.
Cooz
What is best approach/solution to A-Arm dilema for strength, safety, reliability, durability etc when lowering & stiffening suspension?
Please enlighten.
Cooz
#2
Race Director
To prevent balljoint bind you would have to change to an aftermarket control arm. I suppose you could set up some coilovers to coilbind before you bind the balljoint, but that's pretty extreme and would bring its own issues.
Lowering is not so much the issue because if the balljoint can bind within the range of travel of the suspension, lowered or not, it still can bind. You can minimize this when lowering a car by using a much stiffer spring to generally limit the travel of the suspension.
Lowering is not so much the issue because if the balljoint can bind within the range of travel of the suspension, lowered or not, it still can bind. You can minimize this when lowering a car by using a much stiffer spring to generally limit the travel of the suspension.
#3
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Been there, done that with my son's 951. Just buy the Fabcar or Charlie arms and avoid a lot of heartache. We tried rebuilding the 951 arms, and the replacement plastic cups failed in the first event. We then rebuilt them with brass cups, and the ball post snapped at 100 mph in the first event. Fortunately the damage was minimal; my son got real lucky. We immediately bought and installed the Charlie arms before the next event. They are the only safe thing to do, period. Remember, you are trusting your life to this.
__________________
Larry Herman
2016 Ford Transit Connect Titanium LWB
2018 Tesla Model 3 - Electricity can be fun!
Retired Club Racer & National PCA Instructor
Past Flames:
1994 RS America Club Racer
2004 GT3 Track Car
1984 911 Carrera Club Racer
1974 914/4 2.0 Track Car
CLICK HERE to see some of my ancient racing videos.
Larry Herman
2016 Ford Transit Connect Titanium LWB
2018 Tesla Model 3 - Electricity can be fun!
Retired Club Racer & National PCA Instructor
Past Flames:
1994 RS America Club Racer
2004 GT3 Track Car
1984 911 Carrera Club Racer
1974 914/4 2.0 Track Car
CLICK HERE to see some of my ancient racing videos.
#4
Originally Posted by Larry Herman
Been there, done that with my son's 951. Just buy the Fabcar or Charlie arms and avoid a lot of heartache. We tried rebuilding the 951 arms, and the replacement plastic cups failed in the first event. We then rebuilt them with brass cups, and the ball post snapped at 100 mph in the first event. Fortunately the damage was minimal; my son got real lucky. We immediately bought and installed the Charlie arms before the next event. They are the only safe thing to do, period. Remember, you are trusting your life to this.
What spring rate was he using, sway bars, age of pin, circumstances etc.
Thanks.
#5
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
The pin snapped where it went into the bottom of the control arm. He is running 400 lb front springs/550 lb rear springs (no torsion bars) and the cup sway bars. The ball pins were brand new with the rebuild kit. The Charlie arms, with their replaceable lower ball joint have thicker pins as well. If you are going to race it and bounce it off the curbs, I wouldn't go any other way.
Like I said, my son got off lucky as the pin broke and the tire came straight back and jammed itself into the wheel well, while the tie rod caught on the broken pin and held everything together until he got it stopped. A small wrinkle in the fender is all that happened. What could have happened is that the wheel could have kicked out, and ripped the entire right front suspension off the car, and left the car sliding with no brakes at 100 mph. For $1600 it just isn't worth the risk.
Like I said, my son got off lucky as the pin broke and the tire came straight back and jammed itself into the wheel well, while the tie rod caught on the broken pin and held everything together until he got it stopped. A small wrinkle in the fender is all that happened. What could have happened is that the wheel could have kicked out, and ripped the entire right front suspension off the car, and left the car sliding with no brakes at 100 mph. For $1600 it just isn't worth the risk.
#6
Rennlist Member
If you search the archives you'll find plenty of views on this topic. In my opinion the Blaszak arms are by far the most cost-effective solution. The part that usually fails is the ball joint. On the Blaszak arms you could replace them with factory brand ball joints before every race weekend if you so desire for less that $25. To my knowledge neither the Fabcar nor the Charlie arms allow for easy ball joint replacement.
#7
Drifting
Originally Posted by Antonio
... To my knowledge neither the Fabcar nor the Charlie arms allow for easy ball joint replacement.
This is definitely a get what you pay for scenario. While the Blaszak arms based on the steel 944 arms are easy to service, they are somewhat of a frankenstein modified part, and his custom race arms are a better, the factory ball joint is still the weak link. Its also not on the same level as far as design and construction as the Charlie Arm. The Charlie arms are a work of art in terms of design and craftmanship. The only problem is that they are tough to get since they always seem to be on back order.
I agree with Larry, the cost of failure is too high for the amount you are talking about saving.
Trending Topics
#8
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
The Charlie Arms have a replaceble ball joint. My set, according to my mechanic, should be arriving by the end of the month. Not tracking the car this year till I get them on, even if it means missing the first 944 Cup race this year. Have nearly 50 track days w/o them w/o problems, but not taking the chance anymore.
#9
The pin snapped where it went into the bottom of the control arm. He is running 400 lb front springs/550 lb rear springs (no torsion bars) and the cup sway bars. The ball pins were brand new with the rebuild kit. The Charlie arms, with their replaceable lower ball joint have thicker pins as well. If you are going to race it and bounce it off the curbs, I wouldn't go any other way.
#10
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Al, we had the longer pins on the car; they were supposed to be correct for a lowered car to prevent binding. The car is lowered, but if you need to know the exact amount I will have to measure it & get back to you tomorrow. Visually, the top of the front wheel opening is just above the top of the tire with 16x225/50 tires.
#11
Originally Posted by Larry Herman
Al, we had the longer pins on the car; they were supposed to be correct for a lowered car to prevent binding. The car is lowered, but if you need to know the exact amount I will have to measure it & get back to you tomorrow. Visually, the top of the front wheel opening is just above the top of the tire with 16x225/50 tires.
#12
Drifting
jc22,
Don't let the move from DE to racing be the trigger for upgrading. If you feel you need them, do it now. You put just as much stress on the car during a DE (assuming you drive hard) as you do in a race.
Don't let the move from DE to racing be the trigger for upgrading. If you feel you need them, do it now. You put just as much stress on the car during a DE (assuming you drive hard) as you do in a race.
#13
Visually, the top of the front wheel opening is just above the top of the tire with 16x225/50 tires.
Oh, and as far as the switch after moving on to racing, everyone of the 4 or 5 of these that I've seen break has been at a DE
#14
I thought the SSI brass cup balljoint kit was based on a design for a racing series in Europe but could be wrong on this. I've been running it for a couple of seasons now without any issues but have been running street tires and near stock ride height. Has anyone heard of the SSI kit failing?
Thanks,
Mark
Thanks,
Mark
#15
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
We used the SSI brass cups. They are very nice units, and we expoxied them in to take up any play inside the bearing cup in the A arm. Unfortunately it was the ball pin that failed. That's why I like the thicker pins on the Charlie arms. I would have no qualms about the brass inserts for the street.